Azelle Rodney - facts set to remain secret
Discussion
http://www.times-series.co.uk/news/8430474._Secret...
Can anyone explain why there is such a veil of secrecy over this investigation?
I am puzzled as to why the authorities don't just acknowledge that they had intelligence, rather than just clamming up.
It certainly does not show any sort of accountability in the normal way.
Can anyone explain why there is such a veil of secrecy over this investigation?
I am puzzled as to why the authorities don't just acknowledge that they had intelligence, rather than just clamming up.
It certainly does not show any sort of accountability in the normal way.
Mill Wheel said:
I am puzzled as to why the authorities don't just acknowledge that they had intelligence
Just a guess, but perhaps doing so ^ in any way that would be meaningful to the coroner's inquiries, would be at risk of compromising the safety of one or more informants? That would seem to be the obvious conclusion.Mill Wheel said:
Can anyone explain why there is such a veil of secrecy over this investigation?
This is normal where disclosure of the information available will disclose a source. If you gave information to the police that put your life, well being or property at risk, you would not want it disclosed in open court.Many cases have been pulled or have collapsed where defences have demanded the naming of sources.
All the reports I have read seem to indicate it was the result of electronic eavesdropping, which is what has puzzled me.
The way it is described at present makes it LOOK as though somebody was doing something wrong and doesn't wish to own up.
I can see why his mother is concerned - although she appears to accept that his death was not entirely unwarranted - or perhaps that is just the manner in which it is being reported.
The way it is described at present makes it LOOK as though somebody was doing something wrong and doesn't wish to own up.
I can see why his mother is concerned - although she appears to accept that his death was not entirely unwarranted - or perhaps that is just the manner in which it is being reported.
Mill Wheel said:
It certainly does not show any sort of accountability in the normal way.
Which sort of accountability do you mean? Criminal wise, the firearms officers would no doubt have had their actions examined to the degree that had they shot unlawfully they would be tried. The surrounding facts suggest the guy was involved in some serious level criminality to warrant such careful disclosure of intelligence etc.
So far the normal channels have been circumvented by the need to keep some part of the police involvement secret.
The coroners court's investigations are described as:
Is there not some means by which this case can be properly and openly investigated, and the public's mind be set at rest?
Conducting so much of this in secret is not good for justice, and will inevitably lead to claims of a cover up.
Ahh... it already did in the case of Jean de Menezes... just a short while after this case! And look what happened there!
The coroners court's investigations are described as:
Jordan v UK said:
The investigation must be effective (in the sense that it must be conducted in a manner that does not undermine its ability to establish the relevant facts
The investigation must be conducted with reasonable expedition
To maintain the public confidence in the rule of law and to prevent any appearance of collusion or tolerance of unlawful acts
So far this case appears to have fallen down on those aims, and the only recourse offered is a further secret inquiry.The investigation must be conducted with reasonable expedition
To maintain the public confidence in the rule of law and to prevent any appearance of collusion or tolerance of unlawful acts
Is there not some means by which this case can be properly and openly investigated, and the public's mind be set at rest?
Conducting so much of this in secret is not good for justice, and will inevitably lead to claims of a cover up.
Ahh... it already did in the case of Jean de Menezes... just a short while after this case! And look what happened there!
Mill Wheel said:
Is there not some means by which this case can be properly and openly investigated, and the public's mind be set at rest?
I assume that would have already been explored. I wouldn't say it won't be properly investigated just because we won't know the details. As I've already said, there are no criminal charges. It's pretty much certain there would have been at this stage if there were ever going to be. Rarely do Coroners' Court verdicts make the CPS change their minds. Especially with the thoroughness and accuracy that will be applied to police firearms incidents. In terms of why it's a secret, there's so much potential speculation that can be done. But given the excpetional nature of this hearing it's fair to assume there must be significant and highly sensitive information that if disclosed would put someone at serious risk of harm. For example, if person X has told the police that person Y has a firearm and is about to kill person Z, and this information the basis for the fatal interaction, the police will never disclose who person X is in normal circumstances.
I doubt the decision to keep everything hidden is one that has been taken lightly. Given the link between the justice system and the Human Rights Act that's keen on words like, "proportional", "necessary" and "reasonable", I would further assume that there is significant policy and procedure in place to ensure that trials like this are only done when justified.
One of the problems with secrecy is knowing where to stop.
For example, answer the following questions ["would" implies certainty (e.g. approaching 1.0), "could" implies a good possibility (say, 0.5-0.9), "might" implies a fair degree of uncertainty (say 0.3-0.5)]:
- Should details of a technique or technology be disclosed if to do so would compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should details of a technique or technology be disclosed if to do so could compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should details of a technique or technology be disclosed if to do so might compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should the fact of the use of a technique or technology be disclosed if to do so would compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should the fact of the use of a technique or technology be disclosed if to do so could compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should the fact of the use of a technique or technology be disclosed if to do so might compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should the existance of a technique or technology be disclosed if to do so would compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should the existance of a technique or technology be disclosed if to do so could compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should the existance of a technique or technology be disclosed if to do so might compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should the name of an informant be disclosed if to do so would compromise the life or limb of that informant?
- Should the name of an informant be disclosed if to do so could compromise the life or limb of that informant?
- Should the name of an informant be disclosed if to do so might compromise the life or limb of that informant?
- Should the name of an informant be disclosed if to do so would compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should the name of an informant be disclosed if to do so could compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should the name of an informant be disclosed if to do so might compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should the existance of an unnamed informant be disclosed if to do so would compromise the life or limb of that informant - through them being subsequently identified, for example, by the reduction of candidate possibilities?
- Should the existance of an unnamed informant be disclosed if to do so could compromise the life or limb of that informant - through them being subsequently identified, for example, by the reduction of candidate possibilities?
- Should the existance of an unnamed informant be disclosed if to do so might compromise the life or limb of that informant - through them being subsequently identified, for example, by the reduction of candidate possibilities?
- Should the existance of an unnamed informant be disclosed if to do so would compromise the life or limb of others - for example, by exposing them to the probability of torture as a means of identifying the informant?
- Should the existance of a an unnamed informant be disclosed if to do so could compromise the life or limb of others - for example, by exposing them to the likelihood of torture as a means of identifying the informant?
- Should the existance of a an unnamed informant be disclosed if to do so might compromise the life or limb of others - for example, by exposing them to the possibility of torture as a means of identifying the informant?
- Should the existance of an unnamed informant be disclosed if to do so would compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should the existance of an unnamed informant be disclosed if to do so could compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should the existance of an unnamed informant be disclosed if to do so might compromise on-going and future operations?
In an attempt to illustrate the presumed issues involved in this case, I have adapted the above from the sort of risk assessment performed for operations involving intelligence-gathering by technical means and from human assets [Note: this is not knowingly drawn from any UK police manual.]
It's easier for most people to decide to put technology at risk of harm rather than people, because we naturally tend to think in humanitarian terms. But sometimes, protecting the knowledge of a secret technique or technology can be more important than protecting lives. The decision Prime Minister Churchill made to hazard the people and city of Coventry to protect the Ultra secret is typical of this ... and must have been one of the hardest he ever made.
Streaky
For example, answer the following questions ["would" implies certainty (e.g. approaching 1.0), "could" implies a good possibility (say, 0.5-0.9), "might" implies a fair degree of uncertainty (say 0.3-0.5)]:
- Should details of a technique or technology be disclosed if to do so would compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should details of a technique or technology be disclosed if to do so could compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should details of a technique or technology be disclosed if to do so might compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should the fact of the use of a technique or technology be disclosed if to do so would compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should the fact of the use of a technique or technology be disclosed if to do so could compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should the fact of the use of a technique or technology be disclosed if to do so might compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should the existance of a technique or technology be disclosed if to do so would compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should the existance of a technique or technology be disclosed if to do so could compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should the existance of a technique or technology be disclosed if to do so might compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should the name of an informant be disclosed if to do so would compromise the life or limb of that informant?
- Should the name of an informant be disclosed if to do so could compromise the life or limb of that informant?
- Should the name of an informant be disclosed if to do so might compromise the life or limb of that informant?
- Should the name of an informant be disclosed if to do so would compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should the name of an informant be disclosed if to do so could compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should the name of an informant be disclosed if to do so might compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should the existance of an unnamed informant be disclosed if to do so would compromise the life or limb of that informant - through them being subsequently identified, for example, by the reduction of candidate possibilities?
- Should the existance of an unnamed informant be disclosed if to do so could compromise the life or limb of that informant - through them being subsequently identified, for example, by the reduction of candidate possibilities?
- Should the existance of an unnamed informant be disclosed if to do so might compromise the life or limb of that informant - through them being subsequently identified, for example, by the reduction of candidate possibilities?
- Should the existance of an unnamed informant be disclosed if to do so would compromise the life or limb of others - for example, by exposing them to the probability of torture as a means of identifying the informant?
- Should the existance of a an unnamed informant be disclosed if to do so could compromise the life or limb of others - for example, by exposing them to the likelihood of torture as a means of identifying the informant?
- Should the existance of a an unnamed informant be disclosed if to do so might compromise the life or limb of others - for example, by exposing them to the possibility of torture as a means of identifying the informant?
- Should the existance of an unnamed informant be disclosed if to do so would compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should the existance of an unnamed informant be disclosed if to do so could compromise on-going and future operations?
- Should the existance of an unnamed informant be disclosed if to do so might compromise on-going and future operations?
In an attempt to illustrate the presumed issues involved in this case, I have adapted the above from the sort of risk assessment performed for operations involving intelligence-gathering by technical means and from human assets [Note: this is not knowingly drawn from any UK police manual.]
It's easier for most people to decide to put technology at risk of harm rather than people, because we naturally tend to think in humanitarian terms. But sometimes, protecting the knowledge of a secret technique or technology can be more important than protecting lives. The decision Prime Minister Churchill made to hazard the people and city of Coventry to protect the Ultra secret is typical of this ... and must have been one of the hardest he ever made.
Streaky
Permission for a judicial review of Sir Christopher Holland’s conclusion that Azelle Rodney was unlawfully killed has been denied. Prosecutors are considering whether to bring charges against the met officer who killed him. Hmmm, given the history of secrecy around this case I will be very surprised if it ever comes to court. If it is blocked I wonder what excuse will be trotted out this time.
davidball said:
I do not know what your point is.
His point is that a single judge making a decision which he believes is manifestly wrong, is disconcerting.I believe he also seeks to imply that there is a concern over this case which renders a refusal to permit the matter to be revisited in open court, even more of a concern perhaps an indication that there is something to be hidden...
But he may well correct me, that's just how I inferred it.
Martin4x4 said:
davidball said:
"The hurdle of proving that Sir Christopher reached irrational conclusions on the facts is incapable of being surmounted."
So the Judge is a doddering old fool, tell me something new.I want to say how absurd it is that Judge can legally decide what someone else was thinking at a point in time.
But - that judge has access to all those secret files and classified evidence.
He knows stuff we don't.
Every day judges make decisions about suspects thoughts, from shoplifters claiming they 'forgot' they had stuff in their pockets to murderers saying it was an accident.
So, I find it odd, but not absurd.
I'd like to know more, but I have no reason or rights to have that request realised.
Altbough one Judge made the decision I'm sure it's been reviewed by several others who all agreed.
La Liga said:
n my experience Judges are, in general, far from foolish.
Warning. Tangent ahead.Many years ago I recall reading an article in a red top about how out if touch judges were.
The story was something to do with abh and someone had referenced "Linfords Lunch box".
The judge stopped proceeding and asked for the term to be explained.
The paper made a big deal if the judge not understanding the purse and how foolish he was.
It was only later I realised that the Judge probably wanted it explained for the court transcripts - so anyone reading it later would be able to understand.
I'm sure there are posters on here today who have no idea what it means.
But, I think there is a tendency for people to try and think of judges as daft old duffers in silly wigs sitting in ivory towers.
Gassing Station | Speed, Plod & the Law | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


