OK, now I know how the Muslims feel.
OK, now I know how the Muslims feel.
Author
Discussion

simpo two

Original Poster:

93,100 posts

296 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
No, this isn't a Muslim-bashing thread. It's because I too felt 'offended' at something that cropped up on the local news a few days ago.

A mental health charity decided to erect a statue of Winston Churchill in a straitjacket. I thought this was desperately wrong and improper, defacing an 'icon' to make some perverse point.

Tonight I was delighted to here that in response to public outcry - not least from the Churchill family, the statue will be removed from public view.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/no

deevlash

10,442 posts

268 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
The "perverse" point was to highlight the stigma associated with mental health, and churchill suffered from bouts of depression. However nobody bothered to listen to that part...

fid

2,431 posts

271 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
Except Churchill was real

simpo two

Original Poster:

93,100 posts

296 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
I heard it, and what tripe it was. Depression is a very common condition, but we don't all wear straitjackets.

alextgreen

16,010 posts

273 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
How many times have our and foreign national press(es) caricatured Churchill? Countless. All in jest. The man had faults, no harm in taking the mick now and then. A bigassed statue, arguably questioning his sanity, on permanent display in a public place however...

Why can't I caricature a prophet? Because a book says so.

focusonme

691 posts

256 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
alextgreen said:
How many times have our and foreign national press(es) caricatured Churchill? Countless. All in jest. The man had faults, no harm in taking the mick now and then. A bigassed statue, arguably questioning his sanity, on permanent display in a public place however...

Why can't I caricature a prophet? Because a book says so.


It's a good point. If someone had erected a giant statue of Muhammed with a bomb/turban on his head, we'd probably be far more sympathetic to their plight. Pictures are one thing, statues are completely another.

Frik

13,692 posts

274 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
With all due respect (and without trying to be politically correct or nuffink), I would suggest it might just be a little insolent to say "I know how the Muslims feel" in relation to the Rethink stunt.

mybrainhurts

90,809 posts

286 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
I'm offended every time I see Tony Blair...

May we have him removed from public view, too, please......?

denbeer

534 posts

251 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
mybrainhurts said:
I'm offended every time I see Tony Blair...

May we have him removed from public view, too, please......?
So am I, But I would'nt mind him being turned into a statue.

fido

18,932 posts

286 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all

A minor point but ... Churchill suffered from manic depression, which is a bit worse than bouts of depression. it's a life-long bipolar disorder.

R988

7,502 posts

260 months

Monday 13th March 2006
quotequote all
Lets be honest though, you have to be a bit mad to run a country, madness if one of the requirements, noone sane would do it.

I can't think of any leader who isn't or wasn't insane to some degree

chilli

17,320 posts

267 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
Thing is.....What was the reaction? People complained. No-one went mental and smashed everything up....Didn't read that there were any riots or buildings being set alight. Also (arguably) Churchill was a heroic leader who physically led this country in perhaps it's most difficult times, not a potentially fictional character who was merely written about...... know what I mean.............or am I in the wrong queue..?
All in my (almost worthless) opinion of course, perhaps I just can't imagine feeling that strongly about this kinda thing, that makes me wanna "go into one".

Cheers.

Ecks Ridgehead

4,285 posts

259 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
Intention of mental health charity: to raise awareness of mental health issues.

Result of attempting to raise statue: complaints, discussion...and awareness of mental health issues raised.



I'd bet no small amount of money that they knew exactly what reaction they'd get...

nubbin

6,809 posts

309 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
Ecks Ridgehead said:
Intention of mental health charity: to raise awareness of mental health issues.

Result of attempting to raise statue: complaints, discussion...and awareness of mental health issues raised.



I'd bet no small amount of money that they knew exactly what reaction they'd get...


I'm not so sure - it could easily be an excuse by the ignorant to reinforce their prejudices about a difficult and sensitive issue.

It may be true that there's "no such thing as bad publicity" for D-list celebs, but for a serious organisation working in a field where mis-information and bias is rife, it certainly can be a two-edged sword.

Besides many people will not make the link between Churchill and mental illness - most will simply see the defilement of a very public British icon - and if you have to explain the joke, it really isn't a very good joke, is it?

Nick P

29,977 posts

282 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
simpo two said:
No, this isn't a Muslim-bashing thread. It's because I too felt 'offended' at something that cropped up on the local news a few days ago.

A mental health charity decided to erect a statue of Winston Churchill in a straitjacket. I thought this was desperately wrong and improper, defacing an 'icon' to make some perverse point.

Tonight I was delighted to here that in response to public outcry - not least from the Churchill family, the statue will be removed from public view.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/england/no



hi John,

I hope you chained yourself to the forum whilst dressed as a suicide bomber, then ran amok in Norwich city centre threatening to kill all and sundry. After all, that is NORMAL behaviour when one is offended isn't it?

blindswelledrat

25,257 posts

263 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
What on earth has this got to do with 'the muslims'?

Did I miss an article about someone erecting statues of muslims in straight jackets?

>> Edited by blindswelledrat on Tuesday 14th March 08:50

scorp

8,783 posts

260 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
blindswelledrat said:
What on earth has this got to do with 'the muslims'?

Did I miss an article about someone erecting statues of muslims in straight jackets?

Debasing of historical icons, more or less the same as the muslim outrage over the cartoons wouldn't you say?

blindswelledrat

25,257 posts

263 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
I see! good point- I'm having one of those days.

Who can we explode and maim for this then? I'm too furious for words.

warmfuzzies

4,380 posts

284 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
Pardon me, but the "stunt" worked, if it hadn't we wouldn't all be talking about it.

Rightly or wrongly the issue is now high on the agenda.


kevin

JMGS4

8,936 posts

301 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
Firstly, I find it despicable that some "normal" person should even think about putting up a statue which debases the memory of such a great man.

Secondly, why is it that "normal" interfering busybodies always believe that they should "help" others by putting up statues of the disabled, or even promote the "inequalities" of the disabled? The disabled DO NOT WANT OR APPRECIATE this, as they are usually in a position to be able to do this themselves!!

I know as my father was disabled from birth and he found it degrading when some interfering busybody lefty do-gooder tried to "help" as they were usually condescending nosyparker twunts who had absolutely no idea what a disability is, just wanted to reap the rewards from others by "helping", the "Oh isnt he/she a good person for helping" attitude....feckin interfering busybodies should be shot...!!!
A really good person helps but doesn't want or need to be thanked except by the people who he/she helped....all others are just selfserving attention seeking politicians or worse!