Naming a relative from abroad as the driver?
Naming a relative from abroad as the driver?
Author
Discussion

_daveR

Original Poster:

6,146 posts

258 months

Thursday 29th May 2008
quotequote all
Bit of an interesting one as this is a genuine case!

The Mother-in-law recently had an operation and was laid up in bed at home for a few weeks while recovering. Her Sister who lives in France came over to stay and help look after her and was driving the MIL's car while she was here. (I am not sure of how they arranged the insurance but IIRC they added the Sister to the policy as a named driver.)

So, Sister goes back to France and up turns an NIP for 40something in a 30. Mother In Law sends of stating it was her Sister and provides details accordingly.

Mother In Law has had a letter asking for her to provide the following:
Proof of flights or travel from France to correspond with the date of the offence,
Proof of insurance for her Sister,
Proof of the Sisters UK or French driving licence,
A letter from the Sister admitting the offence.

Now it isn't a problem getting anything as they were all legit, but I just find it a bit rich that we have to do all of this? Do we?
I accept that this is the result of people taking the piss with using overseas relatives to dodge points, but do we really have to provide all of that after completing the NIP as required?


mcdjl

5,769 posts

226 months

Thursday 29th May 2008
quotequote all
I'd guess too many people have been trying it on with this one to make the ticket go away, hence you being followed up a bit more- the insurance thing i'd guess is so as to make sure they can get you for even more fines if you did't have it.

randlemarcus

13,646 posts

262 months

Thursday 29th May 2008
quotequote all
TBH, if its a genuine case, I'd be happy to provide everything but the last element of their request. Once you have proven that its likely that it could have happened, its down to them, really.

IIRC, when you name another driver, the NIP resets and they issue it to the newly blamed person.

MrsMiggins

2,867 posts

266 months

Thursday 29th May 2008
quotequote all
I don't believe you have to do any of that. Name the driver and they either accept it or summons for S172 if they don't.

I'd tell them to feck off then turn up in court with all the evidence, but for a quiet life you might want to just supply it.

A middle way might be to reply suggesting that they write to the SIL in France, especially if she's likely to respond admitting the offence.

cs02rm0

13,966 posts

222 months

Thursday 29th May 2008
quotequote all
Welcome to the New Police State, would any criminals please stand up?

Seems crazy to me, beyond you stating that you gave permission for them to use your car I don't see why you should (or even potentially if you weren't on good terms how you could) provide anything else. Innocent until proven guilty is long gone.

slow_poke

1,855 posts

265 months

Thursday 29th May 2008
quotequote all
IIRC, there is the offence of permitting your vehicle to be driven without insurance. So If it was me, I'd send in proof of her being insured.

The rest they could go whistle for. That's police work and it's their job. Let them do it.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Thursday 29th May 2008
quotequote all
slow_poke said:
IIRC, there is the offence of permitting your vehicle to be driven without insurance. So If it was me, I'd send in proof of her being insured.
Ideally, in French - Streaky

Richard C

1,685 posts

288 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
_daveR said:
Bit of an interesting one as this is a genuine case!

The Mother-in-law recently had an operation and was laid up in bed at home for a few weeks while recovering. Her Sister who lives in France came over to stay and help look after her and was driving the MIL's car while she was here. (I am not sure of how they arranged the insurance but IIRC they added the Sister to the policy as a named driver.)

So, Sister goes back to France and up turns an NIP for 40something in a 30. Mother In Law sends of stating it was her Sister and provides details accordingly.

Mother In Law has had a letter asking for her to provide the following:
Proof of flights or travel from France to correspond with the date of the offence,
Proof of insurance for her Sister,
Proof of the Sisters UK or French driving licence,
A letter from the Sister admitting the offence.

Now it isn't a problem getting anything as they were all legit, but I just find it a bit rich that we have to do all of this? Do we?
I accept that this is the result of people taking the piss with using overseas relatives to dodge points, but do we really have to provide all of that after completing the NIP as required?
No you don't. I had that 'try-it-on' with Rowlings South Wales scamera partnership a 3 or 4 years ago; an American supplier was driving my car; we have a cordial relationship and I have driven his car in the US. I wrote to them informing them of his name, business address and telephone number. I got roughly the same as the above demand.

I simply told them that I had already complied with the requirements of RTA 1988 s172 and had provided them with all the required contact information. I was unable to help them as to how or when he had arrived in the UK as I was aware he had had business elsewhere in the EU prior to meeting me. However I could confirm I had dropped him at a UK airport where he would be catching a direct flight to his hometown. As regards insurance, it is normal practice for US citizens travelling to have a policy permitting them to drive such as hire cars and I had satisfied myself that he had such a policy in force at them time. If they wanted to make further enquiries they knew where to write to.

I eventually received a 'no further action letter' that ended huffily with them insisting that I made sure foreign visitors were made aware of British law and I esnured they obeyed it. I sent the letter to him more for amusement than anyting else; he had never heard from the partnership but he was quite forthright about what would happen to the operatives in the US should they try the same stunts as the UK Scameraships do !

jondude

2,441 posts

248 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
I noticed the 'YOU must prove any named driver has insurance' on my NIP, too.

It is, arguably, a way of getting you to accept 3 and 60, even if innocent, as few of us take Xerox copies of other driver's insurance documents.

However, I was advised to parrot the same line if they took it further - that I did all in my power to check he had insurance, and had no reason to believe otherwise.

Websites seem to indicate this is a red herring, as the police know a decent lawyer will turn the 'you prove your innocence' on its head.

As far as your case is concerned, I would, as suggested, return the letter unanswered and remind them you have nominated a driver, given the address, as demanded by law.

Don't offer any more information or help. The police should....police. Not you.

dilbert

7,741 posts

262 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
If they actually stopped people for speeding, at the time of the offence, none of this would be a problem.

_daveR

Original Poster:

6,146 posts

258 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
Thanks guys. Im going to suggest to the Mother-in-law to send it back pointing out that she has already fulfilled her responsibility by naming the driver.
She isn't as pig headed as me though so may just prefer to roll over!

aw51 121565

4,773 posts

264 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
jondude said:
Don't offer any more information or help. The police should....police. Not you.
But the police are adamant that that the 'camera partnerships' are seperate to them... 'They' (not you smile ) can't have it both ways, in my view.

Dwight VanDriver

6,583 posts

275 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
Of the list the only one they can push if they so desired is the question of Insurance.

Section 165 RTA 1988

(c) a person whom a constable has reasonable cause to believe to have committed an offence in relation to the use on a road of a motor vehicle (other than an invalid carriage),

must, on being so required by a constable, give his name and address and the name and address of the owner of the vehicle and produce the following documents for examination.

a person with non UK residencey gives the possibility of not having insurance and owner of vehicle thereby committing the offence of permitting if non shown when requested.

dvd

WildCat

8,369 posts

274 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
_daveR said:
Bit of an interesting one as this is a genuine case!

The Mother-in-law recently had an operation and was laid up in bed at home for a few weeks while recovering. Her Sister who lives in France came over to stay and help look after her and was driving the MIL's car while she was here. (I am not sure of how they arranged the insurance but IIRCthey added the Sister to the policy as a named driver.)

So, Sister goes back to France and up turns an NIP for 40something in a 30. Mother In Law sends of stating it was her Sister and provides details accordingly.

Mother In Law has had a letter asking for her to provide the following:
Proof of flights or travel from France to correspond with the date of the offence,
Mama does not need to give this at this stage. This may be so if her sister contests she was driving. rolleyes
_daveR said:
Proof of insurance for her Sister,
She has this apparently. The cover letter would provide the answer to above anywaywink

_daveR said:
Proof of the Sisters UK or French driving licence,
Would have been checked when taking out the insurance naming her as a driver. Our insurers do so when we tempo insure the relatives who live abroad to drive our cars whilst here.

_daveR said:
A letter from the Sister admitting the offence.
The sister might doubt she break a law here. She might have had "uspet tummy"wink (Precedent already set ..winkwhistle by Sir Man U Manwink)




_davR said:
Now it isn't a problem getting anything as they were all legit, but I just find it a bit rich that we have to do all of this? Do we?
I accept that this is the result of people taking the piss with using overseas relatives to dodge points, but do we really have to provide all of that after completing the NIP as required?
Just send the insurance certificate. The dates of the covering note will prove Mama-in-law not guilty.

Sister in law only has to confess or contest when she sent the NIP to herself. She does not have to 'fess up until then so they out of order on that.. rolleyes

Jasandjules

72,703 posts

260 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
As above, S172 appears to have been complied with, you have named the driver. Provide the insurance certificate of cover for the SiL and tell them to go whistle for anything else.

_daveR

Original Poster:

6,146 posts

258 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
There is no chance of the Sister contensting she was driving. So there is no problem there. (She was a bit surprised though!)

I've double checked and she was added to the Mother in laws policy for the month she was over here and using the car so this is nice and straight forward.

I'm going to offer to write her reply for her as this has put the sts up the Mother in law who has never even had a parking ticket let alone any other kind of "brush with the law" so she is panicing a little.

I'll get her to include a copy of the cert/cover note and include it with the reply.

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
Richard C said:
it is normal practice for US citizens travelling to have a policy permitting them to drive such as hire cars and I had satisfied myself that he had such a policy in force at them time.
That's true, but I would be pretty surprised if it covered them outside the US.

In a similar vein, I used to work for a multi-national company and we used to hire cars for visiting colleagues and we used our company insurance. When one of them crashed, it all got a bit messy because although our insurance covered any employee, the insurance was in the name of the UK company so it strictly speaking only covered employess of the UK company.

Richard C said:
he was quite forthright about what would happen to the operatives in the US should they try the same stunts as the UK Scameraships do !
If the US authorities have your name, there's every chance you'll get stopped at Immigration on your next visit.

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
_daveR said:
There is no chance of the Sister contensting she was driving. So there is no problem there. (She was a bit surprised though!)

I've double checked and she was added to the Mother in laws policy for the month she was over here and using the car so this is nice and straight forward.

I'm going to offer to write her reply for her as this has put the sts up the Mother in law who has never even had a parking ticket let alone any other kind of "brush with the law" so she is panicing a little.

I'll get her to include a copy of the cert/cover note and include it with the reply.
It's all very well PHers being awkward about it, but she's no doubt a salt of the earth, good middle England type of person and will be anxious to co-operate.

I wonder if the Scamera Pratnership will pursue her Sister? Has she retained her UK licence, or did she surrender it on leaving the UK? Without the UK licence they can't use the fixed penalty system and it would have to go to court (so it becomes pointless Pratnership won't get their £60). OTOH it could get messy if she still has her licence and hasn't surrendered it.

Patrick595

88 posts

241 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
Ask for a copy of the picture from the samera or Gatso. They tried to deny me a picture but I kept asking and saying that I couldn't identify the driver without a picture.. After a month they sent me the picture..... the idiots had only taken the picture with sun behind them and the glare on screen prevented any chance of recognition. So I told them I could supply the names of all of the allowed drivers and the 4 friends from the USA who had used the car during that time due to not being abale to SEE who was driving the car.... End of smile

WildCat

8,369 posts

274 months

Friday 30th May 2008
quotequote all
_daveR said:
There is no chance of the Sister contensting she was driving. So there is no problem there. (She was a bit surprised though!)
Try to get a photo of this "offence". Go to scene of this "crime" und take any photos to help just the same.

Sadly.. it sound like she miss a lolly und blip over a bit.. rolleyes

If she run on EU or French licence - not a problem as no "reciprocals" yetwink


_daveR said:
I've double checked and she was added to the Mother in laws policy for the month she was over here and using the car so this is nice and straight forward.
That good as it prove Mama-in-law telling the fact as ist in reality here. She will also have medical evidence to prove too poorly to drive or whatever. They thus cannot prosecute her und if they persist.. the "Waily und StUN" love ..adore such scoops hehe

;)

_daveR said:
I'm going to offer to write her reply for her as this has put the sts up the Mother in law who has never even had a parking ticket let alone any other kind of "brush with the law" so she is panicing a little.

I'll get her to include a copy of the cert/cover note and include it with the reply.
They rely on this reaction from decent folk Tell Mama -in Law not to worry. She ist NOT to take rap for her sister if her sister did indeed blip here.


The cover note showing dates should suffice. It up to them to take further as your Mama in Law fulfil her legality by ensuring sister legally entitled to drive the car und she named her as the driver who pinged the scam. She can prove tempo incapacity here as well in all probabilty.

No trauma would occur if all done in person by real und polite policemen.