dare i say it ... ABS
Author
Discussion

rogerwillco

Original Poster:

2 posts

274 months

Friday 24th October 2003
quotequote all
Just buying a T350 yet i feel confident in my ability it would be nice to have ABS on it for the great deal of motorway driving i do and england being england... on wet roads.

Can it be retro fitted? If so how much n where?

Paul V

4,489 posts

305 months

Friday 24th October 2003
quotequote all
Might be worth reading Johno’s thread about comparing wet braking in his Griff 500, a S2000 and a Elise, should put your mind at rest over the T350’s ability seeing as the brakes have been improved since over the Griff ones. www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?f=9&h=&t=57645

Steve Lewis

141 posts

312 months

Friday 24th October 2003
quotequote all
As a race instructor I often do demos of ABS.
As that Chief Constable once said
"it is the most significant contribution to road safety"... etc.
ALL modern 'normal' cars should have it fitted as standard. I've raced a BMW with it and didn't get on with it.

However ABS gets you out of trouble once you have got in it.

The only cause for a lock-up or skid...
is the nut behind the wheel.

Technically I feel the retro ABS fit would be somewhat costly given the sensors and electronics involved.


Key thing is try to avoid needing it.
Smooth progressive braking always in a straight line.
No sudden hard pressure.

If you do lock up try to 'pulse' the pedal smoothly. 'Cadence' braking or the 'poormans ABS' can be just as effective.

Remember when you are fully locked up you can swivel the steering as you like but it will have no directional control.

A TVR with ABS would somehow be wrong.
Against the pure ethic an all that.

PLease enjoy your car safely and to the full.
Think ahead...
Be safe.

best regs
Steve L



nubbin

6,809 posts

306 months

Friday 24th October 2003
quotequote all
Aha, a favourite of mine!

There is a German company that can retro-fit ABS, and it is something I have seriously considered. No-one in U.K. seems to do it, though there are several Traction control systems available. It's not cheap!!

hughesie2

12,785 posts

310 months

Friday 24th October 2003
quotequote all
nubbin said:
though there are several Traction control systems available. It's not cheap!!


Don't you need the ABS for the Traction Control though Nubbin ??

d_drinks

1,426 posts

297 months

Friday 24th October 2003
quotequote all
If you see the TOp Gear review of the T350C the one where the non JC bloke drives the car and the thing he says is most impressive about the car is the brakes, he couldn't think of anyother car with brakes like it and that was in the wet !!

simpo two

92,570 posts

293 months

Friday 24th October 2003
quotequote all
Anyone tried ABS on snow? I have a 730iV8 with ABS and it's useless - stand on the pedal and slide straight on. I can stop quicker by using ordinary braking progressively. I've never had the wheels lock up on the Griff. Granted, it doesn't go out in bad conditions but the braking is more than sufficient - light car, plenty of rubber. If condition are slippy, I drive slower, take more care over steering and braking and look further ahead. Simple!

rogerwillco

Original Poster:

2 posts

274 months

Friday 24th October 2003
quotequote all
Granted - thanks for all your help

Jon Gwynne

96 posts

278 months

Saturday 25th October 2003
quotequote all
Steve Lewis said:
As a race instructor I often do demos of ABS.
As that Chief Constable once said
"it is the most significant contribution to road safety"... etc.
ALL modern 'normal' cars should have it fitted as standard. I've raced a BMW with it and didn't get on with it.

However ABS gets you out of trouble once you have got in it.

The only cause for a lock-up or skid...
is the nut behind the wheel.

Technically I feel the retro ABS fit would be somewhat costly given the sensors and electronics involved.


Key thing is try to avoid needing it.
Smooth progressive braking always in a straight line.
No sudden hard pressure.

If you do lock up try to 'pulse' the pedal smoothly. 'Cadence' braking or the 'poormans ABS' can be just as effective.

Remember when you are fully locked up you can swivel the steering as you like but it will have no directional control.

A TVR with ABS would somehow be wrong.
Against the pure ethic an all that.

PLease enjoy your car safely and to the full.
Think ahead...
Be safe.

best regs
Steve L





Well said and I agree with most of what you said except the bit about it being the most significant contribution to road safety. I'd say things like disc brakes, seat belts, safety-glass and things of that nature are vastly more important to road safety than ABS. Put another way, it is possible to design a safe car without ABS. It is not possible to do so without another of the other things I just mentioned.

The problem I have with ABS isn't the theory - it is one of those ideas that looks great on paper. The problem is the application.

As you rightfully pointed out, the most important lesson to learn when driving an ABS-equipped car is to avoid putting yourself in a situation where you need it. In other words, learn to drive safely.

In the real world, many ordinary drivers look upon ABS as a excuse to not learn to drive properly and when combined with the general lack of understanding among drivers like these as to what ABS is, how it works and what it can (and more importantly can't) do... I believe it is a recipe for encouraging unsafe driving.

Think about the freeway pileups that will occur as a direct result of a numpty driving an ABS-equipped car in rain and fog while thinking to themselves "Its OK for me to drive 80mph and talk on the phone because I've got ABS and that means I can stop just as well as if the roads were dry".

One of those TV car shows should do a real-world test where they demonstrate the difference in braking distances using the same car with ABS on and off in various situations like dry tarmac, wet tarmac, snow/ice... Oh yeah, and show the difference in good tires vs bad ones. While they're at it, they should probably use a couple different car types from tiny sub-compacts to enormous SUV behemoths. Oh yeah, and also throw in a couple of non-ABS-equipped sports cars like a TVR, Noble, Lotus, etc...

I think everyone who buys any ABS-equipped car should be required to sign a form indicating that they understand ABS won't allow them to either ignore the laws of physics or drive like tw@ts - or more likely both.

Or, as George Carlin so aptly put it: "Some people think that buying a 'safe car' excuses them from the responsibility of learning how to drive the goddamn thing"

pies

13,116 posts

284 months

Saturday 25th October 2003
quotequote all
Isn't the Gatso the greatest contribution to road safetyLD

:gotmecoat:

Don

28,378 posts

312 months

Saturday 25th October 2003
quotequote all
We have this discussion from time to time. ABS - many pros, very few cons and for the average driver a godsend in an emergency. Clearly it is better to anticipate the emergency and simply be somewhere else at the time but if in a moment of weakness ABS helps out then surely, surely its a very good thing.

Same argument with traction control.

As I understand it nubbin is correct and a german firm fitted ABS and Traction to an older TVR - it was in Sprint the TVRCC magazine.

I'll bet the job could be done for a few grand...but then why buy a T350. Why not buy a car with the systems on already?

Personally I'd buy the TVR and go on an Advanced Driving course...

nubbin

6,809 posts

306 months

Saturday 25th October 2003
quotequote all
Bornemann Engineering will fit ABS, and I enquired, and got a figire of about 5000 Euros, but less if several people wanted it. i haven't got the cash at the moment, but maybe some time in the future....

simpo two

92,570 posts

293 months

Saturday 25th October 2003
quotequote all
nubbin said:
Bornemann Engineering will fit ABS, and I enquired, and got a figire of about 5000 Euros, but less if several people wanted it.


You can fix a lot of dented bumpers for 5,000 Euros... ...or send the cash to me and I'll drive it for you?

zumbruk

7,848 posts

288 months

Sunday 26th October 2003
quotequote all
Steve Lewis said:

If you do lock up try to 'pulse' the pedal smoothly. 'Cadence' braking or the 'poormans ABS' can be just as effective.


Only if you've got 4 feet. And 4 brake pedals.