Stamp duty! Can it really be beaten? Some say yes...!
Stamp duty! Can it really be beaten? Some say yes...!
Author
Discussion

AdvocatusDiaboli

Original Poster:

2,278 posts

262 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
www.qck.com/avoid-stamp-duty.html

I am in the process of buying a place and the stamp duty is just murder!

I came across this book during a web search and it inrigued me. I haven't bought it, because I think its probably not workable.

What I am interested here is in the collective knowledge on our forum. Does anyone know any way of stamp duty can be beaten? For example 8000 on a 270k property or some such.

Zod

35,295 posts

289 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
For most people, no it can't be beaten. If it could, the methods would be common knowledge, would have been legislated away by the government. If you have to pay for a book to learn the secret knowledge, that is a good sign that it is bullshit.

touchingcloth

11,706 posts

270 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
The only trick I am aware of is used if just above the threshold. So for a £260k house you pay £250k for the house and £10k for fixtures and fitting, this drops you back down into the 1% bracket rather than the 3% which is a hell of a saving. It is legal but you can't take the mickey, I would think that £20k fixtures and fittings on a £250k house would be a step too far as far as Gordon was concerned, however if you prove it by valuing everything then it would be fine.

Quite why the rates are not staggered like income tax baffles me every time, it should be 1% on first £250K and then 3% only on stuff above that, not backtracked for the full amount. It just creates price black holes in the housing market.. (but I guess it makes money so we have our answer)



>> Edited by touchingcloth on Wednesday 8th March 10:52

theaxe

3,571 posts

253 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
I think the only way to do this is to class items as 'extras'. So if the house is £260,000 you get the vendor to charge £249,999 (thus falling into a lower SD band) and then pay £10,000 in 'cash' as a separate transaction for extras like kitchen units/white goods/curtains/whatever...

minicity

1,009 posts

262 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
Touchingcloth is correct - but be aware that the taxman will focus on all property sold just below the 250k mark. If I understand correctly, a person can sell something for whatever they like (e.g. a house for 50p) - but tax is supposed to be paid at the going rate.

JonRB

80,215 posts

303 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
touchingcloth said:
Quite why the rates are not staggered like income tax baffles me every time, it should be 1% on first £250K and then 3% only on stuff above that, not backtracked for the full amount. It just creates price black holes in the housing market..
Indeed. I have long held the same opinion.

xjsjohn

16,152 posts

250 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
i have heard of one story where the property in question was £400,000 (or thereabouts) and the couple in question bought it as a partnership ....

so 2 morgages, one in wifes name, one in husbands name ... both partners purchase £200,000 share of property and pay 1% stamp

However the problems here are

2 morgages to worry about
2 morgages to raise (can each partner independantly raise teh sum on thier income)
need a creative Financial advisor / soliciter.

Its not illegal as far as i know, but i am sure that it could be scrutinised quite heavily ...

I just bought a very expensive second hand kitchen myself

edited to say that i hasten to add that i only "heard through word of mouth" about this one and could have been told a load of old Bks



>> Edited by xjsjohn on Wednesday 8th March 11:00

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
xjsjohn said:
i have heard of one story where the property in question was £400,000 (or thereabouts) and the couple in question bought it as a partnership ....

so 2 morgages, one in wifes name, one in husbands name ... both partners purchase £200,000 share of property and pay 1% stamp

However the problems here are

2 morgages to worry about
2 morgages to raise (can each partner independantly raise teh sum on thier income)
need a creative Financial advisor / soliciter.

Its not illegal as far as i know, but i am sure that it could be scrutinised quite heavily ...

I just bought a very expensive second hand kitchen myself

edited to say that i hasten to add that i only "heard through word of mouth" about this one and could have been told a load of old Bks

>> Edited by xjsjohn on Wednesday 8th March 11:00


I would guess this is either total bollox or that the costs involved in setting this up in the first place would somehow negate to a certain extent the saving on Stamp Duty.

As has been said before the tax man has become v suspicious of people buying houses close to stamp duty limits. Also any good solicitor will tell you that even if it's not near the limits if you start buying chattels (spelling?) at rediculous prices to lessen your bill then that is viewed as tax evasion and you could end up in rather deep do do!!!

Moral.... be honest or risk a nasty shock call from Mr Taxman!!!





>> Edited by anonymous-user on Wednesday 8th March 11:05

timmy30

9,325 posts

258 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
xjsjohn said:
i have heard of one story where the property in question was £400,000 (or thereabouts) and the couple in question bought it as a partnership ....

so 2 morgages, one in wifes name, one in husbands name ... both partners purchase £200,000 share of property and pay 1% stamp


I would think the IR would be all over that one like a rash.

pcwilson

1,259 posts

267 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
AdvocatusDiaboli said:
www.qck.com/avoid-stamp-duty.html

I am in the process of buying a place and the stamp duty is just murder!

I came across this book during a web search and it inrigued me. I haven't bought it, because I think its probably not workable.

What I am interested here is in the collective knowledge on our forum. Does anyone know any way of stamp duty can be beaten? For example 8000 on a 270k property or some such.



1. Buy lots of cheap houses instead of one expensive house and knock them together.
2. Buy in a SD exempt postal code and learn to love the chav scum.

Hope that helps

pdV6

16,442 posts

292 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
JonRB said:
touchingcloth said:
Quite why the rates are not staggered like income tax baffles me every time, it should be 1% on first £250K and then 3% only on stuff above that, not backtracked for the full amount. It just creates price black holes in the housing market..
Indeed. I have long held the same opinion.

anything else is just profiteering by the government. In fact, this has quite a detrimental effect on the housing market, as it creates "no-go" areas on price; nobody in their right mind is going to pay £255k for a house as it gives a large tax liability for no benefit. Therefore anything with an asking price up to, say, £260k or so is 'rightly' viewed as "selling price: £249,999". Houses in the range £260k - £270k or so struggle as well, as they really need to be able to show that they're worth the extra plus the tax.

Re: the "extras" trick mentioned by a few - HMRC is well aware of this ruse and the revised Stamp Duty Land Tax rules (which came into force in Dec '03) were drafted with this in mind. They can and do check tax returns (for that is now what it is) for irregularities, concentrating specifically on "borderline" cases such as those near the £120k / £250k / £500k SDLT bands.

There's nothing wrong with paying "separately" for certain items in a house purchase, but be aware that the valuations used must be legit - claiming that the curtains are worth £10k+ will land you with a charge of tax evasion, a requirement to pay the tax due, interest thereon, a fine of up to the same amount as the "evaded" tax plus a criminal record.

Simply charging the higher rate on the difference in price would completely sort out all these problems by making it pointless to try to fiddle the system and remove another headache from the HMRC's "enforcers".

I still don't see why we have a tax on moving house in the first place?

>> Edited by pdV6 on Wednesday 8th March 11:25

xjsjohn

16,152 posts

250 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
as stated, it was only something that i had been told, rather than seen in action ..

At the end of the day what people say here is correct, cough up.

Best solution is to have a competent accountant, pay up the obvious taxes that they like to wring out of you (Stamp, NI, etc), and make hay in the less obvious areas ...

Eric Mc

125,928 posts

296 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
And the Conservatives promised that they would abolish Stamp Duty back in 1991. Unfortunately, they "forgot" nad then got booted out of office.

I wonder what Cameron has to say about this subject.

victormeldrew

8,293 posts

308 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
pdv6 said:
I still don't see why we have a tax on moving house in the first place?
I know what you mean, but you could replace "moving house" with pretty much anything, couldn't you?

I still don't see why we have a tax on cars in the first place?
I still don't see why we have a tax on petrol in the first place?
I still don't see why we have a tax on employment in the first place?
I still don't see why we have a tax on added value in the first place?
I still don't see why we have a tax on death in the first place?
I still don't see why we have a tax on capital gain in the first place?
I still don't see why we have a tax on insurance in the first place?

sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
Offer to pay the vendor's estate agent and legal fees on the basis this cost will be omitted from the agreed purchase price.

pdV6

16,442 posts

292 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
victormeldrew said:
pdv6 said:
I still don't see why we have a tax on moving house in the first place?
I know what you mean, but you could replace "moving house" with pretty much anything, couldn't you?

I still don't see why we have a tax on cars in the first place?
I still don't see why we have a tax on petrol in the first place?
I still don't see why we have a tax on employment in the first place?
I still don't see why we have a tax on added value in the first place?
I still don't see why we have a tax on death in the first place?
I still don't see why we have a tax on capital gain in the first place?
I still don't see why we have a tax on insurance in the first place?


Not really.

From that list, my personal view is:

Houses - why? Don't they want people to move house to follow work?
Cars - Fair enough; road users pay for upkeep of the road (in theory! )
Petrol - Again, fair enough; no need for pay-as-you-drive charges - its built-in to fuel costs FFS!
Employent - Fair enough; its the price we pay for our way of life.
VAT - Hmm. Not too sure about this one.
Death - Totally against! They've had their cut already during life. Keep yer grubby mits off.
CG - Against! Smacks of sour grapes. Why should you be penalised for shrewd investment?
Insurance - Yeah, that's a weird one allright.

pdV6

16,442 posts

292 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
sleep envy said:
Offer to pay the vendor's estate agent and legal fees on the basis this cost will be omitted from the agreed purchase price.

Again, HMRC would be over you like a rash.

The wording of the SDLT1 tax return is "What is the total consideration in money or money's worth, including any VAT actually payable for the transaction notified?"

This neatly covers anything you do to get the total cost "down"...

cinque

833 posts

313 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
Yes there is a way around it & its also perfectly legal.

It involves transfer of ownership, off-shore trusts and peppercorn rents.

However, once youve taken into consideration the IFR's fee's, lack of knowledge of the system with solcitors (also including heavier fee's), greasing the palm of the vendor (& also trying to explain to the vendor what the plan is and them abiding to it), its a lot of hassle and money spent for a negligible gain.





>> Edited by cinque on Wednesday 8th March 11:43

Mr E

23,105 posts

290 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
I thought stamp duty was payable on the amount of cash exhanged, not the cost of the house. So you can buy the house for a quid, and million pounds of fittings and you still get stung.....

Zod

35,295 posts

289 months

Wednesday 8th March 2006
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
And the Conservatives promised that they would abolish Stamp Duty back in 1991. Unfortunately, they "forgot" nad then got booted out of office.

I wonder what Cameron has to say about this subject.
They were only going to abolish stamp duty on share sales as far as I remember. They failed to do so and Labour has also failed to do so.