help
Author
Discussion

xdebbx

Original Poster:

1 posts

260 months

Wednesday 19th January 2005
quotequote all
can anyone who has a opinion on the sale of T.V.R to Smolenski let me know how they feel about it....i have to do a talk on it on monday and i would welcome some enthusiast opinions rather than just the statistics i can get off the net......my e-mail is xdebbx@aol.com
thanks debbie

raceboy

13,889 posts

309 months

Wednesday 19th January 2005
quotequote all
A search of the archives is probably your best bet....
We don't really need this all dragging up again

anonymous-user

83 months

Wednesday 19th January 2005
quotequote all
It's not contentious is it?

Financial stability / fab new models / improved quality control etc...

The future's bright, the future's Russian.

For a more informed opinion email Mungo

_Deejay_

5,057 posts

283 months

Wednesday 19th January 2005
quotequote all
unrepentant said:
It's not contentious is it?

Financial stability / fab new models / improved quality control etc...

The future's bright, the future's Russian.

For a more informed opinion email Mungo


It's a great idea. We all love orgasmic living (rumoured to be related to the other 'products' he produces), no discounted speed-6 rebuilds, increased staff turnover, limited runs of 500 cars, 'excellent factory communication' etc etc.

We all wait with baited breath for the next wonderful idea taken from those years of experience in the industry....

(and yes, I know the slogan was dropped, no speed-6 engine has ever failed without being thrashed to 6k revs when cold every day, limited runs will ensure low depreciation (just like the t350), the factory were always c*ap at talking to paying customers etc).



anonymous-user

83 months

Wednesday 19th January 2005
quotequote all
Have you never made a mistake? Orgasmic living was laughable and quite rightly it's been dropped. As far as communication is concerned, I was pleasantly surprised to get the letter from BS at Christmas (can't ever recall that before). The quality of the new cars is also reported to be much better, certainly the ones I have seen in the showroom looked very well finished.

Surely rather than condemn him we should give the guy a chance?

HarryW

16,013 posts

298 months

Wednesday 19th January 2005
quotequote all
As a 'new broom' things will always get swept aside. The apparent keenness, in which legacy items are being discarded, whilst understandable, seems to forget that TVR's main market and its customer base is its existing owners. To alienate them is to put yourself in difficult waters.
The withdrawing of the cerbera is premature IMHO, a replacement needs to be announced first, the Typhon is too far a bigger price step to be considered a replacement IMHO.
The Speed6 whilst a great performer, it is a leap of faith by those that have bought it, to say you the factory will no longer carry out repairs at the factories expense is unacceptable, see previous line about alienating existing customer base .
TVR's have for decades been associated with big loud V8's, there is currently not one in the line up , this is a major marketing mistake IMHO, even 'lesser' manufacturers are carving niches in V8 engine car market at present, why isn't TVR there to defend its mantle .
The right 'sound bites and spin' seem to be coming out of the factory, is there any substance to these though . Most bright people in the UK are developing a reflex reaction to sound bites thanks to the incumbent party at present. Unfortunately this reaction is to stop listening, regardless. Deeds not words, which may be old school, are what people want, something tangible.

Rant finished .

Harry

_Deejay_

5,057 posts

283 months

Wednesday 19th January 2005
quotequote all
unrepentant said:
Have you never made a mistake? Orgasmic living was laughable and quite rightly it's been dropped. As far as communication is concerned, I was pleasantly surprised to get the letter from BS at Christmas (can't ever recall that before). The quality of the new cars is also reported to be much better, certainly the ones I have seen in the showroom looked very well finished.

Surely rather than condemn him we should give the guy a chance?


Yep, but not that many in quick succession.
The future is Russian, but not necessarily bright, more 'in the balance'. It could work out well, it might not.

Reports on PH would suggest that quality is not massively improved, though the long term fruits of their 'quality control labour' remains to be seen.

I'd prefer not to take the 'rose tinted' view and I'll also not condemn the new regime. In my opinion, it's just too early to call it.....


CiderwithCerbie

1,420 posts

296 months

Wednesday 19th January 2005
quotequote all
_Deejay_ said:

unrepentant said:
Have you never made a mistake? Orgasmic living was laughable and quite rightly it's been dropped. As far as communication is concerned, I was pleasantly surprised to get the letter from BS at Christmas (can't ever recall that before). The quality of the new cars is also reported to be much better, certainly the ones I have seen in the showroom looked very well finished.

Surely rather than condemn him we should give the guy a chance?



Yep, but not that many in quick succession.
The future is Russian, but not necessarily bright, more 'in the balance'. It could work out well, it might not.

Reports on PH would suggest that quality is not massively improved, though the long term fruits of their 'quality control labour' remains to be seen.

I'd prefer not to take the 'rose tinted' view and I'll also not condemn the new regime. In my opinion, it's just too early to call it.....




If I were an investor or shareholder I would be jumping up and down and demanding monthly updates on plans and progress. When will it finally be long enough for us to know what is going on and see some results (Tuscan 2 Demos not withstanding)!!!

GingerNinja

3,989 posts

287 months

Wednesday 19th January 2005
quotequote all
unrepentant said:
The quality of the new cars is also reported to be much better, certainly the ones I have seen in the showroom looked very well finished.



...Lady Topazs' thread in the Tuscan forum would suggest otherwise.

anonymous-user

83 months

Wednesday 19th January 2005
quotequote all
GingerNinja said:

unrepentant said:
The quality of the new cars is also reported to be much better, certainly the ones I have seen in the showroom looked very well finished.




...Lady Topazs' thread in the Tuscan forum would suggest otherwise.


I don't think it does

lady topaz said:


Only 700mls on the clock due to a lot of faffing about. Generally the car is streets ahead on driveability. She feels much better planted on the road and much more solid inside. Overall a vastly improved and superior car. But regretfully not run in so cant comment about performance yet.



M'lady does go on to address a few niggles but the overall impression is positive I think.

_Deejay_

5,057 posts

283 months

Wednesday 19th January 2005
quotequote all
unrepentant said:

GingerNinja said:


unrepentant said:
The quality of the new cars is also reported to be much better, certainly the ones I have seen in the showroom looked very well finished.





...Lady Topazs' thread in the Tuscan forum would suggest otherwise.



I don't think it does


lady topaz said:


Only 700mls on the clock due to a lot of faffing about. Generally the car is streets ahead on driveability. She feels much better planted on the road and much more solid inside. Overall a vastly improved and superior car. But regretfully not run in so cant comment about performance yet.




M'lady does go on to address a few niggles but the overall impression is positive I think.


TVR's are exhilarating cars to drive and that's why they have the following they do. I'm sure she is happy with the car.

However, if you're going to delay production to improve quality you shouldn't release a new model where the indicators fall off within a week of the car being built, IMHO.

Is there any possibility that you're not looking at this subjectively and defending TVR in every discussion regardless?

Surely you must agree they have their faults and more that one mistake has been made since the takeover?



anonymous-user

83 months

Wednesday 19th January 2005
quotequote all
_Deejay_ said:



TVR's are exhilarating cars to drive and that's why they have the following they do. I'm sure she is happy with the car.

However, if you're going to delay production to improve quality you shouldn't release a new model where the indicators fall off within a week of the car being built, IMHO.

Is there any possibility that you're not looking at this subjectively and defending TVR in every discussion regardless?

Surely you must agree they have their faults and more that one mistake has been made since the takeover?





If you read my contribution to that debate you'll note my comments regarding the quality of the indicators and the unacceptability of it.

That is not a reason (IMHO as always )to condemn the man who has anted up £15 million plus debt to buy the company and is evidently trying (delaying production etc..) to sort things out.

_Deejay_

5,057 posts

283 months

Wednesday 19th January 2005
quotequote all
unrepentant said:

_Deejay_ said:



TVR's are exhilarating cars to drive and that's why they have the following they do. I'm sure she is happy with the car.

However, if you're going to delay production to improve quality you shouldn't release a new model where the indicators fall off within a week of the car being built, IMHO.

Is there any possibility that you're not looking at this subjectively and defending TVR in every discussion regardless?

Surely you must agree they have their faults and more that one mistake has been made since the takeover?






If you read my contribution to that debate you'll note my comments regarding the quality of the indicators and the unacceptability of it.

That is not a reason (IMHO as always )to condemn the man who has anted up £15 million plus debt to buy the company and is evidently trying (delaying production etc..) to sort things out.



I didn't think I had condemned anyone, just that I am yet to see many tangible product improvements since the takeover. Lots of talk, rumours of frantic work behind the scenes and not much improvement yet.

Based on previous comments surely the fact that you don't own a Tuscan II at the moment precludes you from commenting on it?

As I said earlier, the jury is out. At the moment it seems that you're in the eyes of some people on here you're either pro or anti TVR, whether it's on the topic of the takeover, the speed 6 or whatever.





J_S_G

6,177 posts

279 months

Wednesday 19th January 2005
quotequote all
_Deejay_ said:
As I said earlier, the jury is out. At the moment it seems that you're in the eyes of some people on here you're either pro or anti TVR, whether it's on the topic of the takeover, the speed 6 or whatever.

Think you're spot on there. There are many, many polarised opinions on here. And whenever someone tries to provide a balanced "we'll see" or "maybe", people try to pigeonhole it as a positive/negative, and use it to start an argument/back an opinion up.

Sometimes things are just "ok", or the jury is still out...

anonymous-user

83 months

Wednesday 19th January 2005
quotequote all
J_S_G said:

Sometimes things are just "ok", or the jury is still out...


Of course they are.

My first post was tongue in cheek but I stand by my other comments. Of course everything is not perfect (when is it ever) but let's give the guy a chance for goodness sake. I have run companies and have taken over companies where TLC is required and it takes time to pull everything together. I'm just glad that I never had to do it with the PH collective watching and "advising".

oxbow

567 posts

279 months

Wednesday 19th January 2005
quotequote all
Where's the :yawn: gone?

anonymous-user

83 months

Wednesday 19th January 2005
quotequote all
oxbow said:
Where's the :yawn: gone?




I decided it wasn't constructive in terms of the debate. I'm now looking for you to make a meaningful contribution in your own inimitable style Johnny.

J_S_G

6,177 posts

279 months

Wednesday 19th January 2005
quotequote all
unrepentant said:
let's give the guy a chance for goodness sake.

Agree.

unrepentant said:
glad that I never had to do it with the PH collective watching and "advising".

Agree again.

The "rant gun" wasn't aimed directly at you when I pulled the trigger.

anonymous-user

83 months

Wednesday 19th January 2005
quotequote all
J_S_G said:



The "rant gun" wasn't aimed directly at you when I pulled the trigger.


Don't worry. I never go out without my flak jacket on these days.

mrmaggit

10,146 posts

277 months

Wednesday 19th January 2005
quotequote all
From what I've SEEN, quality appears to have improved, and I'm still in the "give the guy a chance" brigade. As long as he doesn't go trundling down the "lifestyle" route, that is.