Exercise/fitness question
Exercise/fitness question
Author
Discussion

Parrot of Doom

Original Poster:

23,075 posts

265 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
Over the last few years my cycling:food ratio has plummeted, resulting in me putting on a few stones extra. Most of this is down to work patterns. Anyhow, the last few months I've resolved to finally sort this out, and have been cycling like a loon to reasonably close to my proper fitness level (at college I was about 14 stones, gym 3xweek, cycling up to 100 miles a week).

My legs are remembering how they used to be and getting very solid and bulky, but this week I noticed that the scales have actually increased - I'm about 16s 7lb currently, I reckon I'm 1s 7lb stones too fat. I'm 5'11, but my job is quite physical and I have slight extra upper-body muscle to compensate. I've lost about 2 stone over the last 5 months via a combination of cycling and calorie-control.

Is it possibly to actually gain weight over a week-long period, enough weight to offset the fat burnt in that same week - about 2lb at a guess?

I eat mainly fresh meat, fish, and veg. Fruits are normally berries, I don't eat any refined sugars or packaged meals. I do drink lots of coffee though.

Lion-O

242 posts

259 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
If you are converting fat into muscle that would in part explain weight gain as muscle weighs more than fat.

Raify

6,556 posts

279 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
Lion-O said:
If you are converting fat into muscle that would in part explain weight gain as muscle weighs more than fat.


What he said. Lose fat, gain muscle = more weight

KB_S1

5,967 posts

260 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
Yes you can gain weight with exercise.

I am currently as unfit as i have been since i could run yet my weight is approx 12 3/4st.
About 18 months ago i was as fit as i have ever been and weighed approx 13 3/4st.

My training schedule has begun to resume so hopefully my legs will grow back (used to have 25" thighs, now only 21")

Incidently for maximum benefit you should eat within 15mins of strenuous exercise, this ensures the energy in the food goes towards muscle repair and build.

oddman

4,340 posts

283 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
Parrot of Doom said:
I've lost about 2 stone over the last 5 months via a combination of cycling and calorie-control.

[s]edited for dodgy maths[/s]
You don't need to be asking advice you should be giving it. You clearly done very well.

Your BMI is still around 32.4 (>30 is classified as obese) so you're right to think you've still got a way to go

Parrot of Doom said:
Is it possibly to actually gain weight over a week-long period, enough weight to offset the fat burnt in that same week - about 2lb at a guess?


Yes.. if you're hitting a plateau what's probably happened is you've hit caloires in = calories out. A bigger body even if it's a lot of fat still takes more calories to maintain than a smaller one with proportionately more muscle.

It takes about 20 miles on a bike to push out 1000 calories. 700-800calories in 100g of fat. Therefore 140 - 160 miles to burn off 1 kg of fat. Frightening isn't it?

Have you thought about a food diary? - write down everything that passes your lips. Can be a bit of an eye opener may show up some weak spots.

Alcohol is one for most of us - eg. Bottle of Wine + 600 calories. Half a loaf of French bread and 100g cheese to help it go down another 900 calories not hard to do.

Exercising can make you crave carbs and think you can eat massive portions and get away with it. You might want to do what Lance Armstrong does and weigh out your portions of carbs to make sure you're not putting the energy straight back.

I'm trying to lose weight for riding a stage of the Tour next summer and finding it hard too.

T

edited for dodgy maths

>> Edited by oddman on Monday 20th March 13:44

shadowninja

80,189 posts

313 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
I think you are supposed to look at your body mass index or something.

angrys3owner

15,855 posts

260 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
I've just recently had enough of turning into a fat bastard and had one of those I know what'll be a good idea moments and got my mountain bike out and I've been out every working day before work since last monday (a miracle - if you know me) doing at least 30mins of hard work and feeling like I should be dead (it's getting easier by the day though).

I'm more interested in being healthy again that loosing weight per say, however I have a few questions, to loose weight I'm guessing lots of fast cycling for long periods is best to build muscle I'm guessing it's harder work for less time?

Parrot of Doom

Original Poster:

23,075 posts

265 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
I don't place much faith in the BMI personally, I've had massive thighs since I started cycling when I was 16, and my job (lots of holding microphone booms and carrying heavy cameras around) means that I have above-average upper body strength.

I just tend to go on how flabby I feel, just recently I can feel my legs getting far more powerful, but the flab remains Think I'll do a couple of weeks of Ketosis and see if I can get rid of a bit more.

jessica

6,321 posts

283 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
shadowninja said:
I think you are supposed to look at your body mass index or something.


That one doesnt work if you have more muscle than normal or you work out a lot. body wieght gain so long as its muscle is good.
muscle burns more calories and wieghs more so in theory you put on wieght in muscle allowing you to eat more calories and not gain more wieght.
if that makes sense.

john smith

9,922 posts

284 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
wot she said ^

Lion-O

242 posts

259 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
angrys3owner said:
I've just recently had enough of turning into a fat bastard and had one of those I know what'll be a good idea moments and got my mountain bike out and I've been out every working day before work since last monday (a miracle - if you know me) doing at least 30mins of hard work and feeling like I should be dead (it's getting easier by the day though).

I'm more interested in being healthy again that loosing weight per say, however I have a few questions, to loose weight I'm guessing lots of fast cycling for long periods is best to build muscle I'm guessing it's harder work for less time?


Best exercise strategy for losing weight is a tough one. In general the 'calories out > calories in' strategy is the gold standard, which would suggest that cycling hard and long is the ideal.

However.

If you are getting into your upper heart rate range you will be burning your glycogen stores in the muscle rather than fat stores. When you eat after exercise, your glycogen stores will be replaced and you might not see a massive change. If you go for a long slow ride though that keeps you in the fat burning phase and you might start to see a difference more quickly.

angrys3owner

15,855 posts

260 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
Lion-O said:
Best exercise strategy for losing weight is a tough one. In general the 'calories out > calories in' strategy is the gold standard, which would suggest that cycling hard and long is the ideal.

However.

If you are getting into your upper heart rate range you will be burning your glycogen stores in the muscle rather than fat stores. When you eat after exercise, your glycogen stores will be replaced and you might not see a massive change. If you go for a long slow ride though that keeps you in the fat burning phase and you might start to see a difference more quickly.


Thanks for the Response -

Well judging on my general fitness and the fact I could have sworn I'd drop down dead after the first time out probably right in the upper heart popping out of chest range, what is best to replace glycogen after exercise? I've been mainly eating fruit (banannas, apples and such) like I said I'm not really that bothered about loosing weight, I want to be healthy again (and fit into some smaller trousers).

Boosted Ls1

21,200 posts

291 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
[quote=oddmanAlcohol is one for most of us - eg. Bottle of Wine + 600 calories. Half a loaf of French bread and 100g cheese to help it go down another 900 calories not hard to do.

>> Edited by oddman on Monday 20th March 13:44[/quote]

Hope I've got the quotes right.

What do you mean though? I could happily live for a short while on wine and bread with a sliver of cheese? Would that help me lose weight whilst I'm training?

Boosted.

Jay GTI

1,026 posts

254 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
When you first start getting back into exercise after long periods of inactivity, you will cause quite a bit of damage to the muscle fibres in the parts of the body you're putting to work. To enable your body to repair itself it will hold a lot fluid in those muscles as part of the repair process. This means you effectively retain more fluid than normal and weigh more than you would if you weren't going through this recovery period. After a week or so of exercise, the amount of damage being caused by your exercise will reduce considerably as you gain muscle tone again and your weight will start dropping back to normal and even further as your percentage of body fat also decreases.

angrys3owner

15,855 posts

260 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
Fair play, don't do scales - don't need to put a number to it, so I'll just keep going out every day for 30mins+ and drinking loads of water and trying to eat more fruit etc.

Watch out there Jay you'll be on post 666 before you know it...

Lion-O

242 posts

259 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
angrys3owner said:


Thanks for the Response -

Well judging on my general fitness and the fact I could have sworn I'd drop down dead after the first time out probably right in the upper heart popping out of chest range, what is best to replace glycogen after exercise? I've been mainly eating fruit (banannas, apples and such) like I said I'm not really that bothered about loosing weight, I want to be healthy again (and fit into some smaller trousers).


The body converts carbohydrate into glycogen most efficiently, so you should be eating something like a sweet potato (v low glycaemic and carb-tastic) within the hour. They've found that the body metabolises carbohydrates better if there is a bit of protein to wash it down with so if you go with an approximate 80/20 carbs to protein ration you should be great. Think Tuna on potato as a good option.

Jay GTI

1,026 posts

254 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
angrys3owner said:
Fair play, don't do scales - don't need to put a number to it, so I'll just keep going out every day for 30mins+ and drinking loads of water and trying to eat more fruit etc.

Watch out there Jay you'll be on post 666 before you know it...


Oh no, the Devil's post...

The good thing about coming back to exercise, if you've been fit once it's so much easier to regain your fitness than build it from scratch. I used to run 1/2 marathons but due to an injury had to stop, with the obvious immediate fitness drop and weight increase as a result. I've got back into a proper exercise regime over the last few months by starting XC mountain bike racing (doesn't aggravate my running injury) and the fitness is flooding back with the weight flying off. I feel soooooo much better as a result!