Discussion
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/magazine/4
A glimpse into some of the underhand tactics being used to force high house prices and how estate agents (some of them) rip off the customers a treat. It's on at 9:00pm tonight on the BBC.
A glimpse into some of the underhand tactics being used to force high house prices and how estate agents (some of them) rip off the customers a treat. It's on at 9:00pm tonight on the BBC.
some of it is over dramatised and there is a fair bit of artistic licence designed to appeal to those who like to become enraged about things they know very little about.
there are some valid points though, for instance although I have never seen it happen it does not surprise me in the least that some agents falsify signatures and so forth...it's very easy to do, and the signatures they refer to are relating to documents that the EA act and the FSA require them to fill out but that were not required even a few years ago (and therefore tempting to ignore if you're of that persuasion)
also, the fake P60's/payslips/utility bills are very easy to come by, bank statements too.
nonetheless, I don't like the tone of the article it smacks of hysteria and it's noticeable that there is no counter balance applied or any explanation of why things happen or why people may be tempted to do such a thing in that position..not required as a justification as such, more as a further insight in to estate agency as opposed to screaming "look at how bad estate agents are! this proves what we thought!" etc etc etc
i'd be interested to see an deeper insight in to the management and working practices of the large estate agency in question as everyone in the industry knows how bad they are
>> Edited by minimax on Tuesday 21st March 12:34
there are some valid points though, for instance although I have never seen it happen it does not surprise me in the least that some agents falsify signatures and so forth...it's very easy to do, and the signatures they refer to are relating to documents that the EA act and the FSA require them to fill out but that were not required even a few years ago (and therefore tempting to ignore if you're of that persuasion)
also, the fake P60's/payslips/utility bills are very easy to come by, bank statements too.
nonetheless, I don't like the tone of the article it smacks of hysteria and it's noticeable that there is no counter balance applied or any explanation of why things happen or why people may be tempted to do such a thing in that position..not required as a justification as such, more as a further insight in to estate agency as opposed to screaming "look at how bad estate agents are! this proves what we thought!" etc etc etc
i'd be interested to see an deeper insight in to the management and working practices of the large estate agency in question as everyone in the industry knows how bad they are
>> Edited by minimax on Tuesday 21st March 12:34
Surely it's a case of caveat emptor? The estate agent is hired and paid for by the seller, obviously he/she will do all within their power to obtain the highest price for the seller, infact they have a fiduciary duty to do so.
If the buyer is daft enough to overpay, isn't that there fault? We are all adults, buyers aren't forced to lie about their salaries on mortgage applications, anymore than we're forced to get into credit card debt......
Why would you trust a used house salesman anymore than a used car or double glazing salesman?
If the buyer is daft enough to overpay, isn't that there fault? We are all adults, buyers aren't forced to lie about their salaries on mortgage applications, anymore than we're forced to get into credit card debt......
Why would you trust a used house salesman anymore than a used car or double glazing salesman?
nothing wrong in guzumping - its getting the best deal for your client, the seller. In fact the agent is required to pass on other offers.
Knowing what someone can pay for a property and getting the maximum from them for your client is good selling. If they cant afford it dont buy it.
Over-pricing properties to get them on your books, nothing new there. If the price is too high it wont sell, give the agent 2/3 months then move it if its not sold. Reduce it to a realistc level. Greedy owners to blame there.
Bungs - clearly not getting the best deal for your client and is wrong.
Faking documents clearly wrong.
>> Edited by superlightr on Tuesday 21st March 12:43
Knowing what someone can pay for a property and getting the maximum from them for your client is good selling. If they cant afford it dont buy it.
Over-pricing properties to get them on your books, nothing new there. If the price is too high it wont sell, give the agent 2/3 months then move it if its not sold. Reduce it to a realistc level. Greedy owners to blame there.
Bungs - clearly not getting the best deal for your client and is wrong.
Faking documents clearly wrong.
>> Edited by superlightr on Tuesday 21st March 12:43
crankedup said:
Guess most of us people have been reading/learning of these malpractices for more years than would like to think about. Why is it that succesive Goverments have not grappled with this problem and brought in robust legislation to stamp it out?
back handers? fee-free loans? Rolex watches?
It certainly makes you wonder.
what legislation to stamp it out? Why more red tape.
Its already illegal to forge documents, its illegal to take bungs,
It is legal and required to get the best price for the seller, It is legal to overprice a property or are told to by the seller in order to test the market.
HIP's are coming in in June 2007 which is another load of rubbish and red tape and expence
There are already solicitors dealing with the paperwork who have to be qualified. Making EA get x qualification wont stop doggy dealings, it will only inrease the charges to the seller.
If you dont like the agent or they havnt got the property sold within a reasonable time at the price you have agreed for them to try at, move it to another agent. its not rocket science.
>> Edited by superlightr on Tuesday 21st March 12:57
Its already illegal to forge documents, its illegal to take bungs,
It is legal and required to get the best price for the seller, It is legal to overprice a property or are told to by the seller in order to test the market.
HIP's are coming in in June 2007 which is another load of rubbish and red tape and expence
There are already solicitors dealing with the paperwork who have to be qualified. Making EA get x qualification wont stop doggy dealings, it will only inrease the charges to the seller.
If you dont like the agent or they havnt got the property sold within a reasonable time at the price you have agreed for them to try at, move it to another agent. its not rocket science.
>> Edited by superlightr on Tuesday 21st March 12:57
anniesdad said:
crankedup said:
Guess most of us people have been reading/learning of these malpractices for more years than would like to think about. Why is it that succesive Goverments have not grappled with this problem and brought in robust legislation to stamp it out?
back handers? fee-free loans? Rolex watches?
It certainly makes you wonder.
all they need to do IMHO as a person in the industry (not an estate agent btw
) is to bring the contract law in line with scottish law ie offer and acceptance binding. currently the contract is only binding once you have exchanged. this would remove gazumping as there would be a financial penalty. still, though, gazumping is the estate agent working for the customer - after all, the same people who moan about it happening to them would not I wager stop at allowing their buyer to be gazumped for another buyer offering a few grand more
...and bollox to the people who say it's the estate agents pushing the price up to earn more commission that encourages gazumping - if a typical fee is say 1.5% on a price of say £250,000 = £3,750 the negotiator will make 5% usually (more for high banking or time served staff) of that = £187.50. putting another offer forward to the vendor (which they are obliged to do) of say £2,500 would mean increased commission by £1.88. hardly worth it I think you'll agree

Don't forget that the only person involved in the whole house purchase/sale process that isn't regulated is the agent. Your bank/mortgage company are regulated, your financial advisor is regulated, the insurance companies are regulated and your solicitor is regulated.
Strange how the only person who attracts all the bad press is the unregulated one. About time some legislation was brought in to stop all the jumped up little
running riot in the housing market.
Having said that there are a lot of good agents about. I think you can tell pretty quickly which are the good ones and which aren't. The certain chain mentioned around here who all drive around in Minis are well known to all those in London as a company to stay away from!
Strange how the only person who attracts all the bad press is the unregulated one. About time some legislation was brought in to stop all the jumped up little
running riot in the housing market. Having said that there are a lot of good agents about. I think you can tell pretty quickly which are the good ones and which aren't. The certain chain mentioned around here who all drive around in Minis are well known to all those in London as a company to stay away from!
amcphillips said:
Don't forget that the only person involved in the whole house purchase/sale process that isn't regulated is the agent. Your bank/mortgage company are regulated, your financial advisor is regulated, the insurance companies are regulated and your solicitor is regulated.
Strange how the only person who attracts all the bad press is the unregulated one. About time some legislation was brought in to stop all the jumped up littlerunning riot in the housing market.
Having said that there are a lot of good agents about. I think you can tell pretty quickly which are the good ones and which aren't. The certain chain mentioned around here who all drive around in Minis are well known to all those in London as a company to stay away from!
I assume you mean foxtons rather than spicerhaart or beresfords
estate agents do have legislation to deal with, and as such can be considered regulated. and trust me, complaints and bad press come from all areas of the property arena, including mortgage brokers and especially conveyancers (the small shyster ones are especially bad)

i do remember a few years ago being told by a lady that she and her husband had signed blank sheets of paper when putting their house on the market. i felt good about putting her right and telling her to take it off the market,but it made me think how much of this kind of thing goes on?
anonymous said:
[redacted]
foxtons operate different fee structures in different offices depending on what the market will take (in other words, what they can get away with
) so it depends...in fulham where Felicity J Lord are attempting total market dominance in their area foxtons have been known to drop to 0.89% well to be honest tonks old bean i've not known a punter to negotiate a sliding fee (I presume what you refer to is say 1% for at or below X price, 1.25% for at or below XY price etc) usually there will be a fixed fee of X percentage of the purchase price..so my original example stands - but admittedly as only relating to my own company policy
I also don't deal in estate agency so I am an impartial observer..although I do have to deal with the cretins daily

If it wasn't sensationalised it would not make good television.
However the large company in question have a very high staff turnover. Their inexperienced employees are exploited by a system of working which does not produce sound professionalism, this can be discovered in a nano second of meeting one.
This company seeks successfully to exploit the F*ckwittedness of Jo public who accept a marketing smokescreen as a valid reason to trust.
If you wish to use an experienced professional estate agent to handle your property interests it is not actually very difficult to find one. They don't usually wear 'cheep' or 'fashionable' suits and whilst in some cases they may drive Mini's, they will not be styalised.
However the large company in question have a very high staff turnover. Their inexperienced employees are exploited by a system of working which does not produce sound professionalism, this can be discovered in a nano second of meeting one.
This company seeks successfully to exploit the F*ckwittedness of Jo public who accept a marketing smokescreen as a valid reason to trust.
If you wish to use an experienced professional estate agent to handle your property interests it is not actually very difficult to find one. They don't usually wear 'cheep' or 'fashionable' suits and whilst in some cases they may drive Mini's, they will not be styalised.
I am in total agreement with minimax to bring in the system of sales as used by the Scottish system. Whilst its easy to suggest that people have a free choise of agent and we dont need more red tape in the selling of property industry, clearly we need a whole raft of red tape to have the industry 'cleaned up'once and for all. Of course not all agents are shysters,are they, and those that fall into that cat'have nothing to fear, IMHO.
Gassing Station | The Pie & Piston Archive | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



ers should be shot.
i've not ever heard of that before..