Force Feeding Hunger Strikers?
Force Feeding Hunger Strikers?
Author
Discussion

Mrs Fish

Original Poster:

30,018 posts

289 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
ananova said:
Guantanamo force-feeding should end

More than 260 doctors, including best-selling British author Oliver Sacks, have called on the US to abandon force-feeding of Guantanamo Bay hunger strikers.

Medics from seven countries signed a joint letter published in this week's edition of leading journal The Lancet.

International agreements prevent doctors from force-feeding hunger strikers if the individuals have made an informed choice about their protest, the doctors said.

Restraint chairs to hold inmates while feeding tubes are inserted - which are reportedly used at the US military base in Cuba - are also banned, they added.

Doctors at Guantanamo Bay who are carrying out the actions should be disciplined by their professional bodies, the letter concluded.

A total of 263 doctors from the UK, Ireland, US, Germany, Australia, Italy and the Netherlands signed the letter, which was co-ordinated by Dr David Nicholl of City Hospital, Birmingham.

Dr Nicholl said: "This letter really shows the strength of feeling amongst the world's leading medical experts.

"They are saying with one voice that force-feeding of hunger strikers by medical staff at Guantanamo is unequivocally wrong."

Another co-signatory to the letter, psychiatrist Dr William Hopkins of the Medical Foundation for the Care of Victims of Torture, said: "Doctors force-feeding prisoners at Guantanamo are acting as an arm of the military and have abrogated their medical-ethical duties.

"The American Medical Association should launch disciplinary proceedings against any of its members known to have participated in violating prisoners' rights in this way."



Not sure what to think on this subject... should they be force fed or should they be left alone?

Pat H

8,058 posts

287 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Mrs Fish said:
Not sure what to think on this subject... should they be force fed or should they be left alone?


They should be charged with an offence, or released.

The place is a concentration camp and the US government ought to be ashamed of itself.

Mrs Fish

Original Poster:

30,018 posts

289 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Pat H said:
Mrs Fish said:
Not sure what to think on this subject... should they be force fed or should they be left alone?


They should be charged with an offence, or released.

The place is a concentration camp and the US government ought to be ashamed of itself.




Well there is that

Jaglover

46,848 posts

266 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Pat H said:
Mrs Fish said:
Not sure what to think on this subject... should they be force fed or should they be left alone?


They should be charged with an offence, or released.

The place is a concentration camp and the US government ought to be ashamed of itself.



Do you think that German soldiers captured in WW2 should have been released before the end of hostilities? After all, most of them had committed no crime.

The point is that you may not be able to convict these people in a court of law, but they are enemy combatants in an ongoing war. Many of those released have subsequently been killed while fighting against American and allied forces.

sputnik

268 posts

256 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Pat H said:
Mrs Fish said:
Not sure what to think on this subject... should they be force fed or should they be left alone?


They should be charged with an offence, or released.

The place is a concentration camp and the US government ought to be ashamed of itself.





And the US has the cheek to criticise Iran and Korea's record on Human Rights.


hammerwerfer

3,234 posts

271 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Jaglover said:
Do you think that German soldiers captured in WW2 should have been released before the end of hostilities? After all, most of them had committed no crime.

The point is that you may not be able to convict these people in a court of law, but they are enemy combatants in an ongoing war. Many of those released have subsequently been killed while fighting against American and allied forces.


I have to agree with that argument. To allow them commit suicide whilst in custody would be irresponsible, as the deaths would make martyrs of them, just like the IRA lads of not that long ago.

To release them would be even more foolhardy.

billb

3,198 posts

296 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
anyone see the doc on guantaaaa bay last night? was v interesting to see the other side

scorp

8,783 posts

260 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
billb said:
anyone see the doc on guantaaaa bay last night? was v interesting to see the other side

I saw a bit of it, it didn't look like it was anywhere near the geneva convention, oh well, rummy said they are sticking to it 'for the most part'

Yugguy

10,728 posts

266 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Ungrateful , Sainsburys charge me a fortune for my weekly food, and they're getting it for free.

Jaglover

46,848 posts

266 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
scorp said:

I saw a bit of it, it didn't look like it was anywhere near the geneva convention, oh well, rummy said they are sticking to it 'for the most part'


To begin with the facilities were somewhat rudimentary, but they are now superior to WW2 prisoner of war camps, to use an obvious comparison

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Yugguy said:
Ungrateful , Sainsburys charge me a fortune for my weekly food, and they're getting it for free.

I know they've been on a free holiday to cuba for yonks now all inclusive n' all. They even get free haircuts.

You don't see Cubans going to Tipton for their jollies do you?

scorp

8,783 posts

260 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Jaglover said:
To begin with the facilities were somewhat rudimentary, but they are now superior to WW2 prisoner of war camps, to use an obvious comparison


Did you watch last nights program? did you see how the northern alliance (allegedly) treat the POW's?

B17NNS

18,506 posts

278 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Jaglover said:
WW2 prisoner of war camps

dont know what those lot were griping about to be honest.

from the films it looked like a bit of a giggle, lots of footie, digging tunnels etc.

Jaglover

46,848 posts

266 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
scorp said:
Jaglover said:
To begin with the facilities were somewhat rudimentary, but they are now superior to WW2 prisoner of war camps, to use an obvious comparison


Did you watch last nights program? did you see how the northern alliance (allegedly) treat the POW's?


My apologies; I thought you were referring to the early situation at Guantanamo bay.

john75

5,303 posts

278 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
B17NNS said:
Jaglover said:
WW2 prisoner of war camps

dont know what those lot were griping about to be honest.

from the films it looked like a bit of a giggle, lots of footie, digging tunnels etc.


Do not fancy it myself I am sure POW camps in Germany were anything but the like in the film the Great Escape and as of Japan.

Jaglover

46,848 posts

266 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
john75 said:
B17NNS said:
Jaglover said:
WW2 prisoner of war camps

dont know what those lot were griping about to be honest.

from the films it looked like a bit of a giggle, lots of footie, digging tunnels etc.


Do not fancy it myself I am sure POW camps in Germany were anything but the like in the film the Great Escape and as of Japan.


The Germans tended to treat western POW's fairly humanly. In contrast around 3 million(I think) Russian POW's died in captivity.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
The issue is force feeding them!! If they want to kill themselves through hunger let them BUT the US going against all know international conventions on this is totally out of order. Another example of cowboy antics from the Bush administration I'm afraid!!

B17NNS

18,506 posts

278 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
perhaps I should have added a

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
B17NNS said:
perhaps I should have added a
obviously. .

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
stovey said:
B17NNS said:
perhaps I should have added a
obviously. .


My comments were not disrected at you guys. Just making a statement of fact/opinion!!

Personally I think anything to do with tunneling is a big of a giggle!!