Would you lend him the money?
Would you lend him the money?
Author
Discussion

leftie

Original Poster:

11,838 posts

266 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
My son finished a degree in 2005, accrued £20,000 in student loans and went overseas to teach English for a year. He didn't work a job whilst at Uni. and generally got pissed, and travelled Europe with women during the hols but left with a 2:1 from a top ten Uni. I had 2 kids at Uni at that time, so although they both got my help it wasn't as much as they could have had if there had only been one and had his mother and I not divorced part way through, meaning 2 mortgages and 2 lots of bills

He is coming back this summer and wants to do a masters degree and then teach in a university and do a PhD whilst on staff there. Costs for the masters are another £14,000 ( £4500 in fees and the rest to live on as he will be in Edinburgh which is costly).

He is looking at ways to fund the masters degree and has suggested I/ my ex-wife lend him the money and he will pay us back interest free when he is in work. This is on top of his student loan repayment. He has never been good with money. When he went to Uni he had an account we had been saving for him for 10 years which had about £4,000 in which went on following a girl to Canada, a lap top and generally having a good time. Of late he seems more sensible ( he has sent back £1000 to cover his tax when he gets back and has repaid £1000 I lent him when he went overseas).

My daughter spent 6 years at med school which I helped fund, so I feel a little guilty at having second thoughts about lending him a chunk of money that I will have to wait 10 years to see again, if at all. She has just struggled to buy her fist house and didn't come with her hand out (and she never has).

I have the money, or at least my half, have now have a nice house and drive 2 nice cars (well one nice one and an Audi A2). I feel I should try and help.

What would you do? If you did lend him the money, what would you do about the repayment: give it him and don't expect it back, interest free loan, insist interest, ask for a direct debit once he has a job rather than leaving it 'as and when', tell him to make his own way in the world?


robdickinson

31,343 posts

285 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
Wants to stay in happy student land all his life eh...

racefan_uk

2,935 posts

287 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
Personally, I wouldn't. He's got this far and maybe its time that he started to fund his own decisions rather than have you and your ex do it.

Harsh, but just how much more debt is he going to acrue over the next couple of years with the Masters degree, and will a Uni lecturers salary (dependant on him getting one) actually pay this amount back while buying a house/paying rent, living, feeding himself etc?

It's brilliant that he wants to further himself, but where do you draw the line?

And yes, I aree with the above, there's a pang that he wants to go back into the Student life again after doing his travelling...

>> Edited by racefan_uk on Monday 20th March 09:43

bigandclever

14,423 posts

269 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
After long and considered thought, I believe the correct path is to take him to one side and gently suggest that he stops being workshy and gets a bloody job. I'm all for people extending their education, and I'm not for one minute suggesting he's hiding in academia, but FFS he must be in his early twenties, time for him to take some responsibilty.

You asked

timmy30

9,325 posts

258 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
My thought is this.....

If you going to give him the money, give him the money.

BUT don't let him and you pretend that it's a loan not a gift, if he's already £20k in the red with student loans, then you're not likly to see your £14k after he's paid them off are you.

Seems a little unfair on your daughter...which is why I say don't pretend it's a loan, I suspect that the loan idea is so that he/you can tell his sister that it's a loan, if she objects or wonders why he's getting given £14k.

Will you give her a similar amount? She may not be asking but that doesn't mean that she couldn't do with a hand as well?

BliarOut

72,863 posts

270 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
Just a thought, IHT planning?

My father helped me out financially when I was young which meant my mortgage was cleared by the time I was thirty eight. If I'm honest I didn't appreciate it when I was younger but I sure do now.

The additional qualifications may well help him greatly in years to come, but sooner or later he will have to stand on his own two feet financially.

If you think he will achieve results in the end then I don't see a problem with giving him a leg up. The only thing I would suggest you consider is how you would feel if he defaulted for any reason. Could that drive a wedge between you if things went wrong? You have to consider that this may be dead money in the long run.

Buffalo

5,488 posts

285 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
I worked for five years before self-funding my masters...

I am not great with money myself (i spent a bit too much of my earnings over the years on doing up my car! ) but i have done it entirely self funded and have never asked anyone for any money. I had debts and bills to repay comparable to your son (still have about a third of his sum too).

You should ask exactly what he wants to get out of doing the extra degrees and then if he is serious, sit down with him and draw up an actual contract for repayment. I don't think anyone is good with money straight off, you have to learn from some mistakes so you can't be too hard, but you shouldn'tlet him take the P.

The benefit of doing extra degrees is two fold, it can help you get a better job (i need a masters in my field) plus the staisfaction of knowing that you are becoming very knowledgeable about a subject that interests you. We can't all work nose to grindstone - some guys do it differently. If he wants it bad enough though, he'll be prepared to work for it. If he just wants a good time he needs to toughen up a bit.

If i were you, my decision would be based on prior experience of him, his response to your questions and your gut feelings.

>> Edited by Buffalo on Monday 20th March 10:03

chilli

17,320 posts

267 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
Sounds like cake and eat it to me. Sure, you have his best's interests at heart, but surely if he wanted to take this route badly enough, he'd fund part of it himself. He's gonna have to stand on his own two feet at some stage, better sooner than later in my opinion.

nonegreen

7,803 posts

301 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
So he has a drinking mans 1st from a good university? He wants to teach in a university. Hmmmm far from lending him the money I would be furious. A university cardigan can earn a maximum of about 50k. If that was all he was going to do then he could have made more of himself working at MacDonalds FFS. I find it fascinating that parents consider funding no brainer stuff like this. I would be interested to know what he wants to study to masters level?

Graham

16,381 posts

315 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
I'd pay the fees but tell him to get a job to pay his way whilst there....



all the phd students i know have taken teaching positions etc to pay their way...



so you not loaning him any money but you are paying for the education, so not sadling him with any more debt. He'll just have to adjust his lifestyle to what he can earn. If he's serious about getting the PHD then he should see it as a good deal. If he just wants another couple of years sh@gging freshers at your expense then he's stuffed

If he really starts to struggle then you can chip in for his accomodation but I think I'd draw the line at anything else..

cheers

G


and the 10k you save you can sponsor a racing car with

leftie

Original Poster:

11,838 posts

266 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
I have asked him to set it all out properly: student debt, lecturer career start salary, living costs etc. and reminded him he can't live like a student all his days: at some point he will want a house and family and a large debt now won't help that later.

The half way house for me is to help him with living expenses whilst on his masters, and then decide at the end whether to lend him the money (or make him work for me).

Fear is that at the end he can't get a job and has debt he can't pay off. Tough love or not, as a father it would hurt.

timmy30

9,325 posts

258 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
leftie said:
Fear is that at the end he can't get a job and has debt he can't pay off. Tough love or not, as a father it would hurt.


Honestly mate, he is very very very unlikely to actually pay the money back. Why doen't he want to borrow it from a bank, the interest on a £14k loan wouldn't be much, and if he struggled you could help him with the interest payments till he starts work...


...or is it the case that the Bank of Dad is a preffered option as he knows he'll never have to pay it back?

...in which case why not just be upfront, and give him the money, if that's what you're going to do? Why do the 'its a loan charade'?

>> Edited by timmy30 on Monday 20th March 10:20

zcacogp

11,239 posts

275 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
I'd actually bring your daughter back into this. If her brother is being treated differently to her, there is lots of potential for resentment.

How about, if you are going to give anything to your son, you give the same amount to your daughter. This means more equal treating of both of them, and an excuse not to give so much to just one child.

If your daughter feels like it, and your son really needs the money, she could simply give her half straight to him (but let her work that out for herself, don't suggest it.)

The other factor is your ex-wife. Has your son been asking her for money as well? If so, has she given him anything? How much? (He may be getting £14k from her as well ... )


Oli.

anonymous-user

85 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
leftie said:
He is looking at ways to fund the masters degree and has suggested I/ my ex-wife lend him the money and he will pay us back interest free when he is in work.


This I find very worrying if I read it correctly. He SUGGESTS you lend him the money interest free!!! That is taking the piss as far as I am concerned. At least he should offer to pay interest as well!!! I paid my way through Uni by doing bar work and working the holidays. I would never expect my parents to pay! He EXPECTS all this....poor attitude. I think you will do him more harm than good giving him the money. At most pay tuition fees directly as has been mentioned. Give him the lot and all you do is teach and reinforce the fact that it's OK to sponge!!!

fido

18,938 posts

286 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all

one word answer. no.
he's had too much of a good time already, and should be grateful for what you've done -
time for him to find a job and help YOU out.

Jaglover

46,849 posts

266 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
I imagine you are planning to leave him half your money when you die in any case. With many people living to their 80's that means they receive the inheritance when they are in your 50s (and typically financially secure anyway). I think if you have the money you should pay them some of their ‘inheritance’ when they most need it, when they are starting out in life in their twenties. Most obviously by helping them buy their first property. This does not mean you should lend him the money in this instance however. It seems to be he needs to starting earning some money, rather than dosing about at Uni for the rest of his days.,

Wildfire

9,951 posts

283 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
Coming from someone who is probably around the same age and in the same position I would probably say, "sort of". I looked at doing a masters, but couldn't afford the fees (something to do with TVRs) also got a job as well. But a lot of my friends did Masters and most of them did one of 2 things:

1), If their parent's could afford it, borrowed the fee money from their parents and worked whle studying to pay for rent etc.

2). Took 1 year out, worked as temp or such like and paid for it themselves.

I think this a much better way of doing things as your son will come to recognise that he can't party all the time at the expense of his parents. If you lend him the money he will finish his PhD having no real world experience of what it is like to have to work for a living. You can always be there to help him out if he falls on hard times, but i would encourage him to try and pay his way.

When I was at Uni I worked my a**e off during the summer to pay for my rent for the next year and as much of my spending/living money as I could.

Sounds like he's had a pretty good Uni Experience, holidays and all. Also if you refues initially and suggest one of the above, you will find out if he really wants to go to study or just to party. Working for a year and then spending it all on Studying is a big thing and you have to be quite comitted to do that. I know I wasn't. Hence I didn't do a Masters or PhD. A friend of mine is in the middle of his PhD and doing very well. While at Uni he funded his own Degree, and now pays for his master and PhD. he has done everything from stacking shelves to digging graves to pay for his studies. He rarely gets time to party, but really wants to study.

As a young ish person, I know what the temptations to party all the time are like and especially after finshing Uni, it is hard to adjust to the non student life style. I knwo I wanted to do it mainly so I could go back to the lifestyle and not really study and I wasn't prepared to give up my cash to do it.

I think that paying for him to do it all, Uni and everything would be a bad idea, purely because it would set a precedent that he can come to you for any money, any time.

The most I would pay is: lend him the fee money on an interest free basis, as well as the initial Deposit for his house/flat. Tell him he also has to work all summer to pay for his rent/living cost and get a job when he is there.

>> Edited by Wildfire on Monday 20th March 12:03

Fatboy

8,272 posts

303 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
Surely a worthwhile masters/phd will come with funding anyway? I know mine did (if it wasn't for the Ex, I'd have had a very nice lifestyle with no debt on my PHD Grant)...

SlidingSideways

1,345 posts

263 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
Wildfire said:

Tell him he also has to work all summer to pay for his rent/loving cost and get a job when he is there.


Is this how freshers are funding their uni years these days?!? When I was there they were free!! (well, maybe a couple of pints of snakebite....)

Wildfire

9,951 posts

283 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
Arrghhh!! Was it a fruedian slip?