GT5...Which Wheel?
Author
Discussion

Castrol Craig

Original Poster:

18,073 posts

235 months

Monday 27th December 2010
quotequote all
So, ive decided i cant get competitive with the quick lad online & PH Time Trial thread until i get a wheel sorted.

So, a few questions, which one, and has anyone on here got a good one for sale?


Distorshion wave

3,844 posts

205 months

Monday 27th December 2010
quotequote all
Get the gt wheel.

£80 from argos, thats what i have. biggrin

Altrezia

8,740 posts

240 months

Monday 27th December 2010
quotequote all
Yep good wheels. Or, G25/G27 might be a good bet if you've got a few more quid. I could be convinced to sell my G27..

Funk

27,645 posts

238 months

Monday 27th December 2010
quotequote all
I sold my G25 and regretted it..

Original Poster

5,429 posts

205 months

Monday 27th December 2010
quotequote all
Fanatec are the ultimate wheels, although expensive.

andrew186

159 posts

192 months

Monday 27th December 2010
quotequote all
ive got the g27

highly recommend it

Sway

35,067 posts

223 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
If you're thinking of spending g27/fanatec money, might be worth waiting another couple of weeks to see the new official thrustmaster wheel.

10kg for the wheel, 16 kg for the pedals, industrial motor for force feeback, and convertible pedals between floor and top mount... 150N force on the brake pedal as well...

I heard on here it will be £400, and the shifter is additional, but the specs sound very, very good.

Simond S

4,519 posts

306 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
Distorshion wave said:
Get the gt wheel.

£80 from argos, thats what i have. biggrin
Me too. makes the game a whole lot better smile

S3_Graham

12,835 posts

228 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
all depends how much you want to spend tbh, If you want to spend £50 look at second hand GT force wheels *cough* mine *cough* if you want to spend under £100 a new GT force and then you jump to 2nd hand G25 or New Fanatec carrera/turbo which would be £115+, then there is the jump to where im at atm, a fanatec GT3 rs which inc pedals cost me £240. Then there is G27 at just over £300 and the Fanatec GT3 RS clubsport at 400.

they are pretty much your options.

E21_Ross

36,729 posts

241 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Logitech-941-000046-G27-Ra...

will that work with the ps3 yeh?

cheers smile

Patrick Bateman

13,151 posts

203 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
As I've said before although I'm sure the G27 is a bit better than the G25, I can't see it justifying the massive price difference.

SteveC123

54 posts

215 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
S3_Graham said:
If you want to spend £50 look at second hand GT force wheels *cough* mine *cough*
Nasty cough you have there...

(Bank transfer agreeable for the wheel? If so, I'll take it - email me) wink

rich0411

234 posts

209 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
E21_Ross said:
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Logitech-941-000046-G27-Ra...

will that work with the ps3 yeh?

cheers smile
Before you buy that maybe worth a look on play.com

£229 inc delivery

http://www.play.com/PC/PCs/4-/12096740/Logitech-G2...

LocoBlade

7,653 posts

285 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
Funk said:
I sold my G25 and regretted it..
Im glad you did though! biggrin

Still giving good service although doesnt get used as much as Id like due to the PS3 being under the main TV and the wife not taking too well to watching TV in the bedroom that often! Got it mounted to a Wheelstand Pro though which makes all the difference, 2 minute setup and perfect position as opposed to 15 minutes dicking around with the ironing board, a bit of wood and some G clamps every time it was required, then trying to get my legs past the ironing board legs to work the pedals biggrin

LocoBlade

7,653 posts

285 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
The G27 is marginally better than the G25 in a couple of ways but one thing the G25 does that the G27 doesn't is allow the gear shift to be converted from H pattern to sequential shift. I know the H shifter on the G27 is meant to be nicer to use than the G25, but it's still a significant omission IMHO as I find the H pattern shift / clutch combo too hit and miss for serious gameplay. If you don't fully hold the clutch down - shift - then lift the clutch up in that order then the game (GT5 Prologue at least, not tried it on GT5 yet) would give you a false neutral maybe 20-30% of the time, which is bloody annoying and really isnt particularly realistic, you might eventually break a dog ring with a fully depressed stab of the clutch whilst you shift quickly and dont time it right but rarely will it miss a gear, and changing gear like you would on an old school bus to ensure a reliable gearchange makes you too slow, so I suspect you'd end up using the paddles all the time.

Either way though I've found the clutch and H change is nice to play around with and show your mates but in reality a rarely used feature in serious gameplay. Others might have different opinions of the H shift but for me I think something like a Driving Force GT with 2 pedal setup and sequential shifter on the main body would probably be just as good, assuming the other aspects are as good as the G25, namely feedback and the pedal / general build quality.

Edited by LocoBlade on Tuesday 28th December 20:51

y2blade

56,318 posts

244 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
Simond S said:
Distorshion wave said:
Get the gt wheel.

£80 from argos, thats what i have. biggrin
Me too. makes the game a whole lot better smile
+1
got a GT pro for Christmas
makes GT5 EVEN better yes

Altrezia

8,740 posts

240 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
LocoBlade said:
The G27 is marginally better than the G25 in a couple of ways but one thing the G25 does that the G27 doesn't is allow the gear shift to be converted from H pattern to sequential shift. I know the H shifter on the G27 is meant to be nicer to use than the G25, but it's still a significant omission IMHO as I find the H pattern shift / clutch combo too hit and miss for serious gameplay. If you don't fully hold the clutch down - shift - then lift the clutch up in that order then the game (GT5 Prologue at least, not tried it on GT5 yet) would give you a false neutral maybe 20-30% of the time, which is bloody annoying and really isnt particularly realistic, you might eventually break a dog ring with a fully depressed stab of the clutch whilst you shift quickly and dont time it right but rarely will it miss a gear, and changing gear like you would on an old school bus to ensure a reliable gearchange makes you too slow, so I suspect you'd end up using the paddles all the time.

Either way though I've found the clutch and H change is nice to play around with and show your mates but in reality a rarely used feature in serious gameplay. Others might have different opinions of the H shift but for me I think something like a Driving Force GT with 2 pedal setup and sequential shifter on the main body would probably be just as good, assuming the other aspects are as good as the G25, namely feedback and the pedal / general build quality.

Edited by LocoBlade on Tuesday 28th December 20:51
It works better in other games - GT5 even, isn't as picky as Prologue was.


LocoBlade

7,653 posts

285 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
Altrezia said:
It works better in other games - GT5 even, isn't as picky as Prologue was.
OK cheers, will give it another bash in GT5 beer

Funk

27,645 posts

238 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
LocoBlade said:
Funk said:
I sold my G25 and regretted it..
Im glad you did though! biggrin

Still giving good service although doesnt get used as much as Id like due to the PS3 being under the main TV and the wife not taking too well to watching TV in the bedroom that often! Got it mounted to a Wheelstand Pro though which makes all the difference, 2 minute setup and perfect position as opposed to 15 minutes dicking around with the ironing board, a bit of wood and some G clamps every time it was required, then trying to get my legs past the ironing board legs to work the pedals biggrin
I'm toying with the idea of a new one now. D'oh!

Edited by Funk on Tuesday 28th December 23:20

Patrick Bateman

13,151 posts

203 months

Wednesday 29th December 2010
quotequote all
I always have the most fun using the manual gearbox rather than the shifter.