HR / Employment Law Question
HR / Employment Law Question
Author
Discussion

miniman

Original Poster:

30,238 posts

293 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
Mrs Miniman suffers from migraines - what I would term "mild" ones as she isn't out of action for days at a time as I believe some sufferers are. She has had 3 in the last 6 months. On each occasion, she has gone into work at around lunchtime and on each occasion, she has made up the 3-4 hours during the same working week (often during the same working day). Yesterday her employer demanded that she produce a doctor's certificate stating that she does indeed suffer from migraines. They have suggested that she "might prefer to see the 'company doctor' rather than her own" (it's a PR company).

Questions:

1. Do they have any right to demand this?
2. What are their legal obligations in terms of self certification of absence? They have never made her fill in a form, nor have they deducted any pay.
3. Can anyone point me in the direction of some "paperwork" relating to this kind of thing?

I am frankly livid. The company has lost a lot of staff recently and hasn't replaced them, and seems to be losing customers hand over fist. It all smacks to me (in cynic mode) of finding a good excuse to get rid of someone to save some money. Any advice much appreciated

huckster6

245 posts

248 months

Tuesday 21st March 2006
quotequote all
My initial responses, which I hope might be helpful

* "Employment Law" by Deborah J Lockton, Macmillan Law Masters was a big help to me

* urban75 forums website has some boards on this sort of topic and the advice I have read there seems eminently sensible
www.urban75.net/vbulletin/forumdisplay.php?f=46

* membership of a union does help safeguard the rights of working people.

* KEEP DETAILED NOTES, who said what, when, why, where and how did you feel/interpret this. Must be more or less contemporaneous.

I was referred to my employer's occupational health doctor. She behaved as a doctor, seemed to genuinely listen and try to make a truthful assessment, and was not a stooge. I found her sympathetic.

Hope it progresses well.


>> Edited by huckster6 on Tuesday 21st March 22:16

miniman

Original Poster:

30,238 posts

293 months

Wednesday 22nd March 2006
quotequote all
Thanks for the info, and link.

Any other thoughts anyone??

keithyboy

1,940 posts

301 months

Wednesday 22nd March 2006
quotequote all
What about her contract/particulars of employment or staff handbook. Does she have any of these - if so what do they say? The company must abide by its published internal procedures (if it has any!). Many cases are decided at ET in employees favour for companies failing to follow their own rules.

havoc

33,537 posts

266 months

Wednesday 22nd March 2006
quotequote all
Definitely read her handbook / contract, see what that's got to say.

It sounds a grey area, as she's not in for her 'set' hours, yet she's not completing sick forms. That she's making time up sounds like it's up-until-now been an informal arrangement between her and her manager (usually the best way, to be honest).

I can understand the company wanting to get confirmation of why she's not in every so often - I wouldn't take it quite so badly.
The other route they COULD go down is requiring her to fill in a self-cert every time, then of course after 3/4/5 periods of sick, start down the disciplinary route for attendance. If they want to get rid of her this is a quite legal way to do it, if it's written in the handbook (most co's have this now). That they are prepared to just get confirmation of her affliction (is this the right word) sounds like they're trying to be fair, not push her out.

I assume that, if she gets migraines, she has been to the doctor about them already, so the docs will have no problems in writing something to that effect???