Parked on the road with no tax!
Discussion
Can anyone help me please?
My wife's car was parked in our drive, untaxed. While we were deciding what to do with it, I used it to block in our trailer and prevent it being stolen.
About 6 weeks ago, we suddenly had to use the trailer very quickly (I won't bore you with the reason). We moved the car out and got the trailer and off we went. We were only gone 1 hour maximum but returned to find a red ticket on the windscreen. It is headed "Police Warning Notice", "Vehicle Excise Duty". There is then a space to fill in the Reg number and the date of the 'offence'. The writing in both is totally illegible (I can only presume it is the carbon copy). On the bottom of the 'ticket' is a space for the date and signature. The signature is totally blank but the date has been filled in with pen (i.e. it's not a carbon copy, it's original).
About 2 weeks later, I received a letter from the DVLA saying my car was seen in such and such a road and gave the date and time. They want a £149.00 fine. (I am disabled and unfit to work. My wife is, owing to the fact of our two young children and the benefits system also unable to work.) The date matches with the 'ticket' but the road name is ½ mile away! I wrote to the DVLA and asked for proof as there was no way it could have been my car seen in that location. They wrote back and changed the road name where it was seen and included a photocopy of part of the ticket. I, in turn, wrote back and explained the circumstances of the car being on the road, how long it was there (offering neighbours as witnesses) and also explained my personal circumstances and how such a large fine would effect us). This morning, they have replied saying that there is no reason to change their decision and I must pay by the 12th April.
I have the option of taking this case to court. Given the fact that the original ticket is illegible and that they originally stated the wrong road, would I stand any chance of being successful in court? I really cannot afford to pay this fine.
Any help/advice would be very gratefully received.
Many thanks for reading this
Phil
My wife's car was parked in our drive, untaxed. While we were deciding what to do with it, I used it to block in our trailer and prevent it being stolen.
About 6 weeks ago, we suddenly had to use the trailer very quickly (I won't bore you with the reason). We moved the car out and got the trailer and off we went. We were only gone 1 hour maximum but returned to find a red ticket on the windscreen. It is headed "Police Warning Notice", "Vehicle Excise Duty". There is then a space to fill in the Reg number and the date of the 'offence'. The writing in both is totally illegible (I can only presume it is the carbon copy). On the bottom of the 'ticket' is a space for the date and signature. The signature is totally blank but the date has been filled in with pen (i.e. it's not a carbon copy, it's original).
About 2 weeks later, I received a letter from the DVLA saying my car was seen in such and such a road and gave the date and time. They want a £149.00 fine. (I am disabled and unfit to work. My wife is, owing to the fact of our two young children and the benefits system also unable to work.) The date matches with the 'ticket' but the road name is ½ mile away! I wrote to the DVLA and asked for proof as there was no way it could have been my car seen in that location. They wrote back and changed the road name where it was seen and included a photocopy of part of the ticket. I, in turn, wrote back and explained the circumstances of the car being on the road, how long it was there (offering neighbours as witnesses) and also explained my personal circumstances and how such a large fine would effect us). This morning, they have replied saying that there is no reason to change their decision and I must pay by the 12th April.
I have the option of taking this case to court. Given the fact that the original ticket is illegible and that they originally stated the wrong road, would I stand any chance of being successful in court? I really cannot afford to pay this fine.
Any help/advice would be very gratefully received.
Many thanks for reading this
Phil
Don't really see that you have a leg to stand on, as for the illegilble writing you have since written with them confirming where the vehicle actually was which they have confirmed, and it was still illegally on the road with no tax.
Why didn't you put it back on the drive after you moved the trailer?
Why didn't you put it back on the drive after you moved the trailer?
Phil66 said:
(I am disabled and unfit to work. My wife is, owing to the fact of our two young children and the benefits system also unable to work.)
The second a read that, I knew this thread wouldn't go down well.Good luck getting any sympathy.
By the way, you don't have a leg to stand on as you told them you parked on the road without tax. Simple as that. You should have played stupid and asked for proof without telling them you actually did it.
Deluded said:
Phil66 said:
(I am disabled and unfit to work. My wife is, owing to the fact of our two young children and the benefits system also unable to work.)
The second a read that, I knew this thread wouldn't go down well.Good luck getting any sympathy.
By the way, you don't have a leg to stand on as you told them you parked on the road without tax. Simple as that. You should have played stupid and asked for proof without telling them you actually did it.
Good way to start your PH posting career.
markmullen said:
Muntu said:
Take it to court. At worst, they will ramp the fine up, make you pay costs and a ridiculous victim surcharge.
EFAWell, I asked a civilised question of, what I thought, were civilised people. Obviously, I was wrong.
The assertion that because I am disabled and live on benefits, I am therefore some sort of insect, leeching a living from the DWP is really very insulting and unnecessary. I am disabled as a result of an industrial accident and my wife cannot work because she has to care for me. The reason for us having two cars is that I spend 3 days a week in hospital and she has to deal with the children, shopping and everything else.
The responses I have received on this forum are a disgrace and to the detriment of the motor sport industry. Not one; not one person, could give me a civil answer without insulting me in some manner.
I hope you're all very proud of yourselves.
The assertion that because I am disabled and live on benefits, I am therefore some sort of insect, leeching a living from the DWP is really very insulting and unnecessary. I am disabled as a result of an industrial accident and my wife cannot work because she has to care for me. The reason for us having two cars is that I spend 3 days a week in hospital and she has to deal with the children, shopping and everything else.
The responses I have received on this forum are a disgrace and to the detriment of the motor sport industry. Not one; not one person, could give me a civil answer without insulting me in some manner.
I hope you're all very proud of yourselves.
K87 said:
Don't really see that you have a leg to stand on, as for the illegilble writing you have since written with them confirming where the vehicle actually was which they have confirmed, and it was still illegally on the road with no tax.
Why didn't you put it back on the drive after you moved the trailer?
Was that a disabled joke?Why didn't you put it back on the drive after you moved the trailer?
To the OP, you f
ked up by admitting to it. Probably could have got away with it cos of the no signature, date on wrong stuff too.Phil66 said:
Not one; not one person, could give me a civil answer without insulting me in some manner.
You used an untaxed vehicle on a public road. You were caught and have been fined. There are no exceptions. Just pay up. Do you really believe you are exempt for some reason?Was the vehicle also insured and MOT'd?
Do you mean uncivil responses in that you'd not got the responses you expected?
Phil66 said:
Well, I asked a civilised question of, what I thought, were civilised people. Obviously, I was wrong.
The assertion that because I am disabled and live on benefits, I am therefore some sort of insect, leeching a living from the DWP is really very insulting and unnecessary. I am disabled as a result of an industrial accident and my wife cannot work because she has to care for me. The reason for us having two cars is that I spend 3 days a week in hospital and she has to deal with the children, shopping and everything else.
The responses I have received on this forum are a disgrace and to the detriment of the motor sport industry. Not one; not one person, could give me a civil answer without insulting me in some manner.
I hope you're all very proud of yourselves.
Irrespective of your individual circumstances, the bottom line is that your car wasn't displaying the correct VED and it was parked on the road. Maybe only an hour, but where would you draw the line?The assertion that because I am disabled and live on benefits, I am therefore some sort of insect, leeching a living from the DWP is really very insulting and unnecessary. I am disabled as a result of an industrial accident and my wife cannot work because she has to care for me. The reason for us having two cars is that I spend 3 days a week in hospital and she has to deal with the children, shopping and everything else.
The responses I have received on this forum are a disgrace and to the detriment of the motor sport industry. Not one; not one person, could give me a civil answer without insulting me in some manner.
I hope you're all very proud of yourselves.
Sorry chap, pay the fine.
If you don't need the car, sell it. If you do, tax it.
ETA: If it is also uninsured you are VERY lucky you don't have 6 points and an IN10 on your licence.
Edited by NiceCupOfTea on Saturday 27th March 14:35
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



