For just £2 a month .......
Discussion
I am very much in two minds over these very cleverly designed and highly emotive ads.
It does get a bt tiresome when you are wanting to unwind and a sick kitten/puppy/OAP/kid keeps appearing on your screen with the subtext of "if you are a decent person you'll give"...
On the other hand if they get what they need, maybe it is justified.
It does get a bt tiresome when you are wanting to unwind and a sick kitten/puppy/OAP/kid keeps appearing on your screen with the subtext of "if you are a decent person you'll give"...
On the other hand if they get what they need, maybe it is justified.
We have these guys stopping us in the street outside the office. Now, charity is a good thing, but when you get hasstled 5 times a day by the same people wearing different charities "vests" it gets a bit much. I used to be nice and say "Thanks, but I'm already donating", or "sorry, in a right hurry"...Now, unfortunately, I just ignore them.
_dan_ said:
Yep, stopped my tenner a month to the NSPCC after I heard what the execs there are earning and how much they spend on those bloody adverts.
Same here with the RSPCA when I learnt the same (through PH!). EFckin thieving barstewards....
Nowadays I'd rather by a MaccyDs and give it to a beggar than to some of these legalised thefty organisations...... and they prey on their "workers" too, unpaid unwanted but willing, and the directors drive around in RRs or similar...
OXfam was IIRR the worst only 1% actually leaving the country to "help", the rest dissappearing into some dark channels (i.e. golf clubs and Jags)
NOT criticising the really good charities who work damned hard for others, but don't have the massive profile bought with our gifts through TV advertising.....
humpbackmaniac said:
The collectors in the differing vests are scams aren't they? They always look dodgy bunch anyways. I saw the group that hound our highstreet being rounded up by the boys in blue the other day and have not been back since.
I understand they are paid: basic hourly rate and then a commission for those that convert into dionations ( as most people give false details: sorry chugger Victoria Street, December 2003 there is no number 55 Kilmuir House).
Thing is, if they are not prepared to do it for free, why should I give them the money I have worked for (and already been taxed on)?
I presume they do it by you signing uip for donations on a monthly basis because it is worth more and unl;ikley to be stopped, and if you gave them money direct it would be an unauthorised street collection?
Cat amongst the pigeons maybe but... why donate at all? I'm of the (rather harsh) opinion that 90% of people donate money to charities to make themselves feel better, and not to help the good cause is question specifically.
Surely if people felt that strongly about helping, they would donate their time rather than a few quid to ease the conscience?
Surely if people felt that strongly about helping, they would donate their time rather than a few quid to ease the conscience?
humpbackmaniac said:
The collectors in the differing vests are scams aren't they? They always look dodgy bunch anyways.
The ones I get stopped by I think are legit. I get stopped up to 7 times a day and it's really starting to wind me up (I guess because I'm one of the few people who don't look like a tourist
). I wouldn't mind so much but when two of them throw themsleves in my path and force me to stop or walk into them or walk down the middle of a bus lane, it gets really annoying. I find it mildy ironic that it's Amnesty International who are the worst for harrassing me....
anonymous said:
[redacted]
It would be if the money ever got there. When you have high profile charities like Oxfam where 2p out of every £1 donated actually reached the starving people it borders on theft. Going back a bit they used to have offices in the centre of London(why?), there was no shortage of expensive company cars on their fleet.
If you want to help someone, look around you, you won't have to go far to find someone that needs a little help. In this country we look after pets better than old people.
A friend of mine signed up for £2 per week / month - whatever. After a few weeks they rang her and asked if she wanted to up her donation to £10. She politely said no. After a few more weeks they rang her again asking if she wanted to up her donation. At this point she cancelled it. Its all about the "hard sell" it seems.
Ribol said:
anonymous said:[redacted]
It would be if the money ever got there. When you have high profile charities like Oxfam where 2p out of every £1 donated actually reached the starving people it borders on theft. Going back a bit they used to have offices in the centre of London(why?), there was no shortage of expensive company cars on their fleet.
If you want to help someone, look around you, you won't have to go far to find someone that needs a little help. In this country we look after pets better than old people.
How do you know this? Genuine question. I am going to rethink my donations if this is true.
wiggy001 said:
Cat amongst the pigeons maybe but... why donate at all? I'm of the (rather harsh) opinion that 90% of people donate money to charities to make themselves feel better, and not to help the good cause is question specifically.
Surely if people felt that strongly about helping, they would donate their time rather than a few quid to ease the conscience?
YES!
Sadly I no longer trust most charities. It is all too likely that the money donated to them will suffer attrition before it actually helps - there must be *some* administrative costs so that's OK - its when admin costs get to be a high percentage its ridiculous.
THere is also the problem that charities do not always spend your money on the particular cause you wanted to donate to. Often they work in a number of areas: some of which you might not have wanted to give money to! (I'm thinking B***e here.)
So. GIVE YOUR TIME! Your time cannot be misused. You are there, constantly present, to audit that the work you are doing is doing the end object of the exercise some good in the manner you believe to be right.
I do several hours a week for the IAM. I get satisfaction. I am probably improving road safety - I'm certainly not making it worse - and I'm doing it in the manner I believe to be right.
Since my professional time is worth a significant fraction of a grand a day that's a lot of money's worth the IAM are getting.
And every penny is being used right!
I've got a direct debit to give to Cancer Research and they do phone up occasionally to ask you to increase your donation. Last time the woman on the phone asked me if I had lost anyone to cancer FFS. Plus it annoys me that they send a glossy brochure to let me know how they are doing - just get on with it and cure the bugger!
My problem with these charities is that they are greedy.
I donated to PETA online about a month back. I checked the box 'one-off payment' rather than choosing the continual '£xx each month'. They sent me a letter last month basically saying 'Thanks but it wasn't enough. We want money each month also so please give this form to your bank so we can direct debit you'. If I wanted to do it this way then I would have chosen this. Guess that after making the initial transaction they now see me as an easy target...
I donated to PETA online about a month back. I checked the box 'one-off payment' rather than choosing the continual '£xx each month'. They sent me a letter last month basically saying 'Thanks but it wasn't enough. We want money each month also so please give this form to your bank so we can direct debit you'. If I wanted to do it this way then I would have chosen this. Guess that after making the initial transaction they now see me as an easy target...
Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff








