Why is the NHS so rubbish at times?
Discussion
Last year my 15 yr old son broke his ankle and had an appointment for 12 noon to decide whether the plaster could be removed. Three hours went by and they (my wife and son) were still waiting. Eventually the doctor saw them and was very rude to my wife (who burst into tears).
My 13 yr old daughter recently chipped her ankle in a gym competition and needed treatment. She had to wait four weeks for an x-ray, then she needed a scan and waited eight weeks for that. Today (three monts on) we went to see the doctor to get the results. The appointment was at 10:30. After waiting two and half hours in a dirty waiting room I knocked on the doctor's door and told him "I've given up with the NHS from now on I'm only ever going private - please refer all my daughter's records accordingly". The reply was "well that'll be expensive!" To which I replied, "So what, at least you get decent service!"
I've just come off the phone to a private hospital who have given me a choice of dates, as of now. To my mind, the gulf between private healthcare and the NHS is bigger than ever, despite obscene amounts of our Taxes being chucked at it. It's a damned outrage!
My 13 yr old daughter recently chipped her ankle in a gym competition and needed treatment. She had to wait four weeks for an x-ray, then she needed a scan and waited eight weeks for that. Today (three monts on) we went to see the doctor to get the results. The appointment was at 10:30. After waiting two and half hours in a dirty waiting room I knocked on the doctor's door and told him "I've given up with the NHS from now on I'm only ever going private - please refer all my daughter's records accordingly". The reply was "well that'll be expensive!" To which I replied, "So what, at least you get decent service!"
I've just come off the phone to a private hospital who have given me a choice of dates, as of now. To my mind, the gulf between private healthcare and the NHS is bigger than ever, despite obscene amounts of our Taxes being chucked at it. It's a damned outrage!
You are spot on.
I find it almost impossible to get a "normal" doctors appointment - it either HAS to be an "emergency" on the day - or I wait for 3 to 4 weeks - by which time I'm better.
So I now see the Nurse practisioners for as much as possible - at my last visit I asked her why it was so much harder to get appointments and service now than it was 25 years ago - depsite massive spend increases ( so we are told ).
She explained that Labours "Patients Charter" had basically totally
ed up the bookings system for Doctors - the Charter says you are entitled to see the allocated Doctor of "your choice" at the practice - and that they were booked up well in advance.
I was advised that if I was willing to see any Doctor it would be quicker
- it was hard to tell if Labours meddling is to blame ........ or whether practice staff are making excuses ..........
.......I suspect it may be more to do with massive GP "demand" increases with fewere doctors going into General Practice ??
>> Edited by alfaman on Monday 13th March 14:32
>> Edited by alfaman on Monday 13th March 14:33
I find it almost impossible to get a "normal" doctors appointment - it either HAS to be an "emergency" on the day - or I wait for 3 to 4 weeks - by which time I'm better.
So I now see the Nurse practisioners for as much as possible - at my last visit I asked her why it was so much harder to get appointments and service now than it was 25 years ago - depsite massive spend increases ( so we are told ).
She explained that Labours "Patients Charter" had basically totally
ed up the bookings system for Doctors - the Charter says you are entitled to see the allocated Doctor of "your choice" at the practice - and that they were booked up well in advance. I was advised that if I was willing to see any Doctor it would be quicker
- it was hard to tell if Labours meddling is to blame ........ or whether practice staff are making excuses .......... .......I suspect it may be more to do with massive GP "demand" increases with fewere doctors going into General Practice ??
>> Edited by alfaman on Monday 13th March 14:32
>> Edited by alfaman on Monday 13th March 14:33
My wife recently recieved a very apologetic letter from the NHS telling her that due to unforseen circumstances they would have to reschedule her appointment.... by 5 minutes!!!!
In contrast when she gave birth to our new baby last week we waited in the maternity department for 2 days (no joke) for a paediatrician to do the basic checks on the babys health and condition.
By the end of the second day we were told that the only Paediatrician working was on a course and, I quote, 'may or may not be round at some stage today'.
Whilst this was going on I asked the nurse for some cotton wool to wipe the baby and was curtly told ' We do not supply cotton wool- if everyone asked us for cotton wool it would cost a fortune'
In the end our only alternative was to check ourselves out and take the baby home where it would be nearer to a doctor if needed !
>> Edited by blindswelledrat on Monday 13th March 14:28
In contrast when she gave birth to our new baby last week we waited in the maternity department for 2 days (no joke) for a paediatrician to do the basic checks on the babys health and condition.
By the end of the second day we were told that the only Paediatrician working was on a course and, I quote, 'may or may not be round at some stage today'.
Whilst this was going on I asked the nurse for some cotton wool to wipe the baby and was curtly told ' We do not supply cotton wool- if everyone asked us for cotton wool it would cost a fortune'
In the end our only alternative was to check ourselves out and take the baby home where it would be nearer to a doctor if needed !
>> Edited by blindswelledrat on Monday 13th March 14:28
Sorry Steve, but you're wrong, the NHS is utterly brilliant. Hospitals are cleaner than ever and waiting times are shorter. It's non-believers like yourself that are actually the root of the problems in the NHS you know. Now please stop comparing actuality with Labour's carefully managed statistics, it leads to unrealistic expectations.
Tony keeps saying it's fantastic, so it must be true.
Tony keeps saying it's fantastic, so it must be true.
Why is it so rubbish Srebbe?
Why because it is a monolithic nationalised industry. In a world of centrally imposed targets patients are regarded as little more than an inconvenience.
The government's recent restoring of the internal market may soon start to improve matters. But how much time and money has been wasted in first scrapping the internal market (when they came to power in 1997) and now restoring it again (albeit in a different form).
Why because it is a monolithic nationalised industry. In a world of centrally imposed targets patients are regarded as little more than an inconvenience.
The government's recent restoring of the internal market may soon start to improve matters. But how much time and money has been wasted in first scrapping the internal market (when they came to power in 1997) and now restoring it again (albeit in a different form).
blindswelledrat said:
My wife recently recieved a very apologetic letter from the NHS telling her that due to unforseen circumstances they would have to reschedule her appointment.... by 5 minutes!!!!
I can improve on that, mine got a letter to tell her that her appointment had been changed from one date and time to EXACTLY the same date and time but that the consulting room was now not No.4 but No.5. Since you all sit outside rooms 1 to 10 all in a big waiting area until your name is mumbled by somebody whose mother tongue is some Bolivian click language, it matters not a tinker's toss until you're there.
>> Edited by motco on Monday 13th March 14:33
I think healthcare would be much better all run privately via insurance ( with subsidies for those on lowest incomes ).... that way :
1. the "market" would ensure adequate capacity - as funding from insurance would rise with demand
2. the market would drive efficiencies out where there were gains to be made - such as reducing the number of specialist facilities ( Labour won't rationalise facilities as it will lose votes - even if its more cost effective / efficient )
3. there would be much less political interference using the NHS as a tool to "spin" lies to grab votes.
1. the "market" would ensure adequate capacity - as funding from insurance would rise with demand
2. the market would drive efficiencies out where there were gains to be made - such as reducing the number of specialist facilities ( Labour won't rationalise facilities as it will lose votes - even if its more cost effective / efficient )
3. there would be much less political interference using the NHS as a tool to "spin" lies to grab votes.
I've been waiting for two years for a hospital appointment so I'm slightly peeved!
Although my friend is having a hip replacement and she is only waiting 6 months which is good!
Its swings and roundabouts really! Lucky dip or whatever.
Sometimes its good...sometimes its not!
Although it bugs me that my doctor will REFUSE to book appointments say for the next day...you have to ring up after 9 to get an appointment and if its past half one you have to ring at 3 for an appointment!! Why not pre book and get it sorted??
Kitty_Kat
Although my friend is having a hip replacement and she is only waiting 6 months which is good!
Its swings and roundabouts really! Lucky dip or whatever.
Sometimes its good...sometimes its not!
Although it bugs me that my doctor will REFUSE to book appointments say for the next day...you have to ring up after 9 to get an appointment and if its past half one you have to ring at 3 for an appointment!! Why not pre book and get it sorted??
Kitty_Kat
blindswelledrat said:
In contrast when she gave birth to our new baby last week we waited in the maternity department for 2 days (no joke) for a paediatrician to do the basic checks on the babys health and condition.
By the end of the second day we were told that the only Paediatrician working was on a course and, I quote, 'may or may not be round at some stage today'.
Whilst this was going on I asked the nurse for some cotton wool to wipe the baby and was curtly told ' We do not supply cotton wool- if everyone asked us for cotton wool it would cost a fortune'![]()
In the end our only alternative was to check ourselves out and take the baby home where it would be nearer to a doctor if needed !
It's particularly galling being as it's run by the "Labour" party!

Kitty_Kat said:Liar
I've been waiting for two years for a hospital appointment so I'm slightly peeved!
Although my friend is having a hip replacement and she is only waiting 6 months which is good!
Its swings and roundabouts really! Lucky dip or whatever.
Sometimes its good...sometimes its not!
Although it bugs me that my doctor will REFUSE to book appointments say for the next day...you have to ring up after 9 to get an appointment and if its past half one you have to ring at 3 for an appointment!! Why not pre book and get it sorted??
Kitty_Kat
Labour told me no-one was waiting over eighteen months for anything only the other morning. Will you selfish posters please please stop messing with Labour's statistics 
esselte said:
alfaman said:
EDIT : I think healthcare would be much better all run privately via insurance ( with subsidies for those on lowest incomes ).... that way
Would this also include a lowering of tax/ni to reflect the cost of the insurance?
Absolutely .... everyone would be compelled to purchase insurance. and I suppose *some* of the existing tax revenue would be needed for subsidising the elderly / low incomed.
It would also be a MASSIVE incentive to live a healthy lifestyle ....... massively overweight / heavy drinker / unfit ......or infected with HIV ??
"Ooooh - that'll be an extra 100 % on your premiums Sir / Madam "

puggit said:
What I fail to understand is how my GP manages to overrun by 45 mins after 30mins of appointments? ![]()
And when I go to see him, he's got me in and out of his room inside of 5 mins every time!!
Mine does this too. I've even tried the trick of booking the first appointment of the day, and I'm still not seen until 30 minutes after my appointment time...
First of all, the doctor rarely turns up until at least 10 minutes after the start of his consulting time, and then he spends a while making phone calls and getting himself coffee and... No wonder appointments rarely run to time.
Although on the other hand, if ever SBaby has needed an urgent appointment and no slots were free, he'd usually fit us in at the end of consulting for the day. So it's not all bad.
>> Edited by SGirl on Monday 13th March 14:48
alfaman said:
esselte said:
alfaman said:
EDIT : I think healthcare would be much better all run privately via insurance ( with subsidies for those on lowest incomes ).... that way
Would this also include a lowering of tax/ni to reflect the cost of the insurance?
Absolutely .... everyone would be compelled to purchase insurance. and I suppose *some* of the existing tax revenue would be needed for subsidising the elderly / low incomed.
It would also be a MASSIVE incentive to live a healthy lifestyle ....... massively overweight / heavy drinker / unfit ......or infected with HIV ??
"Ooooh - that'll be an extra 100 % on your premiums Sir / Madam "
"Compelled to purchase insurance" - That's a bit nanny state isn't it? Why can't people do as they please?
JagLover said:
Why is it so rubbish Srebbe?
Why because it is a monolithic nationalised industry. In a world of centrally imposed targets patients are regarded as little more than an inconvenience.
The government's recent restoring of the internal market may soon start to improve matters. But how much time and money has been wasted in first scrapping the internal market (when they came to power in 1997) and now restoring it again (albeit in a different form).
Nothing whatsoever to do with it being a nationalised industry. Its not anyway its a public service. The problem with the NHS is the civil service. The civil servants only have one skill set, ticking and stamping forms they have either filled in or checked. Unfortunately these particular skills are of almost no use at all in the health service. In addition the health service has imposed on it all the stupid idiotic nonsense recruitment politics that applies to working for the Gummint. Ie disabled black lesbian muslims get first pick of all the best jobs even if their only skills are zooming down to birthing pools at sunset and drinking them. When we elected the mad cow, the only good thing she did was to smash the nonsense of Unions destroying industry. We need a similar kind of nutter/visionary to deal with the civil service. Just like traffic lights 90% of them need to be removed, sacked, got rid of, redeployed. The only form needed is the p45. It will solve all the helath service problems at a stroke.
It's hardly surprising when you consider how many people abuse the system, just because it's free people turn up for all sorts of non-medical emergencies, leaving those who really need the care waiting.
Did anyone catch the report on 999 calls, it was shameful the reasons people called up for, frankly they should be billed for the costs invloved.
Did anyone catch the report on 999 calls, it was shameful the reasons people called up for, frankly they should be billed for the costs invloved.
minicity said:
alfaman said:
esselte said:
alfaman said:
EDIT : I think healthcare would be much better all run privately via insurance ( with subsidies for those on lowest incomes ).... that way
Would this also include a lowering of tax/ni to reflect the cost of the insurance?
Absolutely .... everyone would be compelled to purchase insurance. and I suppose *some* of the existing tax revenue would be needed for subsidising the elderly / low incomed.
It would also be a MASSIVE incentive to live a healthy lifestyle ....... massively overweight / heavy drinker / unfit ......or infected with HIV ??
"Ooooh - that'll be an extra 100 % on your premiums Sir / Madam "
"Compelled to purchase insurance" - That's a bit nanny state isn't it? Why can't people do as they please?
we are compelled to buy car insurance, pay NI , pay council tax etc. etc. ........it could be collected via your employer.
No compulsion would mean some people being bankrupted after being presented with a large "bill" after an unexpected trip to the hospital etc , or the State picks up the bill and there would be no incentive to have insurance ( bit like the current system)
Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


