What is an "American"?
Author
Discussion

petrol_noggin

3,046 posts

251 months

Tuesday 28th February 2006
quotequote all
if you're saying that effectively the indians were the true American's because their land was stolen by the white people then that means that they are infact not real americans either, the caveman is, the same applies all over the world. A true american, brit, german etc is someone who holds the citizenship and is proud of being from that nation simple as that.

Andy Mac

73,668 posts

286 months

Tuesday 28th February 2006
quotequote all
The thing I've noticed since being in the US is that they desperately want to make eveyone diverse, and have a multicutural society, so much so, that everything is split up into it's own little labels, and groups, and prettymuch segregated so that everyone can appreciate everyone else. Unfortunately it doesn't work. I went to a 'workshop' with my college class, (yes I enrolled at a local college to get some qualifications), and they had a thing about diversity, etc. to promote this, they have courses about Black literature, and courses on Hispanic literature, and course on Black culture, and course on Hispanic culture, and so on, and so forth. Fine I thought, but, I asked the lady presenting it, if you want it all to be mainstream, and part of everyones everyday life, why not just add the literature to existing courses, and teach people in everyday classrooms about other cultures that way, rather than seperating the courses, so that only Black/Hispanic people, and people who are interested, apply for the course. That will not help it get into the mainstream. They like to have a box for everything. And unlike the UK, where we do literature from various cultures during regular literature classes, (at least I did. Wole Soyinka, a poet from Grenada, etc,), they don't. They seem to be going about it differently. They even have Black appreciation month. I'm not black, but if that was my 'race' I'd feel a little patronized.

srebbe64

13,021 posts

268 months

Wednesday 1st March 2006
quotequote all
The USA is amazingly multicultural and in the main a very friendly place, full of nice people. Problem is, it's also a land of extremes. Unfortunately one extreme seems to have control of the airwaves. Therein lies the challenge in my view. The USA has the potential to be a showcase of how different races and cultures can live together - it also has the potential to be a showcase for the reverse of this.

matchless

1,105 posts

253 months

Wednesday 1st March 2006
quotequote all
i heard that the red indian is NOT a native american natives had fair skin and blue eyes aparrently but the CIA stopped this politicaly incorrect fact!

tinman0

18,231 posts

271 months

Wednesday 1st March 2006
quotequote all
los angeles said:
I'm getting rather tired of hearing Caucasians over here in the United States of Amnesia demand anything praying to Mecca, whether a university professor or a car dealer, and all non-whites, and Latinos, be sent home immediately, in order to guarantee America stays a place for Americans.


I dont get it LA. You are knocking a country (as per normal) that you make your living from. The white caucasians are probably repsonsible for paying your way in the US - why don't you just come home and put it all behind you?

You obviously hate America as it is today, so why not make Scotland a better place to be by returning.

srebbe64

13,021 posts

268 months

Wednesday 1st March 2006
quotequote all
matchless said:
i heard that the red indian is NOT a native american natives had fair skin and blue eyes aparrently but the CIA stopped this politicaly incorrect fact!

Aah, the elusive and VERY rare "White Indian".

srebbe64

13,021 posts

268 months

Wednesday 1st March 2006
quotequote all
tinman0 said:
los angeles said:
I'm getting rather tired of hearing Caucasians over here in the United States of Amnesia demand anything praying to Mecca, whether a university professor or a car dealer, and all non-whites, and Latinos, be sent home immediately, in order to guarantee America stays a place for Americans.


I dont get it LA. You are knocking a country (as per normal) that you make your living from. The white caucasians are probably repsonsible for paying your way in the US - why don't you just come home and put it all behind you?

You obviously hate America as it is today, so why not make Scotland a better place to be by returning.

Yeah LA, how dare you suggest that some people demand that they are expelled from a country because they are not a national of that particular country. No such prejudices exist, so I agree with Tinam "get out"

jimbeaux

33,791 posts

262 months

Wednesday 1st March 2006
quotequote all
los angeles said:
I'm getting rather tired of hearing Caucasians over here in the United States of Amnesia demand anything praying to Mecca, whether a university professor or a car dealer, and all non-whites, and Latinos, be sent home immediately, in order to guarantee America stays a place for Americans.


jimbeaux said:

1) LA, that applies to those who are here illegally, on exspired visas, school visa but never reported to school, etc. It's referred to as "the law". The turds who say "leave" because they are not white..well...we agree on that.



los angeles said:
But what is an American?

As far as I can see the true American is a Plains Indian, or a farm Indian, such as Hopi or Zuni. But you don't need me to know Anglos won't ever hand back the land they stole.

There are times I feel America should be divided into three, from north to south. The east coast can be gifted to African-Americans in apology for slavery, and everything else the Whites did to them since to deny them their rights. The west coast here should be given back to the Hispanics, after all, Mexico owned a huge chunk of the place and now runs it again, working menial, degrading but important jobs no Caucasian wants. And the middle section can be handed back to the Indians to roam free again under the great sky as their spirit takes them.


jimbeaux said:

1) The Blacks do not need land to "make up" for slavery. They have advantages here as of late that no white has or has ever had.

2) The Hispanics( they don't like "Latinos" )work $hit jobs(as did the Irish, Italians, etc.)did when they arrived only to improve and "move up"...as the Vietnamese did. Strange you didn't mention the Vitnamese. Oh, I see, since they are successful, we will leave them out

3) One of my very best friends is a leading government official for Indian affairs...an Indian herself(they HATE being called "Native Americans"...they prefer Indians). She states that with government advantages, vast casino ownership by tribes(100%tax free),etc., they have it better than ever, and would prefer that you and I stop tampering with their affairs



I find it a mystery why you stay here with the absolute lack of anything redeeming you seem to find in this country. If money for travel is a problem, I can get the Multi-billion dollar Indian Casino Industry to buy you a 1st class ticket to Glasgow! If you want to complain about a nation's foreign policy, by all means, do so. As what we do affects most other nations, it is your right to complain about foreign policy. HOWEVER, for a foreign national to belittle the DOMESTIC policy of his host nation is a little bit like "sort of not your business"...especially since you are making your living off the very folks you seem to despise.













>> Edited by jimbeaux on Wednesday 1st March 02:16

ErnestM

11,621 posts

298 months

Wednesday 1st March 2006
quotequote all
An "American" is somebody born and/or naturalised in America. Full Stop.

Oh, and regarding your laundry list of Republican evils. So, if they are corrupt and inept, what does that say about the people who managed to lose not one, but two elections to them?

waits for the impending they stole the election through cronyism/haliburton/fraud/brother-in-lawing/whatever the excuse of the month is


ErnestM

rich1231

17,340 posts

291 months

Wednesday 1st March 2006
quotequote all
los angeles said:
I'm getting rather tired of hearing Caucasians over here in the United States of Amnesia demand anything praying to Mecca, whether a university professor or a car dealer, and all non-whites, and Latinos, be sent home immediately, in order to guarantee America stays a place for Americans.

But what is an American?

As far as I can see the true American is a Plains Indian, or a farm Indian, such as Hopi or Zuni. But you don't need me to know Anglos won't ever hand back the land they stole.

There are times I feel America should be divided into three, from north to south. The east coast can be gifted to African-Americans in apology for slavery, and everything else the Whites did to them since to deny them their rights. The west coast here should be given back to the Hispanics, after all, Mexico owned a huge chunk of the place and now runs it again, working menial, degrading but important jobs no Caucasian wants. And the middle section can be handed back to the Indians to roam free again under the great sky as their spirit takes them.

As for the rest of us ... we have to accept that America really is a crucible, a melting pot, a country of many countries, and no amount of saluting the Stars and Stripes, united under one banner, will ever change that fact.

LA


Any chance you could one day stop the constant snide childish attacks on the US, LA? You are not fooling anyone. They are obviously not from a point of moral outrage at what goes on, on your part. If it was you would show some character and not be there or take part. But no you are happy to attack at every chance and yet be part of the very system you hate so much.


If you really believe all that you type, you are a sell out. You should make a stand and come home where you are not taking the pieces of silver with one hand with a knife in the other.


>> Edited by rich1231 on Wednesday 1st March 05:15

towman

14,938 posts

270 months

Wednesday 1st March 2006
quotequote all
America is a continent. Therefore someone from Mexico has every right to call themselves american, just the same as i am a European.
I believe what is being referred to here is The United States - that`s a country.

Petty and pedantic? Oh Yes, that`ll be me then !

Balmoral Green

42,561 posts

279 months

Wednesday 1st March 2006
quotequote all
towman said:
America is a continent. Therefore someone from Mexico has every right to call themselves american, just the same as i am a European.
I believe what is being referred to here is The United States - that`s a country.

Petty and pedantic? Oh Yes, that`ll be me then !
Agree entirely. I get fed up with people saying "Oh, were going to America" to which I reply "Oh really, great, which part? Brazil? Peru? Mexico? Canada? Chile? or the United States?". It's a bit like folks who say they are off to Europe, so you assume they are travelling all over. If it's just France, why not bloody well say so!

pcwilson

1,259 posts

267 months

Wednesday 1st March 2006
quotequote all
towman said:
America is a continent. Therefore someone from Mexico has every right to call themselves american, just the same as i am a European.
I believe what is being referred to here is The United States - that`s a country.

Petty and pedantic? Oh Yes, that`ll be me then !


It's The United States of America. Often shortened in common usage to America.

Nick P

29,977 posts

282 months

Wednesday 1st March 2006
quotequote all
srebbe64 said:
The USA is amazingly obnoxious and in the main a very gun friendly place, full of fat people. Problem is, it's also a land of inbreds. The USA has the potential to be a showcase of how different races and cultures can multiply within the same family - it also has the potential to be a showcase for the dangers of the single gene pool.



ewenm

28,506 posts

276 months

Wednesday 1st March 2006
quotequote all
There is an attitude in the USA (or so it appears) that no-one actually is an "American". Everyone has to modify it, so we have "African-Americans", "Irish-Americans", "Native Americans" etc. Perhaps if everyone just accepted they were American and not hark back to some ancestry from 5 generations ago, then people might be able to look and move forward.

By the way, happy St David's day to any Welsh-Americans out there and the Welsh everywhere else in the world.

skinnyboy

4,635 posts

289 months

Wednesday 1st March 2006
quotequote all
The same could be asked of any citizen of a country they weren't born in. Im an Australian Citizen and a British Citizen. I still think of my self as British, yet am in no way proud of that fact, i think the current state of the UK is appalling, which makes me glad to live in my adopted country, although flawed, is a nicer more pleasant and far less stressful place to live and call "Home".

BTW, all the nicest/amusing/intelligent Yanks i have ever met were the ones who left there, and all voted against the Neocon Overlords, funny that eh.

>> Edited by skinnyboy on Wednesday 1st March 08:50

srebbe64

13,021 posts

268 months

Wednesday 1st March 2006
quotequote all
Nick P said:
Nick P said:
The USA is amazingly obnoxious and in the main a very gun friendly place, full of fat people. Problem is, it's also a land of inbreds. The USA has the potential to be a showcase of how different races and cultures can multiply within the same family - it also has the potential to be a showcase for the dangers of the single gene pool.




Ever get the feeling you've been misquoted!

wolves_wanderer

12,959 posts

268 months

Wednesday 1st March 2006
quotequote all
rich1231 said:

Any chance you could one day stop the constant snide childish attacks on the US, LA? You are not fooling anyone. They are obviously not from a point of moral outrage at what goes on, on your part. If it was you would show some character and not be there or take part. But no you are happy to attack at every chance and yet be part of the very system you hate so much.


If you really believe all that you type, you are a sell out. You should make a stand and come home where you are not taking the pieces of silver with one hand with a knife in the other.
Well said Rich. It does seem more than a little ungrateful when someone makes a living in a place and spends the whole time slagging it off. I'm sure the British film industry could do with the help of a Hollywood Screen Writer, maybe if you took a more principled stand and refused to help the economy of the Great Satan people would take what you said more seriously.

As for "compensating" people for doing crap jobs, as has been said, all immigrants everywhere take the crappy jobs to start with and work their way up - if they work. Who exactly should be compensated for slavery that they never suffered? My dad was Irish, maybe I should be compensated for the Potato Famine?

Nick P

29,977 posts

282 months

Wednesday 1st March 2006
quotequote all
ewenm said:
There is an attitude in the USA (or so it appears) that no-one actually is an "American". Everyone has to modify it, so we have "African-Americans", "Irish-Americans", "Native Americans" etc. Perhaps if everyone just accepted they were American and not hark back to some ancestry from 5 generations ago, then people might be able to look and move forward.

By the way, happy St David's day to any Welsh-Americans out there and the Welsh everywhere else in the world.



I spend a lot of time with the US military and it grips my sh1t, the amount of guys who proclaim "I'm Irish".....so when quizzed of what part of Ireland they are from, they answer "Oh, I've never been to Ireland, my great grandfather once visited".....

I once went to Disneyland Paris, but it don't make me Mickey Friggin Mouses grandson

Jinx

12,023 posts

291 months

Wednesday 1st March 2006
quotequote all
I field this one - anyone with citizenship that declares their allegiance to America above and beyond other nationalistic or racial sympathies.