Does the LAW have a duty to protect us from ourselves??
Does the LAW have a duty to protect us from ourselves??
Author
Discussion

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
The "new kind of speeding camera" thread got me thinking. At what point in the history of Law in the UK did the requirement to protect people from themselves occur?? For example, wearing seatbelts in a car, a legal requirement, but why??

(if you don't wear a seatbelt in a car then surely it's your own choice, i.e. because you just are either willing to take the risk, or because you haven't even thought about the consequences etc. And surely, the potential for death or serious disfigurement ought to be enough of a preventative measure, one to which a £60 fine and a few points is unlikely add much of a deterent)

So , why do we have laws that effectively take away personal choice, for no benefit to others???

(and will we ever get back to a society of "personal responsibility" rather than "blame someone else"???

(any Legalisers on PH care to comment?)

TheEnd

15,370 posts

219 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
Possibly since ancient times, as the Bible has said something along the lines of life is sacred, so Suicide is off the menu.

southendpier

6,240 posts

260 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
because we grow up being conditioned to submit to authority at school. We control ourselves as a society, the police nor army could stop a revolution. We stop us through fear and uncertainty of what the personal cost may be eg death.

Rules add to this.


marshalla

15,902 posts

232 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
Some of the laws do benefit others thought. Taking your example of seat belt law -

How many people have not died as a result of accidents ?
How many families have not been devastated by the loss of a family member because the law required them to wear a seatbelt ?
How much money has the NHS "saved" because people involved in accidents suffered less serious injuries because they were wearing seatbelts ?


Sometimes a law which appears to protect an individual actually benefits more people in the long run.


judas

6,250 posts

290 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
Should you have a crash while wearing no seatbelt some poor bugger has to pick up what's left of you and stick it in a plastic bag. Not much fun I imagine. Then, should you survive, there's all the expense of the emergency services, hospital treatment, convalescence, physiotherapy etc. for which the taxpayers foot the bill. On top of that is all the trauma for those involved - lost working time etc. Whereas if you'd worn a seatbelt you may well escape with significantly less injury and all that entails.

In short, the law's not there to protect you from yourself, it's there to protect everyone else and the taxpayers money.

HTH wink

cazzer

8,883 posts

279 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
The NHS, pure and simple.

If there was no NHS and you paid for your own treatment there would be no seatbelt law. Or helmet law.
They don't give a st if you want to kill yourself or not. They just don't want you to cost money.

ZOLLAR

19,920 posts

204 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
cazzer said:
The NHS, pure and simple.

If there was no NHS and you paid for your own treatment there would be no seatbelt law. Or helmet law.
They don't give a st if you want to kill yourself or not. They just don't want you to cost money.
But isn't it law in America that you have to wear a seatbelt?, don't they pay for their own health care rather than the government?.

cazzer

8,883 posts

279 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
ZOLLAR said:
cazzer said:
The NHS, pure and simple.

If there was no NHS and you paid for your own treatment there would be no seatbelt law. Or helmet law.
They don't give a st if you want to kill yourself or not. They just don't want you to cost money.
But isn't it law in America that you have to wear a seatbelt?, don't they pay for their own health care rather than the government?.
Yes and a huge number of people ignore it and it's very very rarely enforced unless they stop you for something else.

tank slapper

7,949 posts

314 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
marshalla said:
How many people have not died as a result of accidents ? Irrelevant - If someone wishes to disregard the advantage of wearing a seatbelt, then they surely have accepted the increased risk of their death.

How many families have not been devastated by the loss of a family member because the law required them to wear a seatbelt ? An appeal to emotion, and also irrelevant. If someone wish to disregard the increased likelihood of death through not wearing a seatbelt, then they also choose to disregard the effect it might have on their family.

How much money has the NHS "saved" because people involved in accidents suffered less serious injuries because they were wearing seatbelts ? Again an irrelevance. People are forced to pay for the NHS, whether they want to or not. Their behaviour therefore has no bearing on treatment, and nor should it as long as they have no option but to pay.
The state interferes in people's lives in places it has no business doing, because it can. Simply because they think they know better. The law should have no duty to protect people from themselves, assuming they are of sound mind. Advise and educate where possible, yes. Compel, no.

ZOLLAR

19,920 posts

204 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
cazzer said:
ZOLLAR said:
cazzer said:
The NHS, pure and simple.

If there was no NHS and you paid for your own treatment there would be no seatbelt law. Or helmet law.
They don't give a st if you want to kill yourself or not. They just don't want you to cost money.
But isn't it law in America that you have to wear a seatbelt?, don't they pay for their own health care rather than the government?.
Yes and a huge number of people ignore it and it's very very rarely enforced unless they stop you for something else.
Ah i see!.

Mr Dave

3,233 posts

226 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
ZOLLAR said:
cazzer said:
The NHS, pure and simple.

If there was no NHS and you paid for your own treatment there would be no seatbelt law. Or helmet law.
They don't give a st if you want to kill yourself or not. They just don't want you to cost money.
But isn't it law in America that you have to wear a seatbelt?, don't they pay for their own health care rather than the government?.
In some states it isnt the law AFAIK

Pesty

42,655 posts

287 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
cazzer said:
The NHS, pure and simple.

If there was no NHS and you paid for your own treatment there would be no seatbelt law. Or helmet law.
They don't give a st if you want to kill yourself or not. They just don't want you to cost money.
How many people who where severely injured wearing seatbelts i.e costing money would have died not wearing one i.e saving money.

the only person who lived in diana's crash was the body guard because he was wearing a seatbelt. He had treatment for years the others didn't cost anything (relativly).

can you supply us with the data to back up your idea that its a money saving thing?

ZOLLAR

19,920 posts

204 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
Mr Dave said:
ZOLLAR said:
cazzer said:
The NHS, pure and simple.

If there was no NHS and you paid for your own treatment there would be no seatbelt law. Or helmet law.
They don't give a st if you want to kill yourself or not. They just don't want you to cost money.
But isn't it law in America that you have to wear a seatbelt?, don't they pay for their own health care rather than the government?.
In some states it isnt the law AFAIK
Yeah i was just thinking they have different laws in different states.

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
Does the seatbelt law for example actually stop people from driving without one?? I can't really immagine that anyone would consider it to be a deterent in itself?? Who goes out, gets into a car and doesn't belt up, then thinks, cripes, might get fined £60 so then puts their belt on??

Si_steve

1,190 posts

221 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
Max_Torque said:
Does the seatbelt law for example actually stop people from driving without one?? I can't really immagine that anyone would consider it to be a deterent in itself?? Who goes out, gets into a car and doesn't belt up, then thinks, cripes, might get fined £60 so then puts their belt on??
Some people dont enjoy paying fines.

Ari

19,837 posts

246 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
Max_Torque said:
So , why do we have laws that effectively take away personal choice, for no benefit to others???
Because the country is full of people too stupid to think for themselves.

Take the seatbelt law quoted above. No one with any common sense would drive without one, yet before the law many did.

So, sadly, the law has to protect people against themselves because so many of them are so bloody stupid!

hidetheelephants

36,442 posts

224 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
Si_steve said:
Max_Torque said:
Does the seatbelt law for example actually stop people from driving without one?? I can't really immagine that anyone would consider it to be a deterent in itself?? Who goes out, gets into a car and doesn't belt up, then thinks, cripes, might get fined £60 so then puts their belt on??
Some people dont enjoy paying fines.
3 points on the licence is good disincentive, as is the prospect of ending up with a face like a broken wall in the event of a fenderbender.

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
Does anyone enjoy smashing windscreens with their face??? (actually, i bet someone does, it's a funny old world ;-)

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
WHY does society have to protect the stupid though?? 1000's of years ago, if you walked out of your cave in the morning, and there was a tiger waiting for you, if you were too stupid to run, then nature took it's toll, and bingo, the stupid person was "deselcted" and the tiger got a tastey breakfast (a-ha, thats where Tony the Tiger must have started....)

Now, we would have to have a law baning tigers for waiting outside caves just incase a stupid person got hurt??

Rotary Madness

2,285 posts

217 months

Thursday 4th November 2010
quotequote all
Pesty said:
cazzer said:
The NHS, pure and simple.

If there was no NHS and you paid for your own treatment there would be no seatbelt law. Or helmet law.
They don't give a st if you want to kill yourself or not. They just don't want you to cost money.
How many people who where severely injured wearing seatbelts i.e costing money would have died not wearing one i.e saving money.

the only person who lived in diana's crash was the body guard because he was wearing a seatbelt. He had treatment for years the others didn't cost anything (relativly).

can you supply us with the data to back up your idea that its a money saving thing?
And how much did Diana's funeral cost? Im pretty sure the royal family didnt pck up the bill, the taxpayer did.