Echoes of Vietnam
Author
Discussion

timmy30

Original Poster:

9,325 posts

258 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
Reuters said:
BAGHDAD (Reuters) - The U.S. military said on Tuesday it was investigating Iraqi police allegations that its soldiers shot dead a family of 11 in their home last week.

The probe comes a day after a magazine published allegations that U.S. Marines killed civilians in another town in November. A criminal inquiry into those deaths was launched last week.

Time magazine said a patrol went on a rampage after one of their comrades was killed by a roadside bomb in Haditha, west of Baghdad. It published detailed accounts by townspeople.


It looks like Vietnam all over again. I wonder what the headlines would be in the UK/US if there were reports of Iraqi troops masacering Kurdish civilians? Perhaps there'd be calls for regieme change, an invasion? Still as it's our troops doing the killing it's not so bad is it, because we are after all on the side of right and reason, unlike that evil psycho Sadam.

timmy30

Original Poster:

9,325 posts

258 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
los angeles said:


Not necissarily blaming the troops, imagine getting sniped at and booby trapped all day long, day in day out, I'm not suprised they blow a gasket, but that's what happens when you invade a country.

So much for 'War Lite' eh?

r988

7,502 posts

260 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
Wonder if they wear ears as necklaces

Popzak

794 posts

250 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
It's Very Unfortunate,but as already pointed out Soldiers in the line of Fire are at a Tremendous Stress.And after seeing their Brothers,Sniped,or Blown to Bits,besides for Fear,Anxiety,and Adrenaline going over the top...Anger Sets in.All Soldiers the same as all people don't have the same Temperment.If someone fires of a round it can become like Sharks at a feeding Frenzy.Things Happen Fast and can get Very Ugly.I know there are those that will Argue that they are trained professionals and should be able to handle different types of situations.But beleive me all that goes out the window when you see your Mates get an arm or leg or their head blown off.This Civilian Situation is a Difficult Task.Soldiers are not exactly trained as Peacekeepers.And NO there is no reason or excuse to gun down Innocent Civilians.But Some Civilians also Provoke Soldiers.I saw a Vietnamese Villager laugh at an American Patrol after they had been mauled by a VC Ambush,and had taken some heavy casualties.I tell you the Truth,he's no longer laughing.Our Troops in Iraq aren't walking among friendly Civilians,Anyone at anytime could turn on them.That makes matters worse.Friend or Foe?A Patrol in an area where their Troops have been Ambushed and Killed is likely to fire at anything that breathes.This House to House Urban Warfare is a Soldiers Nightmare.Too many places to hide and too easily boobytrapped.And yes we also have the suicide bombers and roadside bombs and an ever growing Sniper Threat,and they are well trained.I've read they eliminated several of our Elite Marine Sniper Teams.What a Mess,and people wonder why these things happen.

tuttle

3,427 posts

268 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
I've often thought it 'incorrect' to judge combat soldiers in wartime(or frontline type activities) by civilian peacetime standards.
I don't have any answers, just doesn't seem right to me.

racefan_uk

2,935 posts

287 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
tuttle said:
I've often thought it 'incorrect' to judge combat soldiers in wartime(or frontline type activities) by civilian peacetime standards.
I don't have any answers, just doesn't seem right to me.

Perhaps we shouldn't be judging the soldiers out there facing the bullets, but maybe the political leaders that have sent them in there in the first place?

timmy30

Original Poster:

9,325 posts

258 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
racefan_uk said:
tuttle said:
I've often thought it 'incorrect' to judge combat soldiers in wartime(or frontline type activities) by civilian peacetime standards.
I don't have any answers, just doesn't seem right to me.

Perhaps we shouldn't be judging the soldiers out there facing the bullets, but maybe the political leaders that have sent them in there in the first place?




A certain 'Home Guard Hero' who was strutting about the deck of a carrier no so long ago in a flight suit proclaiming "Mission accomplished" comes to mind.