Driving automatic with a cast on
Driving automatic with a cast on
Author
Discussion

jaf01uk

Original Poster:

1,943 posts

227 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
As above really, looking for a legal viewpoint. My mate has been injured and required pins in his left ankle, his other half is due a cessarean(sp) section and is therefore unable to drive for 6 weeks leaving them kinda stranded with a new baby plus schoolkids, would it be legal to drive an automatic car with a below the knee plaster cast on his left leg? His timing sucks!
Regards,
Gary.

mph999

2,780 posts

251 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
jaf01uk said:
As above really, looking for a legal viewpoint. My mate has been injured and required pins in his left ankle, his other half is due a cessarean(sp) section and is therefore unable to drive for 6 weeks leaving them kinda stranded with a new baby plus schoolkids, would it be legal to drive an automatic car with a below the knee plaster cast on his left leg? His timing sucks!
Regards,
Gary.
Can't see an issue, as you would only be using your right leg.

Martin

ALawson

8,056 posts

282 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
Simple, inform the insurance company and ask what they say. Normally they will ask what the doctor advise.

I had a procedure on my left knee and whilst I thought I could drive I had to wait three weeks. As convient as it is to drive, imagine being involved in an accident and clambering out of the car with a cast on your leg!

Fort Jefferson

8,237 posts

253 months

Saturday 24th May 2008
quotequote all
I can't see it being a problem, a mate at work drives an automatic, and he hasn't even got a leg below the knee, let alone a leg with a cast on it.

eccles

14,415 posts

253 months

Sunday 25th May 2008
quotequote all
A chap in work spent several months driving his auto mondeo with a cast on his left leg, he went into it all before coming back to work and there were no issues from the insurance company and he was American!

mark69sheer

3,906 posts

233 months

Sunday 25th May 2008
quotequote all
I had an operation on my foot two weeks ago and the nurse informed me that I wouldn't be able to drive unless I could do an emergency stop.
Obviously if your foot was in pain then you wouldn't be able to slam it down on a pedal.
As for the pot in an auto.. not as easy to drive with as no flex at the ankle.
I would imagine if there was an accident wearing a pot would be seen as a contributory factor.
You have to disclose to your insurance company any physical condition which could affect your driving. If not I suspect your insurance could be void.

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Sunday 25th May 2008
quotequote all
mark69sheer said:
I had an operation on my foot two weeks ago and the nurse informed me that I wouldn't be able to drive unless I could do an emergency stop.
Obviously if your foot was in pain then you wouldn't be able to slam it down on a pedal.
As for the pot in an auto.. not as easy to drive with as no flex at the ankle.
I would imagine if there was an accident wearing a pot would be seen as a contributory factor.
You have to disclose to your insurance company any physical condition which could affect your driving. If not I suspect your insurance could be void.
The pot is on his left ankle,wouldn't think that'd be a problem in a an automatic car.....

10 Pence Short

32,880 posts

248 months

Sunday 25th May 2008
quotequote all
No issue whatsoever as far as I'm concerned. You're not expected to use your left foot in an automatic when you have two healthy legs, no different with your left leg in a cast.

If you had a cast on your right leg, an accident occurred and that was contributary, then you'd be looking at dangerous driving.

becca_

9,932 posts

242 months

Sunday 25th May 2008
quotequote all
Put it this way: people who have had one leg amputated drive automatics without any adaptation - I reckon he's fine, as long as he takes care to keep the pot well clear of the pedals.

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Sunday 25th May 2008
quotequote all
The test is whether he is in full control of the vehicle.

Can he operate all the controls which are necessary to drive the vehicle safely and legally?

Does the injury/treatment cause him and pain which might distract from his driving?

Does the injury/treatment cause him to modify his position so that he is less flexible?

Can he turn in the car and see all mirrors and where he is going?

In an accident or other extreme condition will the injury or the cast stop him reacting effectively or reduce his ability to do so?

Is he taking any medication that might render him unfit to drive, or drowsey or lower his reactions?

There are more things to consider but you can, no doubt, see a trend.

I would suggest informing the insurance company as well as they might see this as an additional risk and one which they might want increased premiums to cover or that they might not be willing to cover at all. It is best to have a chat with one's GP before approaching anyone else. However, even a doctor's note to say you a fit to drive is challengeable in court.

The is no absolute answer with regards to a broken leg so before driving one should, perhaps, consider what one might say to a judge in a trial for causing death by dangerous.

jaf01uk

Original Poster:

1,943 posts

227 months

Sunday 25th May 2008
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
The test is whether he is in full control of the vehicle.

Can he operate all the controls which are necessary to drive the vehicle safely and legally?

Does the injury/treatment cause him and pain which might distract from his driving?

Does the injury/treatment cause him to modify his position so that he is less flexible?

Can he turn in the car and see all mirrors and where he is going?

In an accident or other extreme condition will the injury or the cast stop him reacting effectively or reduce his ability to do so?

Is he taking any medication that might render him unfit to drive, or drowsey or lower his reactions?

There are more things to consider but you can, no doubt, see a trend.

I would suggest informing the insurance company as well as they might see this as an additional risk and one which they might want increased premiums to cover or that they might not be willing to cover at all. It is best to have a chat with one's GP before approaching anyone else. However, even a doctor's note to say you a fit to drive is challengeable in court.

The is no absolute answer with regards to a broken leg so before driving one should, perhaps, consider what one might say to a judge in a trial for causing death by dangerous.
Thanks all, pretty much as we thought, I don't know how to do the multiple quote thingy so I'll answer them one at a time,

Yes - left leg so not much to do in auto?
No,
No - lightweight fibreglass cast
Yes - left ankle to mid shin pot
No - Pinned ankle, not a labotomy smile
No - no meds

Insurance will obviously be consulted
Death by dangerous? bit harsh for a stooky? confused

Thanks ALL for contributions, much appreciated,
Regards,
Gary