DVT (Deep Vein Thrombosis)
Discussion
I do quite a lot of long haul flights to the far east and was diagnosed with DVT whilst in Hong Kong last month. I have had 2 weeks in the hospital including surgery to break up blood clots in the left calf and thigh. I am now slowly recovering but it has been a difficult time and the bruising is spectacular, I think this is due to the blood being thinner with medication.
It started as a cramp type pain in the calf which moved up to behind the knee and then onto the inside of the thigh. The calf swelled up and was hotter to touch than the other leg.
The recovery period is expected to be at least 6 months where no alcohol is allowed, special diet to follow and surgical stockings to be worn!!!
On the positive side a break from alcohol can only be a good thing, business class flights from now on and I get to wear white stockings every day!!!!!
So PH travellers please follow the instructions on the flights, you really do not want this.
Kevin.
It started as a cramp type pain in the calf which moved up to behind the knee and then onto the inside of the thigh. The calf swelled up and was hotter to touch than the other leg.
The recovery period is expected to be at least 6 months where no alcohol is allowed, special diet to follow and surgical stockings to be worn!!!
On the positive side a break from alcohol can only be a good thing, business class flights from now on and I get to wear white stockings every day!!!!!
So PH travellers please follow the instructions on the flights, you really do not want this.
Kevin.
Flippin 'eck.
How old are you if you don't mind me asking?
I must admit I am fastidious in doing my leg and feet excercises, and getting up for a walk round every hour on any flight these days.
I should also add - glad you are doing ok. Could have been far worse of course.
>> Edited by alexkp on Monday 20th March 10:13
How old are you if you don't mind me asking?
I must admit I am fastidious in doing my leg and feet excercises, and getting up for a walk round every hour on any flight these days.
I should also add - glad you are doing ok. Could have been far worse of course.
>> Edited by alexkp on Monday 20th March 10:13
Once had a talk for a high up medical chap in BA to say that airline DVT's were all newspaper hype and that he'd never seen a case of DVT which was caused by a flight.
He then went on to debunk 'his words' all the newspaper stories by telling what the patient had done to cause the DVT. eg, long history of clotting disorders, evidence of DVT before getting on flight, too much alcohol, overweight dehydrated. He ended by saying most patients will admit to sitting stationary in front of the TV of an evening for far longer than they sit on the plane and that the altitude effects on DVT are negligible because the cabin is kept so close to ground environmental conditions.
Interestingly I've never heard about a diet associated with DVT, so why have they suggested one to you?
He then went on to debunk 'his words' all the newspaper stories by telling what the patient had done to cause the DVT. eg, long history of clotting disorders, evidence of DVT before getting on flight, too much alcohol, overweight dehydrated. He ended by saying most patients will admit to sitting stationary in front of the TV of an evening for far longer than they sit on the plane and that the altitude effects on DVT are negligible because the cabin is kept so close to ground environmental conditions.
Interestingly I've never heard about a diet associated with DVT, so why have they suggested one to you?
What the airlines don't tell you is they are supposed to maintain a cabin pressure equivalent to an altitude of 6,000 to 8,000 feet above sea level.
On long haul flights they push it further AND reduce the partial pressure of oxygen even further to save money and also to make passengers slightly hypoxic and fall asleep.
There was a medical paper published last week in the USA linking DVT not to activity but to the effects of altitude pressure and cabin atmosphere. There is a discrepancy, apparently, between DVT frequency and inactivity in various forms of travel. Air travel has far higher incidence than other long periods of ground travel apparently, even when other issues factored out.
Airlines have known about it for years and deliberately use ploys to keep people in their seats, cabin atmosphere as discussed, trolleys blocking aisles etc etc.
Then people wonder why they get DVT. Never thought I'd be saying this but I would speak to a lawyer.
edited to add The above info is from an independant medical expert who knows his stuff regarding medical effects of flight. The BA chap julian64 refers to is talking rubbish.
>> Edited by Flat in Fifth on Monday 20th March 10:25
On long haul flights they push it further AND reduce the partial pressure of oxygen even further to save money and also to make passengers slightly hypoxic and fall asleep.
There was a medical paper published last week in the USA linking DVT not to activity but to the effects of altitude pressure and cabin atmosphere. There is a discrepancy, apparently, between DVT frequency and inactivity in various forms of travel. Air travel has far higher incidence than other long periods of ground travel apparently, even when other issues factored out.
Airlines have known about it for years and deliberately use ploys to keep people in their seats, cabin atmosphere as discussed, trolleys blocking aisles etc etc.
Then people wonder why they get DVT. Never thought I'd be saying this but I would speak to a lawyer.
edited to add The above info is from an independant medical expert who knows his stuff regarding medical effects of flight. The BA chap julian64 refers to is talking rubbish.
>> Edited by Flat in Fifth on Monday 20th March 10:25
Flat in Fifth said:
What the airlines don't tell you is they are supposed to maintain a cabin pressure equivalent to an altitude of 6,000 to 8,000 feet above sea level.
On long haul flights they push it further AND reduce the partial pressure of oxygen even further to save money and also to make passengers slightly hypoxic and fall asleep.
There was a medical paper published last week in the USA linking DVT not to activity but to the effects of altitude pressure and cabin atmosphere. There is a discrepancy, apparently, between DVT frequency and inactivity in various forms of travel. Air travel has far higher incidence than other long periods of ground travel apparently, even when other issues factored out.
Airlines have known about it for years and deliberately use ploys to keep people in their seats, cabin atmosphere as discussed, trolleys blocking aisles etc etc.
Then people wonder why they get DVT. Never thought I'd be saying this but I would speak to a lawyer.
edited to add The above info is from an independant medical expert who knows his stuff regarding medical effects of flight. The BA chap julian64 refers to is talking rubbish.
>> Edited by Flat in Fifth on Monday 20th March 10:25
Could be true, the chap was certainly partisan, but quite convincing. But lets play devils advocate for a moment and find out why he was given dietry advice and what his predisposing factors are.
I take a lot of long haul flights. Many people still just sit there for 10 hours. For me, being 6ft 5, Virgin Economy means I can't even sit comfortably for 5 minutes, but others seem to just not move. Crazy. I do a few laps of the plane, always use the toilets at the rear (= longer walk) and generally fidget to keep my blood pumping.
I guess the problem is that DVT doesn't affect you immediately so the airlines can make up reasons for no direct link.
I guess the problem is that DVT doesn't affect you immediately so the airlines can make up reasons for no direct link.
Julian64 said:
Could be true, the chap was certainly partisan, but quite convincing. But lets play devils advocate for a moment and find out why he was given dietry advice and what his predisposing factors are.
Fair enough by me, always two sides to a story.
At all costs must avoid expert witness willy waving competition.
Julian64 said:
Once had a talk for a high up medical chap in BA to say that airline DVT's were all newspaper hype and that he'd never seen a case of DVT which was caused by a flight.
He then went on to debunk 'his words' all the newspaper stories by telling what the patient had done to cause the DVT. eg, long history of clotting disorders, evidence of DVT before getting on flight, too much alcohol, overweight dehydrated. He ended by saying most patients will admit to sitting stationary in front of the TV of an evening for far longer than they sit on the plane and that the altitude effects on DVT are negligible because the cabin is kept so close to ground environmental conditions.
Interestingly I've never heard about a diet associated with DVT, so why have they suggested one to you?
I'm guessing he's been warfarinised; 6 month period, no booze etc.... The diet thing is probably about grapefruit and all that.
As for the cabin being at ground level conditions, utter cobblers, the cabins are only pressurised to 8,000 ft IIRC.
There is more than one cause for DVT - such as cancer treatments, prolonged bed rest / immobility, surgery, HRT, a contraceptive pill with oestrogen to name a few… and there is still a lot of debate and it is unclear whether or not air travel is more risky than other long distance modes of travel (eg coach).
The added risk of developing DVT by travelling is still relatively low, and can be reduced further by exercising the legs hourly… in theory at least you should have a break every hour when driving… how many people actually do that?!??
If you travel a lot long haul, you are advised to exercise the muscles in the lower can be exercised while sitting by pulling the toes towards the knees then relaxing, or by pressing the balls of the feet down while raising the heel. Wear loose fitting clothing, keep hydrated (drink water) and avoid alcohol and even wear those funky stockings...
I seem to recall from my Uni days, that some Doctors were advocating the use of asprin as it helps thin the blood...
The added risk of developing DVT by travelling is still relatively low, and can be reduced further by exercising the legs hourly… in theory at least you should have a break every hour when driving… how many people actually do that?!??
If you travel a lot long haul, you are advised to exercise the muscles in the lower can be exercised while sitting by pulling the toes towards the knees then relaxing, or by pressing the balls of the feet down while raising the heel. Wear loose fitting clothing, keep hydrated (drink water) and avoid alcohol and even wear those funky stockings...
I seem to recall from my Uni days, that some Doctors were advocating the use of asprin as it helps thin the blood...
The study is in The Lancet
www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/issue?volume=367&issue=9513
You have to register to get full text though.
A summary is here
www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/issue?volume=367&issue=9513
You have to register to get full text though.
A summary is here
I try and answer some of the questions.
I am 47 years old, no history of any such illness, reasonably fit and healthy.
I have been working overseas for 15 years, lots of experience with travelling, what you should do and not do etc. Nowadays I am based in Hong Kong and do 5 or 6 Europe trips per year plus regional trips to India, Bangladesh and China.
For the last 2 years I have always used flight socks and taken asprin before long haul flights, I have one glass of wine with a meal, drink lots of water but I must admit I do not walk around much 1, because the flights are usually jammed full and 2, there is basically nowhere to stand or walk!!!!
This came on 2 days after flying from China to UK, I thought it was just a cramp in the calf and it went off after a couple of days. It came back after flying back to Hong Kong and China and then spread up the leg.
I am now on warfarin for at least six months to thin the blood, the special diet is to avoid certain things with vitamin K due to the warfarin.
I am 47 years old, no history of any such illness, reasonably fit and healthy.
I have been working overseas for 15 years, lots of experience with travelling, what you should do and not do etc. Nowadays I am based in Hong Kong and do 5 or 6 Europe trips per year plus regional trips to India, Bangladesh and China.
For the last 2 years I have always used flight socks and taken asprin before long haul flights, I have one glass of wine with a meal, drink lots of water but I must admit I do not walk around much 1, because the flights are usually jammed full and 2, there is basically nowhere to stand or walk!!!!
This came on 2 days after flying from China to UK, I thought it was just a cramp in the calf and it went off after a couple of days. It came back after flying back to Hong Kong and China and then spread up the leg.
I am now on warfarin for at least six months to thin the blood, the special diet is to avoid certain things with vitamin K due to the warfarin.
kgb1 said:
I try and answer some of the questions.
I am 47 years old, no history of any such illness, reasonably fit and healthy.
I have been working overseas for 15 years, lots of experience with travelling, what you should do and not do etc. Nowadays I am based in Hong Kong and do 5 or 6 Europe trips per year plus regional trips to India, Bangladesh and China.
For the last 2 years I have always used flight socks and taken asprin before long haul flights, I have one glass of wine with a meal, drink lots of water but I must admit I do not walk around much 1, because the flights are usually jammed full and 2, there is basically nowhere to stand or walk!!!!
This came on 2 days after flying from China to UK, I thought it was just a cramp in the calf and it went off after a couple of days. It came back after flying back to Hong Kong and China and then spread up the leg.
I am now on warfarin for at least six months to thin the blood, the special diet is to avoid certain things with vitamin K due to the warfarin.
Jeez, glad to hear you're on the mend. I've never really taken any notice of the DVT think "It'll never happen to me" etc..... Think again, eh?
Flat in Fifth said:
What the airlines don't tell you is they are supposed to maintain a cabin pressure equivalent to an altitude of 6,000 to 8,000 feet above sea level.
On long haul flights they push it further AND reduce the partial pressure of oxygen even further to save money and also to make passengers slightly hypoxic and fall asleep.
There was a medical paper published last week in the USA linking DVT not to activity but to the effects of altitude pressure and cabin atmosphere. There is a discrepancy, apparently, between DVT frequency and inactivity in various forms of travel. Air travel has far higher incidence than other long periods of ground travel apparently, even when other issues factored out.
Airlines have known about it for years and deliberately use ploys to keep people in their seats, cabin atmosphere as discussed, trolleys blocking aisles etc etc.
Then people wonder why they get DVT. Never thought I'd be saying this but I would speak to a lawyer.
edited to add The above info is from an independant medical expert who knows his stuff regarding medical effects of flight. The BA chap julian64 refers to is talking rubbish.
>> Edited by Flat in Fifth on Monday 20th March 10:25
Seconded everything above, I had a year of regularly making long haul flights (every few weeks) and flattly insisted on Business Class if the customer wanted me onsite. I was high risk for DVT, alcoholic smoker who spending inordinate hours behind a desk took very little exercise.
Even so the difference in Business Class between budget and well regarded airlines is astounding.
I think it was on an Argentinian flight across the Pacific one time where within about 5 minutes of the meals being finished they must've have seriously reduced cabin O2 levels. I just felt myself slipping into unconciousness and there was nothing I could do about it. Contrasted to say Qunatas or BA long haul flights where more often than not I'd be able to get a few bottles of wine down me and watch a few movies.
Sickening stuff, and I bet these budget airlines are more than willing to risk a few DVT episodes t osave a few dollars.
Hope you make a full recovery Kevin, and one last question, which airlines were you mainly flying with?
best
Ex
Interesting that DVT is no respecter of age or fitness. As I recall from an article a few years back, there was a case of DVT affecting a fit, young athlete following a flight to Aus. I always pop one of these mini-aspirins a couple of hours before boarding the flight, but generally move around alot anyway as the seats are too small for me (cattle class...).
I'm off to Japan next month, flying "Premium economy" which seems to mean Business class seat, economy class service. It's actually not even that much more expensive from what I can make out, but I'm hardly a seasoned traveller - all I know from any long haul flights i've done is that cattle class and my long legs do not mix well.
DVTs aren't unique to flying though - my Mum's just had one apparently as a result of breaking her ankle and wearing a cast.
>> Edited by _dobbo_ on Monday 20th March 13:33
DVTs aren't unique to flying though - my Mum's just had one apparently as a result of breaking her ankle and wearing a cast.
>> Edited by _dobbo_ on Monday 20th March 13:33
TheExcession said:
Flat in Fifth said:
What the airlines don't tell you is they are supposed to maintain a cabin pressure equivalent to an altitude of 6,000 to 8,000 feet above sea level.
On long haul flights they push it further AND reduce the partial pressure of oxygen even further to save money and also to make passengers slightly hypoxic and fall asleep.
There was a medical paper published last week in the USA linking DVT not to activity but to the effects of altitude pressure and cabin atmosphere. There is a discrepancy, apparently, between DVT frequency and inactivity in various forms of travel. Air travel has far higher incidence than other long periods of ground travel apparently, even when other issues factored out.
Airlines have known about it for years and deliberately use ploys to keep people in their seats, cabin atmosphere as discussed, trolleys blocking aisles etc etc.
Then people wonder why they get DVT. Never thought I'd be saying this but I would speak to a lawyer.
edited to add The above info is from an independant medical expert who knows his stuff regarding medical effects of flight. The BA chap julian64 refers to is talking rubbish.
>> Edited by Flat in Fifth on Monday 20th March 10:25
Seconded everything above, I had a year of regularly making long haul flights (every few weeks) and flattly insisted on Business Class if the customer wanted me onsite. I was high risk for DVT, alcoholic smoker who spending inordinate hours behind a desk took very little exercise.
Even so the difference in Business Class between budget and well regarded airlines is astounding.
I think it was on an Argentinian flight across the Pacific one time where within about 5 minutes of the meals being finished they must've have seriously reduced cabin O2 levels. I just felt myself slipping into unconciousness and there was nothing I could do about it. Contrasted to say Qunatas or BA long haul flights where more often than not I'd be able to get a few bottles of wine down me and watch a few movies.
Sickening stuff, and I bet these budget airlines are more than willing to risk a few DVT episodes t osave a few dollars.
Hope you make a full recovery Kevin, and one last question, which airlines were you mainly flying with?
best
Ex
With KLM and it is interesting to read about airline cutbacks as you can really sense this with KLM since the merger with Air France. The food is terrible, the service crap and the changes to the frequent flier programme are ridiculous. They have gone for low budget tourist travel, my wife can get a return ticket to Hong Kong for 300 pounds!
The only reason we continue to use them is because we can fly into Humberside and not have to travel from London or Manchester. However Cathay fly to Amsterdam and I can then still get the hopper over to Humberside....time for a change.
There is no evidence that aspirin has any effect on DVT's. Problem is that although aspirin is very good at preventing clots on the arteries side of blood flow (it stops platelest sticking together and blocking blood vessels causing such nasties as heart attacks and strokes)the factors causing clots on the venous side are more complex and involve more things than just platelets.
Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



