Medical negligence or just one of those things?
Discussion
Some may recall that I posted a few weeks ago about my brother in law (who was a nasty, benefit scrounging good for nothing) who died at the age of 44 during a heart operation. I had no time for the man and in many ways my sis will sadly, in the long term, be better off without him ( I think anyway).
As you can imagine at the time sis was fairly traumatised but now her head is clearing and the inquest is looming she is starting to ask questions about the care and treatment he got at the hospital. I won't bore you with the detail but as a lay person it seems that the hospital were ill prepared for when things didn't go as they had planned and that the decisions made on the night are open to question.
I am caught between helping her find out what happended, and even supporting her to bring the hospital to book, or trying to help her move on and perhaps accept that in his condition the end was never going to be long coming. Had he not screwed the system for 25 years, ignored doctors advice and periodically beat her and the kids I would have little hesitation, come hell or high water, to get her the truth. She is placing her trust in the coroner, but from what I have seen they can be quite idiosyncratic people and I fear that if they see him for what he was their interest might fall short.
I have suggested that for the moment she gets copies of his medical record and notes, as she is entitled to, to protect her interests. To take it seriously I think she should consult a solicitor with a view to getting help interpreting the notes before the inquest. It looks like she will ask me to go with her to ask her questions at the inquest.
Question is: do I support her to pursue the matter, in which case, what should I/we be doing, or should I spend my time helping her to move on (if she can move on without the answers)?
I can see where you're coming from - it's a tough call - but ultimately you need to support your sister in whatever she decides to do. Sure, you can suggest that she focuses on moving on, but you're right - a big part of it will be the closure that the coroner's case provides. As much as you seem to hate the guy (and you do have grounds to), from her POV she's lost the closest person to her and as her brother you're better placed than anyone else to help her through this.
Best of luck to you.
Best of luck to you.

I would say now is a good as time as any for her to say, my life starts tomorrow. No matter what the inquest brings he will still be dead and she needs to move forward, maybe the best thing for her to do now is invest some time and energy in herself, I know this will sound trite to some, but see if there is a 'survivors' of violence group in her area, they go by many different names, sometimes the best place to find the meeting point is by visitng the local civil court as they often have a poster on the the wall.
You need to decide on whether it's right or wrong for her to do anything.
From the point of view of bringing a med neg claim the bar you have to clear is pretty high. You need to demonstrate that the treatment that he received was something that no other doctor/nurse/hospital would give. It's a pretty tough one.
Before a solicitor can review the case properly they will need to obtain a medical experts report which is likely to cost in the region of £1500 plus you have to pay £50 per set for each set of medical records (you'll need GP records plus those from every hospital and treatment centre he's been through in relation to the condition that he had). Once the expert has all the records he will give an opinion of whether he thinks there was negligence or not.
If he says he thinks there might have been negligence he will then go on to consider whether the neglicence was causative of the death. The two don't always follow.
Only if you get both of these is it worth proceeding to Court.
If your sister is on Income Support or similar she might be entitled to Legal Services funding if the initial merits of the claim seem worthwhile. It can be difficult to find a law firm who is registered for clin neg LSC funding. A former colleague of mine does do LSC funded work I think and I can put you in touch if you're interested.
The other option funding wise is if she has Legal Expenses Insurance cover attached to her household insurance - they'll fund a clin neg case if the initial prospects look OK.
If she's planning to fund it herself she'd need to look at around £2.5k I'd imagine to get a medical report.
The other consideration is, putting it bluntly, what he was worth to the family so what amount of compensation they would receive. If he wasn't working and had no likelyhood of working then the payout wouldn't be significant. There are some standard allowances for the loss of a spouse or parent but she might find the court scruitiny difficult to handle when (probably not if) they find out he was abusive to his wife and kids.
The coroner should be fairly thorough especially if she makes it clear that she is unhappy with the treatment he received. It may be worth hiring a solicitor to go along to the inquest if she wants to ensure she is well represented.
You may want to talk this through with her and try to work out what she wants from this. If she wants an apology, she won't get it through litigation and she'll be better off talking to the Patient Liasion unit at the hospital (PAL) and asking them how she goes about complaining. You can't bring a complaint AND litigation at the same time - they'll stop investigating the complaint.
Good luck. Drop me a line if you want a referral.
From the point of view of bringing a med neg claim the bar you have to clear is pretty high. You need to demonstrate that the treatment that he received was something that no other doctor/nurse/hospital would give. It's a pretty tough one.
Before a solicitor can review the case properly they will need to obtain a medical experts report which is likely to cost in the region of £1500 plus you have to pay £50 per set for each set of medical records (you'll need GP records plus those from every hospital and treatment centre he's been through in relation to the condition that he had). Once the expert has all the records he will give an opinion of whether he thinks there was negligence or not.
If he says he thinks there might have been negligence he will then go on to consider whether the neglicence was causative of the death. The two don't always follow.
Only if you get both of these is it worth proceeding to Court.
If your sister is on Income Support or similar she might be entitled to Legal Services funding if the initial merits of the claim seem worthwhile. It can be difficult to find a law firm who is registered for clin neg LSC funding. A former colleague of mine does do LSC funded work I think and I can put you in touch if you're interested.
The other option funding wise is if she has Legal Expenses Insurance cover attached to her household insurance - they'll fund a clin neg case if the initial prospects look OK.
If she's planning to fund it herself she'd need to look at around £2.5k I'd imagine to get a medical report.
The other consideration is, putting it bluntly, what he was worth to the family so what amount of compensation they would receive. If he wasn't working and had no likelyhood of working then the payout wouldn't be significant. There are some standard allowances for the loss of a spouse or parent but she might find the court scruitiny difficult to handle when (probably not if) they find out he was abusive to his wife and kids.
The coroner should be fairly thorough especially if she makes it clear that she is unhappy with the treatment he received. It may be worth hiring a solicitor to go along to the inquest if she wants to ensure she is well represented.
You may want to talk this through with her and try to work out what she wants from this. If she wants an apology, she won't get it through litigation and she'll be better off talking to the Patient Liasion unit at the hospital (PAL) and asking them how she goes about complaining. You can't bring a complaint AND litigation at the same time - they'll stop investigating the complaint.
Good luck. Drop me a line if you want a referral.
Something similar happened to my mother some years ago in hospital care. she had a chest drain fitted and they cocked it up and she took in air into her tissues and died. If there has been neglect then you def. need a solicitor at the inquest the hospital staff will all close ranks and you wont get anywhere. My mothers death was recorded as natural causes.The hospital staff tried at the time to imply she pulled the drain out herself,(suicidE)she was high as a kite on morphene,(what actually happened was it had come loose and no one spotted it). I decided as she was old,and she was already dying from a severely diseased collapsed lung.So she was going to die anyhow. I would not persue it. She would have hated all the fuss and it would have cost lots and in the end she was not going to come back to me.
Upon reflection I wish I had taken them on now.
Get a good lawyer one who specialises in med negligence I have the no of one if you would like mail me through my profile.
The inquest will indeed be closure for you sister. Be there for her what ever she decides,but if you do decide to take them on remember the closure could take years.
Upon reflection I wish I had taken them on now.
Get a good lawyer one who specialises in med negligence I have the no of one if you would like mail me through my profile.
The inquest will indeed be closure for you sister. Be there for her what ever she decides,but if you do decide to take them on remember the closure could take years.
Thanks guys that is really useful on a number of levels, especially the advice from Piglet.
I think I will go with the flow. I have a friend who can take a look at the medical records (no expert in the particular area but they will be able to give me a steer so I know ehere we stand either way). I had realised how dificult medical negilgence is to prove, and I don't feel a need to chase it to put a value on the life of someone who was, in many ways a parasite. His condition was such it was about when, not if he died. Unfortunately for the hospital it happened when he was in theatre when they were having an off day.
I will just cover the bases in case later on she decides she need more closure than the inquest.
I did send me a 'pampering parcel' which went down well and I think a focus on her rather than him is needed.
I think I will go with the flow. I have a friend who can take a look at the medical records (no expert in the particular area but they will be able to give me a steer so I know ehere we stand either way). I had realised how dificult medical negilgence is to prove, and I don't feel a need to chase it to put a value on the life of someone who was, in many ways a parasite. His condition was such it was about when, not if he died. Unfortunately for the hospital it happened when he was in theatre when they were having an off day.
I will just cover the bases in case later on she decides she need more closure than the inquest.
I did send me a 'pampering parcel' which went down well and I think a focus on her rather than him is needed.
As an addition, many of the people I saw who brought claims didn't feel that they gained closure from them. I had some exposure to the organ retention cases and some of the families suffered dreadfully, unfortunately getting to the end and getting a result and a bit of cash didn't give them the closure that they thought they would get.
Bringing litigation as Jess says merely delays the point of closure as they person involved is still having to deal with the incident. They then assume that when the case is finished this will give them closure and mainly it doesn't.
Bringing litigation as Jess says merely delays the point of closure as they person involved is still having to deal with the incident. They then assume that when the case is finished this will give them closure and mainly it doesn't.
stovey said:
leftie said:
I have suggested that for the moment she gets copies of his medical record and notes, as she is entitled to, to protect her interests.
I suspect that these might have 'changed' since the event. Best to get these ASAP if you think that you may need them later.
I would have thought there were arrangements to stop that (handing to the police or something)? I know the coroner has the notes (or a copy?).
They also retained some bits from the postmortem (which I guess are samples).
This post is probably not going to be that helpful to you ,but here goes. Ihave been close to a few bereavements over the years and one thing which has stood out is ;how often a family member points a finger at the hospital/hospice andthe mistakes made by the medical professionals involved. The mistakes (real or imagined) are usually surmises of the accuser, but can seem very plausible to grief stricken relatives who don't know any better.They are angry and the anecdotal tales snowball. For what it's worth , my advice would be to give your sister all the support and comfort you can and let the dust settle a bit.
denbeer said:
This post is probably not going to be that helpful to you ,but here goes. Ihave been close to a few bereavements over the years and one thing which has stood out is ;how often a family member points a finger at the hospital/hospice andthe mistakes made by the medical professionals involved. The mistakes (real or imagined) are usually surmises of the accuser, but can seem very plausible to grief stricken relatives who don't know any better.They are angry and the anecdotal tales snowball. For what it's worth , my advice would be to give your sister all the support and comfort you can and let the dust settle a bit.
I think you are right, it is all part of the 'denial, anger, blame, depression and moving on' cycle. We are currently hovering between anger and blame.
Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



