RENTING PROPERTY !!! PRIVATE v COUNCIL
Discussion
hi,
ive just purchased a flat to rent its now all done up and ready i have the choice to either rent to the council (fixed term 3years) or private via a agent.
The council seem to offer more money and the fixed term seems attractive but i dont want in 3 years for them to turn round and say needs new carpet or needs re painting otherwise what money i will be making will be a waste.
The rent covers the mortgage (interest only) and gives me a further £170pm once the service charge and ground rent etc is paid.
Renting private may pay slightly less (about £50pm less) only guaranteed for 6 months at a time and if i get a agent to look after it and maintain i will loose about 15% of the rent so will only end up with about £20pm not a lot!!!
There is good equity in the property already so im hoping in the years to come there will be a nice chunk towards something tasty or as the mrs says moving!!!
any help or experience with council v private will be appreciated
cheers
J
ive just purchased a flat to rent its now all done up and ready i have the choice to either rent to the council (fixed term 3years) or private via a agent.
The council seem to offer more money and the fixed term seems attractive but i dont want in 3 years for them to turn round and say needs new carpet or needs re painting otherwise what money i will be making will be a waste.
The rent covers the mortgage (interest only) and gives me a further £170pm once the service charge and ground rent etc is paid.
Renting private may pay slightly less (about £50pm less) only guaranteed for 6 months at a time and if i get a agent to look after it and maintain i will loose about 15% of the rent so will only end up with about £20pm not a lot!!!
There is good equity in the property already so im hoping in the years to come there will be a nice chunk towards something tasty or as the mrs says moving!!!
any help or experience with council v private will be appreciated
cheers
J
The difference in income over 3 years is 5400 GBP so that should mean a reasonable amount can still be spend on repairs and you will be quids in. Factor in any vacant time with the agency and you will quickly see an even bigger difference in income
My only concern would be the council tenants you get in and what responsibility the council has for maintaining the property/fuxtures and fittings in a reasonable way. Certainly a new carpet should not be needed in 3 years (if it is new to begin with) and dilapidations over and above normal wear and tear should be paid for by them
My only concern would be the council tenants you get in and what responsibility the council has for maintaining the property/fuxtures and fittings in a reasonable way. Certainly a new carpet should not be needed in 3 years (if it is new to begin with) and dilapidations over and above normal wear and tear should be paid for by them
I don't have any experience of renting with the Council but I would have the same doubts (and probably more) as expressed by Antwerpman. However, they could easily be dismissed with a well written contract.
I can speak about renting privately or through an estate agent. I don't know how you are guaranteed a 6 month income. As I understand it most standard tenancy agreements oblige you the owner to the term/duration of the contract whether it's 6 or 12 months, etc. Whereas the tenant can cancel the agreement with the simple provision of a one month notice to terminate.
As for wear and tear, maintenance issues such as painting and decorating, by renting privately, on a 6 month basis, you could possibly even find yourself shelling out every 6 months.
Having said all that, my last tenant was an absolute star. She did all the redecorating herself (and her son) over a 3 year period and kept the place really nice!!!
Good tenants are out there, but hard to find I'd say.
Best of luck, HTH.
JT.
I can speak about renting privately or through an estate agent. I don't know how you are guaranteed a 6 month income. As I understand it most standard tenancy agreements oblige you the owner to the term/duration of the contract whether it's 6 or 12 months, etc. Whereas the tenant can cancel the agreement with the simple provision of a one month notice to terminate.
As for wear and tear, maintenance issues such as painting and decorating, by renting privately, on a 6 month basis, you could possibly even find yourself shelling out every 6 months.
Having said all that, my last tenant was an absolute star. She did all the redecorating herself (and her son) over a 3 year period and kept the place really nice!!!
Good tenants are out there, but hard to find I'd say.
Best of luck, HTH.
JT.
Warning mate . . Councils are cnuts !!
They put a family in my sis in laws flat.
The guys wife left him within a couple of months and then took the kids so his benefits dropped & he couldn't afford the rent.
Took almost a year to get the fecker out and Westminster refused to take reponsibility of to rehouse him. Eventually they awarded him some extra and backdated it to help with his rent arrears but gave it directly to him. Of course he didn't pass it on to the landlord as he was supposed to do.
At one stage she changed the locks and the council called and said she HAD to let him in. She did find out that he and his new gf were claiming in Lewisham as well so was able to report them.
This was Westminster but I've heard of similar problems with other LAs.
Personally I'd rent privately to professional people. The minute they're a month overdue, begin eviction proceedings.
Harsh but it's your hard earned - why give it away.
>> Edited by vee on Monday 12th December 10:10
>> Edited by vee on Monday 12th December 10:11
They put a family in my sis in laws flat.
The guys wife left him within a couple of months and then took the kids so his benefits dropped & he couldn't afford the rent.
Took almost a year to get the fecker out and Westminster refused to take reponsibility of to rehouse him. Eventually they awarded him some extra and backdated it to help with his rent arrears but gave it directly to him. Of course he didn't pass it on to the landlord as he was supposed to do.
At one stage she changed the locks and the council called and said she HAD to let him in. She did find out that he and his new gf were claiming in Lewisham as well so was able to report them.
This was Westminster but I've heard of similar problems with other LAs.
Personally I'd rent privately to professional people. The minute they're a month overdue, begin eviction proceedings.
Harsh but it's your hard earned - why give it away.
>> Edited by vee on Monday 12th December 10:10
>> Edited by vee on Monday 12th December 10:11
You just need to be careful who the council pays - some local authorities will pay direct to the landlord, which is fine. Others, though, pay the money to the tenant, and it is up to them to pay the landlord. It's all about "empowerment", giving people the dignity to manage their financial affairs themselves. Obviously, not all DSS claimants are dossers, but there are some who will "empower" themsleves by pissing your money away. That's why you get offers from the councils of guaranteed rent at the market rate for 3 years whether your property is occupied or not, 3 months rent in advance, property returned in good condition fair wear and tear excepted, etc etc etc. - effectively they do do all this, but the onus is on you to extract it from the DSS claimant. And of course you have no real control as to who your tenant is, because your deal is with the council.
I have a friend who has recently bought his 20th buy to let house. All 20 houses are let to the council who in turn let the houses to their tenants.
My mate treats the houses as business objects, he has them redecorated, fitted with ultra cheap kitchens, bathrooms and carpets. At the end of the 3 year let, anything that needs replacing is torn out and changed.
You have to factor in the likely costs of repairs, but as others have said, renting to the council seems to be a no-brainer. Good luck.
My mate treats the houses as business objects, he has them redecorated, fitted with ultra cheap kitchens, bathrooms and carpets. At the end of the 3 year let, anything that needs replacing is torn out and changed.
You have to factor in the likely costs of repairs, but as others have said, renting to the council seems to be a no-brainer. Good luck.
cheers for the replys guys
the thing that makes me sway towards the council is im paid by them direct so no messing for money etc, they take over most of the maintenance bar pluming / electrics so i should have no petty door handels etc etc
i like the idea of having nicer people in there by going private but its less money, not a guaranteed income as might have a break in letting.
but looking as a business side the more money the better yea?
has anyone advertised there property themselves in papers etc might still get good money i choose who to let in there plus it will be paid cash/transfer etc so not so many tax issues either
and i though it would be easy to do this
J
the thing that makes me sway towards the council is im paid by them direct so no messing for money etc, they take over most of the maintenance bar pluming / electrics so i should have no petty door handels etc etc
i like the idea of having nicer people in there by going private but its less money, not a guaranteed income as might have a break in letting.
but looking as a business side the more money the better yea?
has anyone advertised there property themselves in papers etc might still get good money i choose who to let in there plus it will be paid cash/transfer etc so not so many tax issues either
and i though it would be easy to do this
J
I rent property via my local councils private landlord scheme (which is managed by a 'charitable' housing association).
The period locks me in for 5 years and 'guarantee's' me a market rent, fixed over this period.
To qualify for this, the house/flat had to be furnished, in a good state of repair, gas & electric tested and all permits aquired (also for the duration of the lease) and various other bits and pieces that varies from council to council (some require new matresses on beds, some fridge freezers and ovens).
The council decides who it rents it to (which in this case is short term tennancies).
When the 5 years is up, the council (not the association) has to hand the property back in 'exactly' the same state as it was leased out in (bar fair wear and tear, which you should 'specifically' check).
Its an absolute no-brainer and i wouldnt hesitate to recommend it to anyone, but go in with 'all areas' checked. I wouldnt under any circumstance rent to private tennants (lack of guarentees,voids. fee's etc etc)
n.b. all councils have different systems and rules.
>> Edited by cinque on Wednesday 22 March 11:48
The period locks me in for 5 years and 'guarantee's' me a market rent, fixed over this period.
To qualify for this, the house/flat had to be furnished, in a good state of repair, gas & electric tested and all permits aquired (also for the duration of the lease) and various other bits and pieces that varies from council to council (some require new matresses on beds, some fridge freezers and ovens).
The council decides who it rents it to (which in this case is short term tennancies).
When the 5 years is up, the council (not the association) has to hand the property back in 'exactly' the same state as it was leased out in (bar fair wear and tear, which you should 'specifically' check).
Its an absolute no-brainer and i wouldnt hesitate to recommend it to anyone, but go in with 'all areas' checked. I wouldnt under any circumstance rent to private tennants (lack of guarentees,voids. fee's etc etc)
n.b. all councils have different systems and rules.
>> Edited by cinque on Wednesday 22 March 11:48
I have a couple of rental properties and round my way the council pay less than the going commercial rate but do guarantee a fixed rental period of 2/3 years.
I understand that they will re-carpet after the end of their tenancy but under no circumstances would I rent to them as they tend to put in far more people than the house can cope with and the houses are returned in an appalling state of repair (at least this is what happened to a friend of mine and I saw the damage first hand).
I understand that they will re-carpet after the end of their tenancy but under no circumstances would I rent to them as they tend to put in far more people than the house can cope with and the houses are returned in an appalling state of repair (at least this is what happened to a friend of mine and I saw the damage first hand).
I had a family of Somali's in one of mine in Tottenham. They thought it'd be fine to take the sash windows out and make a camp fire for their cooking pot in the front room
I couldnt care less, the councils the landlord for term of the lease and its their problem. When it was handed back 2 years later, it was 'better' than the state i gave it.
As mentioned before. Ive had more horror stories (along with 'many' friends of mine) with private tennants.
What would happen if private tennants turned the place upside down? You see how helpful the agencies are at recovering your losses (Thats if you use them. Even more difficult if you dont!)
I couldnt care less, the councils the landlord for term of the lease and its their problem. When it was handed back 2 years later, it was 'better' than the state i gave it.
As mentioned before. Ive had more horror stories (along with 'many' friends of mine) with private tennants.
What would happen if private tennants turned the place upside down? You see how helpful the agencies are at recovering your losses (Thats if you use them. Even more difficult if you dont!)
the council option sounds good to me if you are guaranteed the rent.
i have rented property out to people who earned a fortune,but if they decided to do a runner,whats to stop them? i am getting out of renting property but if this kind of deal was offered to me in my area i would jump at it....subject to contract
i have rented property out to people who earned a fortune,but if they decided to do a runner,whats to stop them? i am getting out of renting property but if this kind of deal was offered to me in my area i would jump at it....subject to contract
zoom_jones said:
I would agree, guaranteed rent sounds very attractive. Is there a definitive list anywhere of councils that DO offer this service? Maybe worth investing in such areas. thanks
letting to the council is generally a great idea - as long as you're not too attached to the property (for instance I wouldn't do it with a house that you've previously lived in unless you're unattached to it) but watch out, because quite a few BTL lenders have clauses that restrict letting to assured shorthold tenancy basis - ie private tenants. the reason for this is that they are uneasy about what is effectively a sub let from you to the council.
if you have a reasonable deposit of cash you can spare, and you buy wisely* I can't think of many easier ways to make money than a 3 or 5 year let to the council combined with a 3 or 5 year fixed rate...
*for example, I know of a 3 bed maisonette bought for 130k I/O reps of £469 PCM and an income of £768 PCM from the council for 3 or 5 years

Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


