Non British Design wins British Design award
Discussion
Eric Mc said:
Concorde has just won the BBC Culture Show's grreatest "British" design icon award.
As it is 50% French, how could it be a "British" design.
(Only miffed as the Spitfire should have won - and it's 100 British).
Spitfire??? Beautiful plane but massively overated, and far out done by the little mentioned Hurricane.
I voted Spitfire in the final three, but actually voted for the K6 Telephone box in the main vote as I consider it a design icon that identifies Britain whenever you see it. It seems every Hollywood film that portrays a scene in London needs a red telephone box and a Routemaster bus to identify it as London.
The Spitfire was emphatically NOT outdone by the Hurricane. This myth seems to have grown out of the genuine fact that the Hurricane shot down three times as many aircraft as the Spitfire (and all other UK defences - IN THE BATTLE OF BRITAIN). That was because during that short time period (May to October 1940) there were three times as many Hurricanes in service with Fighter Command as there were Spitfires.
As soon as the Battle of Britain was over, the Hurricane was withdrawn from service as a front line fighter as it was obvious that it was becoming obsolete and would be completely outclassed within months.
The Spitfire went through a whole series of developments right up to the end of the war - the Hurricane did not. Although the Hurricane did continue in RAF service right up to 1945. after 1941, it mainly flew in the Mediterranean theatre and the Middle and Far East, and mainly in the ground attack role (in which it performed pretty well). However, over Northern Europe its time was over and Spitfires (and later P-47s and P-51s) became the dominant Allied fighters.
One only has to look at the performance figures of a 1945 Hurricane compared to a 1940 Hurricane - they are virtually identical.
In contrast, a 1945 Spitfire was 100 mph faster than its 1940 counterpart.
>> Edited by Eric Mc on Thursday 16th March 22:53
As soon as the Battle of Britain was over, the Hurricane was withdrawn from service as a front line fighter as it was obvious that it was becoming obsolete and would be completely outclassed within months.
The Spitfire went through a whole series of developments right up to the end of the war - the Hurricane did not. Although the Hurricane did continue in RAF service right up to 1945. after 1941, it mainly flew in the Mediterranean theatre and the Middle and Far East, and mainly in the ground attack role (in which it performed pretty well). However, over Northern Europe its time was over and Spitfires (and later P-47s and P-51s) became the dominant Allied fighters.
One only has to look at the performance figures of a 1945 Hurricane compared to a 1940 Hurricane - they are virtually identical.
In contrast, a 1945 Spitfire was 100 mph faster than its 1940 counterpart.
>> Edited by Eric Mc on Thursday 16th March 22:53
morrisman said:
Spitfire??? Beautiful plane but...
... but what? This was a design poll, not a quiz about the RAFs Order of Battle, summer 1940.
The Spitfire should have won. Don't know why the web is in there - it's a medium not a design, if they're going to include that they might as well have put "print" (except that printing was Gutenberg and he's German
). They should have included the HST, Intercity 125, call it what you will. Still looks better than all the new trains and has carried more people than all the other things on the list combined, ever.
morrisman said:
Eric Mc said:
Concorde has just won the BBC Culture Show's grreatest "British" design icon award.
As it is 50% French, how could it be a "British" design.
(Only miffed as the Spitfire should have won - and it's 100 British).
Spitfire??? Beautiful plane but massively overated, and far out done by the little mentioned Hurricane.
Hmm, not entirely true "overrated"; most if not all of the pilots say that the spitfire gave them the upper hand they needed to beat the Jerrys. The design makes it really agile apparently. What about "Never in the field of human conflict was so much owed by so many to so few" -Churchill. He's talking about the Spitfire pilots.
Saying that, I was pleased to see Concorde there, they say it was technically more difficult than sending man into space, and at normal flight speed it is only 10mph slower than a speeding bullet leaving the barrel of a gun!! Clever stuff.
Beetle
>> Edited by beetlebloke on Thursday 16th March 23:39
beetlebloke said:
What about "Never in the field of human conflict was so much owed by so many to so few" -Churchill. He's talking about the Spitfire pilots.
And all these years I've thought Winston meant ALL the pilots who died fighting the hun in the Battle of Britain, whatever they flew. I'll bet my old granddad would be turning in his grave if he realised that most famous of sayings didn't apply to him. (Hurricane pilot)
My dad, (who was in the RAF for nearly 50 years) seems to have some rather different opinions about Spitfires and Hurricanes than our learned colleagues here do. How odd. Maybe it something to do with all the pilots he knew and worked with shortly after WW2

The Hurricane or the Spitfire?
The Hawker business or the Supermarine business?
Sydney Camm or R.J. Mitchell?
Which will win the battle of the Battle of Britain fighters?
Which was better? I would say that they were both better than each other!
Although they were both built to meet the same specification, they were designed to differing design outlooks and were both unbeatable in their chosen areas. The Spitfire was a result of a decision that everything in the design must add to outright flying performance even at the expense of other criteria - the "high technology" route. The Hurricane approach was that the maximum achievable with the technology of the day was to be aimed for whilst meeting the full range of issues affecting a fighting machine. One of the key requirements of the Hawker design was to ensuring that large numbers of operational aircraft were delivered in the shortest possible time.
The Hurricane was the RAF's first 300mph fighter and even as the Battle of Britain raged, Hawker were well on their way to providing the first 400mph fighter in the shape of the mighty Typhoon. Before the war had ended this had been added to by the even better Tempest.
The Hurricane was larger than both the Spitfire and the Bf109. For absolute speed that may have been bad but that disadvantage gave an opposing advantage of greater wing area, with lower wing loading that resulted in a better rate of turn than either of its contemporaries. This is one of the key "performance indicators" of a fighter. A turning radius quoted as 800 feet for the Hurricane and 880 feet for the Spitfire.
The Spitfire has always been regarded as the more responsive of the two. This did, however, have the disadvantage of being unstable when firing the eight machine guns, resulting in difficulty keeping the fire on target compared with the Hurricane that was more stable under the recoil of the same guns.
The thick wing of the Hurricane limited its maximum speed but that price gave other advantages. The large strong wing allowed a much wider undercarriage than the Spitfire with corresponding advantages of stability on rough airfields in battle theatres around the world, better performance on waterlogged airstrips and was easier for the less experienced pilot. All of which reduced accidents, improving the aircrafts serviceability level and versatility. The thick wing gave advantages over the Spitfire in that unlike the Spit's widely spaced armament the Hurri had it's machine guns in compact blocks of four in each wing. As well as the advantage of concentrated firepower, this also gave the ground crew a more efficient re-arming procedure that resulted in aircraft saving precious time in the race to return to operational status after a mission. The larger wings also easily accepted the four 20mm cannons (that became standard British armament after the Battle of Britain), whilst the Spitfire had to make do with just two cannons and keep four of the old machine guns until much later. After the defensive action of the summer of 1940 the two aircraft were used in an offensive role. When called upon to perform ground attack in the thicker air of lower levels, the sophisticated wing of the Spitfire was not at ease with the stresses encountered. There were stories of Spit wings in huge piles at maintenance units as fractured wings were replaced after sharp pullouts at low levels - something that the more solid Hawker products were not affected by.
Without the Spitfire the cost of success would have been greater in fighters lost to enemy action and the battle would have been longer due to the Bf109's high altitude performance advantage over the Hurricane.
The Hurricane was manufactured and repaired with ease and able to use a wide range of non-aerospace sub-contractors. Its solid construction, concentrated firepower and steady firing platform made it the better weapon for the fighter's role of actually destroying enemy aircraft. If the Hurricane had been delayed long enough to improve it's design to match the speed of the Spitfire, vital months output would have been lost in the crucial build-up to the battles of France and Britain and even then production would have been slower. Only the Hurricane could have guaranteed sufficient aircraft for the battle (and even then numbers were desperately small).
Without the high performance Spitfire the cost of success may have been greater and the battle may have been longer but without the Hurricane the Battle of Britain would have been lost, and possibly following that the whole war.
Eric is right though - the Spitfire was developed as the war years went on .... the Hurricane wasn't.
The Hawker business or the Supermarine business?
Sydney Camm or R.J. Mitchell?
Which will win the battle of the Battle of Britain fighters?
Which was better? I would say that they were both better than each other!
Although they were both built to meet the same specification, they were designed to differing design outlooks and were both unbeatable in their chosen areas. The Spitfire was a result of a decision that everything in the design must add to outright flying performance even at the expense of other criteria - the "high technology" route. The Hurricane approach was that the maximum achievable with the technology of the day was to be aimed for whilst meeting the full range of issues affecting a fighting machine. One of the key requirements of the Hawker design was to ensuring that large numbers of operational aircraft were delivered in the shortest possible time.
The Hurricane was the RAF's first 300mph fighter and even as the Battle of Britain raged, Hawker were well on their way to providing the first 400mph fighter in the shape of the mighty Typhoon. Before the war had ended this had been added to by the even better Tempest.
The Hurricane was larger than both the Spitfire and the Bf109. For absolute speed that may have been bad but that disadvantage gave an opposing advantage of greater wing area, with lower wing loading that resulted in a better rate of turn than either of its contemporaries. This is one of the key "performance indicators" of a fighter. A turning radius quoted as 800 feet for the Hurricane and 880 feet for the Spitfire.
The Spitfire has always been regarded as the more responsive of the two. This did, however, have the disadvantage of being unstable when firing the eight machine guns, resulting in difficulty keeping the fire on target compared with the Hurricane that was more stable under the recoil of the same guns.
The thick wing of the Hurricane limited its maximum speed but that price gave other advantages. The large strong wing allowed a much wider undercarriage than the Spitfire with corresponding advantages of stability on rough airfields in battle theatres around the world, better performance on waterlogged airstrips and was easier for the less experienced pilot. All of which reduced accidents, improving the aircrafts serviceability level and versatility. The thick wing gave advantages over the Spitfire in that unlike the Spit's widely spaced armament the Hurri had it's machine guns in compact blocks of four in each wing. As well as the advantage of concentrated firepower, this also gave the ground crew a more efficient re-arming procedure that resulted in aircraft saving precious time in the race to return to operational status after a mission. The larger wings also easily accepted the four 20mm cannons (that became standard British armament after the Battle of Britain), whilst the Spitfire had to make do with just two cannons and keep four of the old machine guns until much later. After the defensive action of the summer of 1940 the two aircraft were used in an offensive role. When called upon to perform ground attack in the thicker air of lower levels, the sophisticated wing of the Spitfire was not at ease with the stresses encountered. There were stories of Spit wings in huge piles at maintenance units as fractured wings were replaced after sharp pullouts at low levels - something that the more solid Hawker products were not affected by.
Without the Spitfire the cost of success would have been greater in fighters lost to enemy action and the battle would have been longer due to the Bf109's high altitude performance advantage over the Hurricane.
The Hurricane was manufactured and repaired with ease and able to use a wide range of non-aerospace sub-contractors. Its solid construction, concentrated firepower and steady firing platform made it the better weapon for the fighter's role of actually destroying enemy aircraft. If the Hurricane had been delayed long enough to improve it's design to match the speed of the Spitfire, vital months output would have been lost in the crucial build-up to the battles of France and Britain and even then production would have been slower. Only the Hurricane could have guaranteed sufficient aircraft for the battle (and even then numbers were desperately small).
Without the high performance Spitfire the cost of success may have been greater and the battle may have been longer but without the Hurricane the Battle of Britain would have been lost, and possibly following that the whole war.
Eric is right though - the Spitfire was developed as the war years went on .... the Hurricane wasn't.
Warning: spotter moment coming......
Think possibly too much importance is being placed on turn radius....if having the smallest possible turning radius was the key combat indicator of a decent fighter then the RAF would have still been using the Gloster Gladiator in the BoB. They weren't and it would have been suicide if they had ! Turn performance is essentially a defensive , not offensive performance indicator.
The Me109 had (allegedly) a bigger turning radius than the RAF aircraft, due to a higher wing loading, but it didn't hinder it becoming one of the top fighters of WW2 and a good foil to the spit. (Top Trumps moment!)
The Me109 had at the start of the BoB, significantly better tactics and similar performance to the Spit, apart from Turn radius it completely outclassed the Hurricane and the Hurricane was generally viewed as cannon fodder by the Luftwaffe. No disrespect to pilots of any ac that fought, all brave young chaps on both sides.
SiKo
Think possibly too much importance is being placed on turn radius....if having the smallest possible turning radius was the key combat indicator of a decent fighter then the RAF would have still been using the Gloster Gladiator in the BoB. They weren't and it would have been suicide if they had ! Turn performance is essentially a defensive , not offensive performance indicator.
The Me109 had (allegedly) a bigger turning radius than the RAF aircraft, due to a higher wing loading, but it didn't hinder it becoming one of the top fighters of WW2 and a good foil to the spit. (Top Trumps moment!)
The Me109 had at the start of the BoB, significantly better tactics and similar performance to the Spit, apart from Turn radius it completely outclassed the Hurricane and the Hurricane was generally viewed as cannon fodder by the Luftwaffe. No disrespect to pilots of any ac that fought, all brave young chaps on both sides.
SiKo
I would never denigrate the Hurricane at all. It was the right aircraft at the right time and its moment of glory was the Battle of Britain. After that, its usefullness as a fighter began to decline. There was no way it could be developed like the Spitfire and would have been a death trap for pilots if they had to encounter more sophisticated German fighters like the Bf-109F and G models and the Focke-Wulf 190. Even the Spitfire struggled against the Fw-190 and it was only the advent of the Mk IX Spitfire which allowed RAF fighter pilots to meet the 190 on even terms.
Supermarine, as a company, were really a one trick pony during WW2. Their main purpose during the war was to refine and develop the Spitfire. Hawkers, on the other hand, were a much more versatile company. Rather than try and develop the Hurricane, Sydney Camm realised that the best option was to create a brand new design. In fact, they created two, the Tornado and the Typhoon - which were actually the same aircraft fitted with different engines. Unfortunately, the engines chosen proved to be massively problematic. Indeed, the Rolls Royce Vulture fitted to the Tornado was such a disaster that the design was abandoned. They perservered with the Napier engined Typhoon, which took a long time to getr right (and was never made reliable enough, really).
In the end, the best wartime Camm design was the Tempest, which was a refined Typhoon (with a much thinner wing, strangley similar to the Spitfire's). Even that had problems (the Napier again) and they didn't really get it right until the Bristol Centaurus powered Tempest entered service just after the war.
Morrisman - you have to understand the psyche of aircrew and groundcrew in their relationships with the aircraft they work on. They become fiecely loyal to the type and will very rarely allow anyone to "rubbish" it, especially in comparison to a rival design.
I've just watched a documentary on the Handley Page Halifax bomber, a contemporary of the Lancaster. Not one of the Halifax crew members interviewed were prepared to accept that the Lancaster was a superior aircraft.
>> Edited by Eric Mc on Friday 17th March 09:06
Supermarine, as a company, were really a one trick pony during WW2. Their main purpose during the war was to refine and develop the Spitfire. Hawkers, on the other hand, were a much more versatile company. Rather than try and develop the Hurricane, Sydney Camm realised that the best option was to create a brand new design. In fact, they created two, the Tornado and the Typhoon - which were actually the same aircraft fitted with different engines. Unfortunately, the engines chosen proved to be massively problematic. Indeed, the Rolls Royce Vulture fitted to the Tornado was such a disaster that the design was abandoned. They perservered with the Napier engined Typhoon, which took a long time to getr right (and was never made reliable enough, really).
In the end, the best wartime Camm design was the Tempest, which was a refined Typhoon (with a much thinner wing, strangley similar to the Spitfire's). Even that had problems (the Napier again) and they didn't really get it right until the Bristol Centaurus powered Tempest entered service just after the war.
Morrisman - you have to understand the psyche of aircrew and groundcrew in their relationships with the aircraft they work on. They become fiecely loyal to the type and will very rarely allow anyone to "rubbish" it, especially in comparison to a rival design.
I've just watched a documentary on the Handley Page Halifax bomber, a contemporary of the Lancaster. Not one of the Halifax crew members interviewed were prepared to accept that the Lancaster was a superior aircraft.
>> Edited by Eric Mc on Friday 17th March 09:06
Just to come in on this, the Germans had better tactics than the British during the BOB The Me 109 also had 20mm cannons, one of which fired through the spinner of the aircraft. The British did not succeed in the battle because of aircraft alone, many factors helped, RADAR for example.
There is an argument that the British did not win the BOB but avoided defeat. The BOB was followed by the blitz of 1940/41 and UK solders did not step foot back on to European soil until 1944. What followed the BOB was the fall of Greece and Creat(sp?), the defeats that lead to Alamein, and the siege of Malta. Hardly what you would call stunning victory's.
Nonetheless, the BOB kept us in the fight and for that it is classed as a victory.
Back on topic, while the Concorde is not a wholly British design, its still a worthy winner. Its sleek design, and beauty make it out standing, also the fact that it has not been bettered.
There is an argument that the British did not win the BOB but avoided defeat. The BOB was followed by the blitz of 1940/41 and UK solders did not step foot back on to European soil until 1944. What followed the BOB was the fall of Greece and Creat(sp?), the defeats that lead to Alamein, and the siege of Malta. Hardly what you would call stunning victory's.
Nonetheless, the BOB kept us in the fight and for that it is classed as a victory.
Back on topic, while the Concorde is not a wholly British design, its still a worthy winner. Its sleek design, and beauty make it out standing, also the fact that it has not been bettered.
Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




...