anyone tried one like this?
anyone tried one like this?
Author
Discussion

Upatdawn

Original Poster:

2,202 posts

177 months

tog

4,949 posts

257 months

Tuesday 12th February 2013
quotequote all
I tried a cheap Centon 500mm f8 many years (T2-EOS fit adapter, on film) ago and it was awful. I believe popular opinion says get a second hand Tamron if you want a 500mm mirror lens.

Upatdawn

Original Poster:

2,202 posts

177 months

Tuesday 12th February 2013
quotequote all
cheers

I think i meant "is an entry level 500/600mm mirror lens better than a non-mirror lens", if you follow

Edited by Upatdawn on Tuesday 12th February 15:33

tog

4,949 posts

257 months

Tuesday 12th February 2013
quotequote all
A decent mirror lens is capable of good results, but does have a few quirks in use. The aperture is fixed at f8 and there is no autofocus obviously (Minolta did make an AF version once upon a time). Highlights in out of focus areas will also tend to form rings instead of blobs. They are much smaller and lighter than a conventional 500mm too, and cheaper obviously. Whether you can live with the quirks of course depends what sort of use you want to put it to. I am often quite tempted to get one for the very rare occasions I need a 500mm. I used to have a Canon 500mm f4.5L but sold it when I realised how long it had been since I last used it (since I gave up doing hard news basically). Even my 300mm gets very little use now.

Upatdawn

Original Poster:

2,202 posts

177 months

Tuesday 12th February 2013
quotequote all
What would be good for a trip TAE Loch Ness?.....

(one on my "do before you die" list)

or would a 200mm and maximum MPixels be as good?

1e35

897 posts

237 months

Tuesday 12th February 2013
quotequote all
I have one of these, although not branded Samyang.
It comes with a Telescope mount with a camera adapter, so the lens is not as rigidly mounted to the camera as I would like.
Be aware that it has a small depth of field, and the focus range goes beyond infinity. This means that even for long distance shots you need to get the focus right.
I find that it works fine on my Film SLR which has a nice bright full frame viewfinder with split prism, but on my APS-C Digital it is difficult to get accurate focus.

HTH