At what age do you tell them the truth
At what age do you tell them the truth
Author
Discussion

morrisman

Original Poster:

264 posts

249 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
My daughter is nearly five, but a month or two ago she came home from school repeatedly singing some inane song: 'Our god is a big big god'

She started telling me about how god was big and good as best she could with her limited 'knowledge'.

I am honestly a bit surprised and disturbed that this sort of brainwashing is still going on in schools, and would have thought it had been stopped years ago, now that religion, god, jesus, the bible and all that clap trap is basically acknowledged to be a personal belief rather than a book of facts.

So, at what age do I start telling my daughter that what they tell her at school is not exactly what it is cracked up to be.

Or don't I?

Parrot of Doom

23,075 posts

265 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
I'd encourage her to figure out her own truths. Engage her in debate, and see how much she can figure out for herself.

If you tell her that God doesn't exist, you're guilty of the same 'brainwashing' as the school are (IMO).

gorvid

22,371 posts

256 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
What kind of school does she attend?
(in terms of relidious affiliation)

Einion Yrth

19,575 posts

275 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
About five years ago would have been a good idea. Given that you missed that deadline, right now should suffice.

scorp

8,783 posts

260 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
Depends on how morally responsible she is, better they believe in a god than believe they can get away with things behind your back

jacksdad

307 posts

293 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
Have two, bith went to a C of E Primary. Left them to make up their own mind and they seem pretty rounded. Not a botherer myself, J has followed me, but the little girl quite likes the village church.

Difficult though, good luck !

hanse cronje

2,423 posts

252 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
mmm we had that and raised it at patronizing evening,

we were told that they are just fascinated by the stories and that no one is force fed religion
RE is compulsory but they cover all faiths

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
morrisman said:
My daughter is nearly five, but a month or two ago she came home from school repeatedly singing some inane song: 'Our god is a big big god'


Maybe she meant Dog.

Do you have a dog a big big dog?

grass widow

2,201 posts

254 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
My two came home from school singing gods praises, but I left them to it, over the years they have questioned things for themselves, and I have been honest with them when they've asked me if I believe.

They know both their father and I are not believers, but I have never directly influenced their beliefs, I have told them that if they believe then that is fine as there is not right or wrong.

They are 11 and 9, and both have decided for themselves that they don't believe in god after all.

Its best to let her make her own mind up as she grows.

ehyouwhat

4,606 posts

249 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
I'd have a chat with them now and mention that it is up to her whether she believes the stories she is told at school, Tell them that no-one really knows the truth, but that the most important thing is that they make their own mind up and figure out what they want to believe.

My future mother-in-law basically tried to brainwash her current grandaughter-in-law into believing that there is a God, and that anyone who believes otherwise is wrong. I really took issue with the fact and I personally sat the little girl down and told her that what she had been told MIGHT not be true. I got into a fair amount of trouble for it but I don't feel any shame or guilt, as it really isn't the right of my future MIL to make someone believe something that she can't prove.

I personally have my own beliefs (atheist) but I would NOT force this opinion on others - I would want them to make up their own mind though, and I would insist that there is no shame in believing something different to what they have been taught in school or by anyone else.

simpo two

93,087 posts

296 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
Kill this nonsense now. Tell her in a suitable manner that 'god' is an simply an imaginary being that helps fools and the insecure find 'answers' to their problems - either when they don't know what the answers really are, or when they are afraid to face them.

Had to chuckle at the vicar who resigned today after a lifetime telling people to 'forgive'. When her daughter was killed it rather woke her up. Welcome to the human race, Vicar.

hedders

24,460 posts

278 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
stovey said:
morrisman said:
My daughter is nearly five, but a month or two ago she came home from school repeatedly singing some inane song: 'Our god is a big big god'


Maybe she meant Dog.

Do you have a dog a big big dog?



Yup, fingers crossed she is just dyslexic, not religous.



BliarOut

72,863 posts

270 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
What makes you think they'll listen whatever you tell them anyway, you're their dad. You open your mouth and all they actually hear is blah, blah, blah.

Just tell them some people believe in a god and some people believe in many gods and some believe in big bang theory. It's up to them what they choose to believe. At their age there's no point ramming home the fact that there isn't a god if it makes them happy. They'll make up their own minds when they are old enough.

victormeldrew

8,293 posts

308 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
Parrot of Doom said:
I'd encourage her to figure out her own truths. Engage her in debate, and see how much she can figure out for herself.

If you tell her that God doesn't exist, you're guilty of the same 'brainwashing' as the school are (IMO).
It might just create some sort of balance though.

It shouldn't be taught in school. Some sort of moral guidance yes, good citizenship or whatever, but not religion. That has to be the choice of the parents to a degree, and of course the child itself once old enough to decide. I get a bit of grief over this as I won't allow my son to be Christened until he is old enough to decide for himself that he wants it, and specifically asks for it.

Still, I was force fed the guff at school and still in the end thought "yeah, whatever".

AL666

2,679 posts

249 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
As someone who was taught all of the Bible stories from starting primary school and never believing in God, I think you should just leave her to it. Any learning when they're young will just help to improve their knowledge and when they get a bit older they'll choose what they want to believe in.... Learning about religion could help them to understand right from wrong.

stone

1,538 posts

278 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
simpo two said:
Kill this nonsense now. Tell her in a suitable manner that 'god' is an simply an imaginary being that helps fools and the insecure find 'answers' to their problems - either when they don't know what the answers really are, or when they are afraid to face them.

Don't mince your words

Pigeon

18,535 posts

277 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
BliarOut said:
Just tell them some people believe in a god and some people believe in many gods and some believe in big bang theory.

No, whatever you do don't mention big bang theory. That's science, not religion; the two are not opposed but are on two orthogonal axes. The failure of loads of people (notably Bishop Wilberforce) to grasp this fact has resulted in the spouting of terabytes of irrelevant garbage.

jessica

6,321 posts

283 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
scorp said:
Depends on how morally responsible she is, better they believe in a god than believe they can get away with things behind your back


or go to confession on a sunday

>> Edited by jessica on Tuesday 7th March 22:11

puffpuff

23,217 posts

257 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
scorp said:
Depends on how morally responsible she is, better they believe in a god than believe they can get away with things behind your back


Almost right. I'd say better they believe in good .....

wolf1

3,103 posts

281 months

Tuesday 7th March 2006
quotequote all
At five I'd leave well alone. Their innocence will dwindle soon enough. Revell in it whilst it still exists.