Liability for collision on building site
Liability for collision on building site
Author
Discussion

blackvanman

Original Poster:

71 posts

245 months

Saturday 7th June 2008
quotequote all
This might be a bit long and boring but if anyone can offer advice for a friend I'd be very grateful!

The guy is a tradesman and parked his van as directed on a building site. He placed a cone a couple of feet behind his van but at some point in the day the site manager moved the cone and allowed a generator belonging to a gas company to be placed up against the van. Later that day, it is believed that a lorry reversing without a banksman hit the generator and sent it into his van, causing about £1,500 of damage. The lorry was stopped leaving the site but the driver denied all knowledge and the vehicle departed.

The construction company in charge of the site initially offered to pay for the damage but then retracted this stating that it wouldn't be covered by their insurance. The situation is complicated slightly by the fact that my mate's boss doesn't want him to make waves with the construction company because the guy wants to win the subcontract for the rest of the development.

What would you advise the guy to do in this situation - we can assume that the lorry driver will continue to deny all knowledge and that nobody witnessed the incident.

He's obviously reluctant to claim off his insurance as it will cost him about £500 in excess and increased premiums. On the other hand he can't raise hell with the construction company because of his boss and the future business etc. A vague hope was that the gas company might somehow have responsibility for damage inflicted by their generator, even though it was the lorry driver's fault? (there is apparently identifiable debris from the generator embedded into his vehicle)

In case it's relevant, I think the generator was one of those yellow trailer things.

I might not get a chance to get back on PH until Wednesday - I won't be ignoring any questions/suggestions, I just won't see them for a while but I hope people can offer up some advice!

TimmyHolland

661 posts

226 months

Sunday 8th June 2008
quotequote all
Hmmm, tricky. His own personal vehicle then? Its the bloody lorry drivers fault! Any witnesses? Must have been some brickies about. Can understand your friends boss's situation but theres no way your friend should have to claim on his own insurance. He was advised by the site manager to park there, put the cone out as a precaution and then the site manager removed it! Maybe split 50/50 with your boss and construction firm, otherwise all your mates boss? All provided there is no luck from getting the lorry driver to pay up.

Good luck, hope it gets resolved and keep us posted. Tim.

mmm-five

12,406 posts

315 months

Sunday 8th June 2008
quotequote all
If the boss wants the contact that badly then the boss should pay for the repairs to the van out of his own pocket.

Parrot of Doom

23,075 posts

265 months

Sunday 8th June 2008
quotequote all
blackvanman said:
The situation is complicated slightly by the fact that my mate's boss doesn't want him to make waves with the construction company because the guy wants to win the subcontract for the rest of the development.
Mate's boss wants contract, mate's boss pays for mate's car to be fixed.

DonnyMac

3,634 posts

234 months

Sunday 8th June 2008
quotequote all
Parrot of Doom said:
blackvanman said:
The situation is complicated slightly by the fact that my mate's boss doesn't want him to make waves with the construction company because the guy wants to win the subcontract for the rest of the development.
Mate's boss wants contract, mate's boss pays for mate's car to be fixed.
Yep

groomi

9,331 posts

274 months

Sunday 8th June 2008
quotequote all
DonnyMac said:
Parrot of Doom said:
blackvanman said:
The situation is complicated slightly by the fact that my mate's boss doesn't want him to make waves with the construction company because the guy wants to win the subcontract for the rest of the development.
Mate's boss wants contract, mate's boss pays for mate's car to be fixed.
Yep
Sounds like the solution to me.

Jasandjules

72,709 posts

260 months

Sunday 8th June 2008
quotequote all
DonnyMac said:
Yep
I'm inclined to agree.


TPS

1,860 posts

244 months

Sunday 8th June 2008
quotequote all
I was thinking just the same.Either boss pays for it or shuts up and lets your mate make waves.Thats the two choices i would give him.
Then you could go after the construction company who put the generator there in the first place and the lorry that hit it if you have its details is the boss does not want to pay.