BBC - Car Pooling ... Does it Work ?
BBC - Car Pooling ... Does it Work ?
Author
Discussion

The Wiz

Original Poster:

5,875 posts

293 months

hedders

24,460 posts

278 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
Just heard on the news that the fgovernment are considering penalising anyone who is not prepared to give up their spare seat.

Great, a new tax for using your car...

Marki

15,763 posts

301 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
hedders said:
Just heard on the news that the fgovernment are considering penalising anyone who is not prepared to give up their spare seat.

Great, a new tax for using your car...


just thinking ,,, in Cuba car owners are by law required to pick up people who want a lift so now we know Comrade

lady summerisle

238 posts

251 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
hmm letting random strangers into my car... that seems safe!!

Mustang Baz

1,653 posts

265 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
As much as I hate the introduction of further anti-motoring action without a realistic public transport alternative, car pooling can - in certain circumstances - work. Living in the US for 6yrs and experiencing this everyday generally led me to believe it encouraged people, with a regular, homogenous journey, to consider sharing their vehicle with work colleagues who lived close by - thus (theoretically) reducing traffic on the road and encouraging sharing. The car pool lane was also open to gas/electric powered cars if memory serves, irrelevant if you had someone sharing with you.

However, as several people have commented on the BBC website, car pools are not a cast iron alternative all the time. On a Friday night/peak commute, the lane generally moved pretty slowly and often got jammed up. In addition, the penalty - $271 for each offence - was not enough to prevent some folk from flaunting the pooling rules.

JoolzB

3,549 posts

280 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
CAR POOLING ... DOES IT WORK ?

No it makes your seats wet.

R988

7,502 posts

260 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
As long as they are fit women they can stay, otherwise I'd just buy an impractical car like a caterham, want a lift on a cold wet friday night? anyone?...

david87M3

1,470 posts

265 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
hedders said:
Just heard on the news that the fgovernment are considering penalising anyone who is not prepared to give up their spare seat.

Great, a new tax for using your car...

So I pay for my car out of my hard earned cash and if this rule comes in my car is a free taxi for anyone who demands to get a lift? stuff that.

mxdi

13,994 posts

280 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
It'll certainly work for some, my partner and I, now work same hours in roughly same place, so we are considering one car between us, could work for us, but how often is that can happen?

Fat Audi 80

2,403 posts

282 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
Its all very well, but how many of us actually have a job where anyone they work with lives in even the same town, let alone on a decent commuting route to pick up?

In this whip cracked economy of ours, who knows what time they will leave work at the end of the day to pick up their "car pooler"?

What if you want to go to the gym on the way home?

I just cannot see it working, certainly not worth spending £6m on it and breaking a perfectly good road for a year to test it.

BRING US SOME REAL ALTERNATIVES AND SOLUTIONS NOT CRAPPY IDEAS THOUGHT UP IN YOUR LUNCHBREAK THAT WILL ONLY HELP 1% OF US! FFS

voyds9

8,490 posts

314 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
Time to dust of the motorbike

3 days a week I work 50 miles in one direction, the other 3 days I work 45 miles in the other direction anyone want a lift for half a week days variable weekly.

RR-eng

5,849 posts

264 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
david87M3 said:
hedders said:
Just heard on the news that the fgovernment are considering penalising anyone who is not prepared to give up their spare seat.

Great, a new tax for using your car...

So I pay for my car out of my hard earned cash and if this rule comes in my car is a free taxi for anyone who demands to get a lift? stuff that.


Has anyone actually got a link to this, I have heard no proposals to force car sharing only plan to fine people who use the lane illegally. If you want to ride one up you can still go in the other lanes.

The problems with car pool lanes:

If they are simply created by marking off a current lane in a congested area they are terrible as they will greatly increase congestion by reducing the amount of road space. If new lanes are created they marginally improve trafic flow on the other lanes.

If the lanes aren't sepperated from the main carriageway it can be dangerous as you have car potentially traveling much faster than congested trafic in the outside lane. If the lanes are sepperated it could be pretty crap as you would essentially be stuck at travelling at the speed of the slowest vehicle, are coachs going to be allowed to use this lane?

Likewise on an uncongested road you are going to have problems with slow drivers getting in the car pool lane on the outside and finding that they are repeatedly over taken by cars on the inside.

Car pool lanes are however a good idea from the point of view that they are a way of justifying extra road building in a way that environ-metalists find more difficult to protest against...

deltafox

3,839 posts

263 months

Monday 20th March 2006
quotequote all
Any chance of a lift?