Pensions reprimand for government
Pensions reprimand for government
Author
Discussion

Jaglover

Original Poster:

46,848 posts

266 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
The ombudsman says the government should pay the pensions of the 85,000 people who have lost all or part of their company pensions.

Why?

These were private pension schemes that formed part of the workers employment package. The government did not guarantee the pension, why should they be held responsible, the company and the directors who ran it were the ones responsible.

There is a sense that many people and organisations regard taxpayer’s money as unlimited 'free' money. The cost of implementing this proposal would be £5bn.

BBC said:
Pensions reprimand for government

PAG members protest at Labour's 2004 Brighton conference
The government has been told to compensate 85,000 people who have lost all or part of their company pensions.
The Parliamentary Ombudsman, Ann Abraham, made the ruling after finding the Department for Work & Pensions (DWP) guilty of maladministration.

She said official guidance on company pension schemes had been "inaccurate, incomplete, unclear and inconsistent".

The government has rejected the report, saying it cannot be held responsible for corporate pension schemes.

Government 'failure'

Ms Abraham argued in her 254-page report that the government's "maladministration" had "caused injustice to a large number of people who, as a result, lost the opportunity to make informed choices about their future".

However, the report is non-binding and the ombudsman cannot force the government to take up her recommendations.

For the report to assert that the taxpayer should make good all such losses - however they arose - is a huge and unsustainable leap of logic

Much of the criticism in the ombudsman's report is directed at government information leaflets which it says gave a misleading impression of the security of company pension schemes.

But Work and Pensions Secretary John Hutton told the BBC there was no evidence that these leaflets were inaccurate or incomplete.

He added that the ombudsman had "not established that people relied exclusively or alone or heavily on the leaflets we did produce as the basis for their financial decisions".

"This was a general advice leaflet designed to provide general information. These leaflets were not designed to provide detailed financial advice for people to make investment decisions."

Stephen Timms, the minister for pensions reform, said "it could not be the responsibility of taxpayers to bail out failed corporate pension schemes.

"For the report to assert that the taxpayer should make good all such losses - however they arose - is a huge and unsustainable leap of logic."

Opposition parties condemned the government's response.

Shadow work and pensions secretary Philip Hammond spoke of "failure... across several government departments and over a number of years."

David Laws, the Liberal Democrat's work and pensions spokesman, called it a "damning account of the government's mishandling of occupational pensions".

Several trade unions said they would now proceed with legal action against the government to enforce their members' claims for compensation.

£5bn bill?
About 400 company pensions schemes have gone under so far, and to restore the pensions lost by their members would cost a lump sum of £5bn, or between £100m and £150m a year for 40 years, according to the Pensions Action Group (PAG), which has campaigned on the issue.

Ros Altmann, the PAG's spokeswoman, said "every right-thinking person... when reading the evidence uncovered by this investigation, cannot fail to appreciate that these individuals have been dreadfully wronged by our government.

"The real worry is that government itself, having seen the Parliamentary Ombudsman's report, seems to be trying to deny the evidence clearly put before it," she added.

She said she hoped the matter would be taken up by MPs.

"If ministers can't see for themselves, then Parliament must force them to," she said.

Ombudsman's findings

Ms Abraham said she uncovered evidence of real suffering among people who had lost their pension after their company went under.

After reviewing the evidence she decided that the government's official information had been:

inaccurate - by telling scheme members that they would receive the full value of their accrued rights if their scheme wound up and/or that the Minimum Funding Requirement was designed to ensure that schemes had enough assets to meet their liabilities in full;

incomplete - by omitting to mention the most highly significant factors - such as that a pension was only as secure as the employer sponsoring the scheme;

unclear - by using expressions such as 'fair value' to indicate the government's settled intention that non-pensioner members would have only an even chance of receiving their pensions;

inconsistent - from September 2000, some official statements and publications - especially those aimed at the general public - continued not to mention risk and to give a misleading impression as to the security of pension rights, while others began to explain the true position.

Complaints

The ombudsman launched her enquiry in 2004 after receiving more than 200 complaints from members of pension schemes that had been wound up.


Ann Abrahams says the government should compensate pensioners

Most of them came from the estimated 85,000 people who lost all or part of their pensions when their company schemes went bust between 1994 and 2005.

Ms Abraham agreed that information and official guidance from bodies, such as the Department for Work & Pensions, had misled scheme trustees and scheme members about how secure their pensions might be if their schemes were wound up.

Many complaints focused on a policy known as the Minimum Funding Requirement (MFR), introduced in 1995 in the wake of the Maxwell pensions scandal.

Ms Abraham found that government advice and literature gave the impression that if schemes were funded to meet the MFR this would ensure the security of current and future pensions if their employer went bust and the pension scheme had to be wound up.

In fact the MFR was never intended to ensure this.

She also found that the DWP ignored advice from the actuarial profession, in the year 2000, that it should point out to pension scheme members that they were at risk if they relied solely on the MFR as a measure of their security.

What next?

Even though the ombudsman's suggestions are non-binding, the Public Administration Select Committee can hold an inquiry into why the government rejected them.

The committee's chairman Dr Tony Wright said: "We will be asking the government to explain itself and review its decision not to accept the ombudsman's recommendations."



Einion Yrth

19,575 posts

275 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
I'd rather pay 5bn to pensions than the bloody ID card fiasco.

alfaman

6,416 posts

265 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
but the Govt advised people to invest in their company's final salary schemes.

arguably the Govt should have put in place some form of regulatory framework ensuring that pensions were somehow underwritten.

I have more sympathy for people whose private pensions have disappeared than the millions of public sector workers and ministers who will be getting gold plated final salary schemes..... funded by the rest of the tax paying population who will be getting dick all.

Jaglover

Original Poster:

46,848 posts

266 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
alfaman said:
but the Govt advised people to invest in their company's final salary schemes.

arguably the Govt should have put in place some form of regulatory framework ensuring that pensions were somehow underwritten.


But why should the government bear ALL of the cost (and in this case a bit more with compensation on top for distress caused )for an (arguable)failure to regulate these companies correctly?

This ignores the responsibility of the workers themselves and that of the company and it’s directors.

How far should we go to compensate people with taxpayers money for financial misfortune brought about (at least in part) by their own actions.

wanty1974

3,704 posts

279 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
But surely if someone like Abbey National can be sued for mis-selling a pension, with incorrect advice given at the time, why shouldn't the government, who gave similar advice for private company pensions, not go the same way?

I do agree that forcing the government to pay the pensions back is perhaps going a little far, but if you look at some of the leaflets the DW&P published, you'd be surprised how they haven't had more ructions about it all.

alfaman

6,416 posts

265 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
Jaglover said:
alfaman said:
but the Govt advised people to invest in their company's final salary schemes.

arguably the Govt should have put in place some form of regulatory framework ensuring that pensions were somehow underwritten.


But why should the government bear ALL of the cost (and in this case a bit more with compensation on top for distress caused )for an (arguable)failure to regulate these companies correctly?

This ignores the responsibility of the workers themselves and that of the company and it’s directors.

How far should we go to compensate people with taxpayers money for financial misfortune brought about (at least in part) by their own actions.



very hard to see how the workers are responsible for this - they were making a risk free investment in their future- and told so by the Govt.

. Agreed the directors , pension fund trustees ARE responsible though, AND the Govt. for piss-poor regulation and no proper ring-fencing of Company pension assets.

I don't see this as THAT different from depositing cash in a Bank (e.g : low/no risk investment ), Bank then goes bankrupt.......... are depositors then compensated ? I think so - but can't remember the maximum amount.


tinman0

18,231 posts

271 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
Jaglover said:
But why should the government bear ALL of the cost (and in this case a bit more with compensation on top for distress caused )for an (arguable)failure to regulate these companies correctly?


I think they are adding the extra compensation cost as a high point to start with in any negotiations. start high, give a few concessions etc.


Who own the pension funds anyway? The company or the individual?

scorp

8,783 posts

260 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
Are these pensioners labour supporters or likely to support labour?

nonegreen

7,803 posts

301 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
Until the government allows us to manage our own pension schemes they are guilty of fraud. Pension funds are simply official thieves, in a free world only a dickhead would use them. While the goverment forces us to have our money stolen they should be liable to compensate us, not out of our tax but out of party funds and their own personal wealth, bastards.

Jaglover

Original Poster:

46,848 posts

266 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]


Exactly

simpo two

93,101 posts

296 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
They could have made most of these missing pensions up with the extra billions they gave needlessly to the EU.

But I suppose unknown foreigners are more important than British pensioners who've worked all their life for a pension and been shafted...

- which is exactly what I just said here: http://newsforums.bbc.co.uk/nol/threa

>> Edited by simpo two on Wednesday 15th March 10:55

Jaglover

Original Poster:

46,848 posts

266 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
simpo two said:
They could have made most of these missing pensions up wih the extra billions they gave needlessly to the EU.

But I suppose unknown foreigners are more important than British pensioners who've worked all their life for a pension and been shafted...


With the net contribution we pay to the EU we could pay for it in 2 or 3 years, but this benefits only around 60,000 people. Holding up examples of governemnt waste in spending does not justify wasting billions more.

alfaman

6,416 posts

265 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
Jaglover said:
anonymous said:
[redacted]


Exactly


sadly the £40bn in ACT credit stolen from pensions by Gordon Brown WAS legally binding ..... so the Govt approach has been to

1. plunder £££ billions from private pension schemes

2. give dodgy and misleading "guidance"

3. cave in to public sector union demands for final salary schemes.

4. force me to take a annuity from my pension - so I lose the capital forever.

5. force me to pay for the completely unfunded public sector pensions black hole.


and then abdicate ALL responsibilty for anything to do with pensions when it goes tits up - CNUTS the lot of them.



>> Edited by alfaman on Wednesday 15th March 11:02

busa_rush

6,930 posts

282 months

Wednesday 15th March 2006
quotequote all
alfaman said:
...and then abdicate ALL responsibilty for anything to do with [inset anything that's going wrong] when it goes tits up - CNUTS the lot of them.


That's the mark of the Bliar !