Benefit spongers!
Author
Discussion

nicecupoftea

Original Poster:

25,608 posts

282 months

Thursday 16th March 2006
quotequote all
There, I knew that would get you lot reading!

Was listening to LBC radio this am (London chat type station) in the car, and on the James O'Brien show at about 10.45 they were chatting about people playing the benefits game and his theory that most unemployed people chose to be unemployed as there are jobs out there but they are too well catered for by the benefits system. Whether this is true or not is a moot point; I have no idea of the figures.

However, what "got my goat"(tm) was one chap rang in to try and justify that he chose not to work and sign on. His take on this was as follows:

He spends his days in the pub reciting his poetry to people in the pub. According to him this is his job and he should be paid in benefits. I shit you not. Furthermore he was entirely happy with the thought that single mothers earning the minimum wage cleaning offices were paying for him to sit in the pub.

What can you do with people like this? The DJ was pretty clear what he thought of the bloke but, rather than not caring less, this bloke really did seem to think he was justified in this! Apparently the pub landlord had offered to pay him but he said no as he thought the state should be funding him!

We are paying for workshy scrounging scum to sit on their arses in the pub all day and it's nothing to do with being an "arty type". Should I go and sit in a pub and play and get the state to fund me?? No, I go out and get work where I can and do other things to support myself.

Why can we not have a system like they do in Scandinavia (IIRC) where you get a jobseekers's allowance for 6 months and if you haven't got a job after that without a decent reason, they stop your benefits. Full stop. No way BLiar would stomach that in his Brave New Britain though

>> Edited by nicecupoftea on Thursday 16th March 16:53

timmy30

9,325 posts

258 months

Thursday 16th March 2006
quotequote all
In a few years I think I'm going to say sod it, pretend to have depsression, give up work, hide all of my savings, and proceed via the benefits system to repatriate all of the taxes that I have paid thus far.

TeamD

5,060 posts

263 months

Thursday 16th March 2006
quotequote all
timmy30 said:
In a few years I think I'm going to say sod it, pretend to have depsression, give up work, hide all of my savings, and proceed via the benefits system to repatriate all of the taxes that I have paid thus far.


I'll think you'll find that they will suss that you aren't their "target" scumbag type and make your claiming anything incredibly difficult indeed. I was unfortunate enough to need to take "advantage" of our wonderful benefits system and found to my dismay that despite having paid into it for donkeys years I wasn't really entitled to very much at all, the sods even suggested that i sell my car, which I found particularly annoying since they are buying them for asylum wasters.

Don

28,378 posts

315 months

Thursday 16th March 2006
quotequote all
timmy30 said:
In a few years I think I'm going to say sod it, pretend to have depsression, give up work, hide all of my savings, and proceed via the benefits system to repatriate all of the taxes that I have paid thus far.


Sounds good to me!

dilbert

7,741 posts

262 months

Thursday 16th March 2006
quotequote all
Don said:
timmy30 said:
In a few years I think I'm going to say sod it, pretend to have depsression, give up work, hide all of my savings, and proceed via the benefits system to repatriate all of the taxes that I have paid thus far.


Sounds good to me!


You need to bear in mind that the government will make you feel preety bad for claiming you money back, down at the jobcentre. From experience, I can tell you that the Trotskyite contents of your local jobcentre are quite good at interrogation.

Once you've got through all that, and you can't find a job of equivalent status, they'll barrage you into a job, just above the minimum wage, where you are required to forget that you are qualified. This is justified on the basis of social harmony......

Yes you guessed it...... I got a job. They told me in the jobcentre, when I queried the contract the agent gave me, that I shouldn't have read the contract, and just taken the job.

Edited to add;

I'll let you know in a year or so if this is the beginning of Communisim.



>> Edited by dilbert on Thursday 16th March 17:11

timmy30

9,325 posts

258 months

Thursday 16th March 2006
quotequote all
dilbert said:

You need to bear in mind that the government will make you feel preety bad for claiming you money back, down at the jobcentre. From experience, I can tell you that the Trotskyite contents of your local jobcentre are quite good at interrogation.

Once you've got through all that, and you can't find a job of equivalent status, they'll barrage you into a job, just above the minimum wage, where you are required to forget that you are qualified. This is justified on the basis of social harmony......

Yes you guessed it...... I got a job. They told me in the jobcentre, when I queried the contract the agent gave me, that I shouldn't have read the contract, and just taken the job.

Edited to add;

I'll let you know in a year or so if this is the beginning of Communisim.

>> Edited by dilbert on Thursday 16th March 17:11


Christ I wouldn't go unemployed, I'd go sick the wages are much better! And that way you can't work so they don't hassle you about jobs all the time.

Code Monkey

3,318 posts

288 months

Thursday 16th March 2006
quotequote all
TeamD said:
timmy30 said:
In a few years I think I'm going to say sod it, pretend to have depsression, give up work, hide all of my savings, and proceed via the benefits system to repatriate all of the taxes that I have paid thus far.


I'll think you'll find that they will suss that you aren't their "target" scumbag type and make your claiming anything incredibly difficult indeed. I was unfortunate enough to need to take "advantage" of our wonderful benefits system and found to my dismay that despite having paid into it for donkeys years I wasn't really entitled to very much at all, the sods even suggested that i sell my car, which I found particularly annoying since they are buying them for asylum wasters.



yup;

been there for a short while as well, spent ages jumping through all the pointless hoops, getting grief when i asked to move my signing on time as i had an interview, then when i went in the next time with all the forms they wanted signed completed and all present and correct they looked at me in suprise convincing me at the time that they had not seen all the forms completed fully since the last person who actually wanted to work had been in.

vipers

33,525 posts

259 months

Thursday 16th March 2006
quotequote all
timmy30 said:
dilbert said:

You need to bear in mind that the government will make you feel preety bad for claiming you money back, down at the jobcentre. From experience, I can tell you that the Trotskyite contents of your local jobcentre are quite good at interrogation.

Once you've got through all that, and you can't find a job of equivalent status, they'll barrage you into a job, just above the minimum wage, where you are required to forget that you are qualified. This is justified on the basis of social harmony......

Yes you guessed it...... I got a job. They told me in the jobcentre, when I queried the contract the agent gave me, that I shouldn't have read the contract, and just taken the job.

Edited to add;

I'll let you know in a year or so if this is the beginning of Communisim.

>> Edited by dilbert on Thursday 16th March 17:11


Christ I wouldn't go unemployed, I'd go sick the wages are much better! And that way you can't work so they don't hassle you about jobs all the time.


Only had one experience with the job centre, and thats enough. Unemployed ONCE in my life, went down the job centre, interviwed by someone of ethnick origins, whom I could hardly understand, didnt bother going back.

And a friend of mine who held an HGV3 license saw a job advertised in the job centre for an HGV3 driver, but only those who had been un-employed for 6 months or over could apply, he said to the guy at the desk (who didnt even have the common curtosy to look up from what he was doing) and said, "Look there is a job for an HGV3 driver, I have an HGV3 licence, can I apply for it", bloke said NOT LOOKING UP "Been out of work for 6months?", "No" said my friend, "Well, cant apply for it then".....

Still, supose I will have to keep working to support the spongers.....

alfaman

6,416 posts

265 months

Thursday 16th March 2006
quotequote all
the benefits system in the UK is perverse:

1. If you are (say ) a single middle class Uni. educated professional over 40 who has worked his arse off , paid £'s hundreds of thousands in tax , saved really hard , and you are made redundant when your employer ( major Bank ) nearly goes under .......... you will get £30 a week for 6 months max.

and nothing more , and bugger all help with job searching.


2. If you have never worked in your life , have loads of kids / wives and spend everything on fags and beer : your means tested benefit , credit and allowances will be AMPLE to live on.


In France - people are paid about 80 % of their previous salary if they are made redundant ( probably why their finances are in such a poor state )

Lois

14,706 posts

283 months

Thursday 16th March 2006
quotequote all
benefits do have a very good purpose but are sooo heavily abused. There are loads of jobs out there whether it be a trolly pusher or whatever there IS work.
I think there should be a limit on how long you can claim for while looking for work. If after that time you havent found a job or doing training etc they should find one for you. If you dont take it or get yourself sacked then tough luck. People should take opportunities given to them.

oo just had another idea. Instead of giving cash, they could pay housing and bills etc and give food vouchers so people couldn't spend money in pubs etc.

>> Edited by Lois on Thursday 16th March 17:29

scorp

8,783 posts

260 months

Thursday 16th March 2006
quotequote all
A mate of mine is stuck in the benefits trap. He's not a bright kid, normally the best he can aim for is warehouse jobs (even though he went to college for 3 years doing IT). He ends up worse off working at the minimum wage than he does receiving benefits, the instant he starts to work his rent subsidies go, and all others kinds of subsidies go so he ends up in a state were all and sundry send threatening letters demanding immediate payment of XYZ, so his only recourse is to quit his job and go straight back on the dole. I imagine he's not the only one stuck in this loop.

>> Edited by scorp on Thursday 16th March 17:32

Piglet

6,250 posts

286 months

Thursday 16th March 2006
quotequote all
alfaman said:
the benefits system in the UK is perverse:

1. If you are (say ) a single middle class Uni. educated professional over 40 who has worked his arse off , paid £'s hundreds of thousands in tax , saved really hard , and you are made redundant when your employer ( major Bank ) nearly goes under .......... you will get £30 a week for 6 months max.

and nothing more , and bugger all help with job searching.


2. If you have never worked in your life , have loads of kids / wives and spend everything on fags and beer : your means tested benefit , credit and allowances will be AMPLE to live on.


Absolutely - don't start me on this one - Happy Snapper was made redundant a year ago and went from having previous paid four figures worth of tax and NI and having worked for the previous 30+ years.

The whole job centre experience was a nightmare and the final upshot is that after six months his jobseekers allowance stops because I work more than x many (16??) hours a week and earn too much money for us to qualify for any other assistance. The fact that we can't pay our rent etc. is irrelevant. As far as the benefits agency are concerned it's game over.

Whereas if I stopped working, we would become funded by the benefit system. So....what's the incentive here then?

I could go on for hours....but it get's boring....

scorp

8,783 posts

260 months

Thursday 16th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]


He ends up with about £20 spare (after bills, essentials) per week on benefits so he's not exactly flush with money, the problem is the rent subsidies and other hidden extra's he gets which are suddenly withdrawn the moment he starts working. I've seen all kinds of threatening letters he gets sent from various people the minute they realise you are working for a living. Part of the problem is the area he lives in, its a poor ex-colliery (sp?) town with not many job opportunities around, and the only mode of transport he has is a mountain bike (so he can't practically commute very far)

On the flip side, he is a bit of a lazy sod and could try harder though, like you say, nothing wrong with working tons of overtime to dig yourself out of a hole. I had to do the same when i was 16.

>> Edited by scorp on Thursday 16th March 17:37

lockstock2sb

2,855 posts

274 months

Thursday 16th March 2006
quotequote all
Well at least Bakhri and his scumbag family are fecking off back to the middle east so thats one less sponger in the uk. I think these w*nkers should go first then start looking closely at the people who wont get off their fat arses.

alfaman

6,416 posts

265 months

Thursday 16th March 2006
quotequote all
the rent subsidies for the low-paid can be a bit odd .......and unfair.

A friend of mine lets out his very nice 1 bed in Fitzrovia for about £1100 / month - last tenant was a woman earning £15k / annum !!!

- somehow she had ALL her rent paid by the council - to be able to rent that flat you'd normally have to be earning £35k - £40k , or about £60k to buy it.

r988

7,502 posts

260 months

Thursday 16th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]


Don't that have that in some other countries (or maybe in the past), goods stamps or food stamps or something?

scorp

8,783 posts

260 months

Thursday 16th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]

Im sure if there were jobs like that he would snap them up, unfortunately he ends up getting stuck with shitty agency work which either lays his group off without notice (all too commonly) or he earns so little above minimum wage he ends up in a worse position than he was when he was on benefits.

He's not the only one in that position, a great chunk of population are benefit recipients in that area.

>> Edited by scorp on Thursday 16th March 17:48

TeamD

5,060 posts

263 months

Thursday 16th March 2006
quotequote all
r988 said:
anonymous said:
[redacted]


Don't that have that in some other countries (or maybe in the past), goods stamps or food stamps or something?


Yeah, but you know what the dogooders would say about that! "The stigma"

dilbert

7,741 posts

262 months

Thursday 16th March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]


That's well and good, but some people have more to offer.

Youy see the thing is that, the actual hard value (or lack of it) of some things that people get very well paid for seems to get forgotten.

Being quite direct;
An example of this, is that I know I can build a machine to put three people out of work. At least that's how it currently seen.

One way of looking at this, is that it's bad because, those three people now have no work, and their managers get the additional profit.

Another way of looking at it is that it's good because those people can be earning more money for our economy. It depends on the managers continuing to scale up their product ranges, and using the extra profit to re~invest in their business, using the otherwise redundant staff to take on a new product where there has been no opportunity to automate.

The crazy thing is that, I'm unemployed. What it means is that now I've automated something, not only are those people redundant, but on top of that, the management aren't investing in their businesses.

This process is a freefall nosedive. In the end, we'll all work in call centres, there won't be a particular need for education, and the value of the work will be very small.

The only question that remains is the one that asks.....

Are the management squandering the money, or nurturing it wisely? Well, if the government are anything to go by it's being squandered before the management are getting to decide.

When we look back in history, the question that we're going to ask of the Blair government, is where did all that money go?

>> Edited by dilbert on Thursday 16th March 17:55

alfaman

6,416 posts

265 months

Thursday 16th March 2006
quotequote all
TeamD said:
r988 said:
anonymous said:
[redacted]


Don't that have that in some other countries (or maybe in the past), goods stamps or food stamps or something?


Yeah, but you know what the dogooders would say about that! "The stigma"


In the States they avoid that "issue" with free school meals for poor kids by making *everyone* purchase lunch tickets , so no-one knows (why don't we do that ?)