South Dakota bans abortion
South Dakota bans abortion
Author
Discussion

Lion-O

Original Poster:

242 posts

259 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
Excerpt from the New York Times:

New York Times said:
Gov. Michael Rounds of South Dakota signed into law the nation's most sweeping state abortion ban on Monday, an intentional provocation meant to set up a direct legal challenge to Roe v. Wade, the 1973 United States Supreme Court decision that made abortion legal.

The law makes it a felony to perform any abortion except in a case of a pregnant woman's life being in jeopardy.


I know my fellow PHers are not ones to shy from controversy, so I thought I would open up the floor. What do you think?


>> Edited by Lion-O on Wednesday 8th March 00:30

wedg1e

27,044 posts

296 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
I think thinking is SO important.




Sorry

nwtony

3,011 posts

259 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
It's been done deliberately as they now think the balance of the supreme court has shifted to anti-abortionists. Personally im pro choice which seems to me everyone gets what they want. Women that want to have an abortion can and those that object don't have to.

unlogic

162 posts

249 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
Not a good idea for discussion or on a motoring forum

nwtony

3,011 posts

259 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
unlogic said:
Not a good idea for discussion or on a motoring forum


In fairness it's an any other subject section of the forums of a motoring website. We've discussed all sorts recently - why not this?

wedg1e

27,044 posts

296 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
Gazboy said:
What's to stop a woman crossing state lines to a more civilised state to have an abortion?


Good ole boys with guns?

Lion-O

Original Poster:

242 posts

259 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
unlogic said:
Not a good idea for discussion or on a motoring forum


IF we can handle the vagaries of the Middle East Conflict and the questionmarks over climate change, I'm sure we can handle a debate on whether the state has the right to legislate against abortion. The Pie and Piston is after all the non-motoring forum.

moleamol

15,887 posts

294 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
nwtony said:
It's been done deliberately as they now think the balance of the supreme court has shifted to anti-abortionists. Personally im pro choice which seems to me everyone gets what they want. Women that want to have an abortion can and those that object don't have to.
Exactly, whether someone regrets their decision or not is not the choice of the law, but of that person. They should be allowed to make the decision.

wedg1e

27,044 posts

296 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
moleamol said:
Exactly, whether someone regrets their decision or not is not the choice of the law, but of that person. They should be allowed to make the decision.


Seatbelts! Don't get me started on seatbelts...

Lion-O

Original Poster:

242 posts

259 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
The trouble with the pro-life argument is that by taking life as starting at conception and endowing a fertilised egg with full human rights, which is the bedrock of their position, they are putting themselves into an interesting legal quandary.

Is the woman who gets drunk one night or takes drugs while knowing or unknowingly pregnant and subsequently miscarries guilty of manslaughter? If we accept the pro-life principle she is.

and what about the IVF doctor who fertilises hundreds of eggs before rejecting most of them. Should he stand trial for mass murder? It sounds ridiculous, but this is what would be the case were you to distill the pro-life argument.

>> Edited by Lion-O on Wednesday 8th March 00:51

moleamol

15,887 posts

294 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
Lion-O said:
The trouble with the pro-life argument is that by taking life as starting at conception and endowing a fertilised egg with full human rights, which is the bedrock of their position, they are putting themselves into an interesting legal quandary.

Is the woman who gets drunk one night or takes drugs while knowing or unknowingly pregnant and subsequently miscarries guilty of manslaughter? If we accept the pro-life principle she is.

and what about the IVF doctor who fertilises hundreds of eggs before rejecting most of them. Should he stand trial for mass murder? It sounds ridiculous, but this is what would be the case were you to distill the pro-life argument.

>> Edited by Lion-O on Wednesday 8th March 00:51
What about the chap having a wk?

Raffles

1,931 posts

261 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
wedg1e said:
I think thinking is SO important.


He looks like a bird who's swallowed a plate, My Lord.

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
Gazboy said:
unlogic said:
Not a good idea for discussion or on a motoring forum


You are kidding aren't you? This has been done to death (excuse the pun) many times. Also there are some people here who appear to be unaware that this place actually is a motoring website (yes it's a gripe of mine- sue me).

Pie and piston is for non motoring matters.

It says so on the front page.

Jaglover

46,848 posts

266 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
Gazboy said:
Also there are some people here who appear to be unaware that this place actually is a motoring website (yes it's a gripe of mine- sue me).


What is this "motoring" you are talking about.

Jaglover

46,848 posts

266 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
The problem with America’s abortion laws is that they were made by the courts rather than democratically elected politicians. This has meant with the 'all or nothing attitude’ of courts, that such abominations as ‘partial birth’ abortions are permitted; and if ‘Roe vs wade’ is overturned it will swing too far the other way and virtually all abortions will be banned in many states.

GavinPearson

5,715 posts

282 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
I'm prepared to be shot down in flames here - in Britain we've tended to not get caught up in a big morality & religious debate when it comes to Politics. When Maggie was in the mantra was extreme capitalism and low tax, shoot the argies and kick the backsides of our friends in the EU. With Blair it's about stealth tax, backhanders and kissing the backside of our friends in the EU. Blair is religious, as we heard last week, but there's not been big talk of letting the church run the country.

The US is not like this, and the Republican voter demographic tends to be a conservative bible basher who likes low tax. Their solution to everything is that the lord helps those who help themselves, we'll pray for you, it was an act of God, etc. The Democrats are a bit more socially conscious and pragmatic, but inclinded to tax a bit too much. And they like lawyers a bit too much.

From a straw poll of friends voting the first time Bush got in I found quite a number of people I thought would be Republicans voting Democrat, the tipping point being Roe v Wade.

If this South Dakota bill goes to the Supreme court, and Roe v Wade is dissolved I think you would find states clarify their policy in law, and at the next election it would be the election issue, which the Democrats would win by mobilising a generally apathetic young electorate to vote on something their care about greatly.

Personally I would be fine with Bill Clinton still being in office, the economy was in much better shape and I don't think God would have had much influence over him on Foreign Policy.

vixpy1

42,699 posts

295 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
Jaglover said:
Gazboy said:
Also there are some people here who appear to be unaware that this place actually is a motoring website (yes it's a gripe of mine- sue me).


What is this "motoring" you are talking about.


Its kinda like accounting..

minimax

11,985 posts

287 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
Gazboy said:
What's to stop a woman crossing state lines to a more civilised state to have an abortion?


hopefully nothing, I think it's bloody awful that the state can tell a woman what to do with her body.

I would imagine that a woman has a pretty good idea as to whether it'd be a good idea to give birth to and bring up a child so if she's inclined to make the (what must be) heart rending decision to terminate that pregnancy then I say let her be free to do that

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
I believe abortion is illegal in Eire too? I believe they even have laws to make it illegal for a woman to travel to the UK to get one.

Am I right, anyone?

I reckon this will be fixed. I doubt the US will go down the "pro-life" route.

Lois

14,706 posts

283 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
Don said:
I believe abortion is illegal in Eire too? I believe they even have laws to make it illegal for a woman to travel to the UK to get one.

Am I right, anyone?

I reckon this will be fixed. I doubt the US will go down the "pro-life" route.


I think they are still allowed one if continuing the pregnancy endangers her life whether it be a physical or psychological problem, if she has learning difficulties, the fetus has abnormalities or if she's been raped.
They cannot prevent a woman leaving the country to have an abortion though.