Cars collide with speed camera
Cars collide with speed camera
Author
Discussion

caiss4

Original Poster:

1,947 posts

228 months

Wednesday 4th June 2008
quotequote all
On the way home tonight the traffic news reported that the A303 was closed eastbound near Ilminster following an accident involving three cars and a speed camera. Can anyone shed any light on this?

Dogwatch

6,387 posts

253 months

Wednesday 4th June 2008
quotequote all
This cannot be. Safety Cameras prevent accidents as anyone on the government payroll will tell you.
Let me guess:
Step one - driver spots safety camera, panics and hits the brakes.
Step two - following car shunts him/her
Step three - other cars swerve to avoid the carnage and one hits the safety camera, which you can bet will be the first thing repaired and working again.

Ho,hum!

thewurzel

287 posts

225 months

Wednesday 4th June 2008
quotequote all
This will be seen by some as irrefutable proof that speed cameras cause accidents. Because people don't collide with signs, other cars etc. It's all the camera smile

caiss4

Original Poster:

1,947 posts

228 months

Wednesday 4th June 2008
quotequote all
Dogwatch said:
This cannot be. Safety Cameras prevent accidents as anyone on the government payroll will tell you.
Let me guess:
Step one - driver spots safety camera, panics and hits the brakes.
Step two - following car shunts him/her
Step three - other cars swerve to avoid the carnage and one hits the safety camera, which you can bet will be the first thing repaired and working again.

Ho,hum!
I have to admit this was my chain of thought. Of course doesn't excuse the following driver etc as clearly was not leaving a safe distance between cars but......

Deltaf01

1,512 posts

228 months

Wednesday 4th June 2008
quotequote all
thewurzel said:
This will be seen by some as irrefutable proof that speed cameras cause accidents. Because people don't collide with signs, other cars etc. It's all the camera smile
Glad you acknowledge it.

tigger1

8,486 posts

252 months

Wednesday 4th June 2008
quotequote all
Deltaf01 said:
thewurzel said:
This will be seen by some as irrefutable proof that speed cameras cause accidents. Because people don't collide with signs, other cars etc. It's all the camera smile
Glad you acknowledge it.
Indeed, people don't make needless emergency braking manoeuvres for signs...

Derek Smith

50,032 posts

279 months

Wednesday 4th June 2008
quotequote all
I was on blues and twos following an ambulance to the scene of a stabbing and waiting for a chance to overtake. As we came up to a speed camera the chap braked hard. I wasn't expecting it but had kept a fair distance and was ble to reduced my speed. After the markings the ambula speeded up.

At the scene and when my heart had stopped pounding I asked the ambulance driver what he had been taking. He said that it took around 20 minutes or so to complete the questionnaires that came round after tripping a speed camera and it was more effective to slow for the lights.

Discusions with the process unit failed to change the system.

Medic-one

3,143 posts

234 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
At the scene and when my heart had stopped pounding I asked the ambulance driver what he had been taking. He said that it took around 20 minutes or so to complete the questionnaires that came round after tripping a speed camera and it was more effective to slow for the lights.
Must be a local thing then as in most counties we don't have to fill in anything when a speed camera is triggered.

U sure it was an NHS ambulance responding to a 999 call and not some private ambulance company on a "emergency" ?

vonhosen

40,597 posts

248 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
tigger1 said:
Deltaf01 said:
thewurzel said:
This will be seen by some as irrefutable proof that speed cameras cause accidents. Because people don't collide with signs, other cars etc. It's all the camera smile
Glad you acknowledge it.
Indeed, people don't make needless emergency braking manoeuvres for signs...
Yet they do for Police vehicles & people on here say they want more of those though. rolleyes

Nobody has given us any evidence of how the collision occurred but the PH hypothesise is signed sealed & delivered.

Edited by vonhosen on Thursday 5th June 07:16

alphadog

2,049 posts

264 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
Nobody has given us any evidence of how the collision occurred but the PH hypothesise is signed sealed & delivered.
Just like those local councils who slap 50 limits on decent bits of NSL then.

WildCat

8,369 posts

274 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
tigger1 said:
Deltaf01 said:
thewurzel said:
This will be seen by some as irrefutable proof that speed cameras cause accidents. Because people don't collide with signs, other cars etc. It's all the camera smile
Glad you acknowledge it.
Indeed, people don't make needless emergency braking manoeuvres for signs...
Yet they do for Police vehicles & people on here say they want more of those though. rolleyes

Nobody has given us any evidence of how the collision occurred but the PH hypothesise is signed sealed & delivered.

Edited by vonhosen on Thursday 5th June 07:16
But they do not shave off 10 mph each time they see a police car though.

I think there are some problems with some as to how to deal with a blues/twos und a vehicle under escort too.

But there also a problem become apparent with unmarked

It off topic .. but linked as it about how folk can have accidents when confronted by something which cause moment of "blind panic" in some..rolleyes (A speed cam ALWAYS cause this effect in too many.. more so than a police vehicle


Couple of times in Manchester area.. in-laws at queue at the Motorway roundabout when they here the "whoo-whoo". Immediately "look around" for location und space to allow pass.. but this sound seem to come from the car two cars from roundabout entrance in L2...

Which led to a woman in L2 panicking und driving her car into the car waiting at her side in L1 once they realised this a BiB vehicle.. rolleyes

Had it been marked .. it would not perhaps have happened.

I think those already on roundabout would have noted und given way...



The in-laws said this unmarked was a people carrier und not the type normally associated with a "stealth-mobile" confused (The stealth mobile allegedly continued to the location of the "unexploded doughnut"wink per our "source"wink .. und a marked car rolled up later und breathalysed everyone...apparently... as routine... )


But back to topic .. A303 scratchchin I drive on that one in past. Nice road.. shame about the cams..

I seem to recall reading that local MP was calling for speed limit to be cut on that stretch near Salisbury though.


Deltaf01

1,512 posts

228 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
tigger1 said:
Deltaf01 said:
thewurzel said:
This will be seen by some as irrefutable proof that speed cameras cause accidents. Because people don't collide with signs, other cars etc. It's all the camera smile
Glad you acknowledge it.
Indeed, people don't make needless emergency braking manoeuvres for signs...
Yet they do for Police vehicles & people on here say they want more of those though. rolleyes

Nobody has given us any evidence of how the collision occurred but the PH hypothesise is signed sealed & delivered.

Edited by vonhosen on Thursday 5th June 07:16
Funny how both you and wurzel are of of the opposing view based on exactly the same "evidence" tho,eh? smile

Mg6b

6,649 posts

294 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
tigger1 said:
Indeed, people don't make needless emergency braking manoeuvres for signs...
Mostly because they are ambivalent towards them or at worst don't even see them!


Edited by Mg6b on Thursday 5th June 09:04

Jasandjules

72,709 posts

260 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
At the scene and when my heart had stopped pounding I asked the ambulance driver what he had been taking. He said that it took around 20 minutes or so to complete the questionnaires that came round after tripping a speed camera and it was more effective to slow for the lights.
Yep, friend is a paramedic, he says the same thing AND if you trip X amount of scamera in X period of time, there is some sort of b***king from management they get..Yet ironically, another paramedic beached his ambulance driving into a river, got out, and waded to the person in distress, and got praised for his actions.... So you can wreck an ambulance, but not speed. All that NHS time and money wasted, simply for scameras to make money.


cs02rm0

13,966 posts

222 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Derek Smith said:
I was on blues and twos following an ambulance to the scene of a stabbing and waiting for a chance to overtake. As we came up to a speed camera the chap braked hard. I wasn't expecting it but had kept a fair distance and was ble to reduced my speed. After the markings the ambula speeded up.

At the scene and when my heart had stopped pounding I asked the ambulance driver what he had been taking. He said that it took around 20 minutes or so to complete the questionnaires that came round after tripping a speed camera and it was more effective to slow for the lights.

Discusions with the process unit failed to change the system.
That's absolutely crazy. Yet somehow I'm not surprised, can't blame him at all given that madness.

Mr2Mike

20,143 posts

286 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
Yet they do for Police vehicles & people on here say they want more of those though. rolleyes
Perhaps because more Police officers could actually improve the standards of driving rather than just dish out thousands of speeding tickets every day?

Mg6b

6,649 posts

294 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
cs02rm0 said:
That's absolutely crazy. Yet somehow I'm not surprised, can't blame him at all given that madness.
A few years ago, I had 8 reports (NIP's) in my tray referring to enforcement camera's I had triggered on my way to immediate commitment jobs. They take ages to research and find the job attended to attach to the exemption form because quite often they do not get to the officer concerned for several weeks after the NIP has been issued to the Transport manager and then then forwarded on to the department owning the vehicle, then sitting on the Inspectors desk for 2 weeks before he manages to do something with it, plus the filling out of reams of questions about the reasons for activating the camera (as if the job printout isn't enough rolleyes)

I have not triggered any cameras since. I always go through them at under the limit, even with blues and twos on. It only slows me down by a few seconds per incident and saves hours of paperwork by not setting them off.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Medic-one said:
Derek Smith said:
At the scene and when my heart had stopped pounding I asked the ambulance driver what he had been taking. He said that it took around 20 minutes or so to complete the questionnaires that came round after tripping a speed camera and it was more effective to slow for the lights.
Must be a local thing then as in most counties we don't have to fill in anything when a speed camera is triggered.

U sure it was an NHS ambulance responding to a 999 call and not some private ambulance company on a "emergency" ?
I think the clues are:

Derek Smith said:
I was on blues and twos following an ambulance to the scene of a stabbing ...
and:

Derek Smith said:
At the scene ... I asked the ambulance driver what he had been taking.
Private ambulances are not normally called to such incidents.

Streaky

Greendubber

15,394 posts

234 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
Mg6b said:
cs02rm0 said:
That's absolutely crazy. Yet somehow I'm not surprised, can't blame him at all given that madness.
A few years ago, I had 8 reports (NIP's) in my tray referring to enforcement camera's I had triggered on my way to immediate commitment jobs. They take ages to research and find the job attended to attach to the exemption form because quite often they do not get to the officer concerned for several weeks after the NIP has been issued to the Transport manager and then then forwarded on to the department owning the vehicle, then sitting on the Inspectors desk for 2 weeks before he manages to do something with it, plus the filling out of reams of questions about the reasons for activating the camera (as if the job printout isn't enough rolleyes)

I have not triggered any cameras since. I always go through them at under the limit, even with blues and twos on. It only slows me down by a few seconds per incident and saves hours of paperwork by not setting them off.
We just shout up over the air 'Gatso activation on the Blah Blah Road, 1234 driving'.

Never hear anything after that!.

Globulator

13,847 posts

262 months

Thursday 5th June 2008
quotequote all
vonhosen said:
tigger1 said:
Deltaf01 said:
thewurzel said:
This will be seen by some as irrefutable proof that speed cameras cause accidents. Because people don't collide with signs, other cars etc. It's all the camera smile
Glad you acknowledge it.
Indeed, people don't make needless emergency braking manoeuvres for signs...
Yet they do for Police vehicles & people on here say they want more of those though. rolleyes
So dangerous cameras are OK because people slow down for the police?
I see.
Interesting viewpoint.
Different from the victims in this incident I think.