What's the Best Italian in York please?
What's the Best Italian in York please?
Author
Discussion

StuB

Original Poster:

6,695 posts

268 months

Monday 16th April 2007
quotequote all
The in laws are coming down this weekend and Mrs. B's father is of good Tuscan stock, ex-restaurant owner and now Italian wine and food importer, so it needs to be very authentic rather than trendy. Flash is not a problem, so long as the proprietor/chef and the food/wine are the real deal.

Tonto

2,983 posts

277 months

Monday 16th April 2007
quotequote all
StuB said:
The in laws are coming down this weekend and Mrs. B's father is of good Tuscan stock, ex-restaurant owner and now Italian wine and food importer, so it needs to be very authentic rather than trendy. Flash is not a problem, so long as the proprietor/chef and the food/wine are the real deal.


Would have been better if he was of Tamora stock, but thats just because I've got one.
paperbag sorry.

(Err can't help on the York thing, someone will be along soon).

speed8

5,124 posts

302 months

Monday 16th April 2007
quotequote all
Don't know in York but would be interested in where is good as Miss8 is from Tuscany too and likes a good bit of Italian food on occasion.


How's your Tamora, Tonto???

StuB

Original Poster:

6,695 posts

268 months

Monday 16th April 2007
quotequote all
speed8 said:
Don't know in York but would be interested in where is good as Miss8 is from Tuscany too and likes a good bit of Italian food on occasion.


With a rather tenuous PH related theme, I can recommend Capri in Selby, opposite the Minster. Medici in North Ferriby got a tick from Don Vito too.

hobo

6,597 posts

275 months

Tonto

2,983 posts

277 months

Monday 16th April 2007
quotequote all
speed8 said:
Don't know in York but would be interested in where is good as Miss8 is from Tuscany too and likes a good bit of Italian food on occasion.


How's your Tamora, Tonto???



Suspension being sorted as we speak (front is too low and hitting bump stops).
Car is feckin quick though! Headed out of Leeds on A65 on Sunday with a 360 following me and he couldn't keep up!

(Sorry for O/T post).

willyworm

433 posts

268 months

Monday 16th April 2007
quotequote all
Try Del Rio's at Micklelgate Bar. Nice atmosphere and not too trendy.

StuB

Original Poster:

6,695 posts

268 months

Monday 16th April 2007
quotequote all
hobo said:


So can anyone recommend a good Italian in Yorkshire? Those reviews are pretty discouraging, to say the least!

wildoliver

9,296 posts

245 months

Monday 16th April 2007
quotequote all
To be honest I would be intereted in the outcome of this thread as I have tried most of the italians in York and suspect that the majority of the staff in most of them would struggle to even point out italy on a map, I know a half decent french, which is cafe rouge which even though it is a chain is pretty authentic, I also know a good greek which is mana, which is run by a grumpy fat greek man who charges a service charge, but the food is worth it.

Italians though are a different matter, about 5 years ago I used to go to one in pocklington but then it went right downhill, even though it hasn't changed owner and they are genuine italians.

burriana

16,556 posts

283 months

Monday 16th April 2007
quotequote all
Tonto said:

Car is feckin quick though! Headed out of Leeds on A65 on Sunday with a 360 following me and he couldn't keep up!


The Tamoras are quick no doubt Tony. The two cars are very similar performance upto about 140 then the 360 would slowly take over onto it's 10-15mph higher top speed depending which data you believe.

speed8

5,124 posts

302 months

Monday 16th April 2007
quotequote all
StuB said:
hobo said:


So can anyone recommend a good Italian in Yorkshire? Those reviews are pretty discouraging, to say the least!


To be honest that guy seems more Pizza hut than Naples. He'd probably be happy with stuffed crust and extra everything on a super thick base.

There's a place Paola likes in Leeds Centre. Quite a few of the waiters and waitresses are from Tuscany. Probably a bit too far for you but I'll ask her the name in the morning unless someone else knows the place I'm talking about. It's a bit flashy but the foods good and some decent choice.

wildoliver

9,296 posts

245 months

Monday 16th April 2007
quotequote all
theres a brilliant italian in leeds run by real italians lol.

Can't remember the name of the place but mama always plays her italian operetta's full blast in to the town centre so not hard to find for a spot of lunch! Cheap too! Just what an italian should be, cheap, cheerful, cheesecloth covers on the tables, mad italians obsessed with italia 90, go in you'll like it!

blueyonder

1,779 posts

239 months

Monday 16th April 2007
quotequote all
StuB

La Locanda in Wetherby - if it still exists....by the river on the LHS at the top end of Wetherby as you head out to Harrogate.
Also isn't Ceasars on Monkgate in York an Italian....pretty sure it is yes

c2look

3,858 posts

254 months

Monday 16th April 2007
quotequote all
blueyonder said:
StuB

La Locanda in Wetherby - if it still exists....by the river on the LHS at the top end of Wetherby as you head out to Harrogate.
Also isn't Ceasars on Monkgate in York an Italian....pretty sure it is yes


Ceasars have just opened in Haxby, spot on from what I've heard so far.

elster

17,517 posts

239 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
I will remember the name later.

but the one under micklegate opposite to the punchbowl.

That is the best italian, rather than English version of italian

S3_Steve

274 posts

279 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
blueyonder said:
StuB

La Locanda in Wetherby - if it still exists....by the river on the LHS at the top end of Wetherby as you head out to Harrogate.


It moved a few years ago to Collingham (2 miles outside wetherby on the A58 to Leeds on the LHS as you enter the village).

minimax

11,985 posts

285 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
StuB said:
The in laws are coming down this weekend and Mrs. B's father is of good Tuscan stock, ex-restaurant owner and now Italian wine and food importer, so it needs to be very authentic rather than trendy. Flash is not a problem, so long as the proprietor/chef and the food/wine are the real deal.



not that I know much about what is or is not genuine Italian stuff, but Totos opposite the barbican is fantastic, old school service, all-italian staff and not 'trendy' as such, more just a nice italian place with good food and a good atmosphere.

if you have the means, I highly recommend it thumbup
/Bueller

speed8

5,124 posts

302 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
Paola says she likes Piccolinos in Leeds.
She usually phones up and chats in Italian with them so I don't know if that influences our food any but it's always nice.

She's asking where in Tuscany are they from??

ellroy

7,816 posts

254 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
My vote goes for the one just outside Micklegate bar, Delrio's. From memory its Sardinian rather than Tuscan, but very good.

If you're looking at lunchtime try La Bottega Delle Langhe on Goodramgate it looks like a deli, which it is, but at the back they have a small sit down place, all the stuff they sell is imported wine, oils, meats and cheese etc and thats all they serve along with home baked bread. The owner's italian always in behind the counter. Top place.

David911rsr

1,446 posts

239 months

Tuesday 17th April 2007
quotequote all
Both Piccolinos & La Locanda are part of a chain! The best most althentic Italian in the Harrogate/Leeds area is Sasso in Harrogate.