Buy to let - mortgage with a limited company or personally?
Buy to let - mortgage with a limited company or personally?
Author
Discussion

thanuk

Original Poster:

686 posts

294 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
I've got the deposit (20-30%) in my limited company and am trying to work out whether it is more cost effective to pay 40% income tax on the money and buy the property privately or set up a SPV limited company to make the purchase.

It seems the interest rates offered are better for individuals than companies but then the company could offset capital gains tax if/when the property is sold.

Can anyone explain the benefits either way? Thanks.

jacksdad

307 posts

293 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
Nathaniel, mail me and I will put you in touch with a source, JD.

minimax

11,985 posts

287 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
oooh, I know but I'm not authorised to tell you what a bummer this FSA stuff is - qualified but not authorised eh! hey ho. try eric mc - he's bound to know

Davi

17,153 posts

251 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
minimax said:
oooh, I know but I'm not authorised to tell you what a bummer this FSA stuff is - qualified but not authorised eh! hey ho. try eric mc - he's bound to know
Bugger aint it

One thing I would point out - the majority of the specialists require personal guarantee's even if it's in a limited company. If you are happy with that we have a couple of lenders that couldn't care if it's a ltd company or individual, rates are good and identical either way - they underwrite on the directors.

Have a look at our website if you want, it's in my profile (crap website I know, but the rates are there)

>> Edited by Davi on Friday 17th March 14:15

Eric Mc

125,948 posts

296 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
If the company is only set up to own and manage the property, it will not be available to avail of the small company Corporation Tax rates and exemptions. These rates etc only apply to small TRADING companies.

Therefore, Capital Gains on the disposal might be payable at 30% CT.

You will probably still want to extract some if not all of the money generated by the property from the company. This will meant that, at some point in the proceedings, personal Income Tax will become due.

Companies do not get the £8,500 Capital Gains Allowance available to individuals, which, when dealing with the gain on the disposal of a property which is in the name of multiple owners, can wipe out the taxable gain completely.

Companies still apply the old fashioned Indexation Relief to Capital Gains. Individuals use Taper Relief.

Yertis

19,745 posts

297 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
I hate these labyrinthine tax rules. Why don't they just take 25% of what you earn, 17.5% of what you sell and be done with it. Hacks me right off. I've yet to meet a tax man who understands, and usefully explain, his own rules on printed marketing matter for charitable bodies.

minimax

11,985 posts

287 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
Davi said:
minimax said:
oooh, I know but I'm not authorised to tell you what a bummer this FSA stuff is - qualified but not authorised eh! hey ho. try eric mc - he's bound to know

Have a look at our website if you want, it's in my profile (crap website I know, but the rates are there)

>> Edited by Davi on Friday 17th March 14:15



wanders off to look at the competition

thanuk

Original Poster:

686 posts

294 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
Thanks for all the replies. I'm not too worried about paying income tax on the profits extracted because I'd only anticipate taking any once I'd retired and was able to take it at the lower tax rate.

Eric Mc

125,948 posts

296 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
My advice - save tax when you can i.e now, rather than anticipating where tax might be in "X" year's time.

Davi

17,153 posts

251 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
minimax said:
Davi said:
minimax said:
oooh, I know but I'm not authorised to tell you what a bummer this FSA stuff is - qualified but not authorised eh! hey ho. try eric mc - he's bound to know

Have a look at our website if you want, it's in my profile (crap website I know, but the rates are there)

>> Edited by Davi on Friday 17th March 14:15



wanders off to look at the competition


LOL been looking up your site since the convo in the other thread

At least your company seems to spend some of its cash on the web department, unfortunately with so much business coming from repeat/recommendation it's very hard to convince bosses of it's worth

Sorry for the brief deviation off topic there.

maxed

1,001 posts

251 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
My advice - save tax when you can i.e now, rather than anticipating where tax might be in "X" year's time.


Yeap, have to agree with this.
Plus often review the situation on buying property via a Ltd Co.
The net result i've found is you lose out on receiving the CGT allowance entitlement etc.

Another point to bear in mind is you never can fully predict a retirement age. The variables of life further on are somewhat unpredictable, however well you plan life!
For example: health or sudden lack of it, desire to move abroad, downturn in company trading etc

Eric Mc

125,948 posts

296 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
I came across a very unfortunate situation which was caused by a broadly similar situation.

The individual purchased a property through a company. The company did nothing other than own and manage the rpoerty. All the rents were received by the company and the company paid Corporation Tax on the net rental income. The individual paid Income Tax as and when he withdrew money from the company. The day came when the individual decided to retire. The company sold the property and therefore incurred a Capital Gains Tax liability. The owner then took his money out of the company - and paid Income Tax on the amount extracted. So, in effect, he paid tax twice on the same amount of money, and had foregone the possibility of utiling his personal Capital Gains Tax allowance - which would have resulted in a Nil tax liability all round.

He had used a company to buy the property because he had assumed that he would be able to obtain retirement relief at the time the company or property was sold. Unfortunately, his original accountant who advised him had not realised that retirement relief was applicable to TRADING companies only. Property companies are not trading copmpanies.

maxed

1,001 posts

251 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
Very relevent points.

Also, you lose the opportunity to overide CGT taxation by moving into the property within 3 years of selling and thus incur no tax! Plus, the pleasure of living in your property investment/s

Eric Mc

125,948 posts

296 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
Absolutely. There are some tax gains which MIGHT arise through a company owning the property, but you lose huge elements of flexibility.

maxed

1,001 posts

251 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
Flexibilty...spot on...and control.

By retaining these 2 important elements allows for expansion or otherwise as market/personal trends alter/change.

JonRB

80,230 posts

303 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
I've run a trading company since 1999 and have a modest portfolio of property. I asked my accountant if I should have my properties owned and administered by the company or personally, and he has always been adamant that it is better to hold them personally.

(Doesn't mean he's right, mind)

Eric Mc

125,948 posts

296 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
In general, that is the correct approach. Now and then there may be advantages in having the property owned by the company. For instance, a trading company might prefer to hold the property used by the business in the company (although, sometimes, directors prefer to own the business property personally and "rent" it to the company instead).

If a company owns a property as part of their trading activity they will not lose their "trading" status and can avail of the small trading company beneficial tax rates. They also can rent out parts of the business premises without any "investment" restrictions being placed on them providing the rental income is incidental to the overall trading activities.

turbo tim

20,467 posts

262 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Property companies are not trading copmpanies.


I didn't know that. So what defines a "trading company"?

NJW 77

17,065 posts

269 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
turbo tim said:
Eric Mc said:
Property companies are not trading copmpanies.


I didn't know that. So what defines a "trading company"?


Its a pain in the arse this one. My company is a property investment company, not trading. I see all these tax breaks for trading companies and wish I could get my hands on them But there are obviously advantages for us or the accountants would advise differently.

We dont buy and sell, just buy and rent out.

What about a self-administered pension plan? IIRC you can now stick residential property into a SAPP?(made up acronym ) Im sure someone will be along to advise on the pitfalls of such a thing. I know you can take out a lump sum upon retirement and also IIRC, contributions are tax free? More of a long term option.

Eric Mc

125,948 posts

296 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
Gordon put the kybosh on that one I'm afraid.

A company is a trading company when it is selling goods or services. A company is an investment company when it derives its income from investments. Investments can mean any type of asset (stocks, shares, bank accounts, pension funds etc) but usually means land and property.
When a company's income is deemed to be investment income, it cannot make use of the small trading company low rates of Corporation Tax. In additions, it also has quite stringent accounting disclosure requirements concerning the valuation of the various assets it holds in its balance sheet. This usually involves ensuring that property portfolios are revalued every year.

Also, in the UK different tax rules apply to income depending on how the income has been earned (trading profits, rents, interest received, dividend income etc). These rules vary tremendously and are often at variance with each other and cause no end of confusion. Most of this is simply down to history and how British taxation has evolved over 200 years.