RE: Survey: Speed Cameras Distract
RE: Survey: Speed Cameras Distract
Wednesday 21st May 2008

Survey: Speed Cameras Distract

Speed cameras make driving worse, claims report



The majority of British drivers believe the presence of speed cameras makes their driving worse, it has been revealed.

53% of drivers believe their attention is distracted from the road ahead as a result of having to look out for speed cameras, a new survey found.

In addition, one in three drivers brake instinctively on seeing a camera regardless of their vehicle's speed, posing a clear danger to any cars following behind.

Many motorists say they are often unaware of deviations from national speed restrictions - 52% stated that there is insufficient signage to notify them of local speed limits.

'It is worrying that many people think that speed cameras are having an adverse effect on their driving, especially given that they were introduced as a means of improving road safety in the first place,' said James Flynn OBE, CEO of RoadPilot, that commissioned the survey.

 

Author
Discussion

Skinner.Daddy

Original Poster:

108 posts

229 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
We needed a survey to tells us this why exactly?

BIB in marked cars is the answer, and speed cameras only in dangerous places like outside schools.

slatess1

437 posts

245 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Skinner.Daddy said:
We needed a survey to tells us this why exactly?

BIB in marked cars is the answer, and speed cameras only in dangerous places like outside schools.
Second that, the home office should stop bogging the bib down with so much paperwork, employ civies to do this work and get the bobbies back out on the streets where they belong. visual deterent to slow works better than constantly speeding and slowing down for scamera's. Also more stop & searches to reduce weapons being carried about can only be a huger benefit to us all!

jas16

378 posts

263 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
i bet the report will be changed to make it look good and support the governemtn policies on road safety...

on top of the fact that the police force seem 'betrayed' by the government over pay, we [public] are always betrayed by the government no matter what!

Just_a_guide

251 posts

235 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
"52% stated that there is insufficient signage to notify them of local speed limits."


52% of drivers need to read that page of the high way code again.

Parrot of Doom

23,075 posts

265 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Skinner.Daddy said:
speed cameras only in dangerous places like outside schools.
No thanks. I'd rather be looking out for children than cameras.

Collaudatore

1,062 posts

233 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Just_a_guide said:
"52% stated that there is insufficient signage to notify them of local speed limits."


52% of drivers need to read that page of the high way code again.
Agreed. This statement completely invalidates the good work done in the rest of the article. I guess now they'll just erect more signs.

I read somewhere a while ago that some motoring group were campaigning for a speed limit sign be placed on the s-camera structure, to avoid any confusion for motorists.
A damned fine idea I though, but I don;t see anything like it happening.

designsubway

37 posts

309 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
I travel on a main road (40mph) with cameras to work and have done for the past three years. I am lucky if I go above 20mph due to the traffic but when I reach a camera I still instinctively check my speedo. Damn Cameras!

Edited by designsubway on Wednesday 21st May 13:45

Trax

1,601 posts

263 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Whatched an old 'Speed Camera Action' episode last night.

Safety camera van aiming down road towards corner, car comes round corner and sees the van, brakes and spins into wrong side of the road and straight into a ditch. A certain drink driving comentator says that the accident was caused as people will do anything to get away with speeding?

I see what could have been a fatal accident (imagine a moterbike coming the other way), that would not have happened if the 'safety' van was not there.

Skinner.Daddy

Original Poster:

108 posts

229 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Parrot of Doom said:
Skinner.Daddy said:
speed cameras only in dangerous places like outside schools.
No thanks. I'd rather be looking out for children than cameras.
You're obviously sensible enough to drive at the correct speed past schools so wouldn't need to worry about the camera thus wouldn't affect you at all.

It's for the morons that drive at 50 that it would be for

Parrot of Doom

23,075 posts

265 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Skinner.Daddy said:
Parrot of Doom said:
Skinner.Daddy said:
speed cameras only in dangerous places like outside schools.
No thanks. I'd rather be looking out for children than cameras.
You're obviously sensible enough to drive at the correct speed past schools so wouldn't need to worry about the camera thus wouldn't affect you at all.

It's for the morons that drive at 50 that it would be for
I'd still see it, look at my speedo, taking my eyes from the road.

The moron doing 50 would still do 50 through the camera, and the ticket would go nowhere as the vehicle would probably be illegal.


So thanks, but no cameras anywhere as far as I'm concerned.

herewego

8,814 posts

244 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Collaudatore said:
Just_a_guide said:
"52% stated that there is insufficient signage to notify them of local speed limits."


52% of drivers need to read that page of the high way code again.
Agreed. This statement completely invalidates the good work done in the rest of the article. I guess now they'll just erect more signs.

I read somewhere a while ago that some motoring group were campaigning for a speed limit sign be placed on the s-camera structure, to avoid any confusion for motorists.
A damned fine idea I though, but I don;t see anything like it happening.
In my area all the fixed cameras have camera warning signs that include the speed limit. I think this is very common and is general policy. You may have seen old signs not yet converted.

SpeedIsProgress

233 posts

230 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Trax said:
Whatched an old 'Speed Camera Action' episode last night.

Safety camera van aiming down road towards corner, car comes round corner and sees the van, brakes and spins into wrong side of the road and straight into a ditch. A certain drink driving comentator says that the accident was caused as people will do anything to get away with speeding?

I see what could have been a fatal accident (imagine a moterbike coming the other way), that would not have happened if the 'safety' van was not there.
Yeah, I seem remember a similar comment when a lorry jack knifed braking for a speed camera and took out a bus load of orfans (realistically it probably just hit a lampost). But the comentator states the accident was caused by the 'dangerous speeding vehicle'. I will argue that it wouldn't have happened had the camera not neen there...since the lorry might have intictivly braked even if it was travelling within the speedlimit, however would not have done had the camera not existed.

Mike400

1,026 posts

262 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Parrot of Doom said:
Skinner.Daddy said:
Parrot of Doom said:
Skinner.Daddy said:
speed cameras only in dangerous places like outside schools.
No thanks. I'd rather be looking out for children than cameras.
You're obviously sensible enough to drive at the correct speed past schools so wouldn't need to worry about the camera thus wouldn't affect you at all.

It's for the morons that drive at 50 that it would be for
I'd still see it, look at my speedo, taking my eyes from the road.

The moron doing 50 would still do 50 through the camera, and the ticket would go nowhere as the vehicle would probably be illegal.


So thanks, but no cameras anywhere as far as I'm concerned.
+1 - as far as im concerned the biggest danger are the uninsured, unlicenced, unfit people on the roads today.

Guy over here (belfast) in news recently, no licence, just bought a runaround for £200 and ended up writing someone off.

Problem is these people cost the government money to chase after. Us law abiding citizens are the easy target and we generate revenue when we make a small mistake.

More BIB means less "real" driving crime and safer roads for us all

Jasandjules

72,699 posts

260 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
It concerns me that people accept that they automatically brake when they see a camera... I often see this and wonder what the hell they are doing.....

And as above really, not a huge surprise people are distracted by cameras, people drive in excess of the speed limit the vast majority of them do anyway, so therefore to preserve their licences must look out for cameras..

CTE

1,524 posts

271 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
I am no saint, but do make an effort to stick to 30mph limits, and 40`s/50`s where the road is conjested (ie restricted views/houses/junctions etc etc). I have to say however, that to stick to 30mph does take some monitoring. Yes you should be in the appropriate gear, but realistically that is probably 2nd, with the engine revving uncomfortably. So while there are no excuses, when travelling at these low speeds, you do need to check your speed, and obviously seeing a scamra will cause an obvious reaction.

neh321

378 posts

253 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Collaudatore said:
Just_a_guide said:
"52% stated that there is insufficient signage to notify them of local speed limits."


52% of drivers need to read that page of the high way code again.
Agreed. This statement completely invalidates the good work done in the rest of the article. I guess now they'll just erect more signs.

I read somewhere a while ago that some motoring group were campaigning for a speed limit sign be placed on the s-camera structure, to avoid any confusion for motorists.
A damned fine idea I though, but I don;t see anything like it happening.
It's only a good idea if the point of scameras is to slow you down; it's self-defeating if their real raison d'etre is cash extraction...

Gerry Breen

140 posts

253 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
Parrot of Doom said:
Skinner.Daddy said:
speed cameras only in dangerous places like outside schools.
No thanks. I'd rather be looking out for children than cameras.
So you can mow them down tongue out

stackmonkey

5,084 posts

280 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
More to the point; as signs (on the other thread) are now deemed a distraction and are being taken down because they haven't reduced casualties over several years, can we not have the speed cameras removed for exactly the same reasons?

urban_alchemist

608 posts

237 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
duh...

mchammer89

3,127 posts

244 months

Wednesday 21st May 2008
quotequote all
urban_alchemist said:
duh...
+1

I hate the way the government have to fund these studies which give the same results that anyone on this site can give, though we can usually see problems a few years before these studies do.