Homework
Author
Discussion

le gravy noire

Original Poster:

1,857 posts

278 months

Friday 7th July 2006
quotequote all
A photo is only as interesting as its subject matter. Discuss.

V6GTO

11,579 posts

272 months

Friday 7th July 2006
quotequote all
Can a photograph make something interesting when in real life it's not?

Martin.

GregE240

10,857 posts

297 months

Friday 7th July 2006
quotequote all
I'll get the ball rolling.

I agree. You could spend the earth on equipment (as some on here regularly do), and yet, if you have no idea on how to compose a decent photograph, the results will suck.

Look at the winner each month of the photo competition - some taken on relatively cheap cameras, I'll wager.

Cameras can't take their own photographs, after all.

cy88

2,808 posts

260 months

Friday 7th July 2006
quotequote all
Depends entirely on how its executed. A photograph used as an art medium, executed properly, can have as its subject something utterly mundane. Likewise, something really captivating, snapped without any thought as to composition, can be completely spoilt and unintersting in print.

However, beauty will always be in the eye of the beholder - beware the family slide show!



Edited by cy88 on Friday 7th July 09:53

graham@reading

26,553 posts

255 months

Friday 7th July 2006
quotequote all
Disagree.

Some of the most boring items can produce interesting photographs yet a Spitfire buzzing you at 100 feet can be shot to look like an airfix kit hanging in the sky.

edit - bah..what they said

Edited by graham@reading on Friday 7th July 09:53

trackdemon

13,452 posts

291 months

Friday 7th July 2006
quotequote all
Disagree. Given freedom a good photographer can make an interesting photo of just about any subject no matter how dull.

le gravy noire

Original Poster:

1,857 posts

278 months

Friday 7th July 2006
quotequote all
Good to see your thoughts...

Personally I think that subject matter is king. I also think that the majority of people see straight through the photo and react to the subject matter rather than the photograph.

LongQ

13,864 posts

263 months

Friday 7th July 2006
quotequote all
le gravy noire said:
Good to see your thoughts...

Personally I think that subject matter is king. I also think that the majority of people see straight through the photo and react to the subject matter rather than the photograph.


Yes. Mostly. And for most people probably.

But every once in a while the image can hold interest from other angles - technical challenges for example. Or unusual context. Or, and I think this is quite common, historical context.