New property vs old property
New property vs old property
Author
Discussion

sjn2004

Original Poster:

4,051 posts

268 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
What type of property would you prefer if both were at the same price?

4 bed new house on a development where the houses are crushed in, very little space to park your car but has En-suite bathroom on master.

vs

4 bed older house but with a big garden, plenty of parking space and scope for an extension but without an ensuite bathroom on master bedroom.

My preference is the older house, can't understand how some of the houses on these crushed in developments sell.

mxdi

13,994 posts

280 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
I prefer old, mainly due to quality of build and the bigger rooms

rico

7,917 posts

286 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
mxdi said:
I prefer old, mainly due to quality of build and the bigger rooms


Ditto... I'd add that the old houses generally have a lot more character.

miniman

30,231 posts

293 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
Old, without a doubt. Build quality of new stuff is dreadful, rooms are small and low-ceilinged, thin walls and are typically crammed together.

monkeyhanger

9,267 posts

273 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
Old. Plenty of scope to put your own stamp on it.

I've seen how the newer estates are built. They look great on the surface but you're in for a shock if you start digging a little deeper.

Mrs Fish

30,018 posts

289 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
los angeles said:
New. I'm fed up with the never-ending patch jobs needed on old property.


But your new house will still get old eventually, so you'll still have to do patch up jobs. For example once it has settled you get all the cracks round skirting boards etc. I would much rather have an older house, with bigger rooms and more land

bga

8,134 posts

282 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
old for me, unless you are paying big money for new they are often inferior in the areas I find important (decent size and good sound insulation). When I last lived in a newbuild I could hear the neighbour logs splashing. My inlaws 10 year old house isn't too bad but is quite noisy.

If I could spec my own house then a newbuild would be good but I imagine it would cost a bit with concrete floors and proper brick internal walls.

Sometimes when having to replaster walls & replace floorboards I long for a modern house, but when the work is finished, all is forgiven.

Paul Drawmer

5,169 posts

298 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
Depends how old. A really old house is just like an old car - it will need constant attention, the completion of one job leaves time to attend to the next!

Having said that, we will probably move into another old house next time. I enjoy the individuality, having a private courtyard, and bloody great open fires in the winter!

Here's how I know about old houses
(advert warning: this house is for sale)
www.postofficecottage.net

hollypop

810 posts

250 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
Old for sure! My boyfriends going from a new build rented place with no charachter, no garden, no parking to a gorgeous old house with ample of everything. I don't like these new builds that are all crammed together.

Lady Summerisle

238 posts

251 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
Old house every time! New build quality is more often than not inferior and I HATE the way they lay out the streets. With some TLC there's no reason why an older house can't have all the mod cons.. our 1860's stone terrace (20" thick walls) has a master en-suite

lord summerisle

8,174 posts

256 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
los angeles said:
I'm thinking about good quality domestic architecture, where they use contemporary materials, insulation, offer a ton of space, light, power points in the right place ....


if you find one let me know...

New is cheap crap thrown up for minimum cot to sell for maximum price...

and within 5 years the upper floor needs relaying as the chipboard settles, stairs creak... you find you cant find something solid to fix those shelves your missus has been pestering you to put up as its just plaster board over a timber frame. the windows need replacing as the double glazing has failed, and you find that the windows reveals have been padded out with chunks of wood and tiles to fit the windows as delivered... and the brickes werent paying too much attention to the brickwork...

all the plants and grass inthe garden start to die off as the ground has crap soil quality, and the builders rubble is hidden just below the layer of turf they threw down...


^^^^ all things i've come accross - some from my Sister's new house she moved into a few years back, my missus' brothers newbuild house. and what i've come accross on site through my practice work

MikeyT

18,508 posts

302 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
Old for me too ...

Who wants a new build where the front door literally opens onto the pavement or has 18" of grass at the front

Or has a garage so thin you can't open your car door? If it has a garage that is ...

Or is about 3" from the house next door ... haven't yet seen a new(ish) house I'd swap my old 'un for.

monkeyhanger

9,267 posts

273 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
New stuff is literally thrown together.

All the brickies, plumbers, sparks, joiners etc will be on Price work and going at it hammer & tongs to make as much money as possible.

My previous employer had seperate housing and commercial/industrial divisions. The housebashers did the new build work and myself and some of the other industrial / commercial sparks frequently got called out to sort the problems they left behind.

I will NEVER buy a new house

soxboy

7,574 posts

250 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
A 'new' house is 'new' only until the next batch of houses are thrown together. If you are considering new, there'll be plenty of snagging problems to chase the developers about (who won't care since they've got rid of the house).

Picture yourself in two summers time when your sat in your garden being stared on by all the neighbours. Would far rather have the space.

sjn2004

Original Poster:

4,051 posts

268 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
I'm surprised so many people think like I do. I can't understand some of these new estates. They build 4/5 bedroom houses which are meant to look like tudor mansions but with a driveway 12 ft long so that everybodies car hangs over the edge of the pavement(thats if they have one). The front garden usually ends up being a triangular strip 10ft x 5ft.

The other thing I've noticed is that they put lots of small windows in so that in any photos, the house looks larger.

simpo two

93,087 posts

296 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
Everybody managed without 'en-suites' until about 15 years ago. Is the landing so scary?

Handy for families I suppose but I never grew up thinking 'if only my bedroom had a bog in it...'

sjn2004

Original Poster:

4,051 posts

268 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
simpo two said:
Everybody managed without 'en-suites' until about 15 years ago. Is the landing so scary?

Handy for families I suppose but I never grew up thinking 'if only my bedroom had a bog in it...'


Well, my grandad always had a bucket by the bedside, does that count?

simpo two

93,087 posts

296 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
sjn2004 said:
Well, my grandad always had a bucket by the bedside, does that count?

Even better, you don't have to get out of bed

hedders

24,460 posts

278 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
As an owner of a new house, I have to say I prefer the build quality of those 1930's places.

But the ensuite IS nice.






clubsport

7,420 posts

289 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
Current grade 2 listed barn conversion (originally built 1860) in conservation area.....put the new roof on at 2pound 50p a tile!...Had to have 6 conservation rooflight!.etc....and the expenditure has gone on and on over the last 5 years........not a bad performing asset none the less

I dream of living in a new house with plastic windows and a upvc front door.....The only thing stopping me is that I would spend Porsche Turbo money on stamp duty which means I will probably be here a little longer....one day

[

>> Edited by clubsport on Tuesday 7th March 22:20