RE: 2,115 Speeding Tickets Overturned
RE: 2,115 Speeding Tickets Overturned
Tuesday 20th May 2008

2,115 Speeding Tickets Overturned

Investigation results in £35,000 in fines being refunded



An investigation has found that over 2,000 motorists were wrongly accused of speeding after a speed camera was allegedly wrongly set up and paperwork incorrectly processed, it has been reported.

It is understood that three members of Lancashire police staff are now facing disciplinary action over the incident.

The Independent Police Complaints Commission investigation found that 2,115 tickets had to be cancelled and 545 convictions overturned.

Uncovering the speed camera error also meant that £35,000 in fines had to be refunded and 1,500 penalty points were quashed.

A speed camera operator and two processing unit staff are now thought to be facing action, while two other members of the force’s Central Processing Unit have been cleared.

Inquiries are underway to assess whether the convictions may have resulted from incorrect paperwork.

Naseem Malik, IPCC Commissioner for the North West, said: ‘The investigations have identified matters that must now be presented before a disciplinary panel and, therefore, it would not be appropriate to go into full details at this stage.

‘However it is correct to say that concerns over the work of these individuals has resulted in a number of convictions having to be overturned.

‘Once the disciplinary panels have been held, the IPCC will issue further details about the findings of the investigations.’

Author
Discussion

officialslacker

Original Poster:

96 posts

231 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
So what happens to the person the was wrongly given points, and ended up with a massive hike in his insurance? What happens to the person that was a professional driver, taxi or what ever, wrongly given points which ended up him losing his licence, thus becoming unemployed, due to being unemployed, gets depressed, wife and kids leave him, can't afford his mortgage so loses his house, becomes bankrupt - compo?? I doubt it

forza whites

2,555 posts

226 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
Anyone know which one this is?

I've had dealings with Lancashire police (2-1 to me!)...and have heard (not sure how accurate) that a relatively high % of officers have 'left/dismissed' for 'illegal' activities relating to speeding offences etc

Titan Simba

18,451 posts

225 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
Marvellous. So it took official complaints for an investigation to eventually come to this conclusion. How many other dodgy fines & penalties (AKA: thieving) are handed out by the anti-car patrols which go unchallenged ?
furious

And how long before Mr_annie_vxr comes to their rescue? tongue out

Edited by Titan Simba on Tuesday 20th May 13:10

dean_ratpac

1,582 posts

309 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
just thinking how many other incidnets like this have gone un-challenged.

you should be able to go back "X" number of years - bit like the bank charges.

and put the police in a meltdown of ticket refunds,

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
First Kent, now Lancs ... the crap is bobbing to the surface up and down the country.

It's time to skim off the scum, rather than letting it scam us.

Streaky

Vagabund

364 posts

225 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
"Inquiries are underway to assess whether the convictions may have resulted from incorrect paperwork."

Right, so they need date, place, car reg, speed - HOW CAN THEY GET THAT WRONG? HOW?

Clearly these people didn't have enough SATS tests as kids!

flattotheboards

6,690 posts

237 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
officialslacker said:
So what happens to the person the was wrongly given points, and ended up with a massive hike in his insurance? What happens to the person that was a professional driver, taxi or what ever, wrongly given points which ended up him losing his licence, thus becoming unemployed, due to being unemployed, gets depressed, wife and kids leave him, can't afford his mortgage so loses his house, becomes bankrupt - compo?? I doubt it
Exactly just think of all the insurance premiums that have increased because of this.

Jasandjules

72,701 posts

260 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
flattotheboards said:
officialslacker said:
So what happens to the person the was wrongly given points, and ended up with a massive hike in his insurance? What happens to the person that was a professional driver, taxi or what ever, wrongly given points which ended up him losing his licence, thus becoming unemployed, due to being unemployed, gets depressed, wife and kids leave him, can't afford his mortgage so loses his house, becomes bankrupt - compo?? I doubt it
Exactly just think of all the insurance premiums that have increased because of this.
IN light of the findings of the IPCC I'd suggest there is a claim for liability to be made against the police/SCP for those losses directly attributable to the incorrect assignment of points.

VladD

8,201 posts

296 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
Vagabund said:
"Inquiries are underway to assess whether the convictions may have resulted from incorrect paperwork."

Right, so they need date, place, car reg, speed - HOW CAN THEY GET THAT WRONG? HOW?

Clearly these people didn't have enough SATS tests as kids!
You're assuming incompetence rather than corruption. Very generous of you. smile

Hoonfest

141 posts

243 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
"2,115 Speeding Tickets Overturned"

Drop in the ocean really. But how many other scameras out there could have been incorrectly set up. We need an independent group to go around and check every camera. The whole situation is a disgrace.mad

Original Message-----

Edited by Hoonfest on Tuesday 20th May 14:03

cowellsj

681 posts

230 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
"Uncovering the speed camera error also meant that £35,000 in fines had to be refunded and 1,500 penalty points were quashed".

- What about the extra dosh people had to pay out on insurance etc etc. I know it would be a waste of police time to deal with something like this. But a standard fee of £200 per person to compensate the victims for this police c*ckup would go someway to rectify the situation.

berkorich

54 posts

258 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
How does the maths work in this?

2,115 speeding tickets overturned results in £35,000 in fines returned. 2,115 tickets should result in a minimum of £60 each returned surely, or £126,900.

OK, 545 cases apparently resulted in convictions, suggesting they went to court either cos they were defended or the alleged speed was considered excessive enough for a more severe penalty. That still leaves 1,570 dealt with as fixed penalties, or £94,200, plus whatever extra fines were dished out by the courts on the 545 cases.

Is this like Kent when only those complaining get their money back?

Fetchez la vache

5,916 posts

245 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
cowellsj said:
"Uncovering the speed camera error also meant that £35,000 in fines had to be refunded and 1,500 penalty points were quashed".

- What about the extra dosh people had to pay out on insurance etc etc. I know it would be a waste of police time to deal with something like this. But a standard fee of £200 per person to compensate the victims for this police c*ckup would go someway to rectify the situation.
They must assume that you could claim it back. Just a Guess mind...

As for lost livelihoods due to going over 9 points... (gaelic shrug smilie)

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
berkorich said:
How does the maths work in this?

2,115 speeding tickets overturned results in £35,000 in fines returned. 2,115 tickets should result in a minimum of £60 each returned surely, or £126,900.

OK, 545 cases apparently resulted in convictions, suggesting they went to court either cos they were defended or the alleged speed was considered excessive enough for a more severe penalty. That still leaves 1,570 dealt with as fixed penalties, or £94,200, plus whatever extra fines were dished out by the courts on the 545 cases.

Is this like Kent when only those complaining get their money back?
If people attended court and were found guilty then won't their fines have been larger?This makes even your £126k look too small..

J16GY

130 posts

228 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
dean_ratpac said:
just thinking how many other incidnets like this have gone un-challenged.

you should be able to go back "X" number of years - bit like the bank charges.

and put the police in a meltdown of ticket refunds,
And I think we can all guess who would end up paying for this... us...

Also to recoup the money they would no doubt stiffen up even more and come down harder!

Bit of a lose lose situation if you ask me!

Russ35

2,719 posts

270 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
forza whites said:
Anyone know which one this is?

I've had dealings with Lancashire police (2-1 to me!)...and have heard (not sure how accurate) that a relatively high % of officers have 'left/dismissed' for 'illegal' activities relating to speeding offences etc
Two cameras are involved, one in Blackpool and the other in Penwortham. They haven't revealed exact cameras involved.

Blackpool local paper report


paranha

633 posts

273 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
2115 people know they were victims of perversion of the course of non justice, so adverts in papers and get the Victims together for a collective action against the police processing dept, and SUE SUE SUE for hundred of thousands ££££££33£££Ssssssss.This will encourage many other victims around the country, and will cost millions to settle----something for the lawyers to get their teeth into.

Droptheclutch

2,622 posts

256 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
Tip of the iceberg methinks...

JPKerr

109 posts

234 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
flattotheboards said:
officialslacker said:
So what happens to the person the was wrongly given points, and ended up with a massive hike in his insurance? What happens to the person that was a professional driver, taxi or what ever, wrongly given points which ended up him losing his licence, thus becoming unemployed, due to being unemployed, gets depressed, wife and kids leave him, can't afford his mortgage so loses his house, becomes bankrupt - compo?? I doubt it
Exactly just think of all the insurance premiums that have increased because of this.
The people who are being investigated over this should be sacked as they could have caused other innocent people to loose their jobs.

Edited by JPKerr on Tuesday 20th May 16:18

DAVEVO9

3,469 posts

298 months

Tuesday 20th May 2008
quotequote all
Hoonfest said:
"2,115 Speeding Tickets Overturned"

Drop in the ocean really. But how many other scameras out there could have been incorrectly set up. We need an independent group to go around and Destroy every camera. The whole situation is a disgrace.mad

Original Message-----

Edited by Hoonfest on Tuesday 20th May 14:03
EFA hehe