Skiing accident - advice please
Skiing accident - advice please
Author
Discussion

diddyman

Original Poster:

3,646 posts

272 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
My wife went on a girly weekend to Villars in Switzerland with 6 friends a couple of weekends ago. They stayed in the apartment of one of the people who she went with. They arrived Thursday evening and returned Monday evening. On Friday my wife - who had only skied once before in her life, 23 yrs ago, went with an instructor who is a friend of the people who own the apartment.

On Friday afternoon they hit some foggy patches and had quite a steep section to ski down. My wife was a little nervous and so the instructor suggested he held her arm/hand/whatever to do this little section. She sad OK, and as they skied down the slope his skis went on top of hers and he pushed her over. As she could not tip her skis cos he was on top of them her upper leg went over and her lower leg stayed upright. There was a "crack" in her left knee. And a lot of pain. The next day it was all swollen but she could walk on it, though it was still painful. The rest of the 3 days she sat miserably in the apartment while the others went off skiing.

This morning I returned with my wife from Princess Grace Hospital in London where last night she had surgery on her knee - a torn meniscus that was rebuilt, a torn articulate ligament that was rebuilt and a cruciate ligament that would only ever function again after more surgery. She is battered and bruised and in considerable pain. And I am close to £3k out of pocket.

The only people who have shown NO sympathy to my wife are the couple who own the apartment. They are almost in denial about the matter. When my wife told them she would need surgery everyone else said "Sorry to hear that" "Oh dear" etc etc. The girl who owns the apartment said "I can't believe you need surgery."

It now transpires that the reason they went down this particular slope in the first place was cos the instructor was late getting back to the shop. He said he was very sorry at the time.

And that is it. No contact form the ski skool, nothing.

While the apartment owners are friends of ours, and I suspect the situation is highly embarrassing to them, it does not take away form the fact that the ski instructor IMHO screwed up.

I feel that our friends have let us down - no support, no assistance to my wife while they were over there. The apartment wife could easily have assisted my wife in getting to see a quack on the Saturday morning, but instead she left her in the apartment and went skiing. Mustn't miss a day’s skiing, even if they do go out there EVERY weekend.

What sort of recourse would I normally have against this person or the skool that employs him? I assume he or the skool would be insured? Can I claim off their insurance? Yes, it may leave a bitter after taste and not do out friendship with these peeps any good - but they haven't exactly acted in the spirit of friendship as far as I am concerned.

I'd just like to say I know nothing about skiing. The idea of strapping a couple of bits of 2 x 4 to my feet and hurtling off a mountain fills me with no joy at all. So I don't know what the deal is with liability and skiing instructors.

Thanks in advance and apologies for the lengthy rambling.

Cheers
Jim

















wedge girl

4,688 posts

270 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
Are you not covered by your travel insurance?

esselte

14,626 posts

298 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
IANAL ... Did your wife pay for her instruction?If not then I would have thought you would have a hard time claiming from his school.Does you wife's ski-ing/holiday insurance cover things like this?

ewenm

28,506 posts

276 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
Was it an official lesson from the school or just a friend of a friend doing a favour? If it wasn't an official lesson you'll have difficulty showing the instructor had a duty of care to your wife.

It sounds like your wife should claim off her own travel insurance. Accidents do happen, especially when participating in a dangerous sport (and skiing IS dangerous).

Carrera2

8,352 posts

263 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
My gut reaction is 'accidents happen'. Skiings can be dangerous - hence good travel insurance is essential. If you have it, claim. I wouldnt' look to try and make anyone liable though, it's not really fair.

diddyman

Original Poster:

3,646 posts

272 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
wedge girl said:
Are you not covered by your travel insurance?

No, because it only covers for medical expenses overseas.

diddyman

Original Poster:

3,646 posts

272 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
esselte said:
IANAL ... Did your wife pay for her instruction?If not then I would have thought you would have a hard time claiming from his school.Does you wife's ski-ing/holiday insurance cover things like this?

Yes to paying and no to insurance as answered above....

dl23

44 posts

276 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
I'm afraid the view generally taken is that skiing is a sport where injury and acicdent is relatively common, and you are advised to take out proper ski/medical insurance before you travel...

the only time you might get something out of someone is if a skier hits you from behind (generally the skier in front has right of way, no matter what speed they are travelling at). It doesn't sound that in this case, so you'd be hard pressed to get anything out of anyone at the ski school.

doesn't excuse people not taking her to the doctor though.

diddyman

Original Poster:

3,646 posts

272 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
ewenm said:
Was it an official lesson from the school or just a friend of a friend doing a favour? If it wasn't an official lesson you'll have difficulty showing the instructor had a duty of care to your wife.

It sounds like your wife should claim off her own travel insurance. Accidents do happen, especially when participating in a dangerous sport (and skiing IS dangerous).

Half and half.

See insurance cover answers above

diddyman

Original Poster:

3,646 posts

272 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
She did have proper skiing insurance, but it only covers for care abroad and not back here. Like I said, I am a numpty when it comes to skiing and so I just took out a policy that covered her for skiing as well. I didn't even think to look to see if it only covered medical expenses abroad. The waiting list under ther NHS was unacceptable to me, her and her back man.

Piglet

6,250 posts

286 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
Check the position with travel insurance, my feeling is that because she's returned home and has gone ahead with treatment she might struggle but it's a long time since I dealt with travel insurance and you'd have to read the policy wording.

Clearly this is not helpful now but she really should have got medical assistance at the time, whatever her friends did or didn't do, whilst I appreciate that she was in pain she really should have insisted that they called a doctor or took her to a hospital.

The only way you could possibly claim against the ski school or the instructor (which would depend on the relationship between instructor and school) is by proving that the ski instructor was negligent - ie that he had a duty of care (likely) and that he breached that duty of care by behaving in a manner that no other competent instructor would have behaved and that his actions caused her injury.

Why do you think he shouldn't have taken her down that particular slope? Did he use a technique that is inappropriate and that nobody else would use (holding her hand)?

My initial instinct is that this was an accident - ski-ing is a dangerous activity where this type of accident and injury occurs (a friend of mine has come back with the same injury. I'd imagine trying to mount an international negligence claim would be horrendously expensive unless there is some insurance to cover it (again check with your travel insurers whether there is any cover for a potential legal claim). I also think you'd struggle to prove that the instructor was negligent from what you've said.

Sorry not to be more positive - as for her friends - some people are like that but there aint much in law you can do about it.

Best wishes to your wife, I hope she feels better soon.

edited to say: you've answered the medical insurance question whilst I was typing.


>> Edited by Piglet on Tuesday 14th March 16:44

diddyman

Original Poster:

3,646 posts

272 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]


No, BR, she was not treated overseas. Only back here. I was not there and so could not take the matter in hand . My waife was abandoned in the apt while the others went off and had a good time. No one took her to the doctor.

The costs are the cost of a surgeon, an anaesthetist and a night in a hospital back in the UK.

She will be in a leg brace for 2 months and needs exstensive physio rehab to get her on the road again.

Yes, the instructor was working for them all in a private capacity and being paid to do so. The apt owners use this guy all the time when they are over there.

diddyman

Original Poster:

3,646 posts

272 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]

Not blaming the apt owners tonker. Just hoped for and expected a little more sympathy form them. I'm sorry, I mean ANY sympathy form them! And yes she did have insurance...

blindswelledrat

25,257 posts

263 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
I feel you are also being unfair to your friends wife!
Although it turns out the injury was quite serious it sounds like at the time she was just limping/hobbling a little.]
Why do you expect your friends wife to spoil her own holiday because your wife had a bit of a limp?
Had the injury seemed as bad as it was then you woulod have a point.
Oh, and I don't agree with your 'I've had an accident who can I blame?' philosophy either.


edit- you answered half of this whilst I was one-fingered typing. ignore me

>> Edited by blindswelledrat on Tuesday 14th March 16:49

chim_knee

12,689 posts

288 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
I would imagine there must be a case here (probably explains the lack of interest from the ski-school/chums - ignore it and it'll go away mentality) but your problem will probably be with culpability (which, of course, is cruicial). Her word against the instructors presumably. "The ski's didn't cross, she got caught out because she was doing what she was told etc. Bloody reckless she was, and no mistake. etc."

I've just realised I've typed that and you are now no further forward that before I started so I apologise for the pointless post!

PS: Did you get my mail about insurance... how timely!

diddyman

Original Poster:

3,646 posts

272 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
Piglet said:
Lots of piglety stuff!


I appreciate that we have made it harder by paying for the work aleady piglet, but we had no choice,. My wife needed the operartion and she needed it now. Actually, shee needed it a few weeks ago! I think no one realised that it was as bad as it was, and the rest of thenm were all having a good time blah blah blah. You know how it is...

It just pisses me off that the ski skool have not done anything. Sent an email, a letter, a cheese fondue and a weeks free yodeling lessons. Shit, ANYTHING would be nice. But no, he stood on her skis, pushed her over (yes, I know it was an accident, but he said at the time "Oh you must go skiiing again tomorrow, or it will all sitffen up" and said "ooo, sorry." He seems to think he's done his bit.

I know it is hard to prove he is or isn't negligent, but I was merely making general inquiries at present as to what the usual course of action was in such an instance...

hobo

6,657 posts

277 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
Why when there were 3 days holiday left, knowing that you had insurance, did she not go to hospital there ?

Carrera2

8,352 posts

263 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
diddyman said:
Piglet said:
Lots of piglety stuff!


I appreciate that we have made it harder by paying for the work aleady piglet, but we had no choice,. My wife needed the operartion and she needed it now. Actually, shee needed it a few weeks ago! I think no one realised that it was as bad as it was, and the rest of thenm were all having a good time blah blah blah. You know how it is...

It just pisses me off that the ski skool have not done anything. Sent an email, a letter, a cheese fondue and a weeks free yodeling lessons. Shit, ANYTHING would be nice. But no, he stood on her skis, pushed her over (yes, I know it was an accident, but he said at the time "Oh you must go skiiing again tomorrow, or it will all sitffen up" and said "ooo, sorry." He seems to think he's done his bit.

I know it is hard to prove he is or isn't negligent, but I was merely making general inquiries at present as to what the usual course of action was in such an instance...



You sound like you've never been skiing. People fall over in accidents like this ALL the time.

I've caused and been in similar accidents a few times and the lawyers didn't fly in.

It's all par for the course. Thats why everyone gets insurance and reads the policy - sorry but it's true.

mr_tony

6,351 posts

300 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
diddy - frankly I think you're on a hiding to nothing with regard to suing an instructor - as others have said proving he was negligent will be a non starter, if his skis ended up on hers thats just bad luck. I'd wager that if he's a ski instructor, and your wife has not skiied for 24 years then the reason she fell over is rather obvious. Ok the instructor probably thought she was going to do something she didn't do to end up in that position, but that just makes it an accident and not something that you can claim for.

Regarding he 'friends' however their behaviour is shocking not helping her. However medical attentiion in ski resorts is ridiculously easy to get - every resort I've ever visited has several medical centres, and multiple doctors able to visit anywhere in the valley (i did last week for broken ribs, and my mate for snapped knee ligaments) so I don't understand given how painful the injury is why she received no help at the chalet.

I wish her well - skiing hurts (I break ribs most years but then I ski a lot and do some pretty daft things in the park / off piste!)

diddyman

Original Poster:

3,646 posts

272 months

Tuesday 14th March 2006
quotequote all
blindswelledrat said:
I feel you are also being unfair to your friends wife!
Although it turns out the injury was quite serious it sounds like at the time she was just limping/hobbling a little.]e
Why do you expect your friends wife to spoil hr own holiday because your wife had a bit of a limp?
Had the injury seemed as bad as it was then you woulod have a point.
Oh, and I don't agree with your 'I've had an accident who can I blame?' philosophy either.


edit- you answered half of this whilst I was one-fingered typing. ignore me

>> Edited by blindswelledrat on Tuesday 14th March 16:49

Pardon???
Unfair on my friend's wife? Ruin her holiday? off arsehole. She's there every weekend. What is a few hours of her time to take my wife to the hospital?

She was not limping hobbling a bit where did I say that? She sat in the apt for 3 days. While they all went off skiing.

You don't like my attitude...? I'll tell you what. Pop round here, see the state my wife is in, and then I'll smash your face in so hard your teeth will march out your arse like soldiers. Piss off.