Who's to blaim for road accident ?
Who's to blaim for road accident ?
Author
Discussion

Bemmer

Original Poster:

1,195 posts

233 months

Monday 2nd June 2008
quotequote all
In the middle of the road stationery indicating to turn right,Car approaching flash's and stop's to let me turn as turning a car UNDER TAKES the car that had let me go at a fair speed Well you can guess "BANG".It was a single lane road at that point but does change to double lane roundabout some 400yrds ahead.No police involved but the guy that flashed me has given a witness statement,the car driver that hit me says it was my fault.Any ideas..???

ps i know blaim should be blame but can't edit the header.

Edited by Bemmer on Monday 2nd June 20:20

Andyr86

209 posts

230 months

Monday 2nd June 2008
quotequote all
I would say 75% your fault. TP undertaking or not you were on his side of the road.

Vaux

1,558 posts

247 months

Monday 2nd June 2008
quotequote all
Just for clarity, if it was a "single lane road at that point", how did the car that hit you get past the car that had stopped to let you go?

Bemmer

Original Poster:

1,195 posts

233 months

Monday 2nd June 2008
quotequote all
Vaux said:
Just for clarity, if it was a "single lane road at that point", how did the car that hit you get past the car that had stopped to let you go?
Used some of the road junction area where i was turning It was definatly a "single lane road.

Major Bloodnok

1,561 posts

246 months

Monday 2nd June 2008
quotequote all
Andyr86 said:
I would say 75% your fault. TP undertaking or not you were on his side of the road.
Remaining 25% shared by the other two drivers: the first for stopping in the first place (should have been aware of the following car) and for flashing (definitely should have been aware of the following car), the second for trying to go through (should have been aware of the possibility of someone turning across the front of the other car - why else had he stopped?).

DonnyMac

3,634 posts

234 months

Monday 2nd June 2008
quotequote all
Sorry chap, sounds like it was your 'fault' in legal terms.

The driver that flashed you in reality.

I'd have probably done the same in similar circumstances.

hifihigh

590 posts

232 months

Monday 2nd June 2008
quotequote all
It sounds like really bad judgement from the person who undertook the other car. Were you at a crossroads so he could have thought the person infront of him was waiting to turn right?

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Monday 2nd June 2008
quotequote all
Insuffcient detail. Precisely what road areas did the undertaking car use? This single lane business is confusing. How did he get past the car that had stopped for you?

hemibum

833 posts

248 months

Monday 2nd June 2008
quotequote all
"Flashing" means " I am here". Any other interpretation of headlamp flashing leaves you totally at the mercy of the law. The Highway Code specifically points out that a flash from someones headlamps signifies that they are declaring their presence. You cannot under law presume it to be permission to proceed. Sorry mate, it's a bummer. God, just realised I'm speaking like VH noweek

Edited by hemibum on Monday 2nd June 23:23

s2art

18,942 posts

284 months

Monday 2nd June 2008
quotequote all
hemibum said:
"Flashing" means " I am here". Any other interpretation of headlamp flashing leaves you totally at the mercy of the law. The Highway Code specifically points out that a flash from someones headlamps signifies that they are declaring their presence. You cannot under law presume it to be permission to proceed. Sorry mate, it's a bummer. God, just realised I'm speaking like VH noweek

Edited by hemibum on Monday 2nd June 23:23
But if someone flashes and then *stops* it seems pretty clear that he intends to let you through, no?

Andyr86

209 posts

230 months

Tuesday 3rd June 2008
quotequote all
Major Bloodnok said:
Andyr86 said:
I would say 75% your fault. TP undertaking or not you were on his side of the road.
Remaining 25% shared by the other two drivers: the first for stopping in the first place (should have been aware of the following car) and for flashing (definitely should have been aware of the following car), the second for trying to go through (should have been aware of the possibility of someone turning across the front of the other car - why else had he stopped?).
Individual stopping and flashing was at no point to blame for accident.

s2art said:
hemibum said:
"Flashing" means " I am here". Any other interpretation of headlamp flashing leaves you totally at the mercy of the law. The Highway Code specifically points out that a flash from someones headlamps signifies that they are declaring their presence. You cannot under law presume it to be permission to proceed. Sorry mate, it's a bummer. God, just realised I'm speaking like VH noweek

Edited by hemibum on Monday 2nd June 23:23
But if someone flashes and then *stops* it seems pretty clear that he intends to let you through, no?
Its not an indication that the flashing driver is giving way. Its mearly an indication of "I am here"

Highway Code sect 110 said:
Flashing headlights. Only flash your headlights to let other road users know that you are there. Do not flash your headlights to convey any other message or intimidate other road users.
Edited by Andyr86 on Tuesday 3rd June 00:17

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Tuesday 3rd June 2008
quotequote all
s2art said:
hemibum said:
"Flashing" means " I am here". Any other interpretation of headlamp flashing leaves you totally at the mercy of the law. The Highway Code specifically points out that a flash from someones headlamps signifies that they are declaring their presence. You cannot under law presume it to be permission to proceed. Sorry mate, it's a bummer. God, just realised I'm speaking like VH noweek

Edited by hemibum on Monday 2nd June 23:23
But if someone flashes and then *stops* it seems pretty clear that he intends to let you through, no?
Well that's what you might assume, but assumption is the mother of many a scratchchin

Of course if you believe one person is according you precedence that doesn't remove you of your obligation to ensure that there isn't another who isn't doing so.

DonnyMac

3,634 posts

234 months

Tuesday 3rd June 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
s2art said:
hemibum said:
"Flashing" means " I am here". Any other interpretation of headlamp flashing leaves you totally at the mercy of the law. The Highway Code specifically points out that a flash from someones headlamps signifies that they are declaring their presence. You cannot under law presume it to be permission to proceed. Sorry mate, it's a bummer. God, just realised I'm speaking like VH noweek

Edited by hemibum on Monday 2nd June 23:23
But if someone flashes and then *stops* it seems pretty clear that he intends to let you through, no?
Well that's what you might assume, but assumption is the mother of many a scratchchin

Of course if you believe one person is according you precedence that doesn't remove you of your obligation to ensure that there isn't another who isn't doing so.
Yes, yes, all correct... but it doesn't need to be said.

Every single individual over the age of 6 in this country knows that if someone flashes you (in this particular circumstance) they are giving way - no question.

The highway code says it means 'here I am' and that is exactly the excuse I’d use if I’d flashed a car into oncoming traffic - and feel guilt as hell.

Grrr... sometimes this holier than thou approach to reading the rules is nonsense - it's his fault, he knows it; he should have seen the gap to the inside of the 'flasher', he didn't his car has a dent in it.

Is he nuts for pulling across a car which flashed him? - No.

Come on people, you can be educational as well as living in the real world by giving empathy and then the 'rules' and comparing to real world examples.

Again, to the OP, sorry to hear about it, probably would have done the same if I didn't know the road and now you know not to gain benefit from a ever rarely courteous (if somewhat unaware) driver.

Best,
D.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Tuesday 3rd June 2008
quotequote all
DonnyMac said:
vonhosen said:
s2art said:
hemibum said:
"Flashing" means " I am here". Any other interpretation of headlamp flashing leaves you totally at the mercy of the law. The Highway Code specifically points out that a flash from someones headlamps signifies that they are declaring their presence. You cannot under law presume it to be permission to proceed. Sorry mate, it's a bummer. God, just realised I'm speaking like VH noweek

Edited by hemibum on Monday 2nd June 23:23
But if someone flashes and then *stops* it seems pretty clear that he intends to let you through, no?
Well that's what you might assume, but assumption is the mother of many a scratchchin

Of course if you believe one person is according you precedence that doesn't remove you of your obligation to ensure that there isn't another who isn't doing so.
Yes, yes, all correct... but it doesn't need to be said.

Every single individual over the age of 6 in this country knows that if someone flashes you (in this particular circumstance) they are giving way - no question.

The highway code says it means 'here I am' and that is exactly the excuse I’d use if I’d flashed a car into oncoming traffic - and feel guilt as hell.

Grrr... sometimes this holier than thou approach to reading the rules is nonsense - it's his fault, he knows it; he should have seen the gap to the inside of the 'flasher', he didn't his car has a dent in it.

Is he nuts for pulling across a car which flashed him? - No.

Come on people, you can be educational as well as living in the real world by giving empathy and then the 'rules' and comparing to real world examples.

Again, to the OP, sorry to hear about it, probably would have done the same if I didn't know the road and now you know not to gain benefit from a ever rarely courteous (if somewhat unaware) driver.

Best,
D.
Evidently ... it does. OP entirely to blame IMHO, (and held to be so by police and insurers when the same happened to me - I was the "undertaker") - Streaky

steven f

538 posts

231 months

Tuesday 3rd June 2008
quotequote all
Bemmer said:
In the middle of the road stationery indicating to turn right,Car approaching flash's and stop's to let me turn as turning a car UNDER TAKES the car that had let me go at a fair speed Well you can guess "BANG".It was a single lane road at that point but does change to double lane roundabout some 400yrds ahead.No police involved but the guy that flashed me has given a witness statement,the car driver that hit me says it was my fault.Any ideas..???

ps i know blaim should be blame but can't edit the header.

Edited by Bemmer on Monday 2nd June 20:20
you are to blame

Bemmer

Original Poster:

1,195 posts

233 months

Tuesday 3rd June 2008
quotequote all
streaky said:
DonnyMac said:
vonhosen said:
s2art said:
hemibum said:
"Flashing" means " I am here". Any other interpretation of headlamp flashing leaves you totally at the mercy of the law. The Highway Code specifically points out that a flash from someones headlamps signifies that they are declaring their presence. You cannot under law presume it to be permission to proceed. Sorry mate, it's a bummer. God, just realised I'm speaking like VH noweek

Edited by hemibum on Monday 2nd June 23:23
But if someone flashes and then *stops* it seems pretty clear that he intends to let you through, no?
Well that's what you might assume, but assumption is the mother of many a scratchchin

Of course if you believe one person is according you precedence that doesn't remove you of your obligation to ensure that there isn't another who isn't doing so.
Yes, yes, all correct... but it doesn't need to be said.

Every single individual over the age of 6 in this country knows that if someone flashes you (in this particular circumstance) they are giving way - no question.

The highway code says it means 'here I am' and that is exactly the excuse I’d use if I’d flashed a car into oncoming traffic - and feel guilt as hell.

Grrr... sometimes this holier than thou approach to reading the rules is nonsense - it's his fault, he knows it; he should have seen the gap to the inside of the 'flasher', he didn't his car has a dent in it.

Is he nuts for pulling across a car which flashed him? - No.

Come on people, you can be educational as well as living in the real world by giving empathy and then the 'rules' and comparing to real world examples.

Again, to the OP, sorry to hear about it, probably would have done the same if I didn't know the road and now you know not to gain benefit from a ever rarely courteous (if somewhat unaware) driver.

Best,
D.
Evidently ... it does. OP entirely to blame IMHO, (and held to be so by police and insurers when the same happened to me - I was the "undertaker") - Streaky
Now thats interesting Streaky.because that is the view i take,At the end of the day you can not under take a vehicle on A "SINGLE" lane road,the driver should HAVED STOPED behind the car that had flashed me,The vehicle that flashed me is within the law

WildCat

8,369 posts

274 months

Tuesday 3rd June 2008
quotequote all
Bemmer said:
In the middle of the road stationery indicating to turn right,Car approaching flash's and stop's to let me turn as turning a car UNDER TAKES the car that had let me go at a fair speed Well you can guess "BANG".It was a single lane road at that point but does change to double lane roundabout some 400yrds ahead.No police involved but the guy that flashed me has given a witness statement,the car driver that hit me says it was my fault.Any ideas..???

ps i know blaim should be blame but can't edit the header.

Edited by Bemmer on Monday 2nd June 20:20
OK .. the Highway Code says as quoted.

Most interpret the "flash" as "courtesy" or rather "misguided courtesy" at times.


You say the village idiot decided to squeeze past using part of the junction you were trying to turn into..

Tja .. I would still have turned carefully .. having a second glance to check for impatient numpty und last time it happen.. - he got a look from me which my kittens say "similar to that scary statue in Dr Who.. which turn one to stone .. yikes


Can the polite driver be a witness to this illegal undertake here..scratchchin

Take some photos .. but the best outcome you can hope for will be a split 50/50 liability from the insurers on this one to be brutally honest here.

Hope it pan out OK. Do you have protected NCB? In which case .. it may notas bad as you think..

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Tuesday 3rd June 2008
quotequote all
Bemmer said:
streaky said:
DonnyMac said:
vonhosen said:
s2art said:
hemibum said:
"Flashing" means " I am here". Any other interpretation of headlamp flashing leaves you totally at the mercy of the law. The Highway Code specifically points out that a flash from someones headlamps signifies that they are declaring their presence. You cannot under law presume it to be permission to proceed. Sorry mate, it's a bummer. God, just realised I'm speaking like VH noweek

Edited by hemibum on Monday 2nd June 23:23
But if someone flashes and then *stops* it seems pretty clear that he intends to let you through, no?
Well that's what you might assume, but assumption is the mother of many a scratchchin

Of course if you believe one person is according you precedence that doesn't remove you of your obligation to ensure that there isn't another who isn't doing so.
Yes, yes, all correct... but it doesn't need to be said.

Every single individual over the age of 6 in this country knows that if someone flashes you (in this particular circumstance) they are giving way - no question.

The highway code says it means 'here I am' and that is exactly the excuse I’d use if I’d flashed a car into oncoming traffic - and feel guilt as hell.

Grrr... sometimes this holier than thou approach to reading the rules is nonsense - it's his fault, he knows it; he should have seen the gap to the inside of the 'flasher', he didn't his car has a dent in it.

Is he nuts for pulling across a car which flashed him? - No.

Come on people, you can be educational as well as living in the real world by giving empathy and then the 'rules' and comparing to real world examples.

Again, to the OP, sorry to hear about it, probably would have done the same if I didn't know the road and now you know not to gain benefit from a ever rarely courteous (if somewhat unaware) driver.

Best,
D.
Evidently ... it does. OP entirely to blame IMHO, (and held to be so by police and insurers when the same happened to me - I was the "undertaker") - Streaky
Now thats interesting Streaky.because that is the view i take,At the end of the day you can not under take a vehicle on A "SINGLE" lane road,the driver should HAVED STOPED behind the car that had flashed me,The vehicle that flashed me is within the law
I'm puzzled by what you say (if I have understood correctly), as the fault was held to be that of the turning driver, NOT the undertaking driver.

My situation sounds to have been very similar to the OP's. Approaching a crossroads on a single carriageway, a vehicle ahead of me (a lorry) was stationary waiting to turn right. There was space on the nearside to pass it. I did so (cautiously - wife and baby daughter in car and I had to slow to pass the turning lorry) and was hit practically head-on by a car that turned across my path. The lorry driver had flashed his lights and the other driver turned without slackening speed (according to the lorry driver's statement - who also agreed with me that the other driver did not indicate ... so why the lorry driver flashed I have no idea).

I called the police because the car that hit me wasn't taxed and the trailer it was towing had no lights or registration ... giving me cause for concern over whether there were other issues, such as the driver not being insured. Fortunately, he did.

"Single lane" does not mean 'only one car wide', neither does it mean one cannot pass another vehicle (even on the inside ... if that vehicle is stationary).

Streaky

Mr POD

5,153 posts

223 months

Tuesday 3rd June 2008
quotequote all
DonnyMac said:
Sorry chap, sounds like it was your 'fault' in legal terms.

The driver that flashed you in reality.

I'd have probably done the same in similar circumstances.
Pretty much follows the advice given by my Dad when I started riding a moped in 1983 (feck me I'm old) which stated something like.

Assume everyone else is an idiot, and don't trust anyone. There is no way of knowing who is going to do what. If someone indicates that the road is clear and it's not It is your fault. If you can't see a car, it does not mean there is not one hiding. If you can see a car, does that actually mean they've seen you ? No.

There was a lack of care on the part of the car undertaking, there was a lack of care from you, and who knows what flasher man was trying to tell you.


cs02rm0

13,966 posts

222 months

Tuesday 3rd June 2008
quotequote all
Sounds like an accident to me.