Another house buying question!
Another house buying question!
Author
Discussion

greatgranny

Original Poster:

9,519 posts

257 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
I went to see a house at the weekend.

I rang the agent today to see if there had been any offers on the property.

He said there had been 2 offers but wouldn't tell me the amounts, only to tell me they were both under the asking price.

I asked him how can I make an offer if I don't know what the highest existing offer is?

He said that it was "not much below the asking price".

Still no use I said. He still wouldn't divulge the figure.

Then I just put the phone down.

If it was the same guy who showed him around the house he must be all of 19/20 and was a complete prat. Definately not qualified in any way.

Can they withold this information?

tonyvid

9,889 posts

274 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
I suppose the offer is only between buyer and seller with the agent acting as messenger - whether we like it or not I don't see why anyone else should be privy to that info. PITA but that seems to be the way it works in our system of buying. Think of it the other way round, would you like another buyer knowing what you offered?

Flat in Fifth

49,051 posts

282 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
Yepp he can. In some countries eg Sweden iirc offers are open and pblic knowledge.

You have to offer what it is worth to you, and your position.

For example you may be in a position to exchange contracts quickly which is what the seller may want. Therefore you have to judge that you are in a good position strategically and offer a low price.

You may not be in agood position strategically and therefore feel you have to offer near or at the asking price.

You may want the house so desperately that you are prepared on first shot to offer asking or over.

Only you can decide, but avoid sending desperate to buy signals as that way leads to the trousers being taken down scenario. Bit like an auction, hat is it worth to you? Anything over or bad vibes walk away plenty of property for sale. In fact like cars too.

B17NNS

18,506 posts

278 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
Common practice I'm affraid.

Try an offer - they are obliged to give it to their client.

If it is rejected you know it is not enough. Keep going up to the point where you want to pay no more.

Your circumstances will also affect the chance of your offer being accepted. For example if you have a cash buyer who will complete (and pay for) the property very quickly he is better than someone in a long chain.

jas xjr

11,309 posts

270 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
sorry but if i was the agent and was asked what the highest bid was
i would probably make up some bs about "near the asking price."
make an offer based on what it is worth to you.if that happens to be way below the asking price,so be it.the agent is SUPPOSED to pass on any and all offers,but its such a dirty unregulated business,what can you do? plenty of other houses out there. i did have dealings with an agent a few years ago who used to "advise" me of prices that might be acceptable to a vendor prior to a property going to auction, for a drink.

timmy30

9,325 posts

258 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]


It is open to abuse isn't it, hence there is alway an offer on the property, but they can never reveal details.....which does give cart blanche to make up non existent offers, if you put the phone down on them and the other 'offer' was non existent then I guess they'll soon call back up saying that the pretend offer has fallen through.

Iv'e had that before, had my offer accpeted, then 'outbid', the agent of course telling me that I'd need to raise my bid, me telling them to stuff it, and suprise suprise the agent phoning up the next day to say that the mystery bidder has withdrawn and do I still want to proceed.

minimax

11,985 posts

287 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
greatgranny said:

Can they withold this information?


they have to.

you are over reacting

minimax

11,985 posts

287 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
timmy30 said:
anonymous said:
[redacted]


It is open to abuse isn't it, hence there is alway an offer on the property, but they can never reveal details.....which does give cart blanche to make up non existent offers, if you put the phone down on them and the other 'offer' was non existent then I guess they'll soon call back up saying that the pretend offer has fallen through.

Iv'e had that before, had my offer accpeted, then 'outbid', the agent of course telling me that I'd need to raise my bid, me telling them to stuff it, and suprise suprise the agent phoning up the next day to say that the mystery bidder has withdrawn and do I still want to proceed.


I think the key here is whether the agent is a shyster or not. if any of my staff behaved like that i'd discipline them immediately.

frequently there are calls to our office asking about properties and frequently we tell them no offers have been taken, and slightly less frequently we tell them that there have been offers made...depending on the actual circumstances. I have never seen or heard of anything like the shady practices happening in any of the estate agencies in my group (there are 370 offices) that some people here are describing...although I can name quite a few others where these practices happens are the norm.

just like everything, there are bad and good people out there, use your loaf to ascertain which are which

timmy30

9,325 posts

258 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
minimax said:

just like everything, there are bad and good people out there, use your loaf to ascertain which are which


I'm going house shopping with the Mrs in Italy the week after next.... I'm sure the antics out there are going to make the UK look tame.

Wacky Racer

41,422 posts

278 months

minimax

11,985 posts

287 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
Wacky Racer said:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/magazine/4



already being discussed on another thread

sleep envy

62,260 posts

280 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]


When I helped the ex-mrs envy buy her flat it was on the condition that I was able to view all the offers made to the vendor.

Technically they're not obliged to do it but to guarantee a sale they would have been silly not too.

Try and argue your case, especially if you're a first time/cash/mortgage ready buyer and have no chain - it's low risk to them as other deals can fall down.

fido

18,938 posts

286 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
greatgranny said:


If it was the same guy who showed him around the house he must be all of 19/20 and was a complete prat. Definately not qualified in any way.



sounds like he hasn't got a clue... you'll have to decide what's it's worth to you (compare with similar houses that have sold / or still for sale)...

while it's still on the market, it's up for grabs - you could try putting in some lower offers - it's your turn to make up b**ls**t to the estate agent.

minimax

11,985 posts

287 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
sleep envy said:
anonymous said:
[redacted]


When I helped the ex-mrs envy buy her flat it was on the condition that I was able to view all the offers made to the vendor.

Technically they're not obliged to do it but to guarantee a sale they would have been silly not too.

Try and argue your case, especially if you're a first time/cash/mortgage ready buyer and have no chain - it's low risk to them as other deals can fall down.




well done for that as it no doubt put you in a good position, but although I expect you give not a chavs damn, the estate agent was breaking the law


another example of it's ok to do it to them but not when they do it to us

greatgranny

Original Poster:

9,519 posts

257 months

Wednesday 22nd March 2006
quotequote all
Thanks for all your replies.

I have decided not to make an offer.

The house was described as needing some improvement but needed totally gutting.

New kitchen, bathroom, windows, rewire, new central heating bioler, total dedecorating. It had no carpets or curtains. It also needed repointing and some work on the roof.

I estimated approx 40-50k to get it how I would like it.

It wouldn't be habitable during the work so with 2 young kids I wouldn't take this kind of house on.

Trying to find the link but their website is down. Probably not a good idea anyway to name them.