Man Hits His Own Car Then Sues Himself
Man Hits His Own Car Then Sues Himself
Author
Discussion

branflakes

Original Poster:

2,039 posts

269 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
Newsday.com said:

LODI, Calif. -- When a dump truck backed into Curtis Gokey's car, he decided to sue the city for damages. Only thing is, he was the one driving the dump truck. But that minor detail didn't stop Gokey, a Lodi city employee, from filing a $3,600 claim for the December accident, even after admitting the crash was his fault.

After the city denied that claim because Gokey was, in essence, suing himself, he and his wife, Rhonda, decided to file a new claim under her name.

City Attorney Steve Schwabauer said this one also lacks merit because Rhonda Gokey can't sue her own husband.

"You can sue your spouse for divorce, but you can't sue your spouse for negligence," Schwabauer said. "They're a married couple under California law. They're one entity. It's damage to community property."

But Rhonda Gokey insisted she has "the right to sue the city because a city's vehicle damaged my private vehicle."

In fact, her claim, currently pending at Lodi City Hall, is for an even larger amount -- $4,800.

"I'm not as nice as my husband is," she said.


www.newsday.com/news/nationworld/wire/sns-ap-suing-self,0,4456902.story

scared but happy

24,147 posts

260 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
Sounds a bit like the woman who sued herself for leaving the floor slippery and going arse over tit. She managed to do this by claiming the 'company' (ie her) did not put up a warning notice.

Popzak

794 posts

250 months

Friday 17th March 2006
quotequote all
I'm waiting for someone to shoot themself and blame the Gun Manufacturer.

Parrot of Doom

23,075 posts

265 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
Wasn't it James Goldsmith who, in his will, left aside a legal fund in case anybody started whinging about the amount they were bequeathed?

I like that. I think the world should have a similar fund, just in case people decide to make up daft claims.

Ballistic Banana

14,706 posts

298 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
scared but happy said:
Sounds a bit like the woman who sued herself for leaving the floor slippery and going arse over tit. She managed to do this by claiming the 'company' (ie her) did not put up a warning notice.


what was the outcome in that case?

groomi

9,331 posts

274 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
Ballistic Banana said:
scared but happy said:
Sounds a bit like the woman who sued herself for leaving the floor slippery and going arse over tit. She managed to do this by claiming the 'company' (ie her) did not put up a warning notice.


what was the outcome in that case?


She cleaned up...

falcemob

8,248 posts

267 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
Er, I don't see what's wrong with this. If I accidentally back my truck into someones car at work, my company will pay the owner for the damage I cause. If it was my own car (or my wife's) I backed into accidentally, then what's the difference. I have still caused damage and my company insures me for any TP liability while at I am at work.

groomi

9,331 posts

274 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
falcemob said:
Er, I don't see what's wrong with this. If I accidentally back my truck into someones car at work, my company will pay the owner for the damage I cause. If it was my own car (or my wife's) I backed into accidentally, then what's the difference. I have still caused damage and my company insures me for any TP liability while at I am at work.


Possible scenario...
Man drives private car.
Private car has problems which will cost £££s to fix.
Same man drives big heavy truck for a living.
Man drives big heavy truck into his private car.
Companies insurance now pays out to replace written-off car.
Man has saved £££s at companies expense.

falcemob

8,248 posts

267 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
groomi said:
falcemob said:
Er, I don't see what's wrong with this. If I accidentally back my truck into someones car at work, my company will pay the owner for the damage I cause. If it was my own car (or my wife's) I backed into accidentally, then what's the difference. I have still caused damage and my company insures me for any TP liability while at I am at work.


Possible scenario...
Man drives private car.
Private car has problems which will cost £££s to fix.
Same man drives big heavy truck for a living.
Man drives big heavy truck into his private car.
Companies insurance now pays out to replace written-off car.
Man has saved £££s at companies expense.

Possible yes, but also dishonest

desmo

144 posts

251 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
It's a Sad Sad world!

hugoagogo

23,438 posts

264 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
groomi said:
falcemob said:
Er, I don't see what's wrong with this. If I accidentally back my truck into someones car at work, my company will pay the owner for the damage I cause. If it was my own car (or my wife's) I backed into accidentally, then what's the difference. I have still caused damage and my company insures me for any TP liability while at I am at work.


Possible scenario...
Man drives private car.
Private car has problems which will cost £££s to fix.
Same man drives big heavy truck for a living.
Man drives big heavy truck into his private car.
Companies insurance now pays out to replace written-off car.
Man has saved £££s at companies expense.


i've thought about how feasible that would be, with all-excess covered hire car (preferably hired in a friends name and get them to crash it into you)

Parrot of Doom

23,075 posts

265 months

Saturday 18th March 2006
quotequote all
falcemob said:
Er, I don't see what's wrong with this. If I accidentally back my truck into someones car at work, my company will pay the owner for the damage I cause. If it was my own car (or my wife's) I backed into accidentally, then what's the difference. I have still caused damage and my company insures me for any TP liability while at I am at work.


They'll pay out because its not the victim's fault.

Paying out when its entirely the victim's fault is silly.

towman

14,938 posts

270 months

Sunday 19th March 2006
quotequote all
hugoagogo said:
groomi said:
falcemob said:
Er, I don't see what's wrong with this. If I accidentally back my truck into someones car at work, my company will pay the owner for the damage I cause. If it was my own car (or my wife's) I backed into accidentally, then what's the difference. I have still caused damage and my company insures me for any TP liability while at I am at work.


Possible scenario...
Man drives private car.
Private car has problems which will cost £££s to fix.
Same man drives big heavy truck for a living.
Man drives big heavy truck into his private car.
Companies insurance now pays out to replace written-off car.
Man has saved £££s at companies expense.


i've thought about how feasible that would be, with all-excess covered hire car (preferably hired in a friends name and get them to crash it into you)


Was done on "Minder" a good few years ago. Ray Daley rented a 7.5 tonner, paid a little kid to throw a ball into the road and then swerved into Arthurs car lot.

falcemob

8,248 posts

267 months

Sunday 19th March 2006
quotequote all
towman said:
hugoagogo said:
groomi said:
falcemob said:
Er, I don't see what's wrong with this. If I accidentally back my truck into someones car at work, my company will pay the owner for the damage I cause. If it was my own car (or my wife's) I backed into accidentally, then what's the difference. I have still caused damage and my company insures me for any TP liability while at I am at work.


Possible scenario...
Man drives private car.
Private car has problems which will cost £££s to fix.
Same man drives big heavy truck for a living.
Man drives big heavy truck into his private car.
Companies insurance now pays out to replace written-off car.
Man has saved £££s at companies expense.


i've thought about how feasible that would be, with all-excess covered hire car (preferably hired in a friends name and get them to crash it into you)


Was done on "Minder" a good few years ago. Ray Daley rented a 7.5 tonner, paid a little kid to throw a ball into the road and then swerved into Arthurs car lot.

I've been offered money on a few occasions to accidently hit someones car, I think £200 was the figure last time a few years ago. Never done it though.

towman

14,938 posts

270 months

Sunday 19th March 2006
quotequote all
Blimey. You can get the whole thing "disappeared" round here for £50!

morrisman

264 posts

249 months

Sunday 19th March 2006
quotequote all
branflakes said:
Newsday.com said:

LODI, Calif. -- When a dump truck backed into Curtis Gokey's car, he decided to sue the city for damages. Only thing is, he was the one driving the dump truck. But that minor detail didn't stop Gokey, a Lodi city employee, from filing a $3,600 claim for the December accident, even after admitting the crash was his fault.

After the city denied that claim because Gokey was, in essence, suing himself, he and his wife, Rhonda, decided to file a new claim under her name.

City Attorney Steve Schwabauer said this one also lacks merit because Rhonda Gokey can't sue her own husband.

"You can sue your spouse for divorce, but you can't sue your spouse for negligence," Schwabauer said. "They're a married couple under California law. They're one entity. It's damage to community property."

But Rhonda Gokey insisted she has "the right to sue the city because a city's vehicle damaged my private vehicle."

In fact, her claim, currently pending at Lodi City Hall, is for an even larger amount -- $4,800.

"I'm not as nice as my husband is," she said.


www.newsday.com/news/nationworld/wire/sns-ap-suing-self,0,4456902.story


It's an automatic in-bred reaction for Americans. Something happens: SUE SOMEBODY.

Ten minutes ago I watched on CNN about a female American taxi driver who was sexually assaulted whilst driving her cab. She is now sueing the cab company for not protecting her!!??

Jeez, she was quite happy to drive the cab as it was before, but now it is suddenly not a safe cab??? She should be sued for not alerting the cab company to potential dangerous work hazards.

And she'll complain when the cab rental prices go up next year.

Remal

25,103 posts

265 months

Sunday 19th March 2006
quotequote all
Only in American