Consumer Law, engine rebuild
Consumer Law, engine rebuild
Author
Discussion

Sogra

Original Poster:

471 posts

242 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
I have sent my classic car in for an engine rebuild (I am not saying what car as the place may read this) 5 weeks ago for a full engine rebuild with a stage 2 head, rebore etc. I was told that it would take 4 weeks but when I phoned at 3 1/2 weeks I was told that suppliers etc were very busy and it was taking longer than expected and that it was out of his hands and couldnt put a time scale on it. I e mailed on Wednesday and got a reply back that he had sent the full engine to his rebuilder now to speed things up and he again said that it was beyond his control.

When I dropped the car off I told him I wanted to go away in it in the 2nd week of June and that I wanted to run it in etc well before I went.

Although it is a classic its parts are easy to come by and the place I have sent it to is a specilist in these cars.

Can anybody advise what my position is, I dont want to fall out with the guy but I am starting to get concerned that I am running out of time.

Is it truly out of his control or as they are his suppliers should he be putting them under pressure?

I have the email that said it would be 4 weeks

It is costing around 4k.

Do I have any position in law?

Can anybody advise me what to do as my normal response would be to charge in there and have a big blow out with him but am concerned that if I do that it may take ages to get my car back.

Any help would be welcome.

Thanks

Alicat

249 posts

261 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
Did you have a written contract/quotation/estimate?

Did you accept the order in writing?

Unless the requirment to complete the rebuild was an express term of the contract i.e. you specified in writing the timescales then you are on to a bit of a loser.

Alicat

Sogra

Original Poster:

471 posts

242 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
I have an email from him saying what it would cost and also another saying how long it would take. I had asked when could he get it in as I wanted to go on holiday in June and he replied around 4 weeks sooner if he used on of his units but suggested using mine to keep the original engine number.

Thanks

Alicat

249 posts

261 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
The issue is whether the delivery date was an 'express term' of the contract or just an indication. Unless, you clearly stated on any order that delivery was required by X, then there is not a lot you can do.

Alicat

Sogra

Original Poster:

471 posts

242 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
Alicat, thanks, I guess it was not an express term of the contract. Can you advise at what point it is resonable that it should be completed by.

I have read that I should write explaining "that time is now of the essence" is this correct because at some point I need to get the car done and back even if its not in time for hols

Thanks again

Alicat

249 posts

261 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
The contract is between you and him, and as you say he should really be putting pressure on his suppliers and not using them as an excuse.

What is reasonable? well if he originally said 4 weeks and it takes 6 weeks, then it could be argued that this would be reasonable. When it becomes unreasonable is not something that is easily quantifiable. However, the other issue is what remedy have you got if time drags on. In reality you would probably reach a point where time is excessive and there is no sign of it being completed at this point you would request that your engine is returned to you to take somewhere else, financially you will not have sufered any loss.

You are correct in that if you put pressure on him he could just be awkward. I would be talking with him, emphasising that you have a contract with him, and that you fully appreciate that he is dependnat on others, however, he did say the work would take 4 weeks. I would then politley ask him what he is doing to speed matters along. The situation is difficult as it is very much dependant on your relationship with the company/person concerned.

Alicat

Sogra

Original Poster:

471 posts

242 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
Okay, thanks. I will procede as you suggest.


Thanks

Brett928S2

1,504 posts

246 months

Friday 16th May 2008
quotequote all
Hi smile

Having built a lot of race engines I will say, suppliers and engineering companies can let a builder down...

But as far as you are concerned, and I hate to say it, if he TAKES A YEAR.....with no contract, you will have to wait or go get it back....

Even that is not easy legally, he can legally ask for whatever cost HE (not you) thinks reasonable, even if everything is in bits...BEFORE he gives it back to you.

You can of course take him to court afterwards, and you "might" win, but its doubtful.

All the best Brett smile

p.s I agree, the grovel to him, and say how highly recommended he was etc etc, is the best way forward...

Edited by Brett928S2 on Saturday 17th May 00:00

grumbledoak

32,571 posts

264 months

Saturday 17th May 2008
quotequote all
From (a slightly different experience) I suspect Alicat is telling it straight: if you have no written agreement they've not broken any law just by being 'a bit late'. The legal discussion of 'reasonable' is very vague: Lawyers have yet to sort out a proper answer, and they've had longer than four-to-six weeks at it.

And, the garage currently has your property. It might not be "9/10s of the Law" as the cliche suggests, but you don't have it, either, so you cannot simply tell them to...

At worst, I would guess that you are looking at going around with a flat-bed to get your property, and, while I don't think they can refuse, you'll get at best most of the bits and the hope that your replacement garage are better/quicker/more honest.

I'd try to put some friendly pressure on your garage...

Brett928S2

1,504 posts

246 months

Saturday 17th May 2008
quotequote all
grumbledoak said:
From (a slightly different experience) I suspect Alicat is telling it straight: if you have no written agreement they've not broken any law just by being 'a bit late'. The legal discussion of 'reasonable' is very vague: Lawyers have yet to sort out a proper answer, and they've had longer than four-to-six weeks at it.

And, the garage currently has your property. It might not be "9/10s of the Law" as the cliche suggests, but you don't have it, either, so you cannot simply tell them to...

At worst, I would guess that you are looking at going around with a flat-bed to get your property, and, while I don't think they can refuse, you'll get at best most of the bits and the hope that your replacement garage are better/quicker/more honest.

I'd try to put some friendly pressure on your garage...
Hi smile

Actually they "can" refuse legally, until he has paid "whatever" they ask...

So yes, the friendly, stroking approach is best....

All the best Brett smile


grumbledoak

32,571 posts

264 months

Saturday 17th May 2008
quotequote all
Fair point. I suspect I bought my "problem" off, the "friendly" way...

Sogra

Original Poster:

471 posts

242 months

Saturday 17th May 2008
quotequote all
to be fair he is a sound guy and I suspect a genuine problem with his suppliers and his idea of 4 weeks a little different than mine.

Thanks all