The end of Pink Floyd?
Author
Discussion

celticpilgrim

Original Poster:

1,965 posts

274 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
I caught a bit of an interview with David Gilmour to copincide with his new CD coming out. He seemed to say that Floyd at Live8 was some sort of closure, and he didn't see much of a future for them. He also had 'interesting' opinions of his fellow band members.

The mag might have been rock sound or something like that.

hedders

24,460 posts

278 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Can't say I am suprised.

We will always have the memories, well those of us that saw them in concert will

paulie-mafia

3,321 posts

254 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Yeah Roger Waters was keen to get the band back together for a tour after Live8, and discussions did go on behind closed doors, but ultimately they came to nothing. I think Dave Gilmour was a little hesitant as the 20 year rift between them still cuts a bit. I guess the other thing is, they're all getting on a bit now and have other interests - Nick Mason has his cars, Dave and Roger have their own musical interests. Not sure what Rick's doing!

Personally, I'm gutted I never got to see them when they were together, but Roger Waters' Hyde Park gig in the summer is going to be as close as it gets for me. Think Floyd and The Real Pink Floyd are worth seeing too!

tubbystu

3,846 posts

291 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
paulie-mafia said:
Yeah Roger Waters was keen to get the band back together for a tour after Live8, and discussions did go on behind closed doors, but ultimately they came to nothing. I think Dave Gilmour was a little hesitant as the 20 year rift between them still cuts a bit. I guess the other thing is, they're all getting on a bit now and have other interests - Nick Mason has his cars, Dave and Roger have their own musical interests. Not sure what Rick's doing!

Personally, I'm gutted I never got to see them when they were together, but Roger Waters' Hyde Park gig in the summer is going to be as close as it gets for me. Think Floyd and The Real Pink Floyd are worth seeing too!


As are The Austrailian Pink Floyd - very good they are, certainly at the The Royal Albert Hall

paulie-mafia

3,321 posts

254 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Just found this from t'Guardian...

http://observer.guardian.co.uk/review

lord summerisle

8,174 posts

256 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
hedders said:
Can't say I am suprised.

We will always have the memories, well those of us that saw them in concert will



thought it was like Woodstock and the 60s...

if you can remember it, you weren't there

scared but happy

24,147 posts

260 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
I think that music has moved on and the young ones of today do not understand such groundbreaking material, perhaps in 20 years Vengaboys will be listened to with the same memories.
Also as a business they need to shift as many albums as possible and with groups like the floyd they will always be referred back to the heady days of Atom Heart Mother, The Wall, Meddle Wish You Were Here (come on have you screamed out How I wish, how I wish you were here at the top of your voice when driving (or is it me ).


Anyway I thought The Final Cut was it?
When I was a lad ...

paulie-mafia

3,321 posts

254 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
scared but happy said:
come on have you screamed out How I wish, how I wish you were here at the top of your voice when driving (or is it me ).


No, you're not alone mate! And isn't 'The Wall' at full volume just the best way to unwind in the car?!

As for the younger generation not appreciating the Floyd, it's sad but true. That said I'm only 27 and I'm contemplating getting a prism tattoed on my back with the words "Run, rabbit run. Dig that hole, forget the sun" beneath it...

hedders

24,460 posts

278 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
lord summerisle said:
hedders said:
Can't say I am suprised.

We will always have the memories, well those of us that saw them in concert will



thought it was like Woodstock and the 60s...

if you can remember it, you weren't there


ah,but I have seen them a few times so i have managed to hold onto a couple of vague recollections

Cotty

42,283 posts

315 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
hedders said:
lord summerisle said:
hedders said:
Can't say I am suprised.

We will always have the memories, well those of us that saw them in concert will



thought it was like Woodstock and the 60s...

if you can remember it, you weren't there


ah,but I have seen them a few times so i have managed to hold onto a couple of vague recollections


I got to see them twice, once in Docklands Arena and once at Knebworth got most of their almums

"through the fish eyed lens of tear stained eyes"

DanBoy

4,899 posts

274 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
A girl I work with said she had tickets to go and see Pink Floyd...

Now I'm confused.

paulie-mafia

3,321 posts

254 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
DanBoy said:
A girl I work with said she had tickets to go and see Pink Floyd...

Now I'm confused.


One of the tribute acts (I think the Australian Pink Floyd are doing a few dates soon), or this:

www.hydeparkcalling.co.uk

hedders

24,460 posts

278 months

Friday 10th March 2006
quotequote all
Cotty said:


I got to see them twice, once in Docklands Arena and once at Knebworth got most of their almums

"through the fish eyed lens of tear stained eyes"


I saw them at docklands, and wembley and in the states, i remember the one in the states best because the drugs are weaker over there

jagdpanther

19,633 posts

250 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
paulie-mafia said:
scared but happy said:
come on have you screamed out How I wish, how I wish you were here at the top of your voice when driving (or is it me ).


No, you're not alone mate! And isn't 'The Wall' at full volume just the best way to unwind in the car?!

As for the younger generation not appreciating the Floyd, it's sad but true. That said I'm only 27 and I'm contemplating getting a prism tattoed on my back with the words "Run, rabbit run. Dig that hole, forget the sun" beneath it...


I got news to make you happy
Ive been into Pink Floyd since I was a little boy, and Im only a young 'un at 24 now

Greatest musicians and lyricists on the planet in my opinion (and my girlfriends!!)

Cotty

42,283 posts

315 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
jagdpanther said:

Ive been into Pink Floyd since I was a little boy, and Im only a young 'un at 24 now

Greatest musicians and lyricists on the planet in my opinion (and my girlfriends!!)


Just out of interest what are you favorite albums, is it the early or late stuff you like

Matthew C

4,028 posts

268 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
I bought myself The Wall today and am listening to it now (for the first time).

jagdpanther

19,633 posts

250 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
Cotty said:
jagdpanther said:

Ive been into Pink Floyd since I was a little boy, and Im only a young 'un at 24 now

Greatest musicians and lyricists on the planet in my opinion (and my girlfriends!!)


Just out of interest what are you favorite albums, is it the early or late stuff you like


I like all of their albums but my favourite albums are
Dark Side Of The Moon
The Final Cut
The Wall
Meddle
Animals

tinman0

18,231 posts

271 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
scared but happy said:
Anyway I thought The Final Cut was it?


Final Cut was the album that could be considered a step in the wrong direction. Roger Waters hated Thatcher, and the Final Cut was an album (in my opinion) that was against war, especially the Falklands Conflict which had just happened (or was happening).

IIRC Roger Waters never met his father as he was killed before Roger was born in WW2, so its easy to understand why someone in that position doesn't like war and could be quite vocal about such a thing. And Final Cut was that outlet.

But that was the problem - it was too much Roger Waters and Michael Kamen.

That direction could not continue, eg one person essentially writing the whole album and an anthem about their own personal outlook.

Its interesting what Dave Gilmour has written recently - that at the time the music was being overtaken by the words, or something like that, and that he wanted to get back to the balance of music and words. Something that you can see demonstrated in the Lapse album after Waters left.



What is even more strange is that the above is from my own research and looking round the interweb several other writers have backed up my theory.

Size Nine Elm

5,167 posts

315 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
tinman0 said:

IIRC Roger Waters never met his father as he was killed before Roger was born in WW2, so its easy to understand why someone in that position doesn't like war and could be quite vocal about such a thing. And Final Cut was that outlet.

Indeed, "When the tigers broke free" was his story of his father's death in the war...
Roger Waters said:

...and thats how the high command took my daddy from me

Floyd was already fracturing then, since Roger Waters efectively fired Rick Wright during the recording of the Wall, brought in Machael Kamen, and then hired Rick Wright as a session musician for The Wall tour. And there had been a lot of bickering over roaylties for years...

However, Amused To Death is a superb Roger Waters album in the style of the 70s Floyd, and well worth a listen. (Also features Jeff Beck on guitar, another favourite). So he hadn't completely lost it

>> Edited by Size Nine Elm on Saturday 11th March 17:52

Cotty

42,283 posts

315 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
Matthew C said:
I bought myself The Wall today and am listening to it now (for the first time).

Good man, see the film next