Antifreeze/Coolant Recommendations
Antifreeze/Coolant Recommendations
Author
Discussion

TVR-Stu

Original Poster:

829 posts

221 months

Friday 3rd February 2017
quotequote all
I've changed all the coolant pipes on my S3 (2.9) and want to put in fresh antifreeze.
After a quick search on here, always a bit hit or miss, and a Google search I am more confused than ever!
I planned on using a ready mixed product as I'm sure I read the minerals in the water cause half the problems?

What do you put in yours or what can you recommend?

If it makes any difference I have an aluminium radiator.

Thanks in advance, Stu.

lewdon

316 posts

187 months

Friday 3rd February 2017
quotequote all
I looked into this when I changed my coolant.
The conclusion was that we should use "old fashioned" IAT (inorganic additive technology) antifreeze, usually blue.
We should not use the newer OAT (organic acid technology) antifreeze, usually red or orange), as, though it is longer lasting and requires changing less frequently, it can damage the seals, gaskets, and any remaining rubber hoses in our old engines.
There are also other variations such as HOAT but the O still stands for organic so should be avoided.
Most cans now state whether the contents are IAT or OAT or you can check on line.
Hope that helps.

PS dont trust the colour to tell you which is which.



Edited by lewdon on Friday 3rd February 13:55


Edited by lewdon on Friday 3rd February 13:58

Kitchski

6,542 posts

253 months

Friday 3rd February 2017
quotequote all
[quote=lewdon]I looked into this when I changed my coolant.
The conclusion was that we should use "old fashioned" IAT (inorganic additive technology) antifreeze, usually blue.
We should not use the newer OAT (organic acid technology) antifreeze, usually red or orange), as, though it is longer lasting and requires changing less frequently, it can damage the seals, gaskets, and any remaining rubber hoses in our old engines.
There are also other variations such as HOAT but the O still stands for organic so should be avoided.
Most cans now state whether the contents are IAT or OAT or you can check on line.
Hope that helps.

PS dont trust the colour to tell you which is which.


This is all true, but generally speaking the blue 2yr stuff does tend to be the one you want. Not always, but usually. The red 5yr stuff is the stuff that can cause problems on older cars, though the main issue would be the old-school radiators, as they used soldered joints inside the core, which the newer antifreeze can attack. If you've an alloy rad, chances are you'd be fine there.

Griffinr

1,017 posts

196 months

Friday 3rd February 2017
quotequote all
Comma Xtream G48 (3 year life) is ok and readily available or something similar.

TVR-Stu

Original Poster:

829 posts

221 months

Friday 3rd February 2017
quotequote all
Thanks for clarifying things for me and for your replies chaps, I knew there would be some helpful advice on here. thumbup

alabbasi

3,098 posts

109 months

Saturday 4th February 2017
quotequote all
The green stuff is just fine if you change it every couple of years. For long life, Ford (at least in the USA) uses G05 chemistry which is the same as what was offered for Mercedes Benz and Chrysler from the 90's.