Ban lorries?? Great idea!
Ban lorries?? Great idea!
Author
Discussion

big dazza

Original Poster:

1,439 posts

265 months

Tuesday 1st March 2005
quotequote all

With some PHers calling for HGV's to be banished from our roads forever, thought something I stumbled across might be of interest.

www.nationaltruckweek.co.uk/life_without_lorries.pdf

Its a bit long winded and dull on the whole, but scroll through to Table 6 on page 21 which pretty much sums up the consequences. All in less than a week, scary.


>>> Edited by big dazza on Tuesday 1st March 21:35

Pies

13,116 posts

285 months

Tuesday 1st March 2005
quotequote all
"Report prepared for commercial motot magazine"

I'll skip reading the rest ta

big dazza

Original Poster:

1,439 posts

265 months

Tuesday 1st March 2005
quotequote all

That will make it innaccurate then?

Pies

13,116 posts

285 months

Tuesday 1st March 2005
quotequote all
Biased

big dazza

Original Poster:

1,439 posts

265 months

Tuesday 1st March 2005
quotequote all

Possibly, but most things are to a certain extent. Doesn't necessarily mean its not correct. Only trying to get some opinions

BMGM3

10,480 posts

272 months

Tuesday 1st March 2005
quotequote all
"With some PHers calling for HGV's to be banished from our roads forever, thought something I stumbled across might be of interest"

You have to be brain dead to think that doing that is going to work . It's the kinda w*nker that thinks that, who would be posting here that he can't get this or that and there's nothing in the shops etc etc etc

Trucks don't make wasted journeys.It costs a fortune to do so and woulndt do any good.Do you think they are just out for a drive for the fun of it ? How much time spent in your car(s) is unnecessary and clogging up the roads,and yet some tt thinks the first thing to go is the trucks ...not very well thought out.

andy4200

5,125 posts

302 months

Tuesday 1st March 2005
quotequote all
I think what would be good is to try and get more long distance freight on to rail or ship at an earlier point. Maybe have local distribution points and rail in between.
Also, do like some of Europe and get the lorries off the road at weekends and bank holidays.

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

284 months

Tuesday 1st March 2005
quotequote all
Towman's gonna get yer.......

towman

14,938 posts

268 months

Tuesday 1st March 2005
quotequote all

8Pack

5,182 posts

269 months

Tuesday 1st March 2005
quotequote all
"Distribution of beer and spirits paralised"!!!
Oh! M' gawd!!!

Trooper2

6,676 posts

260 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2005
quotequote all
If they banned trucking in the USA we could all pack up our tents and go home. A country without a good trucking industry would revert back to stone age.

wedgepilot

819 posts

312 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2005
quotequote all
andy4200 said:
I think what would be good is to try and get more long distance freight on to rail or ship at an earlier point. Maybe have local distribution points and rail in between.
Also, do like some of Europe and get the lorries off the road at weekends and bank holidays.


Far too much like common sense...

On a serious note, why aren't trains used more for long distance stuff? Is it much more expensive?

mrmaggit

10,146 posts

277 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2005
quotequote all
wedgepilot said:

andy4200 said:
I think what would be good is to try and get more long distance freight on to rail or ship at an earlier point. Maybe have local distribution points and rail in between.
Also, do like some of Europe and get the lorries off the road at weekends and bank holidays.



Far too much like common sense...

On a serious note, why aren't trains used more for long distance stuff? Is it much more expensive?



Because there isn't the capacity on the rail network. I remember a company that makes concrete blocks in Knottingley, Yorks sends a trainload of blocks to there depot at Biggleswade, if they miss their slot, the train can be stuck for hours waiting for another gap to appear in the timetable.

DocJock

8,722 posts

269 months

Wednesday 2nd March 2005
quotequote all
Just a couple off the top of my head....

If the rail system could cope (which it can't) with a doubling of freight, it would make <5% reduction in road freight.

Distribution would involve two additional transers of goods (on to, and off of the train)

Companies would require satellite distribution centres instead of centralised.