OCT COMP - Any ideas of how we work this?

[Mrs Fish]

Seeing as you were placed second in September's thread, and seeing as the winner seems to have gone on holiday without judging October's comp, do you fancy stepping in and judging instead please

[Mrs Fish]

Are you around?

[Mrs Fish]

Its looking increasingly like it will be down to third place at this rate....

[Mrs Fish]

Seeing as Furtive isn't around either.... any chance as third place you can judge this months comp?

[CY88]

Bump bumpity bump

[Mrs Fish]

Anyone have any other ideas of what to do?

[Mrs Fish]

Another title change

[Dogsey]

CY88 to judge it? It's his fault we're in this mess!

[KarlosFandango]

Didn't we do a poll last time something like this happened?

[nick_bbb]

If you're really stuck I haven't entered and am happy to be an independant judge.

[havoc]

This is getting silly.

Two options suggested both sound good:-
1) Independent judge
2) Poll by all those who have entered - private mails all sent to one person to collate (Mrs Fish if you're happy to, or I can volunteer if you prefer). Could then do either single vote or a 3-2-1 system* (which would be more likely to avoid a tie)

• 3pts for favourite, 2pts for 2nd fav, 1pt for 3rd fav...add them all up.

Edited by havoc on Thursday 1st November 12:58

[pbsaxman]

nick_bbb said:

If you're really stuck I haven't entered and am happy to be an independant judge.

For speed I think we should take Nick up on his offer and get this resolved. I also am happy to judge but am not well known on this forum and have posted no images here so would understand if you wish to have a proven 'expert'

Peter

[DJ_AS]

nick_bbb said:

If you're really stuck I haven't entered and am happy to be an independant judge.

Thats cool with me! Sounds simpler than collating loads of votes anyway.

[scotty328i]

I can be a second judge to if required

I have not submitted any images

[ruaricoles]

Yep, Nick bbb gets my vote too - we're losing time for November now!

Ruari

[CY88]

havoc said:

This is getting silly.

Two options suggested both sound good:-
1) Independent judge
2) Poll by all those who have entered - private mails all sent to one person to collate (Mrs Fish if you're happy to, or I can volunteer if you prefer). Could then do either single vote or a 3-2-1 system* (which would be more likely to avoid a tie)

• 3pts for favourite, 2pts for 2nd fav, 1pt for 3rd fav...add them all up.

Edited by havoc on Thursday 1st November 12:58

Hold on a second..... Havoc, you were second runner up last month, were you not? And you are now the only winner here from last month..... so, get judging!

[Mrs Fish]

Exactly - now you are here Havoc... GET JUDGING

[nick_bbb]

Mrs Fish said:

Exactly - now you are here Havoc... GET JUDGING

Bit late

[fluffnik]

nick_bbb said:

If you're really stuck I haven't entered and am happy to be an independant judge.

Sounds good to me.

[havoc]

Oops...I didn't see the intervening title thread. Wish I had...some nice pics this month...

OK...judging now...sorry guys...verdict by 10pm, I promise!


Edit...just seen Nick's verdicts...oops! B'gger!!!

Edited by havoc on Thursday 1st November 18:44