Wanna play with guns?
Author
Discussion

Mannginger

Original Poster:

10,309 posts

288 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
The Americans show us how it should be done!

http://video.google.com/videoplay?doc

(Perhaps the kid is a little too young to be joining Dad with this particular hobby however)

Thanks to B3TA for directing me to the link.

Phil

chim_knee

12,689 posts

288 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
I must be getting old because I thought that it was disgusting to have that little girl doing the shooting. Absolutely abhorrent.

In fact, most of it made me think WTF makes these people tick. Violence for violence's sake IMHO.

(Nothing personal of course Mannginger)

>> Edited by chim_knee on Saturday 11th March 09:26

Donut

4,521 posts

282 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
chim_knee said:
I must be getting old because I thought that it was disgusting to have that little girl doing the shooting. Absolutely abhorrent.

In fact, most of it made me think WTF makes these people tick. Violence for violence's sake IMHO.

(Nothing personal of course Mannginger)

>> Edited by chim_knee on Saturday 11th March 09:26



Ditto....

polus

4,343 posts

256 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
Well at least they know how to sort out Pikey camps properly in the US!

falcemob

8,248 posts

267 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
chim_knee said:
I must be getting old because I thought that it was disgusting to have that little girl doing the shooting. Absolutely abhorrent.

In fact, most of it made me think WTF makes these people tick. Violence for violence's sake IMHO.

(Nothing personal of course Mannginger)

>> Edited by chim_knee on Saturday 11th March 09:26


Donut said:
chim_knee said:
I must be getting old because I thought that it was disgusting to have that little girl doing the shooting. Absolutely abhorrent.

In fact, most of it made me think WTF makes these people tick. Violence for violence's sake IMHO.

(Nothing personal of course Mannginger)

>> Edited by chim_knee on Saturday 11th March 09:26



Ditto....


Yep, I have to agree with you, you both must be getting old. What's the problem? apart from the girl letting off so many rounds in one burst might damage her hands.

YamR1,V64motion

5,739 posts

255 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all





wasnt there some documentry a few years ago about guns in the US(not bowling for columbine) might have been a BBC or Chanel 4 one, it went to Texas etc and a few other places and there was an 11 year old boy that could assemble,clean and fire an M16/M4 in very impressive times, have to say it is slightly disturbing that an 11 year old kid is allowed to play with militry assult rifles.

Donut

4,521 posts

282 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
falcemob said:
chim_knee said:
I must be getting old because I thought that it was disgusting to have that little girl doing the shooting. Absolutely abhorrent.

In fact, most of it made me think WTF makes these people tick. Violence for violence's sake IMHO.

(Nothing personal of course Mannginger)

>> Edited by chim_knee on Saturday 11th March 09:26


Donut said:
chim_knee said:
I must be getting old because I thought that it was disgusting to have that little girl doing the shooting. Absolutely abhorrent.

In fact, most of it made me think WTF makes these people tick. Violence for violence's sake IMHO.

(Nothing personal of course Mannginger)

>> Edited by chim_knee on Saturday 11th March 09:26



Ditto....


Yep, I have to agree with you, you both must be getting old. What's the problem? apart from the girl letting off so many rounds in one burst might damage her hands.



Because it is wrong.

pesty

42,655 posts

287 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
why is it wrong? if shes having fun and no one is hurt whats the prob? or is she being forced to do it and shes scared?

very strange reactions to this thread is she shooting at someone? cant view the film cos im at work.

Dont understand the vilonce for violence sake. shooting guns is fun

>> Edited by pesty on Saturday 11th March 10:20

D_Mike

5,301 posts

271 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
if shes having fun and no body is hurt then that makes it sound okay.

of course she's also being trained to use a machine designed to kill people.

Donut

4,521 posts

282 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
D_Mike said:
if shes having fun and no body is hurt then that makes it sound okay.

of course she's also being trained to use a machine designed to kill people.


Thats the point.

Yes shooting guns is fun but firing a machine gun at cars etc is very different to clay pigeon shooting IMO.

I think she looks to young to be taking part in that sort of fun

2wheelsonmawagon

58 posts

252 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
Faintly unpleasant really. It looked like a load of fat inbred "yeehas" with more money than sense who had just upgraded from torching their action men.

Saddle bum

4,211 posts

250 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
"The best form of gun control is to use both hands".

The most fun you can have without taking your clothes off.

Fourteen Lee-Enfields and a sore shoulder.

Mannginger

Original Poster:

10,309 posts

288 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
chim_knee said:

(Nothing personal of course Mannginger)

>> Edited by chim_knee on Saturday 11th March 09:26


And nothing taken at all. I followed the link from B3TA and have to admit that my eyebrows were seriously raised by the age of the kid.

However I also thought about it and thought how much preparation must go into an event like that in order to make it safe and spectaular, which is why I came to the conclusion that as a hobby this is a fairly major one.

Should kids go with their parents when their hobby is related to guns? Difficult one - I used to shoot a lot as a kid and hunt vermin. My dad taught me safety above all else, I suspect that the young girls father did the same.

Therefore I suspect she will be a much safer gun owner than hoods in the cities that pick up guns and are taught by their peers that they're cool and a status symbol.

I'd rather see this supervision (despite gun size) than not.

Phil

stu_the_flat

1,167 posts

249 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
I just think it’s a waist of the world’s resources.

That car rolling down the hill is how I imagine the Americans hitting a moving target. How much lead do you think is in that soil?


>> Edited by stu_the_flat on Saturday 11th March 11:03

xiphias

5,889 posts

258 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
I see that event as quite a lot of fun myself, something perhaps similar to having a F1/Enzo/Zonda and just being given full reign to whang it round an airfield all day. Doing something just for the hell of it! As long as it's safe, does it matter? I wouldn't worry about the lead in the soil, it would have to be private land, and its probably purely used for the purposes of shooting. Landfill sites carry far more lead than that!

With respect to the 11 year old, that's opening a whole new can of worms. Guns in themselves are not inherently dangerous, in the same way that speed is not lethal above an arbitary number. Yes, giving a 17yo pikey, just passed his test, the keys to a veyron, and I expect it would be lethal, not just to himself either. But if an 11 year old can fully dismantle and re-assemble an M16, then I expect he would have some sort of passion for rifles and would therefore fully appreciate the respect needed with one. Far better to educate at an early age than to instill fear in them.

I fully expect some of you learnt to drive far before 17. Did that make you a dangerous overconfident driver, with no respect?

Mr Beckerman

5,349 posts

258 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
Personally, I don't have a problem with it.

My mum used to shoot (.22 up to Bren!) and never, to my knowledge, went on a rampage through a populated area with a fully automatic weapon. I'm a fan of shooting and also haven't decided to exact any sort of 'justice' on the morons who inhabit my place of work (oh, how I may have dreamed of it though)

I think the positive to be taken from this is gun education and respect for the weapons. That little girl is being taught how to use a weapon sensibly (ie. don't point the noisy end at your friends). It's obviously an organised event with proper controls and standards, which lets face it, is better than someone wandering into a gun shop and exiting with a weapon and just going somewhere to loose a few rounds off without too much care and attention.

Meaningless statistic: Since the ban in the UK, there are no more illegal guns in the possesion of criminals.

Kelvin

R988

7,502 posts

260 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
Mannginger said:
chim_knee said:

(Nothing personal of course Mannginger)

>> Edited by chim_knee on Saturday 11th March 09:26


And nothing taken at all. I followed the link from B3TA and have to admit that my eyebrows were seriously raised by the age of the kid.

However I also thought about it and thought how much preparation must go into an event like that in order to make it safe and spectaular, which is why I came to the conclusion that as a hobby this is a fairly major one.

Should kids go with their parents when their hobby is related to guns? Difficult one - I used to shoot a lot as a kid and hunt vermin. My dad taught me safety above all else, I suspect that the young girls father did the same.

Therefore I suspect she will be a much safer gun owner than hoods in the cities that pick up guns and are taught by their peers that they're cool and a status symbol.

I'd rather see this supervision (despite gun size) than not.

Phil


I agree, the same way I hink it's best for parents to slowl introduce their children to drinking and also driving when younger. Allows them to learn some respect for their equipment when younger. Plus shooting is a common hobby in the US and it's only natural for kids to want to do what their parents are doing. Better they do it under supervision rather than wander into the closet when unsupervised and find a gun and start using it as a toy. That shouldn't happen if they are taught properly when younger.

combover

3,009 posts

258 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
If you guys think this is fun, you want to see Fruitcake's collection.

He can strip and reassemble a Bren gun quicker than its makers could, it's actually quite frightening to watch. Add into this, the fact that he could shoot the wings off a fly at 200m, and you'll see why not many people argue with him...

Combover

dogwatch

6,387 posts

253 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
Don't have a problem with guns in the hands of those who have been taught safety procedures and how to respect them. However simply blasting off a machine gun at the scenery does seem a bit pointless if not in a battle situation.

paulie-mafia

3,321 posts

254 months

Saturday 11th March 2006
quotequote all
I started to shoot when I was 11 / 12, starting with air rifles, then progressing to the proper stuff. However, I lived out in the sticks and I was taught to respect a gun and carry and use it safely and the shooting was always done in the context of my environment, ie we shot game birds etc for personal consumption or clay pigeons for practice. Letting an 11 year old loose with an assault rifle or machine gun is nothing like this and serves absolutely no purpose other than entertainment and gradual indoctrination into the agressive, militia-like culture that typifies attitudes towards gun ownership in the vast majority of the US.