HD DVD/Blu-ray shenanigans...
HD DVD/Blu-ray shenanigans...
Author
Discussion

neil.b

Original Poster:

6,546 posts

278 months

Wednesday 25th January 2006
quotequote all
Despite HD analogue TVs being able to display 1280x720 pictures, the Advanced Access Content System (AACS) used by both next-gen formats has been modified to degrade the picture over analog connections - for no good reason except to force the sale of HD TVs.

What a bunch of cnuts.

http://arstechnica.com/news.ars/post/20060122-6027.h

Edited cos i missed a word out.



>> Edited by neil.b on Wednesday 25th January 11:35

scorp

8,783 posts

260 months

Wednesday 25th January 2006
quotequote all
Whats the problem? The signal is downgraded to 960x540 which is what most non-hdtv sets display at anyway (525 lines).

Your screwed if your set has HDTV resolution but no digital HDMI input though.

>> Edited by scorp on Wednesday 25th January 11:32

Parrot of Doom

23,075 posts

265 months

Wednesday 25th January 2006
quotequote all
The article suggests piracy as a reason though.

neil.b

Original Poster:

6,546 posts

278 months

Wednesday 25th January 2006
quotequote all
scorp said:
Whats the problem? The signal is downgraded to 960x540 which is what most non-hdtv sets display at anyway (525 lines).


Because 720 analogue HD TVs are perfectly capable of displaying the higher resolution picture, so why downgrade it?

scorp

8,783 posts

260 months

Wednesday 25th January 2006
quotequote all
Parrot of Doom said:
The article suggests piracy as a reason though.

If thats the case, why display a picture at all?

scorp

8,783 posts

260 months

Wednesday 25th January 2006
quotequote all
neil.b said:
scorp said:
Whats the problem? The signal is downgraded to 960x540 which is what most non-hdtv sets display at anyway (525 lines).


Because 720 analogue HD TVs are perfectly capable of displaying the higher resolution picture, so why downgrade it?


Because its not going over the digital HDMI link, which has built in content protection. They are basically enforcing their DRM by requiring a digital connection. You should be ok, if your tv has the digital input.

neil.b

Original Poster:

6,546 posts

278 months

Wednesday 25th January 2006
quotequote all
scorp said:
neil.b said:
scorp said:
Whats the problem? The signal is downgraded to 960x540 which is what most non-hdtv sets display at anyway (525 lines).


Because 720 analogue HD TVs are perfectly capable of displaying the higher resolution picture, so why downgrade it?


Because its not going over the digital HDMI link, which has built in content protection. They are basically enforcing their DRM by requiring a digital connection. You should be ok, if your tv has the digital input.


Problem is; if you buy the HD-DVD/Blu-ray DVD player and the HD-DVD/Blu-ray disc, but want to play it on your 720 TV, they you over by delivering a picture quaulity less than what your TV is capable of playing.

xiphias

5,889 posts

258 months

Wednesday 25th January 2006
quotequote all
I'll be ed if I'll ever use DRM. Pile of crap.

scorp

8,783 posts

260 months

Wednesday 25th January 2006
quotequote all
neil.b said:
Problem is; if you buy the HD-DVD/Blu-ray DVD player and the HD-DVD/Blu-ray disc, but want to play it on your 720 TV, they you over by delivering a picture quaulity less than what your TV is capable of playing.

Yup. Thats the way things are heading unfortunately, a million and one copy protection systems, restricting how you use your legally purchased media.

Im sure a device could be made which renders a digital signal into a frame buffer of some kind and spits it out as HDTV analogue at the same resolution.

neil.b

Original Poster:

6,546 posts

278 months

Wednesday 25th January 2006
quotequote all
scorp said:

Im sure a device could be made which renders a digital signal into a frame buffer of some kind and spits it out as HDTV analogue at the same resolution.


I'm certain of it. Where there's a will and all that....

What pisses me off is the fact that all this DRM will be cracked or worked-around by some evil geniuses and the underground trade of pirated films/music will continue yet it will be legitimate purchasers who'll have to upgrade their TV/DVD player/CD player or get shafted.

But of course the RIAA give their services/products for free as that's how much they care about safe-guarding artists work. Of course they do. Nothing in it for them at all to promote the idea of global piracy as the doom-bringer of everything creative whilst offering a "solution". Not a thing.

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Wednesday 25th January 2006
quotequote all
xiphias said:
I'll be ed if I'll ever use DRM. Pile of crap.


If you acquire a device with an HDMI socket then you'll have succumbed to DRM.

HDCP (Hi Def Content Protection) is built into the HDMI connector standard.

Its interesting to note that a HDTV capable appliance may not neccesarily implement HDCP so when you come to plug the Sky HD STB in whilst the TV is capable of showing the signal it wont because it has no way of protecting the content...

Displays conforming the HD-Ready standard are the ones to look for.

Neil_H

15,418 posts

282 months

Wednesday 25th January 2006
quotequote all
neil.b said:
But of course the RIAA give their services/products for free as that's how much they care about safe-guarding artists work. Of course they do. Nothing in it for them at all to promote the idea of global piracy as the doom-bringer of everything creative whilst offering a "solution". Not a thing.


That organisation has so many politicians in it's pocket they can get away with anything

Whatever protection is put in, someone, somewhere will crack it. It's like Macrovision on VHS tapes. Hearing shit like this just makes me want to copy stuff.

mr_yogi

3,288 posts

286 months

Wednesday 25th January 2006
quotequote all
I was under the impression that it is part of the spec for bluray and HD DVD, but it seemed likely that at least the first wave of content will not require HDCP for viewing digital content ...or maybe that was enabling HD through component

I'm not sure how true this is but I picked this up from another forum quoting AVSForums and AVForums

The same goes for sky HD, it is likely that HD content will be available through component for TVs lacking HDMI, at least initially. This goes for Sky's channels, however other channels which provide HD content in the future may still mandate HDMI.

>> Edited by mr_yogi on Wednesday 25th January 13:29

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Wednesday 25th January 2006
quotequote all
The Thomson STB will output both Component and HDMI, as far as anyone can currently tell and thats only from a confusing Sony press release.

I was under the impression though that the component outs were protected as well.

mr_yogi

3,288 posts

286 months

Wednesday 25th January 2006
quotequote all
Plotloss said:
The Thomson STB will output both Component and HDMI, as far as anyone can currently tell and thats only from a confusing Sony press release.

I was under the impression though that the component outs were protected as well.


They are protected, original talk was of HD image being converted to 480p over compenent. However this is controlled by the DRM in on the disk, broadcast.

I think I read that sky would allow HD over compenent for their channels however other HD channels may enable more restrictive DRM

Also Sky have said that future STB may NOT feature component outputs.

EDIT: 'cause wot I rite dont make sense

>> Edited by mr_yogi on Wednesday 25th January 13:34

Plotloss

67,280 posts

301 months

Wednesday 25th January 2006
quotequote all
Component is only going to be a short lived thing.

1080p must have HDMI and it makes sense that if we are to standardise on tru-def, or whatever its going to be called this week then HDMI is the future.

Mind you, its also going to have an SD Composite output so anything could and probably will happen in the next half hour.

4WD

2,289 posts

262 months

Wednesday 25th January 2006
quotequote all
Buying the latest jap gadget is a faster way to loose money than buying a rover. Best to wait until one of the new competing formats has died before wading in, just like betamx/vhs and dvd audio/sacd fiasco. Philips and Sony will never learn to co-operate.



>> Edited by 4WD on Wednesday 25th January 14:07

scorp

8,783 posts

260 months

Wednesday 25th January 2006
quotequote all
4WD said:
Philips and Sony will never learn to co-operate.

The CD?

Its more Sony's fault the Phillips, look at all the locked in formats they have come up with in recent times... minidisc, umd, magicgate, blu-ray.

>> Edited by scorp on Wednesday 25th January 14:22

ultimasimon

9,646 posts

289 months

Wednesday 25th January 2006
quotequote all
scorp said:
4WD said:
Philips and Sony will never learn to co-operate.

The CD?

Its more Sony's fault the Phillips, look at all the locked in formats they have come up with in recent times... minidisc, umd, magicgate, blu-ray.



..and Philips DCC (Digital Compact Cassette) which was as good as DAT but would also play standard, analogue tapes.

As far as the DRM is concerned, I wouldn't worry too much:

They said tape to tape would never happen.
They said that Encoded Movies (VHS) would prevent pirate copies.
They said DVD's were uncopyable.

Utter utter bollox. When the powers that be clamp down, the rabid consumer bites back. For every geius tech in favour there is one against.

As long as you have a DVI input there will be ways to circumnavigate the DRM. There are a few very good threads currently going on in the AVS forums (US not UK). Even now I can already buy a plug in card for my projector that is HD digi in and using DVI; and it defeats DRM - the cost? Less than £200 shipped direct from China. Prices will fall as demand grows.

Until they, the media producers, and they, the artists, work together and ask reasonable money for their products, piracy will continue. The whole damned industry should look at how marketable their product is and charge reasonable prices for it and all piracy would stop overnight - period.

If the consumer is backed up against a wall they will come out fighting.

scorp

8,783 posts

260 months

Wednesday 25th January 2006
quotequote all
I wouldn't be so confident ultimasimon, a lot of hardware based digital DRM is uncrackable. MagicGate for instance has never been cracked to date (its been cloned, but never cracked or solved).

Yes i know HDMI can be circumvented in theory, read my suggestion above..

>> Edited by scorp on Wednesday 25th January 15:06