Witness to crash this morning -what are my responsibilities?
Witness to crash this morning -what are my responsibilities?
Author
Discussion

HereBeMonsters

Original Poster:

14,180 posts

213 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
As I was going around the roundabout at the junction of the M3/A34 this morning I saw a car get hit by a van which turned right (without indicating) from the left lane. I was the car immediately behind, probably about 30-50 yards or so.
I pulled over and stopped to offer my details to both involved, but the Traffic Wombles turned up (right next to one of their depots) really quickly and made the van move on, so I never got a chance to give my details to him, or indeed take the details of his van. I did give my details to the car driver though, and got his registration.

To be honest there wasn't much damage, but from what I understand the van driver is not admitting any liability. Should I start drawing diagrams and stuff now? I wouldn't want to side with either driver, but from what I saw the van clearly had a change of mind, turned right from the left lane without looking or indicating, and the car driver was very lucky to get off with a dented wing. How he avoided spinning into the armco I have no idea. He was pretty shaken up, but I think he managed to make a prang out of what could have been a very nasty accident.

GuinnessMK

1,608 posts

253 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
I witnessed an accident a few months back.

Exchanged details with both parties and the coppers.

When I got home I typed up exactly what happened, saved it, and printed it off.

Time, location, direction of travel, my view point, the events leading up to the accident. The number of people in each vehicle. Any apparent damage / injuries etc.

covboy

2,593 posts

205 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
Write it all down now while it's fresh in your mind
(description & drawings)

Remember - stick to the facts don't offer opinions.

HereBeMonsters

Original Poster:

14,180 posts

213 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
GuinnessMK said:
Time, location, direction of travel, my view point, the events leading up to the accident. The number of people in each vehicle. Any apparent damage / injuries etc.
Thanks, I think I got all of that.

Thankfully there didn't appear to be anyone injured, but both drivers appeared a bit shaken up.

I've typed everything up, annotated a couple of Google maps and signed/dated them.

I guess I just wait for someone to get in touch now.

supermono

7,464 posts

279 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
I'd be inclined to take a view of blame in your statement because otherwise the victim (as described it was clearly 100% van's fault for pulling the old unexpected right turn from the left lane without signalling or looking manouvre) will otherwise be a victim a second time when his insurance company work the 50:50 scam to steal both NCDs.

Also it'll perhaps teach the idiot in the van to think a bit more carefully on the road if he's held properly to account.

SM

HereBeMonsters

Original Poster:

14,180 posts

213 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
supermono said:
I'd be inclined to take a view of blame in your statement because otherwise the victim (as described it was clearly 100% van's fault for pulling the old unexpected right turn from the left lane without signalling or looking manouvre) will otherwise be a victim a second time when his insurance company work the 50:50 scam to steal both NCDs.

Also it'll perhaps teach the idiot in the van to think a bit more carefully on the road if he's held properly to account.

SM
I have said that the van quickly changed direction without indicating, and made no attempt to avoid the collision. I only saw his brake lights go on after the impact. The car he hit was indicating, and hit the brakes as soon as the van turned into his path.

Basically, I've tried to lay the facts out in a way that makes it obvious it was the van's fault, rather than saying "it was the van's fault".

ZOLLAR

19,920 posts

204 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
GuinnessMK said:
I witnessed an accident a few months back.

Exchanged details with both parties and the coppers.

When I got home I typed up exactly what happened, saved it, and printed it off.

Time, location, direction of travel, my view point, the events leading up to the accident. The number of people in each vehicle. Any apparent damage / injuries etc.
yes smart thing to do, i'd go with this idea ^^^^^^^^^

jazzyjeff

3,652 posts

290 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
HereBeMonsters said:
I wouldn't want to side with either driver, but from what I saw the van clearly had a change of mind, turned right from the left lane without looking or indicating, and the car driver was very lucky to get off with a dented wing.
Why would you not want to side with the car driver? Seems cut and dried he was a passenger.

If you don't want to 'side' then really there's no point in you getting involved at all? rolleyes

Let your conscience make your decision for you.

JJ

Rude-boy

22,227 posts

264 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
He is not appropriately qualified to make that comment though and as a witness imagine how a decent barrister could, if it were to go all the way (which we know it wont but the point still stands!!) rip him a new one in the witness box.

Phrasing it the way he has makes it very clear what he considers the facts to be and who, if he were asked to give his uneducated opinion, he would point the finger at.

OP

It appears you have covered all the bases. Depending on your outlook I would also be inclined to send a copy of anything you send to the insurance co.s or Police to the car driver as well if you are minded to. You may wish to obscure your personal details on these but then again you have already given these to him!

HereBeMonsters

Original Poster:

14,180 posts

213 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
Rude-boy said:
OP
It appears you have covered all the bases. Depending on your outlook I would also be inclined to send a copy of anything you send to the insurance co.s or Police to the car driver as well if you are minded to. You may wish to obscure your personal details on these but then again you have already given these to him!
I have no idea who the insurance companies are in this case, as I have no details myself from either party. As far as I am aware the Police did not attend, there just happened to be some Wombles nearby who actually told the van driver to drive away. I think the young chap in the car got his details though.

I presume I'll get a message from the car driver telling me a crime reference number or something, or an address to post my statement to his insurers.

Blackpig2

626 posts

212 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
If you gave your details to the car driver, he should pass them on when he makes his report to the Police, they should then send out a witness proforma in the next week or so.

Starfighter

5,352 posts

209 months

Tuesday 23rd March 2010
quotequote all
Write it up, keep it factual, keep it simple. A copy to the driver you got the details from and that should circulate around the insurance companies. If it is damage only and no BiB interest then I would decline to make any further statement as some of the insurance / "accident" management companies wait a long while and then ask for clarification. They are looking for the slightest discrepancy between the statements to use to discredit the initial statement.

streaky

19,311 posts

280 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
jazzyjeff said:
Why would you not want to side with the car driver? Seems cut and dried he was a passenger.
Now, what is it about this sentence that confuses me? wink - Streaky

Piglet

6,250 posts

286 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Blackpig2 said:
If you gave your details to the car driver, he should pass them on when he makes his report to the Police, they should then send out a witness proforma in the next week or so.
There is unlikely to be a report to the Police if nobody was injured and they exchanged details.

Hold onto your statement and at some point in the next couple of months you'll hear from the car driver's insurers.

Good on you for stopping and getting involved. thumbup

Gafferjim

1,337 posts

296 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
You've done the correct thing.
It was a non-injury RTC, which the BiB don't need/want to know about. The details of the vehicles will be logged at the HA Control room. You've passed on your contact details to the car driver, he will probably report the incident to his insurance along with your contact details, who in turn will contact the van drivers insurance. both insurance parties or neither of them may get in touch with you should the van driver not admit that it was his fault, (so writing it down now and keeping it, is a good idea)
It will not go to court, the insurance companies will decide who's paying who, so no worries there.

alock

4,575 posts

242 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
HereBeMonsters said:
As I was going around the roundabout at the junction of the M3/A34 this morning I saw a car get hit by a van which turned right (without indicating) from the left lane.
Were you queueing above the M3 to go into Winnall (i.e. towards Tesco)? This happens all the time. People queue in both lanes to go straight on and in both lanes to carry on around the roundabout and take the A34 exit.

Just looking at the number of exits and the number of lanes per exit you would guess the left lane is Winnall only and the right lane is Winnall and A34. The reality is the A34 takes a far larger proportion of traffic so it makes more sense for both lanes to feed the A34 with the left lane also providing a feed to both Winnall exits.

I use the left lane for Winnall and the right lane for A34 as I've witnessed too many near misses. Being morally/technically correct is of little concern when you've still got to get your car repaired.

http://maps.google.co.uk/maps?hl=en&ie=UTF8&am...

Edited by alock on Wednesday 24th March 12:55

jazzyjeff

3,652 posts

290 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
Rude-boy said:
He is not appropriately qualified to make that comment though and as a witness imagine how a decent barrister could, if it were to go all the way (which we know it wont but the point still stands!!) rip him a new one in the witness box.
Nonsense.

He was there, a barrister wasn't. Not sure what you're getting at - any witness report (even one from a victim) is merely an opinion, nothing more. The more witnesses that are willing to make a statement, the greater the case and better the understanding of the actual events.

Either he's prepared to stand up and be counted, or he isn't.

JJ

HereBeMonsters

Original Poster:

14,180 posts

213 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
alock said:
HereBeMonsters said:
As I was going around the roundabout at the junction of the M3/A34 this morning I saw a car get hit by a van which turned right (without indicating) from the left lane.
Were you queueing above the M3 to go into Winnall (i.e. towards Tesco)? This happens all the time. People queue in both lanes to go straight on and in both lanes to carry on around the roundabout and take the A34 exit.
As you leave the M3 there are 3 lanes to choose from at the entry to the roundabout. Lane 1 goes left only, 1st exit towards Tesco.
Lane 2 is for 2nd exit towards A34.
Lane 3 is for 2nd exit towards A34 and carrying on around the roundabout to subsequent exits.

Van was in lane 2, turned right across the path of the car in lane 3, after 1st exit.



Here you can see the whole junction. At the red spot, there are 3 lanes. The 1st goes to Tesco and beyond, to Winchester, marked "Local Traffic". Past this exit there are 2 lanes on the roundabout, as the first has filtered off.

Driver of the car was aiming for the blue spot, lane 2 of the 2nd exit of the roundabout. Collision occurred at the green spot as the van driver tried to turn right.


As you can see, the slip road is clearly marked "Local Traffic" (lane 1) and "A34" lanes 2 and 3. Driver of the car was entirely correct in his path from lane 3. Driver of the van was not.


As for not "taking sides", as you can see I don't need to. A statement of the facts clearly places the blame with the driver of the van. I do not wish to be on anyone's "side" in the case, however, as it may make my statement less likely to be believed. I'm not going to write "the van driver is a retard", despite that being my exact opinion. I would however fully support a prosecution for driving without due care.

Would posting a verbatim of my statement up here make it inadmissable should it come to court?

alock

4,575 posts

242 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
HereBeMonsters said:
Lots of stuff
Fair enough. I assumed you were talking about a different part of the junction as the part I was talking about I see a near miss at least once a week.

HereBeMonsters

Original Poster:

14,180 posts

213 months

Wednesday 24th March 2010
quotequote all
alock said:
HereBeMonsters said:
Lots of stuff
Fair enough. I assumed you were talking about a different part of the junction as the part I was talking about I see a near miss at least once a week.
Sorry, forgot to quote who I replying to in various parts of the post. I know what you mean from that side as well. TBH the whole junction can be confusing as most people take it at speed. If you know what to do, and are aware of others then you should be OK. I myself have had a couple of near misses - mainly people pulling out in front of me from Tesco direction going over the roundabout, totally misjudging my speed as I'm going from M3 to A34. On the rare occasion when I get to parp the horn as well as take evasive action the look of surprise on their faces is a sight to behold. As if it was the first time they had ever looked to the right in their lives.