Pancake filters
Author
Discussion

crankedup

Original Poster:

25,764 posts

272 months

Wednesday 2nd May 2018
quotequote all
Just going over my new purchase and decided to have a look at the air filters, They are the chrome plated disc bolted onto each SU carb. Took each off and thought the foam looked like it could do with a clean. The car has seen little use over the past decade or so, just enough to keep things going at 100 miles year.
Dropped the filters into paraffin bath and after ten minutes gave them a sloshing around. At this point the foam disintegrated. Off to the motoring accessory shops for some air filter foam.
Tried two shops and both offered the same product, a can of carb cleaner!! Seems that younger generations have no clue about old cars.
Ordered two replacement pancakes from fleabay outlet, almost as cheap as the foam replacement and as my filter bodies were corroding it was a no brainer.

singlecoil

35,825 posts

275 months

Wednesday 2nd May 2018
quotequote all
I'm assuming you are using them because of shortage of room? Generally speaking they're not good from the airflow point of view.

tapkaJohnD

2,000 posts

233 months

Wednesday 2nd May 2018
quotequote all
Foam melted? Bin the hardware as well. Pancakes aspirate their air from the hot stuff in the engine compartment, hot so expanded and less oxygen per litre, so less bang for your buck. About 1% per degree C, which can be a lot!

Filter in front of the radiator, wide ducting, as large an airbox as you can on the intakes. That's the way to do it!
JOhn

crankedup

Original Poster:

25,764 posts

272 months

Wednesday 2nd May 2018
quotequote all
Thanks for inputs, the old foam literally crumbled apart as it was so old. I take the point regarding new air intakes but want to keep the car fairly original and prepared to sa rift e a little performance. I do have the original chamber and pan air filter so maybe at the end of season I might put these back in.

Just to add, the pancakes were fitted to the car when I purchased. My understanding is that the old pancakes were a popular ‘sporty accessory’ back in the 1960’s.
Looks good but diminishes performance laugh

Edited by crankedup on Wednesday 2nd May 19:14

jsf55

11 posts

204 months

Wednesday 2nd May 2018
quotequote all
You can buy filter foam quite cheaply
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/New-Universal-Air-Filte...

aeropilot

40,526 posts

256 months

Wednesday 2nd May 2018
quotequote all
crankedup said:
My understanding is that the old pancakes were a popular ‘sporty accessory’ back in the 1960’s.
Looks good but diminishes performance laugh
Very true....very popular accessory back then.....and a very useless one laugh

Not that very many understood such things back then.

crankedup

Original Poster:

25,764 posts

272 months

Wednesday 2nd May 2018
quotequote all
jsf55 said:
You can buy filter foam quite cheaply
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/New-Universal-Air-Filte...
Spotted that earlier but thanks anyway.
Purchased two new pancakes complete with foam for 16 quid in the end. They will do for now.

crankedup

Original Poster:

25,764 posts

272 months

Friday 4th May 2018
quotequote all
My new pancake filters have arrived today, of course I need to oil the foam elements, will it be OK to use silicone 3 in 1 oil??
I do have some sae 30 but think this may be to heavy grade and the specialist oils are not available locally. Thanks for advise / comments.

steveL98

1,093 posts

209 months

Friday 4th May 2018
quotequote all
Any light oil will do, even olive oil.. Its only to trap a bit of dust that may ingress..

singlecoil

35,825 posts

275 months

Friday 4th May 2018
quotequote all
steveL98 said:
Any light oil will do, even olive oil.. Its only to trap a bit of dust that may ingress..
It will trap SOME of the dust that WILL ingress.

steveL98

1,093 posts

209 months

Friday 4th May 2018
quotequote all
My Corvette has an unoiled ITG panel filter in a cut open box that has no restriction at all to the airflow. Don't want oil getting on the MAF wires..

I used to use a commercial kitchen extractor filter, just as good airflow wise and free off the Estates guys in here.

aeropilot

40,526 posts

256 months

Friday 4th May 2018
quotequote all
crankedup said:
My new pancake filters have arrived today, of course I need to oil the foam elements, will it be OK to use silicone 3 in 1 oil??
I do have some sae 30 but think this may be to heavy grade and the specialist oils are not available locally. Thanks for advise / comments.
Why do you say that you need to oil the foam?

Never did that back in the day when using cheap chrome pancake filters. The foam was washable and that's all you'd do.

You'll ruin the foam if you put oil on them.

This oiling of filters lark didn't arrive until K&N became the 'in thing' to fit in the early 80's.


steveL98

1,093 posts

209 months

Friday 4th May 2018
quotequote all
Oil's been used to trap dust in airfilters for about 100years. K&N only used it in a different way.

markymarkthree

3,595 posts

200 months

Friday 4th May 2018
quotequote all
I used to oil the foam filter in my Husqvarna for scrambling back in the 70s.

crankedup

Original Poster:

25,764 posts

272 months

Friday 4th May 2018
quotequote all
That’s interesting to hear of a ‘no oiling’ on foam filter required. I can very vaguely recall oiling filters in the 1960s, idea to trap fine dust. Coming from pre 1930s stuff now is like re-education
for me, Once I am reminded it floods back. I’ve used sae 30 oil now on my filter foam, just a light smearing on the outer surface.
For the sake of conversation I also recall using some old stockings cut up and secured over the open bellmouths of my dear old Honda 250 SS. Provided. perfect taut fine mesh over the open end and seemed to work well. Things seem more complicated on modern stuff now.


Edited by crankedup on Friday 4th May 16:00

dandarez

14,009 posts

312 months

Friday 4th May 2018
quotequote all
Christ! I thought 'foam' filters went out with the ark? I remember them in the 60s and 70s but 'paper' types since.

K&N etc 'can' be daft money.
For SUs and similar I'd stick these on twins before I'd remotely even consider 'ye olde' nuts foam pancake filters. Cheap too.

https://www.ebay.co.uk/p/Triumph-Spitfire-MK-1-to-...

singlecoil

35,825 posts

275 months

Friday 4th May 2018
quotequote all
Funny how discussions about air filters tend to focus on air flow with filtration hardly getting a mention.

Dandarez's solution is the one to go for.

PositronicRay

28,936 posts

212 months

Friday 4th May 2018
quotequote all
I had some chrome 'accessory' filters on a 1725 sunbeam engine. When I worked out the induction area was far too small I set about inproving it.

So made them deeper, went from 1" to around 2" deep, (around 5" dia) because each end piece had a 1/4" lip original induction depth was only 1/2". All it needed was some filter foam and longer securing bolts. After the mod the car felt like pulled harder at high revs.

crankedup

Original Poster:

25,764 posts

272 months

Saturday 5th May 2018
quotequote all
Would have preferred the pancakes with the paper filters but none available for my inch and half SU. I do have the original air filter and plenum chamber so I will have a look at bolting that back in.

singlecoil

35,825 posts

275 months

Saturday 5th May 2018
quotequote all
If the engine is standard in other respects then I agree that you would be best to refit the original unit which will have been designed and developed to provide good driving characteristics in normal motoring.